Reason.com - Free Minds and Free Markets
Reason logo Reason logo
  • Latest
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Crossword
  • Video
  • Podcasts
    • All Shows
    • The Reason Roundtable
    • The Reason Interview With Nick Gillespie
    • The Soho Forum Debates
    • Just Asking Questions
    • The Best of Reason Magazine
    • Why We Can't Have Nice Things
  • Volokh
  • Newsletters
  • Donate
    • Donate Online
    • Donate Crypto
    • Ways To Give To Reason Foundation
    • Torchbearer Society
    • Planned Giving
  • Subscribe
    • Reason Plus Subscription
    • Print Subscription
    • Gift Subscriptions
    • Subscriber Support

Login Form

Create new account
Forgot password

Libertarianism

Are Libertarian Friends the Key to Fixing American Democracy?

Probably.

Katherine Mangu-Ward | 10.26.2017 2:35 PM

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL
Media Contact & Reprint Requests
Large image on homepages | Michael Bierut/Washington Post Magazine
(Michael Bierut/Washington Post Magazine)
Jessica Hische/Washington Post

Bursting your personal political bubble is important, but hard. It's so annoying to talk to people who totally disagree with you, amirite? Today in a forum on fixing democracy in The Washington Post Magazine, I argue that libertarians are the gateway drug to transpartisan understanding:

On the left and finding that Trump fans turn your stomach? Consider chatting with someone who will give you a hearty amen when you grouse about his immigration restrictionism and warmongering over a craft cocktail or a joint, but can still offer some insight into why a sane person might think environmental regulatory rollback or Social Security privatization is a good idea.

On the right and struggling to figure out how you'd connect with a blue-haired Occupy Wall Streeter? Find a libertarian: We'll grab some burgers and cigars. We can talk about repealing Obamacare and cutting taxes before easing into a conversation about why it might be time to seriously consider reforming our criminal justice system.

Innovative solution for repairing America's broken civic institutions, or shameless bid to make new friends? You decide.

Read the whole forum here, including entries from Kareen Abdul-Jabbar, Yuval Levin, George Takei, and more. Of particular note, ProPublica's Alec MacGillis, who very sensibly suggests allowing garage rental units, and Anne-Marie Slaughter, who likes instant-runoff voting.

Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

NEXT: Alabama Secretary of State Wants Willful Violators of New Voting Law Jailed for 5 Years

Katherine Mangu-Ward is editor in chief of Reason.

LibertarianismDemocracy
Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL
Media Contact & Reprint Requests

Hide Comments (87)

Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.

  1. Eidde   8 years ago

    I know, let's send out the H&R commenters as libertarian evangelists! Nothing could possibly go wrong.

    1. Eidde   8 years ago

      "Attention, slavers, please read this pamphlet and learn how to fuck off."

    2. Citizen X - #6   8 years ago

      Screw you, Eddie! Fuck you! I'm a fucking delightful person to hang out with, you fuck.

      1. Chipper Morning Truthjammer   8 years ago

        I bet most commenters are very pleasant people with whom one could spend some time. Emphasis on most.

        1. Eidde   8 years ago

          Emphasis on *some* time.

          Ha ha, no, y'all are great.

          1. Chipper Morning Truthjammer   8 years ago

            Better than the glibertarians?

            1. Eidde   8 years ago

              Must we get into that?

              1. Chipper Morning Truthjammer   8 years ago

                Deflection!

                1. Eidde   8 years ago

                  Deflection would be saying "I'll say hi to yo momma for you."

            2. CE   8 years ago

              Better, but not as graceful at cocktail parties, because we don't get invited as often.

              1. Eidde   8 years ago

                "Mr. Melon, Your Wife Was Just Showing Us Her Klimt."

                1. Eidde   8 years ago

                  context of that quote

        2. Citizen X - #6   8 years ago

          True fact: Mike Hihn is the most popular man in Boise, and cultured Idahoans clamor for invites to his frequent dinner parties.

          1. John   8 years ago

            True story, I recently had a paid ad show up on my facebook feed for Alan Venneman and his incredible novels. No kidding. The Facebook AI must really hate my guts.

            1. Citizen X - #6   8 years ago

              BEST B*G D*TA EVAH!

            2. Chipper Morning Truthjammer   8 years ago

              Well, now I am intrigued. What are the novels about? Cause I just googled "Alan Venneman" and all I got was a page about recent drunk driving sentences dished out in Jackson County, Michigan.

              1. John   8 years ago

                http://www.amazon.com/Alan-Vanneman/e/B001KHENQ4

                There is is Amazon page.

                1. Citizen X - #6   8 years ago

                  I sort of love his obviously self-written Wikipedia entry.

                  The topic of this article may not meet Wikipedia's notability guideline for biographies.

