Yes, Trump Really Put Higher Tariffs on Israel Than Iran
And he did it after Israel dropped all its tariffs on American goods.

A few hours before President Donald Trump slapped huge new tariffs on nearly all imports to the United States, Israel preemptively dropped all its tariffs on American goods.
That's what some of Trump's defenders say is the goal of this whole madcap scheme: to get foreign countries to lower their barriers to American exports.
Mission accomplished, right?
Apparently not. In Wednesday's announcement, Trump imposed new 17 percent tariffs on all imports from Israel.
Amusingly, that's a higher tariff rate than the president put on Iran—Israel's sworn enemy and America's biggest geopolitical foe in the Middle East. The Islamic Republic got hit with a 10 percent tariff.
The comparison is somewhat silly since the boatload of sanctions on Iran already makes it difficult for Americans to trade with Iranians regardless of any tariffs. However, it should also underscore the blunt and foolish way that the Trump administration is pursuing its trade policies, as well as the bad math that was used to calculate these new tariff rates.
In advance of Wednesday's announcement, Trump said the new tariff rates would be based on various trade barriers that foreign countries levy against American goods. That's not what actually happened. As the White House has now confirmed, the new tariff rates announced by Trump were based on a crude calculation that merely divided America's trade deficit with each country by that country's total exports to the United States.
Iran exports very little to the United States because of those sanctions. In fact, America runs a (small) trade surplus with Iran. Because that's the only thing that matters in the formula used by the Trump administration, Iranian imports got hit with the 10 percent tariff baseline and nothing else.
That ought to demonstrate how completely insane the Trump administration's tariff calculations are. Calculations that have now become the baseline for a global regime of tariffs that will cost Americans an estimated $1.8 trillion over the next decade and reduce incomes by more than 2 percent.
Over in Israel, the tariffs will mean hiring freezes, higher costs, and other economic disruptions, The Jerusalem Post reports. "We are all going to feel this in our pockets," Ron Tomer, president of the Manufacturers Association of Israel, said during a radio interview on Thursday, according to The Wall Street Journal. He said the tariffs felt like "abandonment by a friend."
If Trump is going to treat America's geopolitical friends like that—even after they tried to play ball—he might soon find that the world contains a lot more enemies.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I am increasingly seeing Trump as a layman who declares it would be good to cure cancer... then goes off and starts injecting people with whatever he thinks at the moment would be a cure.
A lot of people will look at the behavior and say "This man is crazy!" And insofar as the giving shots of random stuff seeing what might work is crazy... they are right.
But often that isn't the whole of what they mean. They implicitly (and this is actually drawn from other explicit pronouncements these critics make) mean that he is crazy for wanting to cure cancer.
It puts sane people in a bind.
On one side you have people say "He wants to cure cancer ergo he is doing the right thing!" On the other you have people who say "He is crazy and does not know what he is doing... and we don't want anything to do with crazy so let us even reject curing cancer!"
It is hard to find anyone who will say, "Curing cancer is great. I hope he is successful. And to that end I hope he abandons these reckless attempts and instead becomes sober and thoughtful about how to do it."
I for one will say, "Curing cancer is great. I hope that He is successful. And to that end I hope He abandons these reckless attempts and instead becomes sober and thoughtful about how to do it."
Our Dear Orange Leader does SNOT have the HUMILITY to EVER admit error about ANYTHING!!! Butt we can always go on hoping...
I am increasingly seeing Trump as a layman who declares it would be good to cure cancer... then goes off and starts injecting people with whatever he thinks at the moment would be a cure.
You know who else?
Everyone except Hitler?
Is... is it cheating to say "Anthony Fauci"?
I think it’s accurate.
The reason cancer is so hard to cure is because there are 1000s of types of cancer, each one being unique in each cancer patient, then each cancer cell within that person being slightly different. Essentially there are infinite types of cancer. There can be no universal cure for cancer. One would be much more successful addressing a specific type of cancer, the more specific, the more likely you will succeed with some progress.
So yeah, it's crazy to try one thing to cure all cancer, especially if that one thing has been tried and found to cause more harm than help. Your analogy holds up in this respect.
STFU you ignorant twat
I hear chamomile tea can be calming.
Then why are cat ladies so freaked out?
Catnip?
Toxoplasmosis
There can be no universal cure for cancer.
Not so fast. Cancer cells have basically turned off their 'planned obsolescence' built into DNA via telomers. These are cleaved off during each cell replication, and when they are gone the cell dies, hence aging.
Cancer cells appear to have turned off the mechanism that cleaves off the telomers. So restoring that mechanism could cure cancers. The delicate part is how do you turn that on without having it run amok and cleave off all the telomers, killing the cell.
At least that is a leading theory.
Allow me to point out Trump actually has a degree in economics. Your typical libertarian's economic education usually amounts to an afternoon reading mises.org.
Now, it's entirely possible that neither you or Trump knows wtf they're talking about, but if I have to pick a side here, my money is on Trump.
What about the other 99.9% of economists?
You mean the ones who've accurately predicted 8 out of the last 2 recessions?
Meh, still better than the guy causing one.
Let's check with one of his professors:
"Donald Trump was the dumbest goddam student I ever had.”
-Professor William T. Kelley, Wharton School of Business and Finance
Given that Trump graduated, presumably said professor passed him. If he was that dumb, how did that happen?
Being a billionaire might have something to do with it.
And THAT is the real sin of the Ivy League. Money matters there. Elites producing more elites
Note that Trump and Vance are both Ivy League alums. Neither Biden nor Harris nor Walz are. But Trump conned the American people into thinking he and his fellow oligarchs care.
So education is bad now?
It's just another brick in the wall.
Going ivy league means something for someone like Vance who came from poverty. I think Vance is very smart.
I bet he's screaming in his pillow at night living a real life version of Veep.
Why? He's positioned himself to be the next President. Best case, something happens to Trump and Vance succeeds him just after half term, and we get 2 more terms of Vance.
Trump would have to really fuck up, and Vance would have to really, really fuck up, to ruin the chances of Vance 2028.
There's so many scenarios that could be gamed out where Vance ends up with the 2028 win. Democrats have nothing going on right now, and have to hope that Trump destroys the US (well, they hope to destroy the US themselves) for them to have a shot.
Democrats have nothing going on right now
Hey, that's not fair to say! They have "doubling down on the policies and insanity that cost them the '24 election" going on!
Remember, the whole reason they lost is that they didn't go woke enough.
Allow me to point out that AOC also has a degree in economics, AND Trump was a Democrat for a long long time before changing parties.
NYC is full of fake Democrats because in most of the city, Democratic primaries are the only elections that matter. And Republicans here only care about the already well off. Every Republican voted to keep the draconian restrictive zoning laws that the City Council just relaxed.
You think these commenters would be caught dead reading mises. Org?
You mean this mises.org?
Trump’s “Liberation Day” Tariffs Are a Mistake
Paul Krugman won the Nobel Prize in economics. He has been wrong on every issue for several decades now.
A degree in economics does not mean anything, particularly if you ignore the basic law of supply and demand. It's like a physicist who doesn't take into account the 2nd Law.
"If Trump is going to treat America's geopolitical friends like that—even after they tried to play ball—he might soon find that the world contains a lot more enemies."
You mean to say that EVEN IN TRUMP-LAND, twat cums around, goes around?
Don't SAY that, or ye will be send to Hell-prison in El Salvador!!!
As some people have already said, the real point of these tariffs is to force both U.S. firms and foreign countries to bribe Trump for tariff relief. His "grand plan" is really nothing more than a shakedown racket, a hustle, which is what Trump understands "capitalism" to be in the first place.
As some people have already said, the real point of these tariffs is to force both U.S. firms and foreign countries to bribe Trump for tariff relief.
Um...
Not everyone is gifted with the ability to be coherent or understand basic concepts.
His "grand plan" is really nothing more than a shakedown racket, a hustle, which is what Trump understands "capitalism" to be in the first place.
this^
America has been getting assfucked in trade deals for decades, as a retarded faggot, this appeals to you. But Americans don’t like it.
I can’t help but think that this all works out better if you kill yourself.
That’s what NYC real estate is…and AC real estate was much mafia forward than NYC real estate.
That is hardball negotiating, yes, a common Trump strategy. Sometimes it works, but often the response can be very ugly and work against one's long term goals. In Trump's case the backlash is getting so bad it might tank his Presidency, or at least lose the midterms.
There are sanctions on Iran. Lol.
Isreal also already agreed to 0% tariffs.
Whoa! You can read! You can parrot what the article said!
Trump is still an economic moron.
Quick, choose: economic moron or smart WEF-globalist.
The choice is globalism or poverty. The world doesn't give you another option.
SGT, you seem worked up about this. Why don’t you head out to Trump town and have a nice juicy Trumpburger and relax?
That's funny. What's your advice for Jesse when he farts out profane insults and types so fast half his words are typoes? That's the guy who needs the camomile tea.
As far as Trump meat goes, Jesse's right on that.
typoes
Funny.
BYOBB
That's because Trump is a puppet of Netanyahu... oh wait.
Trump forced Netanyahu to agree to the ceasefire because that was what MBS wanted. And in Trump’s first term he unknowingly appointed an honorary member of the Qatari royal family to Secretary of State…and then sided with MBS over Qatar…Tillerson went ballistic and was soon expunged from his administration. Trump eventually reversed course on Qatar because they groveled to him…and Trump used Qatar to cut a deal with the Taliban to end that asinine quagmire. MBS has given Kushner $2 billion and Trump at least a billion…you probably don’t care though.
Hey fag, that’s one hell of a whopper. Are you working on more democrat fan fiction?
Did they not cover LIV Golf on NewsMax?? I only watch one golf tournament—The Masters…and it isn’t beholden to the PGA or LIV or any other organization besides Augusta National. So it’s kind of like me being independently wealthy with my real estate portfolio more than doubling thanks to Biden’s inflation!
Hey fag, I don’t watch golf on tv.
And your ‘real estate portfolio’ consists of such desirable rental units as Sarc’s piss soaked refrigerator box. So you shouldn’t attempt to brag.
That isn't fiction, unfortunately.
The bullshit you puke up certainly is.
MBS has given Kushner $2 billion and Trump at least a billion
Hey Brain-Fried, your citations fell off.
I'm kind of in the camp that would classify Israel as a dependent ally. Loyal, sort of, but definitely a costly ally to fund. Maybe Trump wants to squeeze the lemon for a bit more juice.
He got tired of squeezing Spermy Daniels? Are the exports of Spermy Daniels now going to get tariff-taxed ass well? HOW can we peons EVER afford Her, then?
Trump definitely doesn’t understand what motivates people like Huckabee to support Israel. Trump’s peers in NYC real estate probably think the Huckabees of America are nuts but they are useful idiots for Israel.
Trump tried to kill aid to Israel one year ago in order to please his Russian puppetmaster.
Hey fag, as you are a retard, I know you’re easily confused, but Biden was president a year ago.
So...WTF is really going on here? Is Trump trying to make Israel pay for their US aid? Or is the Trump administration really stupidly trying to apply a simple formula to all countries so as to appear scientific or fair?
I don't know. It's hard not to think he's lost his mind.
This is part of the problem; the man is so schizophrenic and all-over-the-place nobody can figure it out, least of all him. And the markets respond accordingly.
As many people have pointed out, the formula for Trump's tariffs have nothing to do with the other country's tariffs, but is based on the trade imbalance, with a minimum of 10%
But it's still a departure from his stated strategy of reciprocal tariffs, e.g., we'll reduce ours to zero if you do. This "formula" includes other factors that are not commonly understood to be included in a tariff's calculation, such as "currency manipulation" and "trade barriers," which is why he's levied tariffs on countries with which the U.S. has a trade surplus.
I'm sorry, but this approach is retarded all the way down, and the stock market is reacting accordingly.
Yes. Motherfucker has now moved the goalposts to the only way to get to zero tarrifs is to manufacture your product in the US. You can't even make this shit up.
He even put tariffs on our 51st and 52nd states!
Unfortunately, Democrats have no standing to complain. Very few objected to Biden's continuing the first term Trump tariffs. (I did so repeatedly, and got a lot of pushback.) And these days, no Democrat will openly criticize any institution that is seen as part of the Democratic Coalition. I kept waiting for Harris to have a Sister Souljah moment, and it never happened. Too many labor unions love Love LOVE tariffs, and the United Auto Workers in particular are obnoxious about them even though it is going to cost their workers a lot of jobs. The United Steel Workers are almost as bad, although they are now seriously spooked by the tariffs on Canada.
I want some Democrat to run for President in 2028 on a platform of making all tariffs one percent.
I'm a Trump supporter on most issues, but I agree that the tariffs are ridiculous. I can only hope this mess gets straightened out soon. Maybe Elon can school him.
some of the people around here cheer for the 9/11 Dancers maybe T is responding to that
Trump falsely claimed that the people dancing in the street in celebration of the 9/11 attacks were Muslim immigrants in New Jersey. In fact, they were Arabs in East Jerusalem.
