Reason.com

Free Minds & Free Markets

Free Brazil!

Meet the millennial libertarian activists who helped bring down a president.

São Paulo, March 13th, 2016.Alexandre Santos"Less Marx, More Mises" read signs held by some of the protesters who filled the streets of Brazil's cities on March 15, 2015. With a headcount estimated at more than a million, the demonstrators were calling for an end to Dilma Rousseff's disastrous populist presidency. An organization of libertarian millennials called Movimiento Brasil Libre, or the Free Brazil Movement, led the charge. With the country crippled by recession and a corruption scandal dominating the headlines, the demonstrators expressed their anger in explicitly libertarian terms.

The Free Brazil Movement is the activist wing of the country's surging libertarian movement. Founded in 2013, the group played a key role in ending 13 years of left-wing Workers' Party control.

Two months after the first massive protest, the Free Brazil Movement led a 33-day, 750-mile march from São Paulo to the federal capital of Brasilia while carrying an impeachment bill to deliver to Congress. Following another year of protests and behind-the-scenes maneuvering, lawmakers took action. On May 12, 2016, Rousseff was forced to step down on charges of secretly borrowing money from state-owned banks to paper over the government's fiscal problems.

The Free Brazil Movement's primary focus, however, is changing politics through culture. With a leadership composed mostly of filmmakers and musicians, the group operates on the theory that most people pick their political views based on a desire to fit in. Thus, the way to change the country's politics is to create a new libertarian cultural identity that allows young Brazilians to be cool without fashioning themselves lefty revolutionaries.

The group functions in part as a media outlet, feeding content to its 1.4 million Facebook followers. ("Without Facebook," says 32-year-old Co-Chief Strategist Renan Santos, "we would still have Dilma.") It regularly produces viral videos heavy on satire, scoring a major hit with a 2014 political advertisement featuring a candidate with "privatizing" laser beams shooting out of his eyes that instantaneously turned poorly run government services modern and efficient.

The Free Brazil Movement's chief spokesperson is 20-year-old Kim Kataguiri, a part-time law student who wears his hair long and clothes loose—a look that in no way resembles the "bow tie libertarians" who he says will "never convince anyone here in Brazil." Pedro Ferreira, 32, the group's other chief strategist, started his career working in marketing for the music industry. He believes the libertarian movement can learn a lot from Justin Bieber about expanding its fan base.

What follows are excerpts from interviews with Kataguiri, Santos, and Ferreira. Conducted in English, the interviews have been edited for clarity. Santos and Kataguiri were also featured in a Reason TV documentary, "How Brazil's Libertarian Movement Helped Bring Down a President," which can be found at reason.com.

Becoming Libertarians

KIM KATAGUIRI: When I was in high school, my history teacher started a debate about welfare in Brazil. He said that it was the reason behind the economic growth...and I said, "Wow, welfare really works!" And then I started searching the internet and I found the Brazilian Mises Institute [Instituto Ludwig von Mises Brasil] and the Brazilian Liberal Institute [Instituto Liberal], and I found it was not really like what my teacher was saying. So I made a YouTube video for my teacher and my classmates to show that it was not really welfare that brought prosperity to Brazil. But this video ended up spreading on the internet, and people started asking me to do more videos and [eventually I joined the] Free Brazil Movement.

PEDRO FERREIRA: My libertarianism comes from my family, actually....[My mom] had a video-making business. The labor laws are crazy. For instance: When you're going to fire someone, you have to pay a big fine. So basically, you reward bad behavior in a weird way....From the employer's perspective, it doesn't make any sense. I remember her having people that did not want to work and did not want to produce. She would complain and be really depressed. You want to fire that person because you feel like they are detrimental to the company, but you cannot afford to fire someone. In the '90s, things were looking weird for her and she wanted to fire people because she was having a hard time keeping up with their salaries, but at the same time, she would go broke if she fired them. Everything is very, very bureaucratic and complicated in Brazil....I remember when I tried to start my own company, it took me like, seriously, five months. In America, my accountant opened it for me in two days.

RENAN SANTOS: In Brazil, when you start to have your own business, you must become a libertarian....Most of the guys I met who were also trying to create jobs, [they] just got completely angry about how the state invades their lives, their companies, and their dreams. I got really, really angry with the state and one day I decided to quit what I was doing. I said, "No, no, no. This country is destroyed. I need to do something."

So I decided to open an office with other guys, who are musicians and also movie makers. And I said, "Let's think together and create some kind of aesthetic for this way of seeing the world."

Marketing Libertarian Ideas

PEDRO FERREIRA: The ways that these ideas that we hold dear are being sold to people are very boring—let's say it like that. They are trying to get people through reason, whereas liberals get people and they're very good at doing so because they work with emotions.I come in with marketing experience from the music industry. The idea behind a song is just as important—if not more important—than the song itself. People don't love Justin Bieber because of his songs; [they] love Justin Bieber because of the idea of Justin Bieber. The idea of what [Ludwig von] Mises said, of what [Murray] Rothbard said, has to be secondary. We're only going to get somewhere if people fall in love with libertarianism regardless of the song, you know? The idea of libertarianism has to be powerful and strong for people to fall in love with it. The only way you can do that is not by going balls deep in the technicalities of it, but by creating an idea that people can fall in love with.

PEDRO FERREIRA: We developed this theory of the aesthetic left. They are the majority of the cool kids. They haven't read any books of the left or anything. They don't really know why they are taking those positions, but they feel that taking those positions generates social currency for them, you know? [Opposition to the military dictatorship that ruled Brazil from 1964 to 1985] was the first moment of cultural hegemony for the left. There was really good music...as there was in America in the 1960s. [Guys like] Caetano Veloso, Gilberto Gil, [and] Chico Buarque. It's sort of [like] Bruce Springsteen protesting. You might not understand what he's standing for [but] you can go out and say, "Look, I'm just as cool as Bruce Springsteen because I am defending what he stands for."

RENAN SANTOS: If you were not part of this left, you automatically defended...dictatorship. But we created the kind of civil opposition that defends libertarian ideas, republican ideas, our system, our democracy, our values, [while] at the same time you are not a military guy who wants to do a coup. You are not a guy who hates gays.

KIM KATAGUIRI: You'll never make 205 million [Brazilians] understand any idea in a profound way. I mean, you have to make people like these ideas...I think that's the great secret....When you see someone suited with a bow tie defending lower taxes, defending less bureaucracy, you just think, "Well, this is a banker defending his own interests."...Just dress like a normal guy. You don't need to use suits or look like a banker. I mean, you...just have to look like a normal guy.

Learning From Leftist Tactics

Photo Credit: Alexandre Santos

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Ted S.||

    But Dilma Rouseff has a vagina, and it's just a coup getting rid of her!

  • Inigo Montoya||

    While I'm impressed, I can't help but wish these young people could be imported here. They've recognized the problems in their system and have worked to improve their country and culture.

    Young people here are not only idiotically left-wing, they are descending into madness with their "cultural appropriation" and rejection of science and logic. I'm not saying ALL have gone nuts, but I fear for a future where reason is viewed as woefully traditional and antiquated.

  • Anderson Nascimento Nunes||

    As a libertarian living on Brazil, I surely would like to migrate to a place like New Hampshire, USA, but because of the red tape involved in doing that, I think moving to Panama is more feasible.

  • american socialist||

    Hey Jim,

    Was this guy...

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=bgec9WX21ik

    Pedro or Renan?

    Is Brazil free now?

  • Brian||

    So in Brazil, it's hipster libertarians?

    Weird.

  • Brian||

    On that note, i have always known that socialism's worst enemy with the youth would be its own success.

    Because nothing says excitement like growing up in a world frozen in the amber your parents' generation set up for you, because they were cowards.

  • american socialist||

    Socialism is cowardly?

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosa_Luxemburg

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ People's_Protection_Units

  • Brian||

    These links: so compelling.

    Your point is crystal clear.

  • american socialist||

    Socialists have been fighting fascists, Islamists, and authoritarians for a century now. Libertarians-- at least the Ayn Rand variety-- have been aiding and abetting. It's not a record I'd associate with.

  • Brian||

    How proud you must be, for all those things you never did.

  • american socialist||

    You mean have I gotten beat up and sprayed in the face with mace by a cop at an anti war rally? Yep, been there, done that.

    I only play a small role. Giving right-wingers posing as libertarians the finger now-- rather than street battles with cops-- is where I'm at now. It's ok... I'm good.

