The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
Requiem for Alexei Navalny
This was written shortly after the death of Navalny (a leading Russian dissident) in a Russian prison in February, but I just heard it yesterday. The words were written by Leonid Kaganov, and the performer is the prominent Russian musician Vasia Oblomov (the stage name of Vasiliy Goncharov), who now lives in the U.S.
Here's my attempt at translation:
Now, far from here there lies an empty grave.
We waited for a miracle; well, this was it.
It spoke to us, gave us faith as a gift
By deeds and words, irony and example.For us was performed again the Biblical evil drama,
Where they heal with a word and chase the frauds from the temple,
Where to be loved by millions, they submit to the prejudged indictments,
Surrender to the Sanhedrin, to be crucified on Friday—For their not tolerating falsehood, for their passion for the cause,
And who can be surprised that the earthly body has vanished?
But the spirit will be resurrected on the screens and arises as a living icon,
And the tyrants will tremble under the thick concrete prison beds,
And the spirit will dissolve in the word, in the land of endless nonsense,
In the land of executioners and blood, in the culture of killers and prisons,
Where the thaw turns into autumn, where jokes are heard ever more rarely,
Where they do not pronounce the truth, but also for some reason slaughter it,Where the devil marches naked and it's hard not to see him,
Where the neighborhoods and the schools teach how to shut up and hate,
Where people, simple people, confused by everyday quarrels,
Don't know what will happen, and believe the sewers.And those, who saw the miracle, close their kitchen doors,
Stick needles in voodoo dolls, read the psalms and believe
That the stone in the heart of the killer, the cowardly, cold creature
Will one day stop beating and will give the world peace,And in the sky the blood clots will burst in the crimson Kremlin towers,
And the bombs will become quiet in our neighbors' fields,
And then the ballets will die down, the sons-of-bitches will run,
And the air will smell of Summer, and we can leave the chat.And like heat and water, data and gas and light,
To our homes they will pipe freedom, because you had spoken of this.
And the time will arrive, will judge, will rip the clothes from the executioners,
And this will be done with people, to whom you gave hope.
The words were reportedly written on February 19, three days after Navalny's death on Friday, February 16 ("crucified on Friday"). At the time, his body had not yet been handed over to his mother; I infer that "the earthly body has vanished" and "empty grave" refer to this. The blood clot likely refers to what was claimed to be Navalny's cause of death. The ballets may refer to Swan Lake emerging as a symbol of protest against the Russian government and perhaps even of hope for leaders' deaths. (Thanks to Yurkin0v, a translator on LyricsTranslate, whose translation and annotations I found helpful in producing this.) My apologies if I have missed some other allusions.
UPDATE: I should note that, according to a March 4 MoscowTimes.ru story, the YouTube video was blocked in Russia.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
And here is some life again:
https://skyandtelescope.org/astronomy-news/voyager-1-and-half-its-instruments-are-back-online/
Spirit lives on.
The courage of people like Navalny, contrasted with the well-fed "freedom" rhetoric of politicians we have here, who have never sacrificed so much as a chicken dinner for their beliefs, is both instructive and nauseating.
Donald Trump comes to mind as a very visible exception.
Major Bone Spurs?
Mr. Dead Soldiers Were Suckers?
Mr. What Was In It For Them?
No decent person thinks highly of Donald Trump, particularly with respect to sacrifice, altruism, patriotism, or character.
Low-education bigots and superstitious losers seem to adore him, though.
[comment deleted]
There are certain acts in the world that hard to describe in terms of normal courage. Like John McCain turning around and walking back into a POW cell. Or Navalny getting on a flight back to his Russian homeland. Neither one of them knew exactly what would happen but knew perfectly well that the odds of survival were not good. In Navalny's case pretty much zero.
He did know what Putin is and what he would do. He knew the level of corruption of the Russian legal system via its subservience to the president-for-life regime. I have a hard time emulating in my own mind his calculation of how it would be worth it. Did he really think his martyrdom would be effective? Apparently he did.
What is by far harder to understand is how we have so many Americans who, in the name of "freedom" pretty much piss on the grave of Navalny by supporting congresspeople and a convicted felon for president who are fully in for Putin. The espouse his methods. They adore his effectiveness and projection of manly power. They want the defense of Ukraine defunded in support of Putin, pretending it is infested with Nazi corruption or some other delusion they sell themselves.
And then they will turn around and insist that Biden personally walked the legal papers into court and masterminded the conviction of Trump in a perversion of the constitution. They either believe or pretend to believe that their domestic enemies "rigged the election" or at least any election Republicans lose. No. That is what Putin does. What he did to Navalny and many others like him.
And that is what Trump and his think tank backers are promising to do right here. Openly.
I am beginning to wonder if Navalny did it more for us than for his own country.
To claim that any current politicians "are fully in for Putin" shows a bias that is incapable of understanding anything deeper than "if you're not for us, you're against us."
On the surface, this song seems to be about a Russian dissident. But if you apply the right analytical tools, it actually says Trump sucks.
Of course, regimes which kill their opponents are pretty much, by definition, bad regimes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamal_Khashoggi
At least we’ve been helping out the Yemenis in their war against the evil Saudis.
Or is it the other way around?
Regimes that attempt to imprison their political opponents are also bad regimes. The only way to stop it is to elect Trump.
Why would that "stop it"? How is he supposed to be our "retribution" if he doesn't do the same thing? Are you, perhaps, legally blind?
"The presumptive Republican nominee has threatened to use the federal government to go after Biden during a second Trump administration 25 times since the start of 2023, the study found. These threats include FBI raids, investigations, indictments and even jail time.
He has also threatened or suggested that the FBI and justice department should take action against senators, judges, members of Biden’s family and even non-governmental organisations.
“He is promising to go after what he perceives to be his political enemies,” said Robert Maguire, vice-president for research and data at Crew. “He is promising to essentially weaponise the government against anyone he sees as not sufficiently loyal or who is openly opposed to him."
--------------
"Its report, the first in a series, says his attitude can be summed up in one Truth Social post from August 2023: “IF YOU GO AFTER ME, I’M COMING AFTER YOU!” Indeed, last December Trump posted a word cloud based on his speeches: the biggest word was “revenge”.
Many of his threats to Biden reflect Trump’s now familiar tactic of reversing charges against his opponents, conjuring a mirror world in which he claims they are guilty of the very offence of which he is accused.
In one post about the special counsel Jack Smith, he warned that there will be “repercussions far greater than anything that Biden or his Thugs could understand” and, if the investigations continue, it will open a “Pandora’s Box” of retribution.
In another, Trump wrote that his federal indictments are “setting a BAD precedent for yourself, Joe. The same can happen to you.” In July last year Trump reposted rally coverage quoting him that “Now the gloves are off.”"
Good. I hope Trump prosecutes Biden, Garland, Schiff, and all the other Democrats who supported these political prosecutions. Then I hope we put in some justice reforms so that it never happens again.