Lies, Cheating, and Creativity: Q&A with Behavioral Economist Dan Ariely
"Imagine you have some kind of voice within you asking, 'Am I behaving morally or not?'" says Dan Ariely, a behavioral economist and author of the book The Honest Truth About Dishonesty. "That voice sometimes is asleep."
Reason TV's Naomi Brockwell talked to Ariely at Tribeca Film Festival's Games For Change conference, where Ariely and his team set up a "Truth Box," a sort of confessional where participants could record themselves talking about a meaningful lie they'd told in their lives.
"Having to face some of your own past and some of the lies you've told… is actually a very interesting process for us as researchers and, I think, also very cleansing for the people who are participating in it," says Ariely.
Ariely studies economics by running behavioral studies in a lab setting and says he's discovered that people are less likely to lie when presented with a "moral reminder" of some sort. This can be as simple as something like a disclaimer urging participants not to lie. But he's also demonstrated that urging participants swear on the Bible or recall the Ten Commandments before running an experiment resulted in less cheating overall.
An individual's penchat for cheating, Ariely says, is determined by the balance between two conflicting desires. Most people want to gain the edge that cheating or lying might give them but also don't want to think of themselves as immoral. Ariely has uncovered through experimentation that creative people tend to cheat more on average.
"Imagine it's all about rationalization. You want to look at yourself in the mirror and feel good about it. You also want to benefit from cheating. It's all about telling stories. If you're creative, you can tell better stories, which means you can cheat a little bit more and still feel good about yourself," says Ariely.
Watch the video above for a deeper discussion about cheating, lying, and what to do about it. Approximately 7 minutes. Scroll down for downloadable versions, and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel for daily content like this.
Shot and Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Interview by Naomi Brockwell. Music by Podington Bear.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I always think of cheating when I see a Naomi video
Not me. Apparently, I'm creative because I tell myself a story that makes it not cheating: my wife agrees to a three-way with me and Naomi.
hawt.
Whenever I hear that voice in my head, I lie down until the voice passes.
I will never trust reason again.
Test.
OT: Was working in the yard this morning and don't see the morning links. Are the AM/PM links now optional or did ISIS's trained squirrel jihadis finish Iraq and moved on to the servers?
It's gone, man...it's all gone.
Geez. reason should just call it for the day, pretend tomorrow is Friday and post today's lineup. Would beat the repost fire hose they've been turning on during the last couple of weekends.
It was the Skwerlularity.
Comments were unceremoniously dumped into unmarked mass graves on Friday. Commenters rights groups are deeply concerned.
Back to Chet with an AMAZING video about otters juggling.
Thanks, jesse! I needed that.
I took the kids to the aquarium recently, and the otter was furiously masturbating right next to the glass. I ushered the kids out of there pretty quickly, but not before taking a picture.
You saw an otter masturbating at the aquarium?
I'll need to see those pics at some point.
What is it with gays and animals?
Like cougars?
I would have put it on Facebook, but you know. Co-workers, bosses, and relatives.
I told my story about the masturbating Kodiak bear, right?
You said that it was a foreshadowing event, that he looked at you and kept going.
Here's how I interpreted it: Later in life, your parents walked in on you, and you kept going.
Whoa, no. No, no, no.
Although I did have a girlfriend walk in on me once. That ended very well indeed.
The big topic in AM links was rosebudding, courtesy of SF.
Ya know what? I think I'm ok with the disappearing comments now...
It was a Jezebel article too.
What really sucks is I wore my reason t-shirt today and it dematerialized in the middle of a presentation I was giving.
Mine was suddenly clean, even though I don't do the laundry until tomorrow.
Naomi spelled backwards is "I moan."
Wow. You have done a wonderful service for the world, or at least my brain.
Dyed hair is a lie. That shade of red is a bad lie to boot.
Next time you have a voice in your head telling you to say something disparaging of Naomi, just go ahead and shut your filthy whore mouth instead.
White knight much?
Shut your mouth, babyface.
Make me.
Well, if you want to go through life with your mouth hanging open, I guess that's between you and your filthy whore god, pilgrim.
