Foreign Policy

Iraqi Protests Are Yet Another Reason To End U.S. Intervention

America's exit from Iraq could benefit both Iraqis and Americans.

|

After months of deadly, large-scale grassroots protests demanding reform in Baghdad, Iraqi, Prime Minister Adel Abdul-Mahdi announced his intent to resign and the country's parliament approved his resignation. In the protests, about 400 demonstrators, mostly young and unarmed, have been killed by Iraqi security forces; another 8,000 have been injured; and about a dozen security forces have also died in clashes with a violent minority of protesters. Today, it is unsettled who will become the new head of government.

It is unlikely to be a question easily resolved. The demonstrators' complaints are extensive, including state corruption and incompetence, unemployment and economic stagnation, and a perception of foreign influence over domestic politics, notably from Iran. More important than these specific issues, however, is the protesters' overarching critique of the governance structure in Baghdad—a structure shaped by Washington's nation-building efforts after the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq. That dissatisfaction makes this political unrest a fresh and urgent impetus to end American military intervention in Iraq once and for all.

U.S. exit could signal a move toward meaningful reforms the Iraqi people want. It would also be a boon for the American people, bringing closure to a misguided military intervention that has proven costly and counterproductive to U.S. security.

It is commonplace in U.S. politics to hear of the "end" of the Iraq War under former President Obama, but it is an odd end to a war which leaves thousands of occupying troops in place. The Trump administration began this year with more than 5,000 boots on the ground in Iraq, and, since then, added to their number after reshuffling U.S. forces in Syria. It has been nearly three years since Baghdad declared victory over the Islamic State—whose rise occasioned a growing U.S. footprint in Iraq beginning in 2014. In those years, Washington has ignored repeated Iraqi calls for withdrawal of all foreign militaries, as well as recent insistence from Baghdad that American forces relocated from Syria cannot stay.

The demonstrations this fall are further evidence of Iraqi dissatisfaction with prolonged meddling by Washington. "You know, 16 years, there is nothing good," an Iraqi widow named Hala Chalabi, who is part of the protests, told NPR. Her family had high hopes following the ouster of Saddam Hussein but has been bitterly disappointed with the U.S.-backed government that replaced him. "Nothing happened very good for the people. Everything is bad. Killing, stealing—it's about all the government. All of them are bad and the same thing."

Thus the protesters' aim is not merely a new election but a major restructuring of the electoral system established in 2005 under U.S. influence. Indeed, "public sentiment has reached a point where it cannot be placated by piecemeal or cosmetic changes," Fanar al-Haddad, a Middle East expert at the University of Singapore, explained to Al Jazeera. "If all that the political class can offer is a rearranged constellation of the same faces, there will be more public anger and a possible escalation of protests."

U.S. withdrawal would be a step toward reform for the United States as well as Iraq. The 2003 invasion was foreign policy "malpractice," as military historian (and retired Col.) Andrew Bacevich has argued at The New York Times, guided by fantasy and an utter lack of foresight into the predictable aftermath of external regime change. Its price in blood—thousands of American and hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilian deaths—and trillions of U.S. tax dollars remains utterly indefensible. On strategy, pragmatics, procedure, and ethics alike, this war was a misstep from the beginning, and that error is only compounded the longer it is allowed to continue.

A full and expeditious withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq is overdue. Yet it should appeal to President Donald Trump, who has slammed the war in Iraq as the "worst single mistake" in U.S. history and often speaks of his commitment, so far unfulfilled, to ending "endless wars." It would give the Iraqi people needed leeway and responsibility in forging their own political future. And it would be an easy sell to the American public, which has long since soured on this fight. Iraq's present protests provide a valuable opportunity for the U.S. to get out of a war that never should have started. We would be fools not to take it.

Advertisement

NEXT: ExxonMobil Did Not Mislead Shareholders About Climate Risks, Rules New York Court

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. “it’s about all the government. All of them are bad and the same thing.”

    Hey look at the bright side, all that freedom spreading seems to have created at least one libertarian.

  2. “unemployment and economic stagnation”

    As bad as Iraq’s economy is, I bet ours is even worse. We have stagnation — Charles Koch’s net worth is hovering between $58,000,000,000 and $62,000,000,000 — and an unemployment rate that’s actually too low. Since people are working 2 or 3 jobs to survive.

    #DrumpfRecession

  3. Talk about ungrateful!
    Bush takes the time and trouble to trash this country, and all we get is a bunch of whining and sniveling from the Iraqi people.
    Well, this is the last time we invade Iraq, by God!

    1. They don’t even appreciate the puppet government we set up for them!

      1. Well it seems like the last few tries at spreading democracy didn’t take, so this time we just gotta do it extra hard to make sure it works.

        The beatings will continue until morale improves.

        1. Maybe that was the problem – they touted Democracy instead of a Republic (which the USA is – and is the foundation of its success) and is starting to look just like Iraq the more we pretend its a Democracy instead of a Republic.

    2. How many of them have even thanked Sykes and Picot for creating the country in the first place?

      Do you know how difficult it is to draw some lines on a map in the middle of a war dividing up the land of one of your enemies?

  4. Expect all the troops to come home from Iraq right after all the troops come home from Germany and Japan.

    1. Which will happen right after we wrap things up in the Philippines.

  5. Is more than 5000 boots on the ground 2500 soldiers? fucking hack

  6. ***but it is an odd end to a war which leaves thousands of occupying troops in place***

    Um, Japan, Germany, they both had 10’s of thousands of US servicemen/women on occupation duty for a very long time after the end of WW2. You could almost say that they’re still there today albiet with different justifications used.

    In fact ending a war with occupation troops in place is the default for the past 100 years, not the exception.

    Not to mention all the folks a Guantanamo Bay, a part of Cuba obtained during the peace with Spain over 120 years ago.

    1. I thought about pointing this out. Add South Korea to that list as well. It irks me when, even when I agree with the authors overall thesis they go and make such a blatantly stupid comment. Does Reason not have editors to catch this stupidity?

  7. >>>about 400 demonstrators, mostly young and unarmed, have been killed

    yikes. free iraq?

  8. Those aren’t US troops, they are well armed diplomats.

    /Obamatron

  9. I didn’t think we were intervening. I thought we were exporting democracy?

  10. I bet the CIA is already scouting these protests for their next potential “moderate rebels” to secretly arm and then blame Iran.

    The troops are never leaving the Middle East

  11. Thanks admin for giving such valuable information through your article . Your article is much more similar to https://www.creative-diagnostics.com/VZV-IgM-EIA-Kit-3975-466.htm word unscramble tool because it also provides a lot of knowledge of vocabulary new words with its meanings.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.