The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
Zoom Per-Speaker Timer?
I've been on many Zoom panels, and I've thought it would be good to have an easily visible speaker timer option—and maybe even one that shows the aggregate time used by each speaker during the whole panel (and not just on this particular turn). That would help remind speakers when they are going on too long, and can help moderators balance the times given to the speakers. (For webinar options, the times might be available just to the speakers and the moderator, and not to viewers at large.) Think of it as a sort of chess clock, if you're familiar with those, though Zoom would push the button for you when you start talking, and you won't lose just because your five minutes are up.
Is there such an app available on Zoom? If you've seen it operating either on Zoom or on some other platform, have you found it useful?
I should note that I don't think I tend to get shorted on time in such panels; indeed, I expect that sometimes I'm the one who goes on too long. But part of the value of such a timer would be that it can help remind speakers like me that they should be more concise, or yield time to a colleague.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Long before zoom, I kludged a solution together to solve a similar problem via Powerpoint with automation. Each minute, the slideshow transitioned to a new page showing 1 less minute remaining (then turned red and started counting up if I went too long). I put the powerpoint on a laptop facing so that the speaker could see it but the audience could not.
I'm not aware of anything built into Zoom but you could do the same thing with a shared presentation - though I think it would be visible to your audience as well.
Rossami,
I did the same thing a long time ago. But that really is not a solution for zoom as you have to capture the screen sharing.
I have never seen an app or zoom option for it, but it definitely would be useful.
Here is a suggestion to help the lawyer profession. STFU. Set the timer to zero time left. Nothing you say has the slightest value or the slightest validation in the real world. All lawyer utterances are toxic garbage that damage our nation. Every breath you take damages the economy by $1000's. Every lawyer gibberish, garbage utterance is an of converting the chattel of the public, the law, into a rent seeking theft and fraud.
Ditto for yourself.
Rip, what grade are you in, son?
I have thousands of comments in this site, and yours are the most useless. Your “thoughts” contribute absolutely nothing to the debate. But I’m sure that is your intention. Apparently your role is to be the designated asshole.
Should say “I have read thousands of comments on the site.” Everything else is true.
Rip, are you a lawyer? The lawyers understand me, but are rent seeking deniers.
Rip. Survey question: whom did you vote for President in 2020?
I understood your original comment.
https://marketplace.zoom.us/search?q=timer
Yeah, that is a regular feature to Toastmasters meetings on Zoom. All speeches are times. Speakers are given green/yellow/red warning signals.
Zoom allows you to share your screen. The audience can shrink the size of the shared screen to be as small as they like on their screens Then the shared screen only needs to show a stopwatch, or multiple stopwatches. Both the audience and the speaker can see the times.
However, if the speaker shares his screen to show slides, that won't work.
A second solution is for the timer to hold a cell phone showing a counting stopwatch up to his camera.
A third solution is for the timer to change his screen background color green/yellow/red.
A fourth creative solution is to use sweaters. The timer began with a brown sweater. Then, at the appropriate time he stripped down to a green sweater, then a yellow sweater, then a red sweater. Hot and sweaty but creative.
"Does this count against my time?" - Jeffrey Toobin
I don't know if there's such a feature in Zoom (or Webex, which I use at work). It seems problematic since I'm not sure how well it would distinguish between a speaker and someone who shows up as speaking at the same time due to background noise picked up by the microphone.
A Zoom implementation might count time for each participant while unmuted.