Missouri Still Forbids Free Health Care from Outside the State

Protectionism trumps the needs of patients.

In the aftermath of the tornado that devastated Joplin in 2011, Remote Area Medical, a Tennessee-based charity that provides free health care, sent its mobile eyeglass laboratory to Missouri to help.

But it wasn’t allowed to assist because Missouri law makes it extremely difficult for doctors, nurses and other health-care professionals to offer free services.

“We did send the vehicle up there,” said RAM founder Stan Brock. “Unfortunately, it was not allowed to do anything because we did not have a Missouri-licensed optometrist and opticians available to do the work.”

In May, state legislators passed the Volunteer Health Services Act, which would have allowed health professionals licensed in other states to offer free care in Missouri and also would have relaxed medical malpractice liability for volunteer health workers.

Gov. Jay Nixon vetoed the bill last month, writing that the VHSA “is unnecessary given that Missouri already has a system in place that encourages volunteerism.”

Missouri-licensed health workers can volunteer in free clinics, and the attorney general provides legal representation in the event of a malpractice claim.

But even with the free clinics, there is still a massive need for medical services that goes unmet.

“Existing Missouri clinics are enough to meet the needs of the needy?” asked Patrick Ishmael, a policy analyst at free market think tank Show-Me Institute, in an e-mail. “Would the needy agree with the governor?”

Hundreds of health care professionals provide free dental, vision and general medical care to more than 1,000 people who would otherwise go without treatment at a typical RAM event. Sometimes patients arrive 24 to 36 hours early to reserve a place in line.

“It is really a tragedy to see these people in the condition that they are,” Brock said. “We get a lot of requests from folks in Missouri.”

But providing volunteers with “blanket immunity” from liability would be “bad public policy,” Nixon wrote in his veto message.

Sharon Jones, deputy director of the Missouri Association of Trial Attorneys, which initially opposed the bill, said “even in times of emergency people need to be careful and they need to be responsible. If you harm someone, you should still be held responsible for the harm that you’ve caused.”

But the bill doesn’t actually grant blanket immunity. Trial lawyers stopped actively working against the legislation after language was added providing for civil penalties if health workers engage in “willful misconduct” or a “gross deviation from the ordinary standard of care,” Jones said.

At least seven other states, including Tennessee, Virginia and Illinois, have eased regulatory hurdles that prevent volunteers from providing medical services. If the quality of health care in those states has suffered, no one has noticed.

“Remote Area Medical has seen over half a million — way over half a million — patients,” Brock said. “We’ve had something like 80,000 volunteers in the field and we’ve done 700 of these special events — we’ve got one in progress down in Texas as we speak — and we’ve never identified an incompetent practitioner. How many more patients do we have to see … before somebody will believe that it really is safe to allow doctors to cross state lines? We’re talking free care here at no cost to the government or the taxpayer. So what’s the big problem?”

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Ted S.||

    But it's the libertarians who have no empathy.

  • Juice||

    Your comment reminds me of someone telling me that there was some local government program that tried to help the elderly who can't pay property tax so they won't be thrown out of their houses. That was an example of the government helping people, and libertarians aren't lining up to help these people pay more property tax so it's the government that's empathetic and not those selfish libertarians.

  • Bean Counter||

    I am 65 years old and live in a county with just such a program. Even though my wife and I still work full time and make over 80K, we are eligible for half off our property tax. A young couple trying to raise 3 kids on half our income is NOT eligible. Thus, in the name of compassion, a relatively prosperous couple is subsidized by a couple fighting to stay above the poverty line. That's REAL compassionate.

  • Agammamon||

    Yeah, well those young ingrates don't vote no do they.

    Its like the lottery says - you can't win if you don't play.

  • some guy||

    The problem is that politicians have too much empathy, see? They have so much empathy that they can't just let anyone provide medical care to the needy. They know the needy are willing to wait for the best medical care, no matter how long it takes to get or how much it costs.

  • Almanian!||

    The government sometimes loves us too much, and crushes us, like a child crushing his pet chicken so it stays small.

    All your needs are belong to us.

  • Bryan C||

    You know, I had a little friend once— but he don't move no more!

  • MappRapp||

    Dude has no idea whats going on man.

    www.Privacy-Rox.tk

  • Doctor Whom||

    This blatant example of market failure shows the need for more government involvement in health care.

  • ||

    Wow, that's twisted. Have lived in MO nearly all my life and had no idea this was going on.

  • John Galt||

    Pesky Republican messing with Missouri's medieval medical guild system.

  • Concerned Citizen||

    Protectionism for volunteer???
    WTF?

  • Concerned Citizen||

    "volunteers"

  • Polo Ralph Lauren outlet||

    I agree with the argument downstairs, we can not sit still, we can not lose our
    peace. We want our troops in Darfur to use force to enforce the peace and defend
    Even my beauty fleeting, and I have my life blue as the sea, there is no right to change my dream, nothing can change my right to pursue an ideal, and I do what I dream, I enjoy it beautiful dream
    Nike Free Run
    Nike Free kopen
    Nike Free 5.0
    Nike Free Run dames

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Progressive Puritans: From e-cigs to sex classifieds, the once transgressive left wants to criminalize fun.
  • Port Authoritarians: Chris Christie’s Bridgegate scandal
  • The Menace of Secret Government: Obama’s proposed intelligence reforms don’t safeguard civil liberties

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement