Kenny Xu: The Growing Attacks on Asian American Excellence
The Inconvenient Minority author and head of Color Us United says it's time for the country to become truly colorblind.

Kenny Xu is the president of the nonprofit Color Us United, which advocates "for a race-blind America" and the author of An Inconvenient Minority: The Attack on Asian American Excellence and the Fight for Meritocracy. He's also a Robert Novak fellow at The Fund for American Studies.
Xu is the son of Chinese immigrants. Some of the most interesting parts of his book retell his experiences grappling with failing to live up to model-minority expectations. Just 24 years old, he writes passionately about the long history of legal discrimination against Chinese and Japanese people in America and what he says are increasingly harsh attacks on traditional definitions of merit and achievement that disproportionately hurt Asian Americans. He's a critic of Harvard's controversial admissions practices, which he says discriminate against Asians in an ill-fated attempt to pump up representation by blacks and Latinos.
In a fiery and intense conversation with Nick Gillespie, Xu also talks about the roles of religion and family in his life and the life of the Asian American community more broadly.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Yellow Privilege?
If you ask the darker POC types, yup.
>> increasingly harsh attacks on traditional definitions of merit and achievement that disproportionately hurt Asian Americans
by whom?
Colleges and hiring powers-that-be, especially when hiring for Government Almighty positions, or positions in which Government Almighty is heavily involved... Which are becoming more and more prevalent! Any day now, you'll have to get Government Almighty permission to hire or contract your own fingernails to scratch your own ass!!!
>>powers-that-be
ya is where I was going with it ...
TDS-addled spastic asshole forgets we had a POTUS who made some successful efforts at reducing those requirements, but TDS-addled assholes commonly do.
>by whom?
Nice code talk, you anti-Semitic prick!
Uh, Harvey, know your history. Jews were targeted by quotas in academia a century ago. and Anglos were the powers-that-be back then and still have a big toe-hold. What happening with Asians is basically a replay.
Take up yoùr beef with Rev. Artie. He's the one who rhapsodizes these upper-crust Ivy League scions of the bigotry of stick-up-the-ass-edness.
Booker T Washington has been dead for over 100 years, and his quote on racism remains as true as ever. It's not happening this century either.
He wrote many things. Which quote are you thinking of?
There is another class of coloured people who make a business of keeping the troubles, the wrongs, and the hardships of the Negro race before the public. Having learned that they are able to make a living out of their troubles, they have grown into the settled habit of advertising their wrongs — partly because they want sympathy and partly because it pays. Some of these people do not want the Negro to lose his grievances, because they do not want to lose their jobs.
Booker T Washington was one of the profound thinkers of our nation.
Sounds like he's describing Fox News.
And you sound like a woke CRT asshole.
Because he is a woke CRT asshole.
That is a good one. I've always liked:
"A lie doesn't become truth, wrong doesn't become right, and evil doesn't become good, just because it's accepted by a majority.”
That's a really good one!
"...wrong doesn't become right, and evil doesn't become good, just because it's accepted by a majority.”
The person who said this would've objected to Lenin & Co.'s killing of "capitalists," "exploiters," and (later) "kulaks," as well as to Hitler & Co.'s killing of Jews.
In other words, they gotta keep their phoney-baloney jobs! And get a harrumph out of Big GovCo, Big Biz, Big Media, Big Tech, and Big Academia!
Harrumph!
https://youtu.be/jLO7VrRij_M
Little. Yellow. Different. Better.
Ah! Someone else remembers the Nuprin Commercials! Even this Sistah agrees:
Nuprin the little yellow different better 1990 commercial
https://youtu.be/y_AmUX88ptE
I'm surprised that Kanye West and Daft Punk from Japan didn't make a song with the ad words. They would fit perfectly into "Stronger":
Kanye West Feat. Daft Punk--"Stronger"
https://videos.sapo.pt/6hTtDP3QCIF83khbvj4o
On the contrary, we Koch / Reason libertarians should encourage our progressive allies to continue promoting their #SkinColorAboveAll mindset.
Anyone who's been paying attention to American politics should have noticed the Democrats' transition from a primarily working-class party, into the party of billionaires. It's no accident this coincided with the "Great Awokening." By viewing immigrants as Black and Brown bodies, contemporary race-focused Democrats had no choice but to embrace open borders — literally the #1 item on the wishlist of billionaires like Reason.com's benefactor Charles Koch.
#ImmigrationAboveAll
#IntersectionalityHelpsWhiteMaleBillionaires
What's with the "black and brown bodies?" Don't they have minds too? Or is it too much to grant them rationality and agency?
time for the country to become truly colorblind.
Critical Race Theory explicitly states that colorblindness is racist.
Indeed.
And don't you dare suggest CRT doesn't belong in public schools. Or else chemjeff will march into this discussion and explain how wrong you are.
#RadicalIndividualistsForRacialCollectivism
CRT can be in those publik skrool buildings. Let's just get the students out of them, into private schools, homeschool, or unschooling. Since no kids will be enrolled, the teachers and staff will have to find work in the private sector.
