Canceling the Cancel Culture Deniers
If everything is cancel culture, nothing is.

In the latest Reason Roundtable, editors Matt Welch, Peter Suderman, Katherine Mangu-Ward, and Nick Gillespie discuss a recent editorial in The New York Times and a wave of laws regulating school curriculums.
1:42: The New York Times' editorial on the state of free speech in America.
24:47: Lawmakers trying to ban certain content from being taught in schools.
31:56: Weekly listener question: Who do you think was the best postwar president? P.S. Is the Western the ultimate libertarian genre?
This week's links:
- "America Has A Free Speech Problem," by the New York Times editorial board
- "Self-Cancellation, Deplatforming, and Censorship," by Nick Gillespie
- Google Trends, "Cancel Culture"
Send your questions to roundtable@reason.com. Be sure to include your social media handle and the correct pronunciation of your name.
Today's sponsors:
- Did you know opening a charitable investment account is as simple as opening a brokerage or checking account? More Americans are discovering a financial tool known as a donor-advised fund, and are using the account to maximize potential tax benefits and give to the causes they love. DonorsTrust is unique. It serves charitable givers who love our Constitution and the freedoms it protects. It's the oldest and largest donor-advised-fund provider committed to those principles. That's why more and more people are starting new funds or even moving their charitable dollars from the big national donor-advised funds. Do you want to partner with an organization that honors your values, helps streamline and grow your impact and also connects you with charities promoting individual freedom, personal responsibility and free markets? If so, visit www.donorstrust.org/reason to download our prospectus and discover whether a donor-advised fund with DonorsTrust is right for you. Find out how you can make a greater impact with your giving.
- You may not be feeling down and out and depressed, or like you're at a total
loss. But if your stress is high, if your temper is shorter than usual, or even if you're starting to feel strain in any of your relationships, you could probably use the chance to unload the stress and get it out. Talk to someone who's completely unbiased about your life. Someone who isn't going to judge you or take sides on anything. When there are things you can't tell anyone, or feel like you can't unload to family and friends, you need to unload it, and that's what therapy can be. BetterHelp is customized online therapy that offers video, phone, and even live chat sessions with your therapist, so you don't have to see anyone on camera if you don't want to. It's much more affordable than in-person therapy, and you can start communicating with your therapist in under 48 hours. Unload the stressors and get some unbiased feedback: You'd be pretty surprised at what you might gain from it. See if it's for you. This podcast is sponsored by BetterHelp, and The Reason Roundtable listeners get 10 percent off their first month at BetterHelp.com/roundtable. - Hey, New Yorkers! Are you sick and tired of cancel culture and thought police? Are you looking for live, unfettered conversations with maverick thinkers? Then come out on Monday, April 4, to see a live taping of The Reason Interview With Nick Gillespie featuring Columbia neuroscientist Carl Hart, author of Drug Use for Grown-Ups: Chasing Liberty in the Land of Fear. Doors open at 6 p.m. at Caveat Theater and Bar, 21-A Clinton Street in Manhattan's Lower East Side. Tickets cost $10. In an age when the drug war is being challenged like never before, Carl Hart is breaking bold new ground on how we think about drugs and individual freedom, even copping to his own recreational use of heroin. "I do not have a drug-use problem," he declares. "Never have…I pay my taxes, serve as a volunteer in my community…and contribute to the global community as an informed and engaged citizen." Reason's own Nick Gillespie will talk with him about that and his pathbreaking research on addiction, how he turned from an ardent supporter of the drug war to one of its leading critics, elitism within the legalization movement, and how he talks with his kids and students about responsible drug use. Go to reason.com/events for details.
Audio production by Ian Keyser
Assistant production by Adam Czarnecki
Music: "Angeline," by The Brothers Steve
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Katherine, I love you. Come to my place and I will show you my science fiction etchings. And I won't even mention the MCU. Promise.
Leftist faggot
Katherine ManGoo-Ward....?
Why are you all such fucking creeps.
I make 85 dollars each hour for working an online job at home. KLA04 I never thought I could do it but my best friend makes 10000 bucks every month working this job and she recommended me to learn more about it. The potential with this is endless.
For more detail.......... http://currentjobs64.cf
https://twitter.com/morphonios/status/1505996278072762369?t=I9hJxxH0CZ6ddEzsSsSTrg&s=19
The deputy mayor of #Dnipro, Mykhailo Lysenko, announced on his Facebook/Telegram channels that local meat packing plants would be used to wrap the dead bodies of Chechen Muslim fighters in pig skins so they can't go to heaven.
[Link]
As all infidel dogs go to heaven, does this mean they face an eternal bacon shortage?
Dogs, pigs, and us humans are all made of star-stuff and according to The Laws of Thermodynamics, that star-stuff cannot be created or destroyed.
As long as you can preserve the chemical, biological, and genetic template for pigs, bacon need never have a shortage. It's just a matter of keeping the Putins of the world out of the way. Have a BLT for me and keep up the good fight! 🙂
No one goes anywhere except The Worm's Valhalla. Your best bet is to make life better here and now on Earth and in The Natural Universe. That means stop supporting terrorist warmonger tyrants like Putin and the Saudis and stop supporting pie-in-the-sky salesmen like Patriarch Kirill and the Ayatollahs!
Think for yourself, fear nothing, and live free as long as you can...maybe forever if you can swing it!