You just made the list, buddy.
Which list would that be?
Lighten up, Francis.
I don't like seeing the French win, so this blowout is painful.
I hate to say it, but the French appear to have come to this tournament to score goals and chew bubble gum, and found themselves all out of bubble gum.
I don't like seeing the French win, so this blowout is painful.
Sorry for being long-winded.
Probably the hottest girl I met in college was a red-headed French exchange student.
Deja vu to you, too.
All my comments gone forever. I'm going to sue all of you.
I can see how that would be extremely traumatic for a lawyer.
For the rest of us, however, the thought that our comments have gone the way of Lois Lerner's emails brings a great sense of relief.
Now, will the server squirrels 1) cause this post to vanish or 2) suddenly find my previous reply so that I double post?
All my comments gone forever. I'm going to sue all of you.
I would like to hire you to sue....YOU. Because you made a reference to posts which no longer exist, I am experiencing real trauma! What happened to these posts?! What funny or enlightening quip did I miss? (yeah, I admit I am stretching here) How can I be whole without the knowledge of those missing posts to which YOU informed me of their existence!
I expect a seven figure settlement offer on your desk within the week. I also expect to to be brutal with yourself in the negotiations. Show yourself no mercy!
I'd like to get in on this. Class action? The case of ProL vs. ProL! You're going to take you for all you're worth, ProL!
Either way ProL will win. Probably as defendant.
All your comments belong to us.
Sincerely, Squirrels
^are
I'm entitled to a public forum hosted at someone else's expense! I demand restitution! Damnit, listen to meeeeeeeeeeeeee
I wonder if this is a crime of some sort? You know, wire fraud? RICO? ECPA? BSA? Treason?
In memory of comments that once were, and are now no longer =
"Naomi; OMG she hawt"
Rest in peace, homie. (pours 40oz of Old English)
She brocks well.
"Is it safe?"
No my child. You're just in the eye of Hurricane Squirreltrina.
That's it... I cannot comment under these conditions
Call the weekend guy, I don't care!
SpaceX launch in less than 10 minutes!!!!!!!!!!!
http://www.spacex.com/webcast/
Welp, they aborted again.
I blame the squirrels.
Where the heller have you been all this time?
Doing stuff. I got tired of the echo chamber I guess.
heller...heller...heller...
Can you hear me?...hear me?...hear me?
'I'm not gay. I'm not gaayyy'
Last?
So not only are we not getting a new server on The Independents, we're not getting The Independents?
Someone should be getting a bit embarrassed...
Joe Arpaio is going to be on the show for the immigration section. We may all be better off.
THAT should cause embarrassment right there!
I've felt a great disturbance in the force server. As if a thousand lives comments were suddenly extinguished.
Squirrlz or malicious attack?
or mercy killing?
I think they're doing the server cutover today that they promised would tame the squirrels. The squirrels seem to be fighting for their very lives.
The national Republican party has some really razor sharp wits working for them.
Hey, guys, what happened?
Clearly Reason HQ has been over-run by Zapatista Guerrillas and their servers infected with the DERPBOLA Virus
They are trying to break the iron grip that the KOCH Organization has had on the entire internet - rigorously suppressing truths about global warming, helping maintain the fiction of 'global debt', and forcing batrooms to remain cis-gendered.
This is just step 1 in "Operation: Squirrelgeddon"
"One time I was pretty drunk with a friend at a Target buying Risk."
already we have the 'tell' of a poor fiction-writer. Its an effort to gain 'veracity' by throwing in lots of unneeded detail.
He should have stuck with the 'i'm tall, and like to fart of children'
Yeah, but the idea is original. Farting on spoiled children is genius, and I whole heartedly support the practice.
Superb.
You can listen to your spouse's call and read his texts. If you want to see what he or she does in real time, then, we can help you. We clone mobile phones. This will ensure you never miss a thing. For everything he or she does, you will always be one step ahead of the game. Feel free to contact cyberghostbusters911@gmail.com if you need our services.
"The international language of love!"
Yeah sorry, that 80s movie reference went over my head.
I'll drink to that.
A very short story that everyone should read.