The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
My Forthcoming Article on "Empowering Hispanics to Vote With Their Feet"
It's part of the annual Frankel Lecture symposium in the Houston Law Review.
My forthcoming symposium article, "Empowering Hispanics to Vote With Their Feet" is now available on SSRN. It is part of the University of Houston's annual Frankel Lecture symposium, which this year focuses on the role of Hispanics in our democratic system.
My contribution applies my general ideas on democracy and foot voting to the situation of America's largest minority group. Here is the abstract:
This symposium contribution outlines the significance of foot voting for America's Hispanic population and highlights ways in which we can better empower them to "vote with their feet." People vote with their feet when they make individually decisive choices about the government policies they wish to live under, as opposed to ballot box voting, where each voter usually has an only an infinitesimally small chance of determining electoral outcomes or otherwise affecting policy. There are three major foot voting mechanisms: through international migration, by moving between jurisdictions in a federal system, and by making choices in the private sector.
Part II summarizes the advantages of foot voting over conventional ballot box voting as a mechanism of political choice. Foot voters have more meaningful opportunities to make decisive choices with a real impact on their lives, and better incentives to become well-informed. Part III outlines ways in which Hispanics often benefit from foot voting opportunities even more than most other groups in American society. This applies to both international migration and domestic foot voting. Part IV describes ways in which we can enhance both international and domestic foot voting opportunities for Hispanics. Much can be accomplished by increasing access to legal migration, legalizing the status of current undocumented migrants within the United States, and breaking down barriers to domestic interjurisdictional foot voting.
Expanding Hispanic foot voting is not merely a benefit for this group alone. Empowering them to "move to opportunity" also benefits other groups, including native-born Americans of all races. The liberty and prosperity of America's largest minority group is of obvious significance to the nation as a whole.
The piece also includes a brief explanation of why I use "Hispanic" instead of the more academically fashionable "Latinx" (a term rejected by most actual members of the group in question).
The principal Frankel Lecture was that of Prof. Rachel Moran (Texas A&M), entitled "The Perennial Eclipse: Race, Immigration, and How Latinx Count in American Politics." There is also a commentary by Prof. Joseph Fishkin (UCLA). I will post links to them when they become available online.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
IMO, the level of disconnection from basic reality displayed by continuing to advocate for even further relaxing of what remains of our borders and their control (nearly 25% of the paper) is a clear sign that not enough "bus voting" has occurred in Arlington yet. Hopefully that oversight can be addressed soon.
Yeah, people secure in the logic of their argument always advocate for needless cruelty, collective guilt, and view other humans as nothing more than instruments of spite.
Texans and other drawling, bigoted clingers figure they will not be held to account for their antisocial cruelty (sending busloads of ill-clothed people to cities at random times, refusing to coordinate provision of services with the destination jurisdictions).
These deplorable right-wing culture war casualties deserve everything that is coming to them.
It is unfortunate there will be no judgment day; I would pay extra to stand behind Abbott, Cruz, Paxton, and similar assholes and watch them stammer and cry when they reach the head of the line and try to defend their disgusting conservative conduct.
Watching some faux libertarians try to explain habitual use of vile racial slurs -- in 2023 and 2024 -- would be entertaining, too.
Better Americans will impose a reckoning of sorts on these losers soon enough.
They could air drop them...
Just as the culture war's winners -- the modern liberal-libertarian mainstream -- could start to position progress sideways when shoving it down the throats of the culture war's conservative casualties.
No rule obligates better Americans to be magnanimous in victory toward disaffected conservative losers.
Or, you could skip the hand-wringing invective and stick with more reality-grounded lingo such as "minimizing externalities" and "spreading the [alleged] wealth."
I think the bus thing is great... if it weren't just a kidnapping-based political stunt.
Give immigrants a bus ride to their destination of choice.
Good grief. This is what you come up with in response to "skip the hand-wringing invective"?
kidnapping
noun
1. The act of stealing, abducting, or carrying off a human being forcibly.
2. The unlawful act of capturing and carrying away a person against their will and holding them in false imprisonment.
3. The crime of taking a person against their will, sometimes for ransom.
Please share your intended definition and post video -- there should be plenty by now!
Give them a bus ride back to where they came from.
Simpler: Somin argues for non-Americans to take advantage of stupid Americans.
Ilya Hates America -- and should go back to where he came from.
You are both shitty at baseline being American.
Ilya can take you with him.
why do you consider having asylum seekers helped to get to Arlington needlessly cruel?
LoB is aiming at making Prof. Somin specifically miserable because of what he posts on the Internet. Which is really dumb. But of course he's not the only person in the mix here.
It's kidnapping, it's fucking with infrastructure not expecting or made for these people, and it's all based on Internet posting?
It's bad, Careless.
See my reply to Randal above.
Inflammatory talk is cheap. Back it up or pipe down.
Open wider, clinger. And hope better Americans continue to be lenient with the culture war's conservative roadkill.
well they're going to make somewhere miserable in these numbers. it seems least cruel to inflict it on those who asked for it.
And no, voluntary bus rides aren't kidnapping
Ilya the Lesser in Poland, circa September 1939: "the Germans and Russians are just voting with their feet!"
Count on Somin to advocate whatever is bad for the USA.
Like the Germans, the Hispanics just want "living space."
Hispanics are Nazis.
Hence the machine guns, I guess.
You can't possibly be stupid enough not to see the similarity.
What you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
You stole a movie line and think that's a valid response. Do better.
The Spic Span! https://youtu.be/a47dmb7wOl0?si=LsqJEYb5rnATNDLv
"The piece also includes a brief explanation of why I use “Hispanic” instead of the more academically fashionable “Latinx” "
Is any explanation necessary?
Apparently to Rachel Moran, former Dean of UCLAW
Yes. Somin offends Americans at every opportunity, so he wants to explain that he is trying not to offend Mexicans.
He doesn't offend me, because I can disagree with people and not call them not American.
You ARE an American, you're just like the worst at it of anyone I've seen.
Are you sure he's not a Russian bot? What would a Russian bot do differently?
Bad news.
His handle links to his blog. It goes back to 2002.
Wow. He's even more of an antisemite than he expresses here.
No, just that someone is bad at it...you above:
"You are both shitty at baseline being American."
Glass houses, tomato, tomahto.