You seem to have a lot of faith in yourself. Lean not to your own understanding.
And that faith in himself is woefully misplaced.
I'll place faith in myself over faith in Putin, Patriarch Kirill, or the God they worship that evidently allows them to do their atrocities.
Leaning on your own undersatanding and expanding that understanding is what the faculty of Reason is and what the magazine Reason too often falls short of doing.
Great.
Confession via projection.
https://twitter.com/disclosetv/status/1505983224278917131?t=WcA9GrO8fod-7dWp5rVtaA&s=19
NOW - White House: Russian government is "exploring options for potential cyberattacks" on critical infrastructure in the United States.
[Video]
https://twitter.com/nypost/status/1505988142431670272?t=F_HoiIZ2JCCghSebxOyRtw&s=19
Huge solar flare ejected from Sun could hit Earth in days, mess with power grid
[Link]
That means Putin's convoy of supply vehicles might be affected by EMP. Did you Putineers bring your Bullets, Beans, Bandages, and Bullshit Bibles?
It was nice of Biden to give Putin a list of things we'd appreciate they NOT engage in cyberattacks on.
Sadly, this is not a joke.
Is it the impetus to get us into the war then?
Biden - 'We told them not to to hit X and Y.'
On a more serious note, you are right that a solar flare can do damage to electrical and electronic equipment worldwide, but the New York Post story cited in the Tweet said:
Fortunately, the solar storm predicted for this Wednesday, March 23, is only likely to be a “G1 minor,” meaning you probably won’t even notice it if it happens.
When it becomes a direct hit more intense than a G-1, then we'll all havd reason to be concerned.
Fortunately, I do stock up on disaster commonality provisions and have and learn new Survival and Preparedness skills all the time. It would be rough doing without power but I lived through Hurricane Hugo in 1989 which did a ton of damage, so I may be better off than many and could help some with relief too.
Cancel Culture denial on the literary left has a rather serious problem with its own editorial history. The Editors and Publishers of such iconic journals as The Nation and The Paris Review head the list of those whacked from the mastheads of lefty Must Reads.
Cancel culture is nothing more than modern day book burning with a dash of social media lynching.
The cancellatti are in a snit because dead tree books are growing in rarity, and an awful lot of kindling is needed to keep bytes li on a bonfire of the vanities.
The title of this article demonstrates that you just don’t get it.
We get that you'd cancel anything anybody 5hat is not you and your ilk.
Fuck off, Nazi!
Correction, since I'm not an Aryan Pure Superman:
We get that you'd cancel anything and anyone that is not you and your ilk.
Again, Fuck off, Nazi!
What makes you believe that’s true?
You've already admitted you'd outlaw every decent fishing trip for the lies people tell on the boats.
I guess Shirley Temple was lying too when she sang of her sugar-coated fantasies "On The Good Ship Lollypop" too.
And I guess you song of reply will be "Meet Me On The MS St. Louis, 'Louie."
Meanwhile, I'm whistling the Yacht Rock Anthem "Sailing" by Christopher Cross and paddling on my dinghy, The U.S.S. Fuck Off Nazi.
Jews gonna need a new religion that doesn’t advocate lying Kol Nidre boy.
What are you wastes of skin going to do when you can’t lie?
My hovercraft is full of eels.
"How would you like to come to my place, bouncy-bouncy?...My nipples explode with delight!" 🙂
This dialogue is making me Hungary! You great boff!
"If everything is cancel culture, nothing is"
What a facile, idiotic statement.
Kanye West Banned From Performing AT Grammys Due To Concerning Online Behavior
https://share.newsbreak.com/pq47iux0
Kanye West has been barred from performing at the Grammy Awards due to his "concerning online behavior," a rep for the artist confirms to Variety. Reps for the Recording Academy and CBS, which present the Grammys, did not immediately respond to Variety's requests for comment on the claim early Saturday.
I guess his Thousand Mile Stare burned a hole in somebody's camera lens and the electronic guts beneath it, so they couldn't take chances.
American Boys are dangerously unpredictable…
Someone claims anti-CRT laws banning using the 1619 Project means you can't talk about historical events in ways that make certain people feel bad. What a terrible mischaracterization of reality.
The 1619 Project is demonstrably false. So the ban is preventing false propaganda from being taught as fact. It's not clear to me why Reasoners support lies being taught in schools. But when one political party has so captured the education system that it politically indoctrinating students it's clearly time to overrule them.
This seems very much like using federal forces to overrule state and local governments which enforced Jim Crow. When one level of government becomes sufficiently corrupt the level above it is obligated to intervene.
I despise Critical Race Theory as much as I despise Communism and Nazism, as they are all Collectivist ideologies. However, instead of "There Oughtta Be A Law..." which is another Collectivist solution, parents would do well to teach children how to use their Reason and real small-"c" critical thinking skills to question and counteract fallacies and propaganda such as Critical Race Theory.
Expecting students to correct biased teaching is absurd. It's not possible for minor students to successfully dispute the conclusions of their teachers. The only way to correct biased government teaching is with government.
I'm surprised libertarians aren't more supportive of ostracism. "Dude - you're a dick and you need to apologize or leave" is a cornerstone of freedom. Behavior has consequences and if people don't want to associate with you as a result of your behavior, they don't have to.
I'm honestly stunned at what passes for coherent thought these days.