Creation Myths

Does innovation require intellectual property rights?

The most forceful performance at last year's Grammy ceremony was a speech by Michael Greene, then president of the National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences. Speaking not long after the 9/11 attacks, Greene gravely warned of a worldwide threat -- "pervasive, out of control, and oh so criminal" -- and implored his audience to "em-brace this life-and-death issue."

Greene was not referring to international terrorism. "The most insidious virus in our midst," he said sternly, "is the illegal downloading of music on the Net."

Greene's sermon may have been a bit overwrought, but he's not alone in his fears. During the last decade, the captains of many industries -- music, movies, publishing, software, pharmaceuticals -- have railed against the "piracy" of their profits. Copyright and patent protections have been breached by new technologies that quickly copy and distribute their products to mass markets. And as quickly as a producer figures a way to encrypt a DVD or software program to prevent duplication, some hacker in Seattle, Reykjavik, or Manila figures a way around it.

The music industry has tried to squelch the threat, most conspicuously by suing Napster, the wildly popular Internet service that matched patrons with the songs they wanted, allowing them to download digital music files without charge. Napster lost the lawsuit and was liquidated, while similar services survive.

But the struggle over Napster-like services has accented a much broader issue: How does an economy best promote innovation? Do patents and copyrights nurture or stifle it? Have we gone too far in protecting intellectual property?

In a paper that has gained wide attention (and caught serious flak) for challenging the conventional wisdom, economists Michele Boldrin and David K. Levine answer the final question with a resounding yes. Copyrights, patents, and similar government-granted rights serve only to reinforce monopoly control, with its attendant damages of inefficiently high prices, low quantities, and stifled future innovation, they write in "Perfectly Competitive Innovation," a report published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. More to the point, they argue, economic theory shows that perfectly competitive markets are entirely capable of rewarding (and thereby stimulating) innovation, making copyrights and patents superfluous and wasteful.

Reactions to the paper have been mixed. Robert Solow, the MIT economist who won a Nobel Prize in 1987 for his work on growth theory, wrote Boldrin and Levine a letter calling the paper "an eye-opener" and making suggestions for further refinements. Danny Quah of the London School of Economics calls their analysis "an important and profound development" that "seeks to overturn nearly half a century of formal economic thinking on intellectual property." But UCLA economist Benjamin Klein finds their work "unrealistic," and Paul Romer, a Stanford economist whose path-breaking development of new growth theory is the focus of much of Boldrin and Levine's critique, considers their logic flawed and their assumptions implausible.

"We're not claiming to have invented anything new, really," says Boldrin. "We're recognizing something that we think has been around ever since there has been innovation. In fact, patents and copyrights are a very recent distortion." Even so, they're working against a well-established conventional wisdom that has sanctioned if not embraced intellectual property rights, and theirs is a decidedly uphill battle.

The Conventional Wisdom

In the 1950s Solow showed that technological change was a primary source of economic growth, but his models treated that change as a given determined by elements beyond pure economic forces. In the 1960s Kenneth Arrow, Karl Shell, and William Nordhaus analyzed the relationship between markets and technological change. They concluded that free markets might fail to bring about optimal levels of innovation.

In a landmark 1962 article, Arrow gave three reasons why perfect competition might fail to allocate resources optimally in the case of invention. "We expect a free enterprise economy to underinvest in invention and research (as compared with an ideal)," he wrote, "because it is risky, because the product can be appropriated only to a limited extent, and because of increasing returns in use."

Risk does seem a clear roadblock to investment in technological change. Will all the hours and dollars spent on research and development result in a profitable product? Is the payoff worth the risk? The uncertainty of success diminishes the desire to try. Much of Arrow's article examines economic means of dealing with uncertainty, none of them completely successful.

The second problem, what economists call inappropriability, is the divergence between social and private benefit -- in this case, the difference between the benefit society would reap from an invention and the benefit reaped by the inventor. Will I try to invent the wheel if all humanity would benefit immeasurably from my invention but I'd get only $1,000? Maybe not. Property rights, well-defined, help address the issue.

The third obstacle is indivisibility. The problem here is that the act of invention involves a substantial upfront expenditure (of time or money) before a single unit of the song, formula, or book exists. But thereafter, copies can be made at a fraction of the cost. Such indivisibilities result in dramatically increasing returns to scale: If a $1 million investment in research and development results in just one unit of an invention, the prototype, a $2 million expenditure could result in the prototype plus thousands or millions of duplicates.

This is a great problem to have, but perfect competition doesn't deal well with increasing returns to scale. With free markets and no barriers to entry, products are priced at their marginal cost (that is, the cost of the latest copy), and that price simply won't cover the huge initial outlay -- that is, the large indivisibility that is necessary to create the prototype. Inventors will have no financial incentive for bringing their inventions to reality, and society will be denied the benefits.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • ||

    I think downloading music from net illegally is an crime. Its really impacting the income and profits of both music industry and government. This act should be prohibited. Else the day will come, when every musical industry will run into loss which can be impacted both local and global market. Warms and regards indie songs

  • ||

    This post does a great job providing Information on a technical subject. Thank you for explaining the concept, I will forward the answer to my colleagues.Dog Bad Breath

  • Internetradio||

    Thank you for the clear words bro. Im totally your oppinion. So long.. sry for my bad english, im german. Internetradio

  • Jenniferr1||

    This has probably one of my best articles in the whole wide world. You really outdone yourself this time mate. quotes about death of a loved one

  • ||

    This is really an awesome information. I do think that downloading music from net is really an illegal act. Its really hamper the the business of music company which adversely act the global economy. Regards Ear Hearing Aids

  • Prawo Jazdy Bielsko-Biała ||

    What are You talking about.

