The Volokh Conspiracy

Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent

Politics

"A Lawsuit Is a Fruit Tree Planted in a Lawyer's Garden"

An Italian proverb, which I just learned yesterday.

|

The earliest reference I could find in a case is State of Illinois v. Harper & Row Publishers, Inc. (1972), but I found a 1944 newspaper reference as well, so it was known even then. My colleague Paola Sapienza confirms that it is indeed an Italian proverb, "Una causa è un albero da frutto piantato nel giardino di un avvocato."

Paola also pointed to another proverb, "Causa che pende, causa che rende." That translates to "A pending case makes money [for the lawyer]," but somewhat less precisely (and changing the focus from the lawyer to the client), as

A pending case is a spending case.