The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
2021 Saw Most Cops Killed Feloniously on the Job since 9/11
FBI Director Wray on "The Cops Who Didn't Come Home"
Murder rates are up. Apparently cop-killing is as well.
From an op-ed in today's Wall Street Journal by FBI Director Christopher Wray:
Baltimore Police Officer Keona Holley, ambushed while alone in her car, died on Christmas Eve. Five days later in Illinois, Wayne County Sheriff's Deputy Sean Riley was killed during a call for assistance. On Dec. 30, also in Illinois, Bradley Police Department Sgt. Marlene Rittmanic was shot while attempting to locate the owner of dogs left in a car. And on New Year's Eve, Cleveland Police Officer Shane Bartek was killed in an attempted carjacking.
These four murders brought the total number of officers feloniously killed in the line of duty in 2021 to 73, the highest annual number since the 9/11 attacks. That's the equivalent of one officer murdered every five days. In a year when homicides and violent crime reached distressing levels, this 20-year high hasn't received the attention it deserves.
Especially troubling is that a record number of officers killed—nearly half—had no engagement with their assailant before the attack.
The full op-ed is here.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I'd rather see Prof. Adler's independent take rather than trust what comes out of the FBI.
You think some of these cops are actually still alive?
Piss off.
Okay, what part of "what c[ame] out of the FBI" here are you skeptical about?
The part where yo mama.
No, but I'm not sure I'd take the FBI's word for it on how/why they died.
100% the fault of the scumbag lawyer profession and of the lawyer party, the Democrat Party.
It’s odd then that their unions aren’t protesting against the use of Kevlar vests like they do for vaccines…
https://www.npr.org/2022/01/12/1072411820/law-enforcement-deaths-2021-covid
BS that all covid deaths are counted as line-of-duty.
In my anesthesiology group, 25 physicians 20 nurse anesthetists, we are the most in the patient's face that any group can be.
Anyone with covid over the past 2 years can easily track the source back to non-work exposures; after all, non-work time and time we let our guard down outnumbers work time 4 to 1.
You don't get covid when tasing someone.
You've convinced me. It's high time the police start killing more civilians!
Well I have to agree, but just a select few.
It kind of funny, Ashlee Babbitt was a righteous shoot we are told, but why wasn't that the rules of engagement throughout the summer riots?
Why yes, overthrowing the government and yelling at cops are exactly the same thing.
Reminder: The CA murders and the attack on the police station were false-flag operations by right-wing terrorists:
https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/boogaloo-bois-member-charged-attack-minneapolis-police-building/story?id=73789955
So you're telling me wall to wall narratives of cops being vicious thugs slaughtering blacks and we need less law enforcement and criminals are heroes has consequences? Nahhhh...all this must be do to.......uh......WHITE SUPREMACY! And maybe climate change too...Yeah thats it
Your reading and analytical skills remain nonexistent.
Poor marxist twat, maybe you need your sarcasm detector adjusted. Sorry, but adding "the patriarchy"" those are the go to excuses for you leftists for everything under the sun including sunburns.
I don't believe ACAB. However, there are some who are.
Like the thug Sheriff's deputy who smacked some kid around with his baton after the kid asked the cop where they were taking his arrested friend, got a BS answer after which the kid said something derogatory to the cop. The cop was subsequently found guilty of assault and was removed from the force (against the Sheriff's wishes).
Some of these folks are certainly low grade psychopaths who should not be trusted with any position of authority.
Personally I generally have a negative to neutral view of police. And I think it attracts a lot of powertrippers. However, from all the evidence cops simply abuse their authority with whoever happens to be around. Labeling it as a racial phenomenon misses the point.
" However, from all the evidence cops simply abuse their authority with whoever happens to be around. "
That is precisely the stupid, uninformed position an "often libertarian," White, male, 'colorblind,' right-wing blog is inclined to cultivate.
This is why you lose, clingers.
Yes and no. If you are a police officer, "whoever happens to be around" is far more likely to be a young black male than a wealthy white stockbroker, so even if the police aren't any more racist than the general population, it could still have a substantial negative race-based impact.
Though I suspect the police as a group probably are more racist than the general population.
