New Mosquitos Can Help Beat Malaria
Malaria is making a comeback in the United States. Mosquitos might be part of the solution.

For the first time in 20 years, nine cases of locally acquired malaria have occurred this summer in the United States: seven in Florida, one in Texas, and one in Maryland. The feverish illness is caused by infection through the bites of mosquitoes carrying protozoan parasites.
The parasites were introduced to the Americas via colonization and the transatlantic slave trade and adapted to local mosquito species. "By 1850 malaria had become established in practically every settlement from New England westward to the Columbia River valley and from the southernmost part of Florida to the inland valleys of California," wrote the Tulane University parasitologist Ernest C. Faust in 1951. The U.S. Census Bureau reported that in 1850, malaria was responsible for 45.7 out of every 1,000 deaths nationally and 7.8 percent of deaths in the South.
The Communicable Disease Center declared malaria eradicated in this country in 1951. Today that entity, now known as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, typically reports around 2,000 cases of malaria annually contracted by travelers returning to the U.S. from abroad. The World Health Organization estimates that there were nearly 250 million cases and 620,000 deaths from malaria in 2021, concentrated in sub-Saharan Africa.
Back in 2014, in my article "Let's Play God," I asked, "Wouldn't it be great if scientists could genetically engineer mosquitoes to be immune to the malaria parasite, thus protecting people from that disease?" Nearly 10 years later, a team of biotechnologists associated with the University of California, Irvine; the University of California, Berkeley; and Johns Hopkins University report that they have achieved just that.
According to the researchers' July article in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, their malaria-carrying mosquito species received genes coding for anti-malaria proteins combined with a gene drive to spread the code quickly in wild mosquito populations that mate with the engineered insects. Normally, genes have a 50–50 chance of being inherited, but in this case, the gene drive systems increased the chance of inheriting the anti-malaria genes to upward of 99 percent. Applying an epidemiological model, the researchers calculated releasing the bioengineered mosquitoes to interbreed with wild ones would reduce the incidence of human malaria infections by more than 90 percent within three months.
Unfortunately, various Luddite activist groups seeking a global moratorium on gene drives have managed to tie up research and deployment with red tape, using United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) procedures. A CBD technical committee is supposed to issue a risk assessment report on the technology in 2026, while hundreds of millions already know the real and present risks of life without it.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I’m not sure why the Luddite activist groups are opposing this. The covid vaccine has been 99% safe and effective and I’m sure this will be too!
Infected mosquitos 100% safe and effective, no downside, no choice.
I’m making over $7k a month working component time. I saved hearing other people inform me how lots cash they could make online so I decided to look at it. Well, it turned into all proper and has definitely modified my life. This is what I do———>>> http://Www.Smartcareer1.com
Luddite activist groups are allied with the Lizard People, who want us ALL to SUFFER-SUFFER-SUFFER, and then DIE-DIE-DIE from COVID and malaria!
Sad to say, the Luddites and Lizard People are likely to have their way with us, concerning the GMOs.
It's a GOOD thing that I still have my freedoms to get COVID shots! The Luddites and the Lizard People did NOT win on THAT one!
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/united-states-rates-of-covid-19-deaths-by-vaccination-status?country=~All+ages
Just LOOK at the interactive graph right at the top of this link!!!! COVID deaths among the unvaccinated VASTLY outnumbered, and still outnumber, the deaths among the vaccinated!!!
I know, right? The fucking deplorab, I mean, anti-science Luddites need to knock it off with the ineffective, but risky, HCQ and horse paste bullshit. The real, proven way to treat malaria is with unprecedented genetic engineering.
Only luddites believe in t cell exhaustion. No downsides.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41577-019-0221-9
Trust the science. Use Off!
Great, you're actually smarter when you're trying to be full of shit. Go full sarc all the time and you'll practically be a genius.
Experimenting on poor people in poor communities is totally OK.
Yes, much better to leave poor people to suffer the way they have for millennia. Who cares, they're used to it.
There's no connection.
There once was a woman who modified a fly.....
Modified male mosquitos have been used to eliminate dengue fever. The female mosquitos are the ones that transmit the pathogen.