Agree.
Let's get government out of education.
any theory that says Dr. King *and* Sesame Street are incorrect cannot be a sound theory.
Best description of Sesame Street I have read was along the lines of "black magic enables puppets to co-exist with humans in an unnatural urban dystopia."
Haven't seen it in years, but I somehow doubt it still adheres to Dr King's philosophy anymore.
The Snuffleupagus was like God for Big Bird, since he revealed himself only to Big Bird and not to the others.
I was convinced Sesame Street was riddled with allegory.
Snuffalopagus you already have. Cookie Monster is the sin of Gluttony, and Oscar is Sloth.
Bugs Bunny is even more so, but I won't get into it. Don't want to bring the discussion board off topic.
Cookie Monster is the sin of Gluttony, and Oscar is Sloth.
Elmo is lust?
no discussion of Bugs Bunny can be considered off-topic.
Now when has that ever stopped anybody on the Comments section??? Ge ahead and derail away! 🙂
I suppose those are important, but I will dismiss CRT since it also challenges things like math, reason, cause and effect, and individual autonomy.
Oh, speaking of the left's continued program of aggressive racism, they're now quietly backing away from "LatinX" as a term.
Fuck all of you. Own it. This is all the result of a recent poll which showed that 98% of Latinos didn't like the term, and a shocking percentage said they wouldn't vote for a candidate if the word fell out of his or xer mouth.
You're not going to quietly slink away from this shit. You tried desperately to force this shit down our throats and now you're discovering it was a political loser for you and there's no pretending you never uttered it in public.
I fully agree.
It's another example of White Man's Burden that the Affluent Coastal Elite operates under. They presume to tell People of Color how to speak their own native tongue. The arrogance is staggering.
En español, los sustantivos tienen género. Te marca como un tonto.
https://translate.google.com/
Hey, I'm not the one advocating "latinx". Did you even bother to read my post?
Maybe he meant in general. Using latinx does make one sound like an idiot. Though if he were referring to you in particular, he wouldn't be wrong either.
LatinX = 10
At the very least, progressive Latinos got in bed with the rest of the woke clown car (sorry for the mixed metaphor). Perhaps they never liked Latinx but lending even passive support to the retarded woke movement deserves some nasty consequences. And many brown people have been way more than passive.
At the very least, progressive Latinos got in bed with the rest of the woke clown car
That would be the two percent in the poll that liked the term.
The metaphor works if the clown car is a camper van.
Goddammit!
*tears up shares of shipping container stock purchased in 2016*
No it's perfect. The clown car has upgraded to a massive RV, so it would have a very big and soiled bed.. In fact, each faction of Wokeism has it's own RV. Mercy sakes, they got 'em a Convoy!
C.W. McCall (Caw! Caw!)--Convoy
https://youtu.be/Sd5ZLJWQmss
I, for one, interact with many Hispanics in my store and have never heard "LatinX" used by any Hispanic people.
I have only heard it on a couple of programs on National Public Radio (even here, there's another Latino-orientated program that didn't use the term "LatinX.") And I've only seen "LatinX" in print in USA Today McPaper.
I would think that Transgender Hispanics from Latin America would use for themselves either "Latino" or "Latina," depending on the sex with which they identify themselves.
One thing's for sure: The Woke crowd have violated Saul Allinsky's strictest of Rules For Radicals: They've gone outside of the experience of the very people they want to reach!
Here's something else sad, mad, and funny (both funny ha-ha and funny ironic):
English is a merger of the Romantic family of languages--which have sex-specific Nouns-- and the Germanic family of languages--which also have sex-specific Nouns---yet English Nouns are sex-neutral!
It's like the Romantic horse and the Germanic donkey got together and made an English mule!
And yet the Anglo-Saxon male is taken as the universal archetype of the knuckle-dragging, misogynist, sexist male! What the Hell, man?
"Yet English Nouns are sex-neutral!"
Yes, one of the quirks of the English language is that only the pronouns have gender. Most European languages have three genders. Some languages have five genders. These genders are NOT references to genitalia or sexual social roles. It's just how the nouns are split up. Information theory explains why nouns have inflection.
"And yet the Anglo-Saxon male is taken as the universal archetype of the knuckle-dragging, misogynist, sexist male!"
Except the Spanish (both old world and new world variety) routinely take home the World Mysogyny Trophy. The English speaking world (outside of the scots/irish) got nothing on them. The Germans also have their share of sexist trogs, but the like Scandanavians, they like to keep hushed up and out of site.
What I don't get is why they just can't use "Latin" and "Latins". I mean, it's obvious they don't mean the language.
I think "Latin" is sometimes used to refer to people descended from the parts of Europe where Romance languages are spoke. Italians, Spaniards, etc.
I've heard "Latine" used as a gender neutral term before. It seems obviously better, both because it appears to have actually originated in Spanish speaking countries, and because it can actually be pronounced in Spanish (that's another reason "Latinx" is dumb, the letter "x" makes the "h" sound in Spanish, not the "ecks" sound!).