All parts of the truth matter. Even if the black community did need extra stuff for police brutality you'd certainly want to get the precise root causes correct.
Remove the race and your post becomes more accurate. Stockbroker and young and poor are what actually mattered.
Race isn't the only inappropriate factor police have traditionally considered in the context of abusing their position.
Just out of law school, driving a crappy car but living in an upscale neighborhood, I was pulled over repeatedly. When I began to drive BMWs, the stops stopped.
Race generally seems to trump apparent wealth, however, in this context. A Black friend continued to recount traffic stops before, during, and after his term as managing partner at a law firm whose annual revenues are approaching $2 billion.
Progress continues along this line, but those who deny a substantial racial problem in this context are wrong, and for unattractive reasons.
I got pulled over driving a nice Lexus in a Latino neighborhood that I had to drive through to get to a nicer smaller neighborhood for a Christmas dinner. The stop ended quickly once they realized I wasn’t “liquored up” looking for prostitutes and cocaine, or maybe they just spotted a Black guy driving a car. 😉
I had a Lexus for a few years at introduction. Too "soft" a ride for my taste, but a nice car, and I can't recall being stopped (for no reason) in that Lexus.
Oh I don't know. I was once young, poor and white, and while I had some interactions with the police, it wasn't nearly like what happened to young poor black males.
So in Chicago, with over 800 homicides how many were killed by police? one percent? Pretty much shows where the problem is.
Yep, White Supremacy if the local Leftists are to be taken seriously.
The OpEd page of the WSJ might seem like the mainstream but how far do stories like these travel outside of the middle aged right of center college educated male demographic? I'm not sure its very far. I'm guessing the rest of the media buries it.
I believe the report also said that Covid19 caused the most deaths of police. Police officer stopping a car or entering a house don't know if the person they are seeking is armed. They also don't know if that person has Covid19. Unlike the public they cannot walk away in either case.
I am also troubled that I did not see mention of officer suicides mentioned. Even though this has gotten more attention this year.
The media black out of murders that were straight up hits on cops was astounding. I used to have an article that listed all of them from that year, but can't find it now. If I do I will post the link. But, if you want to know how the media handled these, just search the NYT archives.
Media blackout? The figures were released today, so far as I can tell, 13 days after yearend. Director Wray chose to start coverage with an opinion article he wrote, for publication in today's Wall Street Journal. Criticism concerning other publishers' handling of the story, or a "blackout," would be more reasonable in a day or two.
Progressive policies like “defund the police” are extremely unpopular and why Republicans overperformed in 2020 and why everyone has known since Election Day that Republicans would take back Congress even though conservatism is almost as unpopular as progressivism. Trump getting a$$raped by McConnell and Ryan and boomer generals and then inexplicably governing as a hyper partisan Freedom Caucus Republican was a huge missed opportunity for America.
Conservatism is so unpopular in today's America -- especially among educated, successful, reasoning communities and audiences -- that some people avoid use of the term conservative and try to use "often libertarian" or "libertarianish" instead.
Liberalism is so unpopular in today's America--especially among educated, successful, reasoning communities and audiences--that some people avoid use of the term liberal and try to use "common sense" or "Progressive" instead.
Fixed it for ya, "Rev"
Just for the record, Cleveland Police Officer Shane Bartek was not on duty.
So which groups killed the most cops and what group did each victim belong to. the press is quick to id the race of a cop involved in killing someone so can we have it both ways?
Politics is not Burger King; you get the progressive way, or you don't get it all.
Culture wars have consequences. Is that surprising or troublesome?
I'm thinking lots of Afros and names with apostrophes.
Paywalled = WSJ
I can't read the piece, but the Officer Down page has slightly different/higher statistics (but same ballpark). But (and I don't know if the op/ed mentions it since I can't read it) Covid killed far more cops than people did.
Maybe they should focus their ire on police unions that fought against vaccine mandates.
84 too many killed by human felons, 301 killed by SARS COV 2.
https://nleomf.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/2021-EOY-Fatality-Report-Final-web.pdf
We can work on both, and must, but it's clear what offers the best return on investment. It's not there today, but the Officer Down Memorial Page used to have a banner urging police to get vaccinated to protect themselves and their fellow officers. The general population should do the same.