Free Minds & Free Markets Forced to Liquidate What's Left to Pay for Employees’ Defense Against Feds

Government asset seizure destroys the ability to pay for lawyers.

Certainly a conversation starter.Craigslist adThe law may require citizens charged with crimes to be presumed innocent until proven otherwise, but the government frequently assumes in advance that these same folks’ property is guilty as sin.

So it goes with the website In August, the Department of Homeland Security assisted the New York Police Department in raiding the Manhattan offices of Rentboy, a site that helps a primarily gay audience connect with paid male escorts. There are no federal laws against prostitution. Rather, the seven workers stand accused of violating the federal Travel Act, which makes it a federal crime to use communication methods and interstate travel to violate certain state laws, prostitution being one of the triggers.

The Rentboy raid became national news and focus of some anger because it wasn’t some tiny little operation. The site is very well known in the gay community, had been around for about two decades, and there was no evidence that there was any nonconsensual sex or trafficking happening because of it. The site was very popular and was bringing in millions of dollars in revenue per year, money the federal government is now trying to seize.

And so, because the federal government has frozen its assets, Rentboy employees are now forced to sell off the property the government hasn’t already seized and beg for donations in order to pay for its own defense. They’ve put up an advertisement on Craigslist offering up all its office equipment for sale in Manhattan. You won’t find any velveteen chaise lounges on the list—the site hosted ads from escorts; it didn’t employ them. But you will find desks, monitors, file cabinets, office equipment, and apparently lots of cables.

For those who can’t make it Manhattan or don’t need old web design manuals, the father of the site’s CEO has started a defense fund to gather donations. So far he’s raised $3,200. He’s trying to get $250,000 to cover legal costs. He writes, “One thing I know is that my son is NOT a criminal. Jeff is a hard-working small businessman who built several successful companies. He employed good people who were then able to support their families. He paid taxes, gave to charitable organizations, and he gave back to his community.” Read more here.

Jacob Sullum has written for Reason about how prosecutors use asset seizure to keep citizens from being able to defend themselves from criminal charges and the terrible consequences. Read about other cases here.

Photo Credit: Craigslist

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Fist of Etiquette||

    He paid taxes, gave to charitable organizations, and he gave back to his community.

    Unfortunately, he also had assets that could be seized and used for whatever whims law enforcement had.

  • sarcasmic||

    Gave back to the community? What did he take?

  • Doctor Whom||

    He made money, didn't he? Everyone knows about the law of conservation of wealth.

  • Doctor Whom||

    Seizing assets so you can't pay for your own defense is one of the favored tools. Not even the money that you have paid to your lawyers is necessarily safe.

    On the other hand, we're being protected from, um, something that would presumably be very bad. #WithoutGovernmentWhoWould

  • wef||

    Why bother pretending the DHS and NYPD aren't enforcers for extortion and protection racketeers?

  • Diane Reynolds (Paul.)||

    Huh, founded in 1997, and it survived the Moralizing, dangerous conservative John Ashcroft. How is that even possible? Does not compute.

  • LarryA||

    and there was no evidence that there was any nonconsensual sex or trafficking happening because of it.

    DHS & NYPD: "We didn't consent to all that homo-canoodling!"


Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online