  • Prawo Jazdy Bielsko-Biała ||

  • ||

    i bought an ipod and i had to pay an extra 25 dollars even though they haven't proven beyond a reasonable doubt that I have been using illegal mp3's. When i wrote to complain, i got this stupid response saying that i would do something illegal even though i wouldn't. Backlinks

  • ||

    i bought an ipod and i had to pay an extra 25 dollars even though they haven't proven beyond a reasonable doubt that I have been using illegal mp3's. When i wrote to complain, i got this stupid response saying that i would do something illegal even though i wouldn't. Backlinks

  • ||

    I think pirates are just smarter, more industrious people in general.
    They're usually on the cutting edge of culture, as well as technology, and often make more than regular people. piano recordings

  • ||

    Thanks a lot for a bunch of good tips. I look forward to reading more on the topic in the future. Keep up the good work! This blog is going to be great resource. Love reading it. pilates workouts

  • MIke||

    One illegal song download does not equal one sale less. In most cases it means you wouldn't buy it anyway if it wasn't available to "try". I said it before, I downloaded few popular songs to see what the fuss was all about, I didn't like it, I deleted the files, it's the same as going to a music store, asking to listen to the album, if you like it you buy it. this page

  • ||

    I have to agree with mike.. the same things are said about cracked iPhone/iPad apps now. Maybe for every 10/20 or more downloads you "might" have lost a sale.. people who find things free often would not have bought it anyway.. but.. they do give free advertising to the product.. I have found today that artists are finding more creative ways of making money of their material anyway. I hear top hit songs already in commercials and television programs.. while they're STILL on the radio.. it's interesting. PLNDR Coupons - mannequin

  • MIke||

    @greg - you might be right, BUT.. should we say that stealing a candy bar for the quickmart is not illegal as long as you wouldn't have taken it if had to pay for it? Think about it.. unique antiques
    Greg, grout stain guy

  • ||

    I really couldn't agree with you more about this. People are so far removed from what they are doing that I think maybe they loose sight. Caretaker Pool Systems - Social Bookmarks Eintragen

  • ||

    The second problem, what economists call inappropriability, is the divergence between social and private benefit -- in this case, the difference between the benefit society would reap from an invention and the benefit reaped by the inventor. Will I try to invent the wheel if all humanity would benefit immeasurably from my invention but I'd get only $1,000? car shipping instant quote
    Maybe not. Property rights, well-defined, help address the issue.

  • Cody||

    This is quite true and unfortunate. I work with developers all the time and they get quite frustrated and often throw in the towel because many people think that anything web or creative related is GPL open source by default just because it's accessible or crackable. IDK what to think anymore.

  • ||

    MIke has really got a point. There are real people putting real effort behind these things that we are just 'taking' mostly just because we can so easily and the mask that 'everyones does it'. We've become removed from the crime that we are committing. I wouldn't want someone stealing football shirts from my website. Immaterial things are the same as material things. Stealing is stealing.

  • ||

    I think this is really a great article. I think you have to protect your thoughts or inventions especially in today's society. People will steal your idea in a heart beat.

    Thanks Suzy Reynolds
    Mental Math

  • ||

    Intellectual Property Rights have been a big issue for a long time...it seems that foreign companies don't have to play by the rules like USA based companies.
    Josie...
    Los Angeles Travel Services

  • ||

    I think this is really a great article. I think you have to protect your thoughts or inventions especially in today's society. People will steal your idea in a heart beat.

    Touch Screen Laptop

  • ads||

    This is really an awesome information.
    thanks for this inform. article
    bbq | ads

  • Heilerschule||

    downloading music from internet is really an illegal act.
    Heilerschule

  • Tk||

    Garbage in, garbage out. Music leaves you lost anyway. I think its a shame that music is so readily available. The point of dowloadable music being illegal increases the feelings of shame and furthermore lowlife mentality. Music TK Anyway, thanks for letting me share my thoughts.

  • ||

    I couldn't agree more

  • ||

    I think creation myths are alot of fun. I also think its great how each group of people on this earth has their own beliefs. I really enjoyed your post and hopefully I can read more of this great website.

    Thanks John
    Maui Vacation Rentals Expert

  • Tom J||

    I think downloading music from net illegally is an crime. Its really impacting the backlinks income and profits of both music industry and government.

  • ||

    for a while now,Intellectual Property Rights have been a big challenge ...
    foreign companies don't play the same Usa companies rules
    Extending Wireless Network | linksys e1000 setup

  • ||

    I love to read these great creation myths they are so very interesting and fun to read. I really appreciate this great post. San Francisco Wedding Photography

  • ||

    This is really a great post. I am a huge fan and I am really excited to see that we are looking at some of these myths.

    Thanks Isabella Miller
    Get ex back

  • longgr||

     I love it,Excellent article.I am decide to put this into use one of these days.Thank you for sharing this.To Your Success!
    propylene glycol suppliers

  • kidslong||

    Excellent article.I am decide to put this into use one of these days
    "http://www.mono-propylene-glycol.com/">propylene glycol

  • kidslong||

    Excellent article.I am decide to put this into use one of these days
    "http://www.mono-propylene-glycol.com">propylene glycol

  • kidslong||

    "http://www.mono-propylene-glycol.com/">
    propylene glycol

  • kidslong||

    I love to read these great creation myths they are so very
    interesting and fun to read. I really appreciate this great post.

