Libertarians Quietly Notch Local Wins in Michigan and Pennsylvania
Nonpartisan ballots and small electorates create openings where party identity fades and community ties decide outcomes.
It wasn't just the Democratic Party that did well on Election Day this year. The Libertarian Party won several notable local races.
In Renovo, Pennsylvania, voters elected Justin Lynn mayor. Lynn, a lifelong Libertarian, told WNEP, a local ABC affiliate, that he'll prioritize fiscal restraint, saying Renovo is "four times the national average of poverty" and lacks the tax revenue of larger municipalities. He begins his term on January 1.
Elsewhere in Pennsylvania, 22-year-old Reece Smith won a seat on the Carlynton School Board, which serves the boroughs of Carnegie, Crafton, and Rosslyn Farms. Although the race was officially nonpartisan, Smith openly identified as a member of the Libertarian Party and the state and county parties publicly recognized his affiliation. On his website, Smith criticized the board's decision making process, writing: "The School Board makes too many decisions behind closed doors." He has pledged to push for greater transparency and public input, to conduct an audit of the budget, and to reevaluate the lunches that schools provide to students.
The Libertarian Party also scored some victories in Michigan. Chris Clark, a party member, won a seat on the Taylor City Council. Clark's platform includes some ideas that are at least libertarian-flavored, such as a property tax freeze for senior homeowners on fixed incomes, but it also includes several measures that libertarians would typically reject, such as expanding code enforcement, offering city-backed loans to small businesses, and applying "aggressively" for state and federal infrastructure subsidies.
In Detroit, Scotty Boman was elected to the city's Board of Police Commissioners. Boman is well-known within the Libertarian Party of Michigan, where he has served as both vice chair and political director. His election placed a prominent Libertarian voice in a position involved in police oversight and departmental accountability.
The results in Renovo, Carlynton, Taylor, and Detroit don't mean that a Libertarian wave is about to sweep the nation. The Libertarian Party has usually had its best results on the local level, and this is in line with that history. But if nothing else, these wins are another reminder of the country's simmering discontent with the two major parties—and of the Libertarian alternative waiting to step in when Republicans and Democrats fail.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please to post comments
I had a friend who tried to run as a Libertarian for our local municipal council of a suburb of approximately 8,000 people. He got a visit at his house from people working on behalf of the democrat running for the same seat, and was shown a folder full of 'opposition research' they had done on him. Convinced him to not campaign in exchange for not releasing it publicly.
According to him, most of it wasn't true, but it would have taken more than his entire campaign fund to try to counter it.
8,000 people? He could've personally told them each it wasn't true. What fund does that require?
When was the last time you spoke to 8,000 people? Did you organize a free event where 8,000 people showed up so that you could talk to them or did you, go around calling 30 people a day for a week just to get back to where you started.
I don't know the specific election or suburb but lots of new politicians are funded out of pocket or through community donations. Getting a donation only to have to turn around and assure your donors that allegations aren't true isn't a great way to start a campaign.
Certainly not impossible but your, "I don't see a problem?" reply is pretty cavalier. And I say that as someone who thinks RCV is a gimmick and Duverger's Law is fake news propaganda.
...
Andre Marrou did the latter, visiting nearly every voter.
He attributed his success to television, but he also did that.
My experience was worse than that. Since there was no dirt to dig up on me the papers ran mindless boilerplate stories saying, "Like all libertarians he is in favor of prostitution, drug abuse and gambling." I garnered 5% in a three-way race and helped unseat the reigning monarch of the Texas Senate anyway. Then I was elected to the school board in a landslide since my neighbors actually knew me personally. It still didn't make any difference in the long run.
Clark's platform includes some ideas that are at least libertarian-flavored, such as a property tax freeze for senior homeowners on fixed incomes
I dunt unnerstan. How is favoritism like that even libertarian-flavored? Is that some subtle joke about chewing up and spitting out libertarianism?
You don't understand how freezing someone's — anyone's — tax is even libertarian flavored?
You don't understand even the basics of how using the government to pick favorites is corruption, not individualism?
Libertarians have been winning local and non-partisan elections for a very long time. It has had zero impact on the growing political disaster. I won a seat on the school board in Texas in the 1990s and had no observable effect on the educational culture of multimillion dollar football stadiums while cutting actual educational programs.
How do you know it, and you, had 0 impact? You can't see the world in which it didn't happen.
It's not that you have 0 impact, just that you have impact in proportion to your number. It's not like you have a force multiplier at your hand. Don't expect to exert more weight than you actually have, on average. If you're good, you'll be more effective than your number; if you're bad, less. As with any job.
Exactly my point. My weight was zero.
LIBERTOPIA IS HERE!! Renovo PA cancels out NYC NY.
Dozens of lives are affected, meanwhile we the editors continue to simp for our Lefty Boos whenever possible
It wasn't just the Democratic Party that did well on Election Day this year. The Libertarian Party won several notable local races.
You mean leftists did well, since anyone who isn't with Trump is a leftist.
the Libertarian alternative waiting to step in when Republicans and Democrats fail.
"We're not clowns!" he screams, "We're just biding our time! STOP STARING AT MY BIG ROUND RED NOSE AND MY OVERSIZED SHOES! AND MY CRACK PIPE!"