You are uninformed as shit about "The Spanish Language" (dipshit) and you should really just start by fixing the moronic misspelling in your handle. Thank you.
"Latin" is for specifically Latin Americans, "Chicano" is specifically Mexicans, and 'Hispanic" is for Spanish speakers everywhere, even though Spanish is a Romantic language derived from the "dead" language Latin.. I just live in this world. I didn't make the way it is.
There is already a gender neutral term for spanish heritage people.
they are Hispanic
Any Latino annoyed by a snotty little SJW trying to make him say "LatinX" should refer to the offending twerp as a "Pendejx".
-jcr
More likely, he wouldn't say anything but: "Imma cut chu, mane!" 😉
How does Kenny Xu feel about Kenny G?
“He brrows” - Kenny Xu
Not "He Bang, He Bang?"
Kenny Xi
Xu's on first.
Only if you're Lenny Bruce in a line to a Chinese restaurant. 😉
Been busy today but I just wanted to stop by and wish a festive Fuck Joe Biden to all.
On the twelfth day of Christmas, my true love sent to me
Twelve Fuck Joe Bidens
Eleven Let's Go Brandons
Ten Fuck Joe Bidens
Nine Let's Go Brandons
Eight Fuck Joe Bidens
Seven Let's Go Brandons
Six Fuck Joe Bidens
Five Let's Go Brandons
Four Fuck Joe Bidens
Three Let's Go Brandons
Two Fuck Joe Bidens and
A Hunter in a pear tree
Thanks for the holiday cheer! My family will be singing your carol around the Christmas tree this year.
Merry Fuck Be Unto Biden and a Happy Let's Go Brandon!
good
Asians. Honorary White Folk. You can sit at that table with the Jews.
Seriously though, that's what it feels like. My hometown had a bit Chinese and Japanese population. Chinese dads who came here from Hong Kong with nothing in their pockets, started a business, and had all their children attend Ivy League. Not impossible, it was common in my town. Nowadays they are being punished for that. Just like Jews were a couple of generations back.
Shame on you Asians, you should have come over on the Mayflower, same as Elizabeth Warren's ancestors...
Overseas Chinese in Viet Nam, Singapore and other Asian destinations actually filled the sociological/economic role that Jews did in medieval Europe.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Chinese
Lenny Bruce once asked a waiter at a Chinese restaurant if there were any Chinese Jews. The waiter went to the back for a few minutes, came back and said: "No Chinese Jews. Orange Jews,,,grape Jews...Tomato Jews...But no Chinese Jews!"
Wait, I thought Asians were white these days.
Pretty much anyone with some degree of success who does not dedicate their identity to victimhood--and does not embrace the entire woke dogma--is white.
And Asian hate crimes are perpetrated by..................................................................................SUVs.
I detect wrongthink.
OT: Does anybody else have this problem where they are typing a comment, and then suddenly the page scrolls up to that stupid "AnyClip" embedded video ad at the top of the comments section? This article doesn't have one, but all day I have been getting more and more frustrated as I start typing, the text-field loses focus and zips up to the video, and then I have to go searching through 300 messages again to find the comment box again.
It is driving me up a wall.
If browsing on a desktop, use ublock.
If browsing on a some mobile device, use firefox and ublock, or use brave.
You might also try umatrix.
Do note that if your mobile device is made by Apple, however, things get trickier.
colorblind may be ideal but will never happen. we are all color blind at birth. we learn because of what we are taught and from experiences in life. when we continue to have. bad experiences we cant help seeing the people for what they are. government can pass all the laws it wants and won't change how anyone feels. I was raised in a neighborhood that was mixed with every race that was in America. each day we saw a new face at our table because we had food It was only later in life I learned to discriminate. It didn't come because of color. It came from their actions. Now actions are excused by blaming everything on race. Acting in an uncivilized manner is allowed because you have been treated badly. So we continue with an eye for an eye until the nation is blind. ------Grampa
Many of the blacks claiming oppression are wealthy and highly successful.
Women live longer, are more highly educated, spend 80% of the money in the US, and suffer far less violence, yet they are supposedly an oppressed minority and have massive government programs to improve outcomes in the areas in which they are already doing better.
I don’t see why it would work any differently for Asians: they can simultaneously war earn and succeed way above average as a group and still claim that they are being “oppressed by whites” and still get favorable treatment from the government.
No, becoming colorblind it is not at all a good idea.
Instead of becoming "colorblind", how about just having a normal perspective on color? How about just acknowledging it as a fact like everything else but not assigning idiotically outsized importance to it? That would, casually, allow us to perceive natural differences and at the same time not become radical over their implications.
Someone probably said this already, but I think "colorblindness" is just another dumb, extreme reaction to the perpetual racial neurosis that apparently nobody who was born in this country can even see anymore. So that's what Americans are blind to, they're blind to their racial neurosis and the idiocy it spawns.
I think that is what "colorblind" metaphorically means. Not literal deficiency in vision, but rather, not granting color any moral or political significance. On that, I fully agree.
If you discriminate in favor of one group, you must necessarily discriminate against every other group. This should not be difficult to understand.