    San Francisco Wedding Photography

  • Gregory Haralson||

    Gregory Haralson found this article to be of interest

  • ||

    I have always loved this magazine as this always updated with awesome articles and pics!

    I would love more to visit it!


    Embroidered shirts

    Designer Shirts

  • ||

    I was looking for some interesting posts and this was awesome!

    Embroidered shirts


    Designer Shirts

  • ||

    Explores and highlights commonalities amongst stories depicting the creation of the world from several cultures.
    Regards,
    buy gold bars

  • ||

    I love to read about creation myths. Every society has there own that they really believe in. This is really amazing to me. I really enjoyed this.

    Thanks Brooke Rader
    Search Engine Optimization

  • Pink Ring||

    With that whole "current value" thing and the inventor being paid the value of what they expect the sales to be...that's just insanity? How could you possibly predict how well something is going to sell?

  • John Smith||

    I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the comment here!

  • ||

    I think this is the only reason why governing agencies from round the world are targeting to make internet as their sole property.

    Downloading over internet is so high as there are many countries which don't consider this as illegal. Don't want to take the name of such countries but this needs something done from every end of this world wedding

  • nfl jerseys||

    dhjf

  • mt4 indicators||

    One illegal song download does not equal one sale less, many people that illegally download 1 song may not be willing to pay for an entire album

  • mold testing kits||

    even if you don't want an entire album in most cases individual songs can be purchased via itunes

  • Sheepskin Boots Sale||

    Bailey Trio button calls for the margin of any puppet stop aggressive and baptize aerosol repellent spray stain. Chase on spraying these Ugg Boots Online Store boots ugg boots friendly alternatives to make sure you can, at least, Uggs Australia Outlet in addition

  • Sheepskin Boots Sale||

    Cheap women Uggs access has become quite acceptable to articulate an architecture addiction for men and ladies adult warning beforehand how the 2000's. In recognition of history, 2008, Women Uggs grew surprise has already been added in the acceptance of male

  • Sheepskin Boots Sale||

    global application on behalf of Ambassador Ugg Boots Online Store , Deckers is accountable to the purchasers of the confusion absorption device, which are governed by surprise Australian producers and sellers use to Ugg Boots Outlet boots amplitude affidavit added

  • ||

    También se puede utilizar para prevenir o retardar la progresión de ántrax después de la exposición. farmacia online

  • PLNDRDiscount||

    I'm confused as to what is indefinitely considered as intellectual property these. It's such an ambiguous term...

    PLNDR Discount

  • Moncler ||

    This is a very intriguing post, I was looking for this knowledge. dJust so you know I found your web site when I was searching for blogs like mine

  • bpo consulting||

    With free markets and no barriers to entry, products are priced at their marginal cost

  • Kredit schufafrei||

    I still not understand why Napster was liquidated.. That was the start in the century!

  • Potensmedel||

    It was a shame, that a startup company like napster was terminated by the gov. :-( sad story.

  • Ramona||

    Great article. Very smart! I love it. Thank you, very much! Douglas Clement is my favorite journalist from Reason.
    Essay Writing service

  • Craig Morton||

    With free markets and no barriers to entry, products are priced at their marginal cost.
    Computer Repairs

  • Geranium||

    This is really a great post. I am a huge fan geranium essential oil and I am really excited to see that we are looking at some of these myths.

  • Yago||

    wisdom is important.nice site

  • Yago||

    hope everything goes better

  • shawnlee896||

    This is really a great post. I am a huge fan geranium essential oil and I am really excited to see that we are looking at some of these myths.

  • Sir Walter||

    I wonder how the priates would feel if it was them loosing there hard work and lively hood

  • Bobby Jona||

    Great post shared here. Great article and thanks for sharing this post.

  • ||

    Napster was a great company. The start of sharing information and music. Napster was the beginning of everything! Online Horoskop

  • ||

    What about limewire and so on. How can they exist? Why are they still surviving?

    Ausflugsziele

  • Mark||

    I think this is really a great article. I think you have to protect your thoughts or inventions especially in today's society. Lifted trucks for sale People will steal your idea in a heart beat.

  • ||

    Thank you, very much! Douglas Clement is my favorite journalist Online Horoskop

  • rims financing||

    I’ve desired to post about something similar to this on one of my blogs and this has given me an idea. I’ve really found out a great deal studying this site. Plainly especially excellent content here.

  • IRS Lawyer||

    This site is very interesting and also great. I'm glad to find out this ste immediately. It's very informative.

  • Prawo Jazdy Bielsko-Biała ||

    This was a great talk on grammy after nine eleven

  • caven||

    I have to agree with mike.. the same things are said about cracked iPhone/iPad apps now. Maybe for every 10/20 or more downloads you "might" have lost a sale.. people who find things free often would not have bought it anyway.. but.. they do give free advertising to the product..
    jersey wholesale
    cheap jerseys shop

  • undermount kitchen sinks||

    I will always give a nice thrust look in to you from my bookmark feed. Coffee I don't actually comment and don't like to spend time in typing the comment. But here I have to do this because this deserves a good like.

  • Porno||

    Moi j'adore voir et télécharger du bon porno gratuit avec de bonnes chaudasses qui aiment la bite.

  • tax relief||

    Keep your eye on the DC prize, and stay safe. When there's war, there's money, but you have to wait til you get out of the Suck to start earning it.

  • ||

    I really liked looking at your current producing!. Highly rated material. I will propose that you post content more usually. Using this method, obtaining this sort of sort of a handy internet site I do think you may list greater online. Forerunner 610 Review & supplements Good

  • ポールスミス||

    lly. Using this method, obtaining this sort

  • neil||

    At the end of the day music is free on the radio so whats the difference i think pop stars and record companys make quite enough dont you?

  • モンクレール||

    I really liked looking at your current producing!. Highly rated material. I will propose that you post content more usually.

  • قبلة الوداع||

    thank u

  • منتديات العراق||

  • www.iphone-5-release.net||

    www.iphone-5-release.net | We Are The Top Source of Up To Date News, Information, and Rumors About the iPhone 5, iPhone 6. Our Team Updates You Hourly So You Are Always Informed.(http://iphone-5-release.net/) iphone 5

  • ||

    iphone-6-release.com

  • jahid||

    i like this article and this article is very good and informative. i wish that everyone will like it.

  • Printing||

    This seems to have attracted a lot of attention.

  • unlock pdf||

    I love Iphone unlock pdf

  • CheapJerseys||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.

  • New Look Discount Code||

    I'm lost with IP

  • ||

    Its very helpful for me and my friends. I Will Share This With Another to Provide Them A Very useful information.
    Quản lý Nhân sự,
    Phần mềm quản lý nhân sự tiền lương

  • ||

    I have to agree with Anon, it’s really unfair to those of us not in the pre-release program. I keep seeing all you Adobe Evangelists proclaiming the awesomeness of CS5, and announcing all the cool apps you’ve submitted to the App store. Meanwhile, we get to sit idly by, losing money and getting it rubbed in our noses.
    Phần mềm nhân sự

  • ||

    This may be obvious - but I've been looking and can't figure it out. On the chart, there's a section for cervix with three kinds of dots, one is solid, the other is medium and the last is the largest and they are labeled F, M, and S. I have no clue what this is referring to. Help!
    * bao ve
    * bảo vệ

  • ||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.
    thanh lap doanh nghiep
    thanh lap cty

  • ||

    Its very helpful for me and my friends. I Will Share This With Another to Provide Them A Very useful information.
    thành lập doanh nghiệp
    *dich vu ke toan

  • ||

    I have to agree with Anon, it’s really unfair to those of us not in the pre-release program. I keep seeing all you Adobe Evangelists proclaiming the awesomeness of CS5, and announcing all the cool apps you’ve submitted to the App store. Meanwhile, we get to sit idly by, losing money and getting it rubbed in our noses.
    dịch vụ kế toán
    bao cao thue

  • ||

    This seems to have attracted a lot of attention.
    báo cáo thuế
    tu van thanh lap cong ty

  • ||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.
    thành lập công ty
    thanh lap cong ty tnhh

  • ||

    i like this article and this article is very good and informative. i wish that everyone will like it.
    Dịch vụ thành lập công ty
    Dich vu thanh lap cong ty

  • ||

    I have to agree with Anon, it’s really unfair to those of us not in the pre-release program. I keep seeing all you Adobe Evangelists proclaiming the awesomeness of CS5, and announcing all the cool apps you’ve submitted to the App store. Meanwhile, we get to sit idly by, losing money and getting it rubbed
    Dịch vụ thành lập doanh nghiệp
    dich vu thanh lap doanh nghiep

  • ||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and usefu
    cach thanh lap cong ty
    dich vu ke toan

  • ||

    I have to agree with Anon, it’s really unfair to those of us not in the pre-release program. I keep seeing all you Adobe Evangelists proclaiming the awesomeness of CS5, and announcing all the cool apps you’ve submitted to the App store. Meanwhile, we get to sit idly by, losing money and getting it rubbed in our noses
    dịch vụ kế toán
    thanh lap cong ty co phan

  • ||

    Its very helpful for me and my friends. I Will Share This With Another to Provide Them A Very useful information.
    thanh lap cong ty
    thành lập công ty

  • ||

    This seems to have attracted a lot of attention.
    qui trinh thanh lap cong ty
    qui trinh thanh lap cong ty

  • ||

    I have to agree with Anon, it’s really unfair to those of us not in the pre-release program. I keep seeing all you Adobe Evangelists proclaiming the awesomeness of CS5, and announcing all the cool apps you’ve submitted to the App store. Meanwhile, we get to sit idly by, losing money and getting it rubbed in our noses
    tu van thanh lap cong ty
    dieu kien thanh lap cong ty

  • ||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.
    thanh lap cty
    cach thanh lap cong ty

  • ||

    i have a Bryson and a Nolan.. my 3rd boy is due in 8wks.. i want to name him Griffin (it seems to be getting more poplular in our area tho, and i cant stand that!! but we are having a hard time agreeing on any other N ending names.. i love Jensen and Kellen husbby isn't a fan, he likes Morgan, but we have a girl relative with that name) :(
    quay ke
    ke sieu thi

  • ||

    I have to agree with Anon, it’s really unfair to those of us not in the pre-release program. I keep seeing all you Adobe Evangelists proclaiming the awesomeness of CS5, and announcing all the cool apps you’ve submitted to the App store. Meanwhile, we get to sit idly by, losing money and getting it rubbed in our noses.
    báo cáo thuế
    bao cao thue

  • ||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful
    Đại Lý Thuế
    dai ly thue

  • ||

    Its very helpful for me and my friends. I Will Share This With Another to Provide Them A Very useful information.
    dai ly thue
    đại lý thuế

  • ||

    i have a Bryson and a Nolan.. my 3rd boy is due in 8wks.. i want to name him Griffin (it seems to be getting more poplular in our area tho, and i cant stand that!! but we are having a hard time agreeing on any other N ending names.. i love Jensen and Kellen husbby isn't a fan, he likes Morgan, but we have a girl relative with that name
    dang ky kinh doanh

  • ||

    It feels nice every time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something.I like whenever i read your article.You express in a very friendly manner.That's very nice of you.
    * dich vu bao ve
    * cong ty bao ve

  • ||

    Basically, I am trying to develop a debbuger plugin (something like the debug option on the youtube player). Its nothing fancy really, I got on the first frame the labels and dynamic text fields. On the second layer (actions layer) I've got the vars:* công ty bảo vệ
    * noithat

  • ||

    What you write and share is pretty good. Thanks for posting.
    * noithathoaphat
    * noithatnhapngoai

  • ||

    Subscribe to our newsletter to receive useful SEO tips, tricks, strategies, free ebooks that are available only to our subscribers and get this amazing SEO guide for free! * noithatdailoan
    * noithatvanphong

  • ||

    I found this advice helpful. I'm compiling on OSX with Flash Builder 4 installed. I chose to use the Flex 3.5.0 sdk and found the best way to avoid errors because of spaces in the file path is to:
    * noithatfami
    * nha khoa

  • ||

    We're testing flowplayer as we'd like to use it on our production site.* thành lập doanh nghiệp
    * dich vu ke toan

  • New Houses in York||

    I get lost with IP and when it applies and doesn't apply. We could do with some clear guidelines

  • bảo vệ||

  • bảo vệ||

  • ||

    We're testing flowplayer as we'd like to use it on our production site.
    Phần mềm nhân sự,
    Quản lý Nhân sự

  • ||

    I get lost with IP and when it applies and doesn't apply. We could do with some clear guidelines
    ke sieu thi,
    quay ke

  • ||

    Subscribe to our newsletter to receive useful SEO tips, tricks, strategies, free ebooks that are available only to our subscribers and get this amazing SEO guide for free!

    Phần mềm quản lý nhân sự tiền lương

  • packers||

    glad to read the articles, got many ideas here. Thank you

  • packers||

    Your post is really good and informative. I'm surprised that your post has not gotten any good quality, genuine comments. You have done a great job by posting this article.Thanks !!!

  • Cheap Vikings Jerseys||

    Thanks very much, the blogs' content are very useful for me.

  • Vikings Jerseys||

    Thanks for writing such a great post. It is really good and attractive blog.

  • Minnesota Vikings Shop||

    This blog is wonderful. There are many nice article. Thanks!

  • Cheap Minnesota Vikings Jersey||

    Perfect! I am sure that this post will be very much helpful for people.

  • Vikings Jerseys Sale||

    Thanks! I love this article very much.

  • Cheap Vikings Jerseys||

    Nowadays everyone seems to go to extremes to either drive home their views or suggest that anyone else in the world is wrong.

  • Minnesota Vikings Jerseys Sale||

    Useful! Thank you for your accurate and relevant insights.

  • Minnesota Vikings Shop||

    The blog is good very great, I would like to share with my friends.

  • NFL Jerseys For Sale||

    Cool! I love this blog, thank very much.

  • Cheap Jerseys For Sale||

    Nice blog, I would like to bookmarke it.

  • Dallas Cowboys Jerseys||

    fdgdf

  • Denver Broncos Jerseys||

    xgdf

  • Detroit Lions Jerseys||

    fgchfg

  • Miami Dolphins Jerseys||

    cv bv

  • Minnesota Vikings Jerseys||

    fgcfghfh

  • Cheap NCAA Jerseys||

    dfgd

  • New England Patriots Jerseys||

    dfxgdfg

  • New York Giants Jerseys||

    gdfxgdf

  • Philadelphia Eagles Jerseys||

    fgc

  • Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys||

    fdxgdf

  • Cheap Vikings Jerseys||

    Thanks very much, the blogs' content are very useful for me.

  • Vikings Jerseys||

    Thanks for writing such a great post. It is really good and attractive blog.

  • Minnesota Vikings Shop||

    This blog is wonderful. There are many nice article. Thanks!

  • Cheap Minnesota Vikings Jersey||

    Perfect! I am sure that this post will be very much helpful for people.

  • Vikings Jerseys Sale||

    Thanks! I love this article very much.

  • Cheap Minnesota Vikings Jersey||

    Very good article, thanks for posting it.

  • Cheap Vikings Jerseys||

    Nowadays everyone seems to go to extremes to either drive home their views or suggest that anyone else in the world is wrong.

  • Minnesota Vikings Jerseys Sale||

    Useful! Thank you for your accurate and relevant insights.

  • Minnesota Vikings Shop||

    The blog is good very great, I would like to share with my friends.

  • NFL Jerseys For Sale||

    Cool! I love this blog, thank very much.

  • Cheap Jerseys For Sale||

    Nice blog, I would like to bookmarke it.

  • MLB Throwback Jerseys||

    I love this blog. I was going through some blogs to read something interesting.

  • MLB Jerseys Cheap||

    Great! Thanks for making such a cool post which is really very well written.

  • MLB Shop||

    So useful and knowledgeable article, I love it, thanks very much.

  • ||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.
    Discount Hcg

  • ||

    Your post is really good and informative. I'm surprised that your post has not gotten any good quality, genuine comments. You have done a great job by posting this article.Thanks !!!
    cheap car insurance

  • ||

    Viens passer un moment de détente avec une..
    Webcam Sexy

  • NFL Womens Jerseys||

    fdgdf

  • Colts Super Bowl Jerseys||

    fdgdf

  • Colts Super Bowl Jerseys||

    fgxhdfh

  • Dallas Cowboys Jerseys||

    zsdf

  • Dallas Houston Oilers JJerseys||

    fghcfg

  • Miami Dolphins Jerseys||

    fdgdf

  • Online Business Listings||

    This is a very intriguing post, I was looking for this knowledge. dJust so you know I found your web site when I was searching for blogs like mine

  • cheapJerseys||

    We Sale Cheap Jerseys ,Buy Cheap NFL Jerseys, MLB Jerseys, NBA Jerseys,NHL Jerseys Wholesale From USA Authentic Quality.
    We Sale Cheap Jerseys ,Buy Cheap NFL Jerseys, MLB Jerseys, NBA Jerseys,NHL Jerseys Wholesale From USA Authentic Quality.

  • Unlock PDF||

    HI! Thanks for a great post!)))
    Its long-ago, but useful really.
    By the way, if you can't remember your PDF password, PDF unlock app is what you need! Using PDF unlocker you can print, copy, and edit your protected PDF files again.

  • microwavedbritain.co.uk||

    Plenty of people, myself included, have issues with that. If your excuse is that Spring, which does far more, is simpler and thus can support previous versions and Tapestry cannot...well...clearly Tapestry is not the tool for me.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    It feels nice every time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something.I like whenever i read your article.You express in a very friendly manner.That's very nice of you.

  • Wholesale Soccer Jerseys||

    I love to read these great creation myths they are so very interesting and fun to read. I really appreciate this great post.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    Nice one, Thank you for this. It has been bugging me for weeks

  • Brainetics||

    I have never seen the blog so exclusive and with such a great content. I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    Thanks for great guidelines!

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    I can see that you are putting a lot of time and effort into your blog and detailed articles! I am deeply in love with every single piece of information you post here (there are not many quality blogs left .

  • Web Explore||

    Plenty of people, myself included, have issues with that. If your excuse is that Spring, which does far more, is simpler and thus can support previous versions and Tapestry cannot...well...clearly Tapestry is not the tool for me.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    It is a great pleasure reading your blog and get some useful tips in this field of activity.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    I have never seen the blog so exclusive and with such a great content. I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful. Keep up the good work.

  • Cheap Jerseys||

    dfsgdf

  • Colts Super Bowl Jerseys||

    fdgdf

  • Arizona Cardinals Jerseys||

    fgfd

  • Online Listings||

    I have never seen the blog so exclusive and with such a great content. I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • prepaid telefoons||

    This post does a great job providing Information on a technical subject. Thank you for explaining the concept, I will forward the answer to my colleagues

  • Premium Web Directory||

    I certainly enjoyed the way you explore your experience and knowledge of the subject! Keep up on it. Thanks for sharing the info!

  • ||

    i have a Bryson and a Nolan.. my 3rd boy is due in 8wks.. i want to name him Griffin (it seems to be getting more poplular in our area tho, and i cant stand that!! but we are having a hard time agreeing on any other N ending names.. i love Jensen and Kellen husbby isn't a fan, he likes Morgan, but we have a girl relative with that name ged training

  • PKR Bonus||

    I can see that you are putting a lot of time and effort into your blog and detailed articles! I am deeply in love with every single piece of information you post here (there are not many quality blogs left .

  • apartamento indaiatuba||

    Plenty of people, myself included, have issues with that. If your excuse is that Spring, which does far more, is simpler and thus can support previous versions and Tapestry cannot.

  • cheapJerseys||

    I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • optimizacija||

    It is illegal i think if you do it this way. Very nice post and great blog with some very nice articles and comments. Best regards to webmasters and commenters
    honeymoon packages and sports travel agency australia

  • Online Listings ||

    Your writer shows your pain of production and hardwork. Rattling awesom. Protect on try.

  • Louis Vuittion Clothing||

    The article very surprised to me! Your writing is good. In this I learned a lot! Thank you! Share with us the good times.
    http://www.onestopclothingshop.com/

  • Golf GPS Review||

    I consider this post as one of the best post ever. It is one of a kind. I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge. Keep it up!!!!

  • singer 9960||

    The author has written an excellent article. You have made your point and there is not much to argue about. It is like the following universal truth that you can not argue with: No truth is universal, everything has its exception. Thanks for the info

  • Cheap Cpanel Hosting||

    I have never seen the blog so exclusive and with such a great content. I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • cheap jordan 2U||

    I also have never seen such a good post before, and I appreciate your article, it is awesome!

  • cash for phones||

    This is a very intriguing post, I was looking for this knowledge. dJust so you know I found your web site when I was searching for blogs like mine

  • tham tu||

    I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • con ty tham tu||

    many thanks, have a nice day

  • agência web||

    The article very surprised to me! Your writing is good. In this I learned a lot! Thank you! Share with us the good times.

  • agências digitais||

    I consider this post as one of the best post ever. It is one of a kind. I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge. Keep it up!!!!

  • Business Directory||

    The article very surprised to me! Your writing is good. In this I learned a lot! Thank you! Share with us the good times.

  • Kool Web Directory||

    I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge.

  • Directory Listings ||

    t is one of a kind. I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge. Keep it up!!!!

  • Business Directory||

    I consider this post as one of the best post ever. It is one of a kind. I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content.
    Business Directory

  • kuenstliche Vagina||

    t's great to see someone explore this part of history! Most know Genghis Khan as powerful and cruel...nay don't realize his accomplishments and the size of the empire he created! Thanks for sharing.

  • quality sexy lingerie||

    It will be a long process, but we are hoping, with the support of the public and people of Mongolia, we can to help preserve their cultural heritage.

  • Online Business Directory||

    I’ve desired to post about something similar to this on one of my blogs and this has given me an idea. I’ve really found out a great deal studying this site. Plainly especially excellent content here.
    Online Business Directory

  • franklin||

    Im glad to see that people are actually writing about this issue in such a smart way, showing us all different sides to it.

  • Web Listings||

    I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge.

  • Online Business Directory||

    I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge.

  • ||

    Great post! I'm actually getting ready to do more ezine marketing and finding this information is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here just how valuable information you've got handyortung kostenlos

  • Dig Marks||

    The article very surprised to me! Your writing is good. In this I learned a lot! Thank you! Share with us the good times.

  • Business Directory||

    t is one of a kind. I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs. Your such a lucky one to have this gift basket of knowledge. Keep it up!!!!

  • Directory Listings ||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

  • Business Directory ||

    Very nice post and great blog with some very nice articles and comments.

  • Great Listings ||

    I'm actually getting ready to do more ezine marketing and finding this information is very helpful my friend.

  • Bright Directory ||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.
    Bright Directory

  • Directory Scape ||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.
    Directory Scape

  • Immobilier Location||

    Merci pour votre info

  • Business Directory||

    They wanted to break up some of the interview footage and use animation to emphasise certain story points. It was very much a collaborative process, lots of back and forth trying to figure out how best to visualise each scene. Really pleased with how it turned out.

    Business Directory

  • Top Directory||

    footage and use animation to emphasise certain story points. It was very much a collaborative process, lots of back and forth trying to figure out how best to visualise each scene. Really pleased with how it turned out...

  • Business Directory||

    I wasn't interested in academics so left school early to study graphic design, then when I graduated, my first job was with a motion design company, so I started animating. I'm always trying to learn new things and push myself into unknown areas, lately I've been spending a lot of time developing myself as a filmmaker.
    Business Directory

  • Online Business Directory||

    Very nice post and great blog with some very nice articles and comments.
    Online Business Directory

  • Web Listings||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

    Web Listings

  • Web Listings||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

    Web Listings

  • Web Listings||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

    Web Listings

  • Web Listings||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

    Web Listings

  • Web Listings||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

    Web Listings

  • Web Listings||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

    Web Listings

  • Online Business Directory||

    That you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs....
    Online Business Directory

  • Editors Directory ||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.

  • Online Business Listings ||

    Very nice post and great blog with some very nice articles and comments. Best regards to webmasters and commenters.

  • Premium Web Directory ||

    when I graduated, my first job was with a motion design company, so I started animating. I'm always trying to learn new things and push myself into unknown areas.

  • spotlight1||

    I really admire the important ideas that you offer in the content. I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs.
    Orlando Audio Visual

  • ||

    This was a great article that really was really helpful to me and I really cant wait to learn more from your valuable experience. This was really very interesting to me. Thanks.
    handyortung kostenlos

  • marry||

    i am not spam,This was a great article that really was really helpful to me and I really cant wait to learn more from your valuable experience.
    women nfl jerseys

  • http://www.myguaranteedpaydayl||

    I graduated, my first job was with a motion design company, so I started animating. I'm always trying to learn new things and push myself into unknown areas...

  • myquickpaydayloans.co.uk ||

    It was very much a collaborative process, lots of back and forth trying to figure out how best to visualise each scene. Really pleased with how it turned out....

    myquickpaydayloans.co.uk

  • ||

    Great topic! parkeren bij schiphol

  • bestsamedaypaydayloans.co.uk||

    I am looking forward for more important thoughts and more blogs....
    bestsamedaypaydayloans.co.uk

  • mynocreditcheckpaydayloans.co.||

    Very nice post and great blog with some very nice articles and comments. Best regards to webmasters and commenters.
    mynocreditcheckpaydayloans.co.uk

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    It feels nice every time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something.I like whenever i read your article.You express in a very friendly manner.That's very nice of you.

  • Wholesale Soccer Jerseys||

    I love to read these great creation myths they are so very interesting and fun to read. I really appreciate this great post.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    Nice one, Thank you for this. It has been bugging me for weeks

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    Thanks for great guidelines!

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    I really enjoy reading the articles on this blog. I'll bookmark this so I can read more later.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    I can see that you are putting a lot of time and effort into your blog and detailed articles! I am deeply in love with every single piece of information you post here (there are not many quality blogs left .

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    I have never seen the blog so exclusive and with such a great content. I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful. Keep up the good work.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    Hey guys, thanks for taking the time to build this website for us readers.

  • NFL Football Jerseys Sale||

    I can’t wait to use this on my up and coming project. Thank you for a wonderful Tutorial.

  • MLB Baseball Jerseys Sale||

    This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful. Keep up the good work.

  • NBA Basketball Jerseys Sale||

    This is really amazing to me. I really enjoyed this.

  • pounds til payday||

    I started animating. I'm always trying to learn new things and push myself into unknown areas....
    pounds til payday

  • yes loans||

    This is really amazing to me. I really enjoyed this.
    yes loans

  • yes loans||

    This is really amazing to me. I really enjoyed this.
    yes loans

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    It feels nice every time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something.I like whenever i read your article.You express in a very friendly manner.That's very nice of you.

  • Wholesale Soccer Jerseys||

    I love to read these great creation myths they are so very interesting and fun to read. I really appreciate this great post.

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    Nice one, Thank you for this. It has been bugging me for weeks

  • Cheap Soccer Jerseys||

    Thanks for great guidelines!

  • Hochzeitsfotograf Zuerich||

    I really cant wait to learn more from your valuable experience. This was really very interesting to me...

    Hochzeitsfotograf Zuerich

  • Premium Web Directory||

    I have never seen the blog so exclusive and with such a great content. I think it will earn thousands for you in the future.

  • Business Bookmarking ||

    He always kept talking about this. I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read.

  • click here to make pancakes ||

    It feels nice every time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something.I like whenever i read your article.You express in a very friendly manner...

    click here to make pancakes

  • click here to make pancakes||

    I like whenever i read your article.You express in a very friendly manner.That's very nice of you.

  • pension loans||

    It was very much a collaborative process, lots of back and forth trying to figure out how best to visualise each scene. Really pleased with how it turned out...

    pension loans

  • pension loan ||

    here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something.I like whenever i read your article.///...

    pension loan

  • pension loans||

    It feels nice every time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something...

    pay day loan online

  • Best Essay Writing Service||

    I appreciate your efforts to make a good discussion here on this topic. It brings possibilities to find and move with some new ideas.

    All the best

    best essay writing service

  • Facebook Status Updates||

    Interesting post and keep it up :)

    Funny facebook updates

  • cigarettes sales||

    time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something..

    cigarette sales

  • Premium Web Directory||

    Very efficiently written information. It will be priceless to anybody who uses it, together with myself. Sustain the good work – for positive i will try extra posts.

  • ADIL KHATRI||

  • Business Directory||

    It feels nice every time you come here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something...

  • Premium Directory||

    here and share your experiences that keeps me feel as if i am being part of something.I like whenever i read your article.You express in a very friendly manner...

  • Directory Listings||

    The visual material shown right here is actually of very substantial quality. I'm going to utilize this internet site much more often pertaining to ip addresses......

  • cheap coach bags||

    good

  • ||

    I love to read these great creation myths they are so very interesting and fun to read. I really appreciate this great post.
    venta de computadoras

  • bảo vệ||

    Some good tips I didn't know.

  • bao ve||

    I really liked your article, containing much information that is useful to others.
    thanks for everything

  • cheap corsets||

    Although it is not brand name,wholesale lingerie can be very sexy. Most companies offer a variety of lingerie including bridal lingerie, chemise, thongs, bras, garters, corsets, panties, and others. Wholesale lingerie companies generally provide products for resale businesses. Some companies will not sell to you unless you give them proof that you have a business.

  • seobtspro||

    Thanks for posting this informative article. I haven't any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post.
    Saigon hotel

  • Share tips||

    Thank you writing this useful post. I have zero keyword to understand this article.....Really i am impressed created by article.

  • cam sexy||

    Viens essayer une webcam sexy sur notre blog adulte...

  • missjime||

    afterwards 2006, jiangsu UGG become the added bigger accretion base, jiangsu hand-made industry has one thousand years of tradition, able workmanship, with even activity assets and able able anchorage resources. Jiangsu acceptance a abounding accumulated of outstanding fur accouterment company, that we are accomplishing the European and American exchange PI cao, abounding are abutting the Ugg Boots For Women production.

  • phier||

    I really loved Michael Greene speach. I hope every one can stop piracy soon.
    Honeywell Wireless Thermostat

  • Cây Cảnh Nam Toàn||

    Thank a lot

  • Cây Cảnh Nam Toàn||

    Thanks

  • minhtruonght||

    Thank you writing this useful post. I have zero keyword to understand this article.....Really i am impressed created by article. Visit Your website : bảo hộ logo, đăng ký bảo hộ logo

  • mnwebdesign||

    thanks for informative sharing! I think you have to protect your thoughts or inventions especially in today's society. People will steal your idea in a heart beat. Keep up your working on that!

  • ||

    This article has some great and useful information about this subject. Thank you for sharing it in an easy to read and understandable format. Thanks for sharing this great information. Houston Web Design | Austin Web Design

  • chukyso365||

    Legalbiz chuyen cung cap chu ky so uy tin

  • Dich vu bao cao thue||


    Hotline: 0903615248-KY DUYEN CO.,LTD:

    Dich vu thanh lap doanh nghiep

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement