MENU

Reason.com

Free Minds & Free Markets

The TSA Is Still Really Bad at Evaluating Risk

The GAO says the TSA doesn't do a good job of putting its resources where the threats are.

Michael Goulding/ZUMAPRESS/NewscomMichael Goulding/ZUMAPRESS/NewscomAs millions of Americans get a friendly holiday pat-down on their way to Grandma's house, here's a not-so-comforting reminder: The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is still really bad at the one thing it's supposed to do.

A new Government Accountability Office (GAO) report concludes, yet again, that the TSA does a poor job of assessing risk and allocating resources appropriately. Though the agency is most obvious (and most obnoxious) at airports, the TSA also plays a regulatory role in the security of America's train lines, mass transit systems, and pipelines. You're not going to see X-ray machines installed at your local metro stop—thankfully—because surface transportation operators have the primary responsibility for securing their systems.

The TSA, meanwhile, employs "surface inspectors" to enforce security regulations for freight and passenger rail. According to the GAO, the agency has not updated its comprehensive risk assessment since 2009. "Given that TSA spends only about 3 percent of its budget on surface activities, it is crucial that the agency have complete information on how resources are being used in order to best allocate these limited federal surface transportation security resources," the auditors write.

Even with the information it has, the TSA makes poor decisions. One mode of surface transportation deemed the lowest risk by TSA (the report does not specify which mode) accounts for 6 percent of domestic risk, but it received between 35 and 45 percent of the agency's attention between 2013 and 2016.

"TSA officials could not provide documentation of how and why they selected certain work plan activities to address lower risk modes, or how they monitored the extent to which implemented activities aligned with or addressed risks," the GAO finds. "As a result TSA could continue to prioritize its limited resources to lower risk surface modes, leaving fewer resources available for higher risk modes."

Remember: Assessing and countering terror risks is literally the TSA's only job.

Terrorism, even the threat of it, is scary. But it is unrealistic to expect any government agency—espescially one that routinely fails to catch knives and other weapons being smuggled through its own airport security apparatus—to stop all determined attackers. There simply aren't enough resources to cover all the potential targets and stop all potential threats. That's why risk assessment is critical, and it's why understanding of risks must evolve as threats and terror tactics do.

Bureaucracies are not exactly famous for their ability to evolve quickly. The TSA's problem likely goes well beyond the simple fact that it has not updated its comprehensive risk assessment guidelines in eight years—something the agency says it will start doing shortly. The deeper problem is that it is a sprawling, calcified government operation that was created to counter a very specific method of attack in the wake of 9/11. Terrorism today looks quite different. If the TSA cannot keep up, Congress should consider some alternatives.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Citizen X - #6||

    The TSA is what happens when you declare war on terror and then lose.

  • Old Mexican's Speedos||

    A new Government Accountability Office (GAO) report concludes, yet again, that the TSA does a poor job of assessing risk and allocating resources appropriately.


    A planet where bureaucracies are lousy at allocating resources appropriately?

    Damn you! Damn you all to hell!

  • Rich||

    The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is still really bad at the one thing it's supposed to do.

  • Rich||

    The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is still really bad at the one thing it's supposed to do.

    But think of the JOBS!

  • BYODB||

    The TSA only exists to make people feel like they're safe since we have known since their inception that they are utterly valueless at actually stopping terrorists. Random passengers have stopped more terrorism in the skies than the TSA. Fact.

  • tekxpert||

    TSA also plays a regulatory role in the security of America's train lines, mass transit systems, and pipelines.
    https://crumbles.co/best-kodi-add-ons/

  • Akhilesh Patel||

    The TSA Is Still Really Bad at Evaluating Risk Thanks for info..

    http://www.maxtoursandtravels.in/

  • Technical Support||

    The TSA has been facing this issue for along time. For any tech help visit- Geek Squad Support

  • airlinesphonenumber||

    The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is really bad. Need to do something. Apart from this, American Airlines Phone Number is a great source of hassle-free air ticket booking process. The associates at this helpline are at customer help desk for 24/7 and that too globally.

  • Nick Furie||

    If you are looking to book flight ticket with some extra benefits then quickly book your ticket with air hawaiian airlines. Call at toll free number of Hawaiian Airlines Reservations and book your ticket. You will definitely avail great deals, discounts and promo codes that would be a surplus for you. Want to avail all such benefits? reach for Hawaiian Airlines Reservations without second thought.
    1.Affordable flight booking rates
    2.Flight booking at last moment

  • Technical Support||

    Epson Printer Support is a team of technical pros who are liable for any help you may require for your gadget or device. These experts have been working from almost a decade in the same domain. Reach for their help at Epson Printer Support number accessible 24/7.

  • Technical Support||

    AOL Tech Support Phone Number covers all your AOL mail related issues. The experts at AOL Tech Support are quite proficient in dealing with your issues with ease. For any help related to AOL, contact AOL Tech Support

  • Technical Support||

    HP Printer Support is a group of experts who deals with every issue with your HP printers. These experts are proficient enough to give you the best of services. HP Support experts are quite efficient in giving repair services.

  • Technical Support||

    Dell Printer Support is a team of experts who takes care of your dell printer issue. Our support is capable of dealing with any dell printer glitches. In case you're having issue with you dell printer contact dell Printer Support and get instant help.

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online