Crony Capitalism

The Senate’s Rejection of Export-Import Bank Critic Shows How Entrenched Crony Capitalism Is in Washington

Several Republicans broke ranks to kill the nomination of Rep. Scott Garrett to head the Export-Import Bank.

|

Scott Garrett
Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call/Newscom

The Senate Banking Committee voted 10–13 yesterday to reject former New Jersey Rep. Scott Garrett to head the Export-Import Bank, an institution that has become synonymous with corporate welfare. Two Republicans on the committee—Sens. Mike Rounds (R–S.D.) and Tim Scott (R–S.C.)—broke ranks to vote against Garrett, who had called for the bank's elimination while he was in Congress and who had promised to reform the institution if tapped to lead it.

Scott cited Garrett's "long history opposing the Ex-Im Bank" in explaining his vote. Scott's state contains a plant for the aviation giant Boeing, whose customers get some 40 percent of the Export-Import Bank's financing. The institution is sometimes called "Boeing's bank."

In opposing Garrett's nomination, Scott and Rounds made common cause with their Democratic colleagues.

Sen. Maria Cantwell (D–Wash.)—whose home state also contains major Boeing operations—said in a statement that she "applauds" the banking committee's rejection of Garret. "If we want to create jobs across America, we need a fully functioning Export-Import Bank approving these deals from manufacturers that are ready to close sales and hire workers." Sen. Sherrod Brown (D–Ohio), the ranking Democrat on the banking committee, called Garret's nomination "inappropriate," adding that "the National Association of Manufacturers, Chamber of Commerce, Aerospace Industries Association and the Ohio Manufacturing Association all oppose his nomination."

The Bank works by giving low-interest loans—backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. taxpayer—to foreign customers of American exporters. It also issues guarantees to private banks making loans to foreign purchasers of American products, promising to cover these banks' losses should these foreign debtors fail to make good on their obligations.

Because of these direct taxpayer subsidies for corporate sales, critics have long derided the bank as one of the worst examples of crony capitalism. The Competitive Enterprise Institute's Daniel Press calls it "one of the capital's greatest boondoggles." Veronique de Rugy of the Mercatus Center—a Reason columnist—has frequently suggested that the bank should be scrapped.

On this point, Garrett was once in agreement. While in Congress, he voted repeatedly to eliminate the Export-Import Bank. He has described it bluntly as an institution that "embodies the corruption of the free market system." If Garret had been approved—and if he kept that reformist spirit—he could have used his perch to expose bad deals and improper conduct.

Since 2015, operations of the Export-Import bank have been largely stalled, as empty board seats have left it without the quorum it needs to approve larger deals. The silver lining to Garrett's rejection is that the Bank will continue to be hobbled in conducting many of its ordinary operations.

Regardless, the Senate's refusal to confirm him demonstrates how entrenched, and indeed how bipartisan, corporatist interests in federal government are.

For all his faults, President Donald Trump has appointed a number of reformist, free-market-minded officials to staff his administration, including Neomi Rao at the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs and Scott Gottlieb at the Food and Drug Administration. But Garret proved a bridge too far. Big business, progressive Democrats, and conservative Republicans closed ranks to prevent him from getting his hands on Boeing's bank.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

13 responses to “The Senate’s Rejection of Export-Import Bank Critic Shows How Entrenched Crony Capitalism Is in Washington

  1. Can we assume no Democrats “broke ranks” to support the nomination?

    1. They did, however, break wind.

  2. Sen. Maria Cantwell (D?Wash.): “…we need a fully functioning Export-Import Bank approving these deals from manufacturers that are ready to close sales and hire workers.”

    I need to go grocery shopping tonight, and am suddenly wondering how I will manage without a bureaucracy to approve my purchases.

    1. Or a nation of taxpayers to subsidize them.

  3. The Senate Banking Committee voted 10?13 yesterday to reject former New Jersey Rep. Scott Garrett to head the Export-Import Bank, an institution that has become synonymous with corporate welfare.

    “Oh, well, who wants to spend time in an institution?”

    /Garrett

  4. Hooooh boy, another Import-Export Bank article? Well, this should be good. 500 comments?

    [Gets popcorn]

  5. For all his faults, President Donald Trump has appointed a number of reformist, free-market-minded officials to staff his administration, including Neomi Rao at the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs and Scott Gottlieb at the Food and Drug Administration.
    Trump getting some credit.

  6. “Big business, progressive Democrats, and conservative Republicans closed ranks to prevent him from getting his hands on Boeing’s bank.”

    There is nothing more bi-partisan the crony corruption.

    1. Yep. Out here in Seattle people are all about fearmongering over “big business”, but suggest you take away some of the handouts to Boeing and suddenly they are very pro business.

      Kind of like the way elderly Republicans feel about entitlement reform – even when their benefits would be grandfathered in.

  7. “If there was ever somebody who didn’t belong at the helm of the Ex-Im bank, it was Scott Garrett,” said Senate Democratic Leader Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.).

    Schumer called on Trump to withdraw Garrett’s nomination and choose someone who will “fulfill the mission of the Ex-Im bank.”

    Always looking out for the little guy, he is.

  8. “President Donald Trump has appointed a number of reformist, free-market-minded officials to staff his administration”

    Let’s be honest: that is his one saving grace and what makes it hard sometimes to criticize his policies. I don’t know who is orchestrating these nominations (God knows the man isn’t smart enough to pick these people), but they are really upsetting a lot of people in DC. Good for them

  9. Some people fear Trump will remake the GOP as his kind. I hope they’re right.

  10. At least , apparently , it makes a little money .

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.