The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
A Radio Interview on Academic Freedom
WBUR's On Point dedicated an hour to a discussion of the threat to academic freedom on college campuses
I recently appeared on WBUR's radio talk show On Point hosted by Meghna Chakrabarti. The episode allowed for a wide ranging discussion of threats to academic freedom on college campuses and to the efforts of organizations like the Academic Freedom Alliance, which I chair, to push back.
Among the topics of discussion were the cases of Steven Salaita at the University of Illinois, Donna Hughes at the University of Rhode Island, and Tom Smith at the University of San Diego and the recent wave of "anti-CRT" legislation in the states.
From the interview:
I would hope the country as a whole gets better, as well, about tolerating dissent and the free expression of ideas. Universities ought to be leaders on that front. They ought to serve as an example that it's possible to tolerate people who disagree with you, and actually engage them constructively. And so it's terrible [that] universities, instead of being models for that kind of civil discourse, instead become models for cancel culture.
Moreover, if universities become places where certain ideas can't be explored constructively and with due diligence, the result is our scholarship will be worse, our education will be worse. We will not actually learn the truth about things. We will not understand the world as well as we should. And society as a whole will be worse off as a consequence because we won't be pushing forward the boundaries of human knowledge, which is what universities ought to be doing.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Didn't listen to the interview yet, but did you mention Beverly Gage at Yale?
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/30/arts/yale-grand-strategy-resignation.html
All woke schools should lose their tax exemption. They are doing indoctrination not education, the main purpose of the exemption.
Princeton is very woke. Defund it. De-accredit it. Shut it down. Start by making them pay all taxes. including local taxes. Their endowment rocketed up this year, with our tax exempt dollars. Half of that endowment belongs to the taxpayer. It should be retrieved. We are sick of these privileged elite school. All they do in return for their privilege is run down our country.
Clem. Courteous to sum up the points of an article that requires payment. There is no chance of ever sending money to the vile NY Times.
These things seem to go in cycles.
As someone put it during the last cycle, in 1990, the academy used to be the acknowledged place where you could engage in the free exchange of ideas. Now it's about the only place you can't. Time Magazine did a cover story on this at the time, called "Thought Police".
Tennessippians don't send their kids to college anyway (cause you know; education = BAD), so what's the problem?
Just go to Sunday school and ALL your questions and prayers will be resolved.
Bigot
C'mon - I'm agreeing with you guys here.
I mean it is true that the Lord will guide us onto the righteous path, um, right?
A handy guide to how to make your prayers come true.
Typical bigot Artie shows up, makes no sense, calls it a day
If you could not enjoy that one, there may be no hope for you.
Here is another version.
So the Univ of Tennessee and Vanderbilt don't exist in your cognitive dissonance?
No throwing shade on Vanderbilt.
OTOH, as we used to say, "Nothing sucks like a big orange."
Question for the gallery, or Prof Whittington if he bothers to read the comments:
How much of a kook or a crank do you have to be to lose your job in academia? Especially if you're being a kook in a field that you are ostensibly an expert in?
Tom Smith is a law professor, so perhaps it doesn't matter if he's on about wacky theories like flat earth, faked moon landings, etc. But suppose he started spouting off about the sovereign citizen movement, or started teaching it seriously in his class. Should tenure protect this?
The AAUP states “The controlling principle is that a faculty member’s expression of opinion as a citizen cannot constitute grounds for dismissal unless it clearly demonstrates the faculty member’s unfitness for the position.”
That sounds pretty reasonable, the problem of course is that different people will have differing opinions about what it means when applied to a specific situation.
The bigger issues might involve science.
Does someone who believes a religious text accurately describes the original of our universe, or contends that evolution is a Satanic plot, belong at the lectern in a science classroom?
Not in academia, but wouldn't the kookiness be irrelevant if followed up by sound logic and facts? You can push back against the cherry picking of facts or ignoring inconvenient factors but part of the point of academic freedom, to me at least, is to run down rabbit holes to see where they go or get them to collapse.
Sovereign citizen may be kooky because it's got a lot of wrong premises but a logical, precedent backed argument based in truth for avenues of it being utilized wouldn't be against academic freedom to me even if the likelihood of winning in court was near 0.
On the same public radio station that runs On Point, I recently caught the end of a show in which all agreed that cancel culture is fake news. Just like political correctness. And yes, they actually said that.
Looking for a way to stay up-to-date on the latest news, music, and sports? Look no further than Radiofmluisteren! This online radio service offers users a convenient way to listen to their favorite radio stations from anywhere in the world.
Whether you're at home, at work, or on the go, Radiofmluisteren makes it easy to stay connected to the programs and stations you love. With a user-friendly interface, this service offers a wide range of features that make it a must-have for any radio enthusiast.
For starters, Radiofmluisteren gives users access to over 10,000 radio stations from around the globe. So whether you're looking for a local station or one from another country, you're sure to find it here. You can also search for stations by genre or topic, so you can easily find the type of programming you're looking for.
In addition to a comprehensive station directory, Radiofmluisteren also offers a variety of other features that make it a top choice for online radio listeners. These include:
- A built-in player that allows you to listen to your selected station directly on the website
- A personalization feature that lets you create a custom list of favorite stations
- An alarm function that lets you wake up to your favorite radio station each morning
- A sleep timer that lets you set how long you want to listen to your station before falling asleep
With so many great features, it's no wonder Radiofmluisteren is the go-to choice for online radio listeners. So why not give it a try today? You'll be glad you did!