FDR in Qom

|

Something incredible has been happening in Iran. Thousands of furious Islamist protestors in Qom have been parading in blood-soaked shrouds and carrying black flags, a newspaper has been closed down indefinitely by government order, and three journalists are under arrest, and all because of a 1937 cartoon depicting President Franklin D. Roosevelt's struggle with Supreme Court justices who had been declaring his New Deal programs unconstitutional.

The reformist newspaper Hayat-e-Nou published the 65-year-old, pro-FDR drawing last week. It depicts a bearded justice being squashed by a giant thumb; Americans of the period would have understood that the thumb was Roosevelt's, because the president had instigated a major campaign against the Court's "Nine Old Men," and was attempting to expand and pack it with friendlier appointees.

Hayat-e-Nou ran the drawing without explaining what it was, and may have intended the now-ambiguous image as a comment on pending reform proposals that would loosen conservative control of the Iranian judiciary. But that isn't clear. What is clear is that Iran's religious conservatives perceived the squashed man in the drawing—he's wearing a black robe and has a white beard—to be none other than the late Ayatollah Khomeini. The closed paper, the jailed journalists, and the blood-soaked protestors in the streets of Qom are all responses to this imagined affront.

NEXT: Guilford County Exposed

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. They’re both wrong: The character depicted in the cartoon wasn’t Khomeini AND the “New Deal” wasn’t constitutional.

  2. Brad,

    I agree with your sentiment, except perhaps us future generations that are working to support growing numbers of retired people who now get more back than they ever put in are the ones who are doomed.

  3. amazing how easy it is to scare the people, eh? Like 40 percent of Americans believe one or more of the 9/11 highjackers was an Iraqi.

  4. Actually, I’m quite sure that FDR was NOT a great guy, Brad. At all. He was the most ignorant, dictatorial president of the Twentieth Century. We have him to blame for a hell of a lot more than Social Security. Which, by the way, is just welfare under a different name.

  5. I’m sure FDR was a great guy and all, but in my book he made a big mistake with Social Security. Basically, he doomed generations of senior citizens to be dependent on the earnings of future generations for their livelihoods.

  6. I don’t think FDR was ignorant at all. I think he knew exactly what he had to do to pull the country out of the Depression and into WWII.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.