Hey fag, that’s a funny bunch of bullshit. You’re just a silly bitch, aren’t you.
Trump is out-jewing the jews. Amazing!
That reminds me of the Republican senator that out-gayed the gays in the airport bathroom. 😉
Democrats are always the most rabid bigots.
Wow now hold on a minute. Maybe tariffs arent so bad after all
'Yes, Trump Really Put Higher Tariffs on Israel Than Iran'
Was he wearing one of those gay terrorist scarves?
Perhaps the Trump Administration thought that it would be pointless to impose tariffs on a nation that the USA doesn't really trade with and imposes sanctions on?
https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/02/fact-sheet-president-donald-j-trump-restores-maximum-pressure-on-iran/
Do you know how much trade there was between the USA and Iran in 2024?
A little over $90 million ( yes that is million not billion) and the USA has almost an $84 million surplus. For the math challenged that means the USA imported a little over $6 million in goods from Iran. This is just outrage for the sake of being outraged over the bad orange man
But not so pointless that 10% is OK. Wouldn't want to tax 18% of nothing, that could deter imports from Iran.
You're either an absolute retard, Eric, who made no effort whatsoever to understand any of this before you decided to be 100% against it because of your bigotry against orange people;
or
You're straight up evil. Lying to our faces, peddling intentional misinformation, crafting a narrative against your political enemies that is 100% devoid of truth, and actively working against the American people.
Which is it?
Reciprocal Tariff Plan. Every country is assumed 10% based on trade barriers and currency manipulation. If you are only 10%, it's likely we don't do a lot of trade with you in the first place. If that's the case, we go tit-for-tat. 10% in return.
However, if you also tariff us, we add that to the ten percent. Then we divide by two and tariff that amount instead. Pretty simple. Even a knuckle-dragging retard Reason staff writer can figure it out.
Israel tariffs us 33%. The discounted reciprocal tariff is therefore 17%. Half. This is expected to be removed in short order, given that Israel has now removed all tariffs on US goods. WOW, YOU MEAN TARIFFS KINDA WORKED THERE????
Now let's go to Iran.
Iran doesn't get a lot of trade with us - economic sanctions, you friggin' moron. So, they're assumed 10%. They therefore get the same baseline 10% as everyone else.
Well isn't that convenient for a BS narrative from a lying hack marxist puke that hates America and Americans. "OMG MEANER TO ISRAEL THAN IRAN LOLOLOLOLOLOL!!!!"
When that's not even slightly true.
Eric, I say this with as much natural compassion and empathy and willingness to give the benefit of the doubt to people that I have: GO DIE IN A FIRE.
You are irredeemable. You are fake news. Go die in a fire.
Btw the USA -Israel trade is right around 370-380 times that of USA -Iran trade and the USA trade deficit vs Israel last year was $7.4 billion versus the USA having an $84 million trade surplus over Iran. The amount that the USA imports from Iran is barely a rounding error vs what the USA imports from Israel and wouldn't even be a rounding error as a percentage of total USA imports.
Too bad trade deficits between pairs of countries in a world of 200 countries are meaningless. Here, see if you can follow along.
Country A sells $1B of spoons to Country B.
Country B sells $1B of knives to Country C.
Country C sells $1B of forks to Country A.
They've all got trade deficits and credits with each other.
When the article makes an issue of why one country is hit harder by the tariffs than the other doesn't it make sense to compare how the trade circumstances between these two nations and the USA are? I mean really total trade doesn't even come into the conversation .
You are a lazy irredeemable fake news propagandist who didn't even read the article. Israel ended all tariffs on US imports this week. The article says so. Yet you promote lies. STFU.
I covered that. Reread before kneejerking, kneejerk.
The problem is that most of this should be worked out one-on-one with the country in question, rather than in the public sphere. Trump may be damaging his brand beyond recovery. This could induce a return to the idiocy of the Biden years.
IOW, Trump is thinking very short term and tariffs could have disastrous long term effects.
I'm not sure why a writer here would be complaining about that. I know why I might, but the "editors" here all seem to think Israel is just a genocidal apartheid state, so...
This entire article is worthless and even the author mentioned the reason it is simply an attack piece.
The treason it is simply an attack piece is that it speaks the truth and does SNOT PervFectly Suck Orange Dick!!! Yes, we know this already!
Reason has no article about there murder of first responders by the Israeli military.