Milei's Sweeping Reform Package Triumphs in the Legislature's Lower House
In exchange, the libertarian president had to scale back some of his free-market ambitions.

Argentine President Javier Milei achieved a significant milestone on Friday after the lower house of Congress approved his sweeping free market reform package, clearing one of the biggest hurdles on his path.
After three days of heated debate and amidst opposition pressure to thwart the entire reform package, the lower chamber of deputies approved the controversial legislation with a vote of 144 in favor and 109 against. After a short recess, lawmakers are expected to vote on the legislation article by article, beginning on February 6.
When Milei assumed the presidency on December 10, he promised to shock the economy out of its economic crisis. The South American country is dealing with the world's highest inflation at 211 percent, as well as a large fiscal deficit and depleted foreign currency reserves.
After devaluing the peso by more than 50 percent, cutting state subsidies, and reducing the number of ministries by half, Milei presented a package that encompasses most of his plans to transform Argentina into a free market economy. The 351-page bill proposes to deregulate and modify laws governing fiscal matters, labor, the environment, health, and more.
Holding just 28 of the chamber's 257 seats, Milei's party, La Libertad Avanza, was able to gain enough support to pass the bill only by dropping a number of key measures. About half of the changes in the original bill survived. Several fiscal measures were dropped, including tax increases on exports—one can dispute whether those qualify as a free market reform—and modifications to the pension system.
Milei's government also agreed to reduce the number of state-run companies it promised to privatize. Originally aiming to jettison 41 state-owned companies—including the flagship airline, Aerolíneas Argentinas; the country's largest bank, Banco de la Nación; and the news agency Télam—the revised bill now targets 27 companies. Notably, the oil company YPF and the national mint will remain state-owned, while other entities will undergo partial privatization.
While the bill was being debated, protesters gathered outside Congress in opposition to Milei's reforms. The protests led to clashes with riot police, as protesters threw rocks at the neoclassical building and the police responded with tear gas and rubber bullets. More than 20 journalists were injured by projectiles, and at least eight demonstrators were arrested. Seven police officers were also injured, according to government sources.
After the vote, Milei said that the opposition leaders who supported his reforms "understood the historical context and chose to end the privileges of the caste and the corporate republic, in favor of the people, who have been impoverished and are hungry."
The approval of the bill comes after the International Monetary Fund (IMF) approved on Wednesday a $4.7 billion disbursement for Argentina—the fund's largest debtor. "So far, we have seen a good economic team in place, looking at ways in which the country can move out of this difficulty," the IMF's managing director, Kristalina Georgieva.
The approval of the omnibus bill and the IMF disbursement are good news for Milei's administration. But it is still too early to celebrate. The omnibus bill will now have to clear its next obstacle: its approval in the Senate, where Milei's party has only 10 percent of the seats.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Liberty or death!
The approval of the bill comes after the International Monetary Fund (IMF) approved on Wednesday a $4.7 billion disbursement for Argentina
The Davos crowd gives Milei their blessing.
So? He might make share holder capitalists out of them, yet.
In any negotiation you start from extreme ends and hope you do well in the middle. It's likely that even half of his original program would significantly improve the economic and social conditions of Argentina and the people so I think this is good progress.
I'm writing in Javier for president given my current choicies. Hell we've ignored the constitution for less/more (less important, more government).
I'd do that in my state except that write-ins don't even get READ unless they're on an approved list. Nobody would ever see that I put his name there so it doesn't communicate anything to lawmakers.
¡Viva la Libertad! Good idea.
Or you could vote for Haley, who is the closest we have to Milei. Pro-Israel, Pro-Ukraine, wants to reform social security, isn't a big tariff person like Trump or Biden
Trump was the most pro-liberty president since Ronald Reagan. He actually instituted a policy whereby, whenever a federal regulatory agency wanted to introduce a new regulation, it had to eliminate two existing ones. But you are probably one of the ubiquitous fake libertarians around here, which is why you'd rather talk about tariffs.
Wish Milei the best but he governs a people that will vote Peronism at the drop of a hat.
Apparently enough of them "have seen the light" -- they voted him in, after all!
Time to get a Duolingo account.
Just think, another 5 years of Bidenomics, and America might be able to elect a President as libertarian as Milei.
Big Beautiful Walls and Trade Wars might bankrupt us instead ...
It took 80 years for Argentina to elect Milei and it will take us at least as long.
And some news organizations are STILL calling him "far right wing" although a few are calling him "radical libertarian" which, I suppose, is good for our brand recognition!
I'm surprised at how much of the original package passed. I expected more of a fight from the opposition.
Actually, the package did not pass the chamber of “Diputados” (the "lower chamber" the article is about). It was rejected, in what is considered a significant defeat for Milei. Though he can keep trying, making more concessions, etc.; I think the odds are low unless he gives up a lot more.
I don’t have a source in English, but here’s one in Spanish:
https://www.lanacion.com.ar/politica/no-la-vieron-la-trastienda-de-un-fracaso-anunciado-en-el-congreso-que-dificilmente-pueda-remontarse-nid06022024/
Even if it had passed, it would have faced the Senate later before it could make it into law.
At first, the radical rhetoric and rabble rousing troubled me. Although he is almost the opposite of Trump on policy, liberalism, and economic understanding, the simple fact that the mere visuals invoked that comparison made me think he would overreach and fail to maintain support, especially that a turn towards liberalism will cause much pain and upheaval for years before bearing fruit.
That is why I was hoping for Patricia Bullrich, a center right liberal who was determined but more gradualist and with an established base.
As it turns out, though, Milei is de facto implementing the Bullrich approach. He did not let the currency float in one fell swoop, let alone dollarise. His deregulatory zeal has targeted the indefensible, cronyist extremes and areas with immediate consumer and export benefits that would be felt and demonstrate positive effects - think falling prices for air travel and retail banking. His swingeing cuts to social spending has targeted the privileged, while he doubled social spending targeting the poor.
In fact he seems pretty good at politics after all. He does not seem to render worthy issues toxic through extremism, as Trump did with border security by obsessing about the symbolism of physical walls. His rhetoric has set a clear direction, but he lets pragmatism reign when deciding how and when to progress.
So maybe he can actually make it work. Still less likely than not, my knowledge of Argentine history tells me, but much more likely than a few months ago.
What experiments with space travel planning have confirmed their effectiveness, NASA to Deploy a Surgical Robot MIRA to the ISS Today? What distances are achievable within the framework of the current technological capabilities of traveling through space?