Florida's War on Pill Mills Is Also a War on Patient Privacy

An anti-drug taskforce in Seminole County has illegally confiscated the records of more than 5,000 patients, according to the Orlando Sentinel. As part of their investigation into Dr. Vincent Mamone and 29 of his patients, agents with Sanford's City-County Investigative Bureau received a warrant to seize "business and financial records, prescription records, charts for 29 patients, sign-in logs, prescription pads and cellphone records" from Primary Care Physicians of Sanford. 

Yet CCIB agents didn't take the records of only those patients under investigation:

[I]n addition to the records seized, CCIB agents copied the computer servers from the medical practice, which [Mamone attorney Amy] Tingley said was not authorized by the search warrant. So instead of having data on 29 patients, agents with Seminole's countywide drug task force now hold information on more than 5,000. 

The CCIB hasn't said why it's investigating Mamone, though it's pretty obvious based on Tingley's claim that her client's office "is not a pill mill," that this investigation is about prescription painkillers. The records will remain sealed until all 29 patients have been notified that they are under investigation and been given a chance to object to his/her record being unsealed. But then what happens to the other 4,971 records? The CCIB won't say. 

Historically, Florida cops have had no more love for the Fourth Amendment (or the concept of privacy) than cops in any other state. But what they've done in the name of combatting the prescription pill epidemic is pretty extraordinary.

Back in October, the Sarasota Herald-Tribune reported that the Sarasota County Sheriff's Office had written privacy waivers ("Authorization for Release of Protected Health Information") and asked 30 pain clinics throughout the county (politely, I'm sure) to slip the waivers into the stack of forms new patients must sign the first time they seek treatment. If the patient signed the form, the sheriff's office could obtain their records without a warrant.

While the language in the waiver wasn't particularly dense, what made the department's scheme so nefarious is that the forms contained no indication that they had been written by law enforcement.  

According to the Herald-Tribune, no doctor has returned forms to the Sarasota County Sheriff's Office. 

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • SugarFree||

    [I]n addition to the records seized, CCIB agents copied the computer servers from the medical practice, which [Mamone attorney Amy] Tingley said was not authorized by the search warrant. So instead of having data on 29 patients, agents with Seminole's countywide drug task force now hold information on more than 5,000.

    If they wanted privacy, maybe they shouldn't have sought medical treatment.

    So they violated the 4th, violated medical privacy statues, and stole computerized personal information (a Federal and State crime). I'm sure they under arrest, right?

  • nicole||

    If they wanted privacy, maybe they shouldn't have sought medical treatment.

    Duh. Or are you suggesting there is some kind of "right to privacy?"

  • SugarFree||

    I was going to say "Leave your curtains open tonight and we'll find out," but I stopped myself because that sounds really creepy.

  • nicole||

    Ha! I am slightly obsessed with curtains and other window dressings, because I do enjoy my privacy at home.

  • SugarFree||

    My wife had blackout curtains made for our bedroom. Best curtains ever. Our bedroom is an infinite ocean of blackest night. And they block sound well too.

  • nicole||

    Yeah, I have those too for the bedroom. I'm a super light sleeper in the morning and have east-facing windows, so in summer I don't usually make it past 5 staying asleep without them. It's also good for the cold.

  • gaoxiaen||

    Me too, so don't look at me when I'm walking around naked on the balcony.

  • BlogimiDei||

    Those pigs must of loved that part in Willy Wonka where the kids sign a contract...

    ...A contract the size of a wall, with a first letter font size of about 1000 down to a sub-atomic font size...

    I love our protectors and servers.

  • Tablet pc||

    I really hate the war

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement