The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
Trump Administration Targets Iranian Christians for Deportation
They face severe persecution if deported to Iran.
Christianity Today reports that the Trump Administration is targeting Iranian Christian migrants for deportation:
On June 19, as Iran and Israel exchanged volleys of missiles and officials secretly finalized plans to dispatch American bombers to strike Iranian nuclear sites, pastor Ara Torosian published a letter to his church.
Torosian, an Iranian pastor at Cornerstone West Los Angeles, leads the church's Farsi-speaking congregation. He came to the United States as a refugee 15 years ago after being imprisoned for his faith. He has always carried in his heart a prayer, Torosian wrote: "that Iran would be free…."
But five days later, the suffering of his loved ones came suddenly very close.
On Tuesday, the pastor recorded on his phone as masked Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents arrested two of his church members on a Los Angeles sidewalk. The Iranian husband and wife had pending asylum cases, according to Torosian. They fled Iran for fear of persecution for being Christians and had been part of his congregation for about a year.
The detentions add to a growing number of church members and Christians seeking religious protection who get picked up by ICE. Often they have no apparent criminal history. In many instances, they were in the United States lawfully, complying with orders from immigration courts. ICE has traditionally not deported individuals with pending asylum petitions, who are allowed to work while their cases proceed.
If deported back to their country of origin, Iranian Christians face severe persecution at the hands of Iran's radical Islamist theocracy. That persecution has actually intensified in recent years, and includes criminalization of the promotion Christianity, and severe punishments for Christians considered to be "apostates" from Islam. This persecution makes Iranian Christians obvious candidates for asylum or refugee status (for which applicants are eligible based on persecution on the basis of religion, among other possible criteria). At the very least, those who have filed such applications must not be deported until those applications have gotten proper consideration.
I'm old enough to remember a time when conservative Republicans saw themselves as defending Christians against radical Islamism. Today, a GOP administration wants to deport Christians to persecution by a radical Islamist regime. The only people Trump considers worthy of refugee status seem to be white Afrikaner South Africans. While they may have a plausible case (and I don't oppose admitting them), that of Iranian Christians - and many other severely oppressed groups - is much stronger
Sadly, this is far from the only situation where the Trump Administration seeks to deport migrants who fled oppression by the types of regimes conservative claim to especially oppose. The same story plays out in efforts to strip legal status from Afghans who fled the Taliban (including many who aided the US during the war), and Cubans, Venezuelans, and Nicaraguans who fled socialist dictatorships.
People who genuinely oppose socialism and radical Islamism would not close the doors against those regime's victims. Doing so is both unjust and harmful to the US economy (to which these immigrants contribute) and to America's struggle in the international war of ideas against these regimes. It's hard to credibly tell people we are better than these brutal despots when we callously deport their victims back to them, thereby facilitating the very oppression we claim to oppose.