False.
First, Dengue fever still exists and is still prevalent in the areas that it previously was prevalent. The trials are only something like 77% effective at best specifically because in order to out compete native populations you have to generate enormous amounts of mosquitoes.
Second, along the lines of the enormous amounts of mosquitoes, the solution in this case isn't genetic engineering. It's simply infecting a population of mosquitoes with a naturally occurring, innocuous, competing parasitic bacterium.
https://www.labiotech.eu/trends-news/oxitec-mosquito-dengue/
Yup. I see 95% suppression of Aedes aegypti, which both the nominal of several favorable studies, still isn’t 100% (or necessarily above the equivalent conception of herd immunity), applies to only one mosquito of multiple to carry the disease, and I see precisely zero data correlating it to dengue reduction despite the fact that there are other studies with other technologies that do measure both native mosquito displacement and dengue reduction.
This isn’t the first time Ron’s posted these articles and it’s not the first time Oxitech or others have performed these PR&D studies. Florida and Grand Cayman have both discontinued studies citing cost-benefit because, as indicated by my comment about competition, in order to push upwards past 88 and 95% you have to produce and distribute legions more mosquitoes. Further, you have to artificially maintain those populations for several years/generations.
It’s almost like not everyone who disagrees with you is a deplorable or Luddite and your religious zeal for a technology that’s nowhere near magical in its degree of advancement is more of an iss-you than anything else.
Why do you continue to be deliberately retarded?
Hey Casually Mad...
Eating isn't perfect either! People DIE on a regular basis, from food poisoning!!
Why do you continue to EAT?!?! Idiot, STOP eating!!!
True (in a sense).
There's more than one way to control dengue fever.
One way is the method that you discuss.
Another way is the method that Homer discusses.
https://www.euronews.com/next/2023/04/25/dengue-fever-outbreak-biologists-are-sterilising-virus-carrying-mosquitoes-with-nuclear-en
It doesn't "eliminate" dengue fever, in the sense of totally eradicating it from the face of the earth, but it does get rid of it for a time.
Second, along the lines of the enormous amounts of mosquitoes, the solution in this case isn’t genetic engineering. It’s simply infecting a population of mosquitoes with a naturally occurring, innocuous, competing parasitic bacterium.
Can we get Dr. Fauci to head up this pogrom... I mean program?
Yeah I don't know about this. Snarky criticism aside, this just seems like a recipe for disaster. The problem is the "gene drive system". If there is some problem in the genetic modification that makes the mosquito immune to the parasite, then that problem coupled with the gene drive system, means that the problem will be propagating in the wild forever.
I'm fully supportive of the concept of genetically modifying mosquitoes. I am just much more leery of the idea of having those genetic modifications be inheritable to subsequent generations, let alone having them be inheritable on overdrive.
"Something could go wrong" could be said of everything humans have ever done! When did it start? Chimps and other apes, even monkeys, do it, too! Cracking nuts with rocks! This must be STOPPED! (Or at least, they must PROVE that nothing can go wrong!) Oh, and beavers building dams...
What's your specific fear? Did anything bad happen when smallpox was eliminated from the wild? Not enough "culling of the herds of humans" going on now, in the wake of all that? Selectively bred plans and animals (bred by humans, while NOT using GMOs) ALSO could mutate, and pass on... Forever!
Well when you start modifying things like mosquitoes and viruses, which are so widespread and highly communicable, then you open Pandora's Box. If you screw up, then the damage is massive and near uncontrollable.
Hey wait! I have the fix!
Protozoan parasites have rights, too, sure! All humans who WANT to be infected with malaria, can have direct, deliberate injections of protozoan parasites! The endangered protozoan parasites will then have refuges!
And the REST of us could be FREE of this disease, thanks to GMO cooties, and people who have enough COMMON SENSE to reduce suffering and death when it can be done! When the... OMG, here comes a BAD word... When the TECHNOLOGY is there, ready to be applied!
(Do I have to think of EVERYTHING good, around here?!?!?)
Plugging a gene into an insect where it doesn’t belong? Wonder if this could be called buggery.