  • Brian||

    Wow. You're practically Che.

    And, clearly concerned not of yourself, but of helping others.

    It comes through the way you talk about yourself all the time.

  • american socialist||

    I was just about to say... This article is about Brazilian politics. Roussef spent the first 4 decades of her life battling a military dictatorship. What have libertarians done? Make excuses for Donald Trump?

  • Brian||

    I get it: socialists are awesome, and libertarians are horrible.

    How convenient.

    We should all be ashamed of ourselves, shouldn't we?

  • american socialist||

    Depends on the socialist or the libertarian. I don't paint in the broadest possible of brushes like most of the Reason commentariat. I'm a peace and love socialist. What are you, Brian? You know, besides someone that gets upset-- unduly, I say--at Asian jokes.

  • Brian||

    Geesh: typical racist. Blames everyone else for noticing.

  • american socialist||

    I'm bored. Political correctness just kills all debate.

  • Brian||

    Do you want to talk about how guilty libertarians again?

  • american socialist||

    No... I would never, for example, claim that a libertarian is collectively guilty of 100 million deaths.

    I think, though, that someone who makes an argument like this "You'll never make 205 million [Brazilians] understand any idea in a profound way." may have a problem persuading others as to their viewpoint. I blame the lack of Ayn Rand indoctrination in our elementary schools.

  • Brian||

    .

  • Brian||

    Oh, BTW: do you know the difference between a libertarian and an objectivist?

    Or, what Ayn Rand thought of libertarians?

  • american socialist||

    I hear ya, but I'm unconcerned about internecine squabbles. Just as a Welfare state social democrat is a bloodthirsty Stalinist Marxist so is every libertarian a greedy, selfish asshole that would probably build a lead smelter next to your house if it were profitable. Details, details.

  • Brian||

    Oh I see: this is about libertarians saying mean things to you one time, and this is how you deal with it.

    Inspiring. You democrat socialist are so high minded.

  • american socialist||

    One time!? I could have my financial misadventures read back to me on a daily basis if I chose to.

    But you're right to say this isn't about me. I want to hear about all the brave libertarians who have suffered the torments of the damned by saying that rich and politically connected men should acquire even more wealth and power. There's got to be one, but I'm wearing my Che shirt so I'm all aflutter.

  • Brian||

    And you've always been so civil and fair to libertarians.

    Gee. What gives?

  • american socialist||

    You keep arguing about what I've done and then complain about making this all about me. How do you want me to proceed?

  • Brian||

    Oh now it's all about me, isn't it?

    Don't ask me. Ask all your friendly like-minded American Socialists to take a vote and figure out what you should do next.

  • Suicidy||

    Libertarians aren't going to be responsible for collective mass murder because libertarians consider the intrinsic collectivism necessary anathema. However, nothing says 'mass murder' like a bunch of socialists and their need for 'collective rights'.

  • Ted S.||

    All of America's Communists turned on a dime the minute the Molotov-von Ribbentrop pact was signed, becoming isolationists until June 1941 when Hitler invaded the USSR.

  • hive of scum||

    Socialists have been making excuses for Islamists for ages. It's all Israel's fault!

  • american socialist||

    Libertarian hipsters are all over San Francisco. The take to Twitter to complain that they have to step over homeless people on their way to "work" at the 17 companies there that allow you to send dick pics to hook-up sites. Don't worry... You aren't alone.

  • Brian||

    At least they're not redistributing penis pumps for the elderly, as if old geezers trying to swole just can't pay $14.99.

  • american socialist||

    .

  • Ted S.||

    Is this piece not on H&R, and if not, why not?

  • Suell||

    One of the better articles I have read in reason in some time. These Brazilian guys get it. The way we are going to defeat the socialists is through popular culture. Sure, some people are going to respond to logical arguments, but emotional arguments will ultimately persuade many more.

  • jester||

    Unfortunately, the shit really had to hit the fan for meaningful change to occur.

  • ceviz fidanı||

    when i read this article once again i understand that the power of Facebook as a social media platform

  • Uncle Jay||

    RE: Free Brazil!

    Yay!
    Free Brazil!
    Now I don't have to pay for Brazil.
    That would've been expensive.

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online