Urban Optimism
Writing in the Washington Post, Joel Kotkin hails the resurgent fortunes of the second-tier city:
What used to take place almost entirely in New York, Los Angeles, Chicago or San Francisco -- whether in high finance, advertising or marketing -- is now happening more and more in unlikely locales such as Omaha, Des Moines, Fargo, N.D., and Columbus, Ohio….
For many cities in the South and Midwest, spreading the wealth could signal the dawn of an era of renewed urban development, a new cosmopolitanism and growing cultural, technological and economic influence. For the long-dominant coastal cities, it offers an opportunity to rethink their priorities and where they want to go. For the country as a whole, it means a more vibrant, heterogeneous landscape, more living choices, a livelier cultural and social panorama -- let's face it, a nation that's more vital and more fun.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Joe--
I have a number of friends back in Atlanta that are already doing that. When they graduated, they got jobs out in the 'burbs and continued to live in the city. They get to and from work about three times as fast as all the others that commute in the opposite direction.
hey brian,
would that the reverse commute were better in chicago as in atlanta! it's worse. outbound morning, inbound evening on the Eden's is an exercise in watching geological time pass you by...
maybe if we could have central planning look at this... (jest kiddin')
hey Lefty! let's root for the Twins! keep the white sux (!) out of the playoffs...
have a good weekend, all,
drf
Nomah's gonna help you out with that this weekend.
The author does a great job describing the manifestations of the rise of second cities - brew pubs, lofts in old buildings, people fixing up vitorian-era houses in old neighborhoods. But I think he's fundamentally wrong in setting up a zero-sum game between first tier and second tier cities. Another interpretation is that the urban renaissance experienced by NYC, SF, Boston, etc. has gained enough momentum to spread to smaller old cities. He writes as if the big cities are undergoing actual decline, when in fact they are stronger than they've been in half a century, and continue to make strides.
It's also goofy to set this up as a coastal-vs-heartland competition. Both of these areas have both first tier and second tier cities.
This guy leaves the impression that all those good jobs left the big city and went to the heartland. Wrong. For the most part they were either eliminated or went overseas.
Look at St. Louis or Des Moines or Fargo and you will see that manufacturing and jobs are down. Gateway, located in Sioux Falls, just announced the vaporization of 850 jobs.
There really are some cool things going on in the so called second-tiered cities. Job growth coming from first-tiered cities is not one of them, unfortunately.
The only thing Columbus has going for it right now is the hope of light rail.
Yeah, we have a pretty fun and safe downtown and arena district, but the job growth front isn't impressive.
The local news headlined a few weeks back with a mayoral announcement that the city had given a tax break to an Internet firm that was employing fewer than 25 people! They moved from Indianapolis or somewhere.
On the bright side, the traffic is bearable, the weather has some nice variety to it, and there are plenty of hobby shops and high speed internet providers so we don't kill each other out of sheer boredom.
Job growth, at least in base industries anyway, happens on a regional level these days. In 20 years, the predominant commuting pattern could be from bedroom cities to the suburban job centers.
hey joe.
when carl everett homered, that was a bummah.
but nice call there!
drf