Help! My bugs have been bugged... And that BUGS me!!!
Next thing ya know, GMO bugs will be thugs!
only if the ''gene" in question actually refers to a guy's name
https://twitter.com/disclosetv/status/1724372506159509597?t=7fsEZVDfibriHav6vDrWIw&s=19
NEW - NY Gov. Hochul is "collecting data" from "surveillance efforts" on social media to combat "hate speech" for your safety.
[Video]
Does not include threats against white people, conservatives, or Jewish people. Oh. And not Asians.
Who released the squirrel?
Squirrels are justifiably PISSED OFF because humans fucked 'em over in North American, by bringing a chestnut-tree-killing fungus here!!! And now humans REFUSE to fix it, even though they COULD! Regulators have been SITTING ON THEIR ASSES since Jan 2020, Deeply Debating whether humans will be ALLOWED to fix what they broke! Hell yeah, squirrels are PISSED!
https://www.sciencenews.org/article/8-gmo-history-genetic-modification
From there... "This genetically engineered tree is more resistant to the fungal blight disease thanks to a wheat gene that breaks down the harmful chemical the pathogen produces. The tree has been under review by regulatory agencies since January 2020. After approval, the American Chestnut Research and Restoration Project at the State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry in Syracuse plans to start distributing it to restoration programs and the public."
Wait another 50 years... Regulators need paychecks, ya know... And then MAYBE we'll get healthy trees back, to feed the squirrels!!! I WANT MY CHESTNUTS BACK!!!!
Ask him about Stormy Daniels and Section 230.
I told ya so!!!!
The Sad Saga of the Stolen Erections
And lo, it came to pass, that Tim the Enchanter blew upon His Magic Flute, and led me to a secret cave (the Cave of Caerbannog), whereupon mystic runes carved into the very living rock foretold of a day to come.
This sad, sad day has now manifested itself, just as foretold. The Promised One had been delivered to us, and was to fertilize His Queen, Spermy-Stormy Daniels, in an amazing scene; a glaze of Vaseline. Their offspring were to be called Strumpets… Which is a concatenation of Stormy and Trump. They were to number in the millions… About 332 million; enough for all residents of the USA to be issued one Strumpet per each resident, to sit on his or her right shoulder, and make sure that each resident stayed WAAAY Righteous. Each Strumpet was to progressively exert more and more Righteousness Control over each resident, by covering them in Strumpet Vines.
Sad to say, the Bad Bider-Grunch stole Trumpsmas AND Trump’s Erections! The stolen erections prevented the birth of the 332 million Strumpets, in the world’s WORST mass murder (genocide) so far! Even Saint Babbitt could NOT save the Strumpets!
This is the Sad Tale of the Demise of the USA!
https://twitter.com/xbtGBH/status/1724257918495670429?t=17zCg8PnFx9FUrtf3DRw1Q&s=19
I am beyond words...
They are literally giving a standing ovation for the black hockey player that killed that white guy a couple weeks ago...
White People are beyond saving...
[Link]
Don’t kneel, don’t stand and applaud… MAKE UP YOUR MIND! /sarc
More testing needed!
How can anyone possibly judge the effectiveness of anything related to science or medicine without first knowing the political affiliations of the people involved?
The study came from UC-Irvine and Johns Hopkins, both in blue states. Already looking bad.
I looked up the contributing author on Open Secrets, and I couldn't find any political donations, but c'mon, he's a professor, so he's totally a left-wing progressive and probably a hard-core communist.
So the mosquito is most likely bio-engineered, once it bites people, to turn them into BernieBros. That is the most likely explanation here.
Tree-huggers and lovers of the endangered protozoan parasites are generally left-leaning... So we MUST all get malaria if we REALLY are environmentalist lefties!!!
The right, on the other hand, supports the Lizard People and their Heroic Efforts to WARN us all about the micro-chips in our COVID vaccines! Shit is our PATRIOTIC DUTY to get COVID and fall over dead, so that the Lizard People can inherit the Earth, as was foretold in the Bible!
Either way, we must all suffer and die... Pick your "team"... Is it Team Malaria, or Team COVID?
While I detect the sarcasm, we learned this lesson from Covid and all of the failed gov't policies.
The left used Covid to rule. It's undeniable.
Yet the distancing, mask mandates and other policies failed to become permanent.
If COVID was an excuse for a permanent power grab, well it failed miserably.
Yet the distancing, mask mandates and other policies failed to become permanent.
Neither was The Final Solution... So Now Libertarianism is "Hey, sure it was a draconian, tyrannical policy that destroyed tens of thousands of businesses, eviscerated health outcomes for massive swathes of the population, likely caused cardiac harm to many thousands of young people who weren't at risk for the disease in the first place, but hey man, no one's like, talking about it anymore. Can't we just treat everyone who pushed this stuff with grace and humility?"
If COVID was an excuse for a permanent power grab, well it failed miserably.
It succeeded spectacularly. If you think that they didn't keep any measurements on what they were able to get away with successfully, and use it again... and again and again... and again in the future, forever and ever, amen, you're more naïve than I thought.
If you don't think that sending out a massive police response to stop a windsurfer out on the ocean wasn't something that the government stuck in its back pocket for later user, you're sorely mistaken.
FYI, Politifact rated this story as "mostly true". Because, and I quote:
But hey, the stay at home order was lifted, so like Yassir Arafat, he STOPPED killing people so Nobel Prizes all around!
Are you familiar with the term 'proof of concept'?
Riiiiiiiiight. It's definitely them, and not the four million border jumpers swarming in from the malaria capitals of the world.
We don't need new mosquitoes to beat malaria. We already beat malaria without them. We need to do something about the people bringing malaria to the United States.
ya great until they stop also carrying west nile and whateverdafuq else mosquitos will remain the only thing I kill on purpose.
Now let's engineer them to not want human blood.
Dengue is nothing to snark about. it kills about fifty thousand people a year, and the bad news is that far from imparting immunity, being bitten once raises the odds of your dying if re-infected.
The US faces a demographic ouble whammy in that people are flocking to the sun belt, and the sun belt is slowly widening as temperatures rise.
From the CDC, the font of all science and truth:
As many as 3.6 billion people, or 40% of the world's population, reside in dengue-endemic areas. Each year, an estimated 400 million people are infected with dengue virus, 100 million become ill with dengue, and 21,000 deaths are attributed to dengue.
So, table napkin math time. 11% of 40% of the world's global population get infected with dengue. 25% of the 11% of the 40% actually get ill. And .021% of the 25% of the 11% of the 40% die.
Are we moving to a place where we're optimizing for the margins so much that the less risk of a thing requires a greater response?
My stats are from the new Lancet dengue global review
So... more table napkin math... 0.042% of the 25% of the 11% of the 40%. I'm still not convinced we need to genetically engineer a new breed of mosquito in a Wuhan lab and "see how it goes".
The better news on dengue is that an RNA vaccine has passed the first round of trials without single wet market closing.
Are we moving to a place where we’re optimizing for the margins so much that the less risk of a thing requires a greater response?
I pointed this out back when Ron was going full retard about mandatory vaccinations, Zika, and yet-unknown-virus-more-virulent-than-influenza-and-deadlier-than-ebola; if the last 5,000, 2,000, 1,000 or even 500 yrs. has shown us anything, it's that if we are going to be wiped out, or nearly so, by a disease going forward the probability of us being the origin is well greater than zero and climbing. The old idea that we were going to find the Shangri La of cancer cures or Pandora's box of deadly diseases hanging off a vine in some Amazonian rain forest is dim and vanishing and our ability to misunderstand plain evidence, invent stupid non-solutions to (non-)problems, coalesce into group think around said stupidity, and obliterate anyone who thinks otherwise doesn't seem to be abating. Definitively in the 21st century, direct human-caused human mortality rivaled infectious disease mortality and, for the latter half, eclipsed it. If anybody kills us all going forward, barring the discovery of a ELE-triggering celestial body or alien invasion, it will be us (robot uprising is also likely but we would be at least partially responsible for that).
Or, we could bust out the DDT and wipe the bastards off the face of the earth. Just a thought.