                  1. CE   8 years ago

                    So NOW Wikipedia is gonna make a big deal about notability? What are they running out of bits or something? Why not have 7 billion wikipedia pages, one for each person on Earth?

                  2. Chipper Morning Truthjammer   8 years ago

                    He is 73? If I knew that, I would have enjoyed all his comments that much more.

                2. Fuck =><= sevo   8 years ago

                  he was making a stupid joke about your spelling john

            3. Mainer2   8 years ago

              I think you misspelled Alan's name ?

              1. Eidde   8 years ago

                Oh, John misspelled the guy's *last* name, well, that's less interesting than I thought.

          2. Chipper Morning Truthjammer   8 years ago

            Cultured Idahoan libertarian = turnip?

            1. John   8 years ago

              I am starting to think Memory Hole is a Hihn sockpuppet. Just a theory but it seems to fit.

              1. BestUsedCarSales   8 years ago

                Until he writes (snicker) I don't believe.

          3. Uncle Jay   8 years ago

            That would explain why Idaho is such a socialist enclave.

        3. John   8 years ago

          Watch it chipper, there are a lot of people on here who take great pride in being insufferable assholes.

      2. BestUsedCarSales   8 years ago

        All are welcome to hang out with me. I have a lot of video games and alcohol, but I only currently have one controller. If you let me know ahead of time I can buy another. Also we can go shoot a gun or something, shit. Maybe I'm not fun to hang out with.

    3. CE   8 years ago

      Libertarians make the best friends because they don't tell you how to live your life, they don't want your money, and they don't expect you to bail them out.

      1. CE   8 years ago

        And we always have alcohol on hand.

        1. I am the 0.000000013%   8 years ago

          Alcohol in hand...

          And we do want your money, we just plan to get it by convincing you that you want to give it to us.

      2. EscherEnigma   8 years ago

        What you talking about, Willis? Libertarians love telling folks how to live their lives just as much as the next. The only difference is that, if you actually stick to your principles, you don't try to use the government to *force* folks to. But you lot are no more restrained in backseat driving then anyone else.

  2. Domestic Dissident   8 years ago

    Yes, we absolutely have problems that need to be dealt with, but I'm not sure I buy the premise that American democracy is fundamentally "broken". I suspect most of the people making this claim are just sore loser Obamatards who thought things were pretty awesome a year ago.

    1. colorblindkid   8 years ago

      I do think there were many times we were more "broken" than today. All in all, things are pretty good. Our poor people live better than 75% of the world. Does it still suck to be poor? Absolutely. But everybody really needs to keep things in perspective once in awhile. Open a goddamn history book and then complain today's really that terrible.

      1. JunkScienceIsJunk   8 years ago

        - The federal deficit is at its highest rate of all time, even adjusted for inflation.
        - The number of Americans incarcerated each year is the highest number for any country in the history of the Earth.
        - War has been rampant as america builds its empire. Civilian casualties are the norm, although we're probably getting better at this (because you can't get much worse than the early to mid 1900s...).
        - Taxes are at their highest rate ever.

        I don't think I share as optimistic view as you. But I agree that despite the US government's interventions in our affairs and in the lives of others, there has been net progress in technology, wealth, and health (the three being strongly interrelated of course). But I can't help but think that we would be even further along if the US would cut the shit already.

        1. colorblindkid   8 years ago

          "The number of Americans incarcerated each year is the highest number for any country in the history of the Earth."
          This is largely because there are only two countries in the history of the Earth with more people than us, and up until recently they were shitty third world countries with almost no functional government or court system. Yes, we incarcerate too many people, but this is a stupid statement.

          "War has been rampant as america builds its empire. Civilian casualties are the norm, although we're probably getting better at this (because you can't get much worse than the early to mid 1900s...)."

          America is arguably the least warmongering and least aggressive military superpower the world has ever seen. Never before has a nation or empire with such overwhelming military prowess not used it to acquire new territory or invade its neighbors to steal their resources. To compare historical wars of conquest and actual invasions to the last century of naive and futile attempts at trying to turn shitty countries into functioning countries is just dumb.

    2. TrickyVic (old school)   8 years ago

      ""but I'm not sure I buy the premise that American democracy is fundamentally "broken". ""

      I find most people that say our democracy is broken isn't aware that we are not a democracy.

      1. Hank Stamper   8 years ago

        Are we an anarcho-syndicalist commune?

  3. colorblindkid   8 years ago

    Fun little snippet by Katherine, and I wholeheartedly agree.

    However, the next suggestion after her is mandatory voting and the one after that is actually proposing we focus even more on identity politics, so I'm thinking we're not getting better anytime soon.

    1. John   8 years ago

      Race, class, gender. These lenses on society have proved revelatory, and no one would ever deny their importance.

      What do you do when confronted with someone who says that other than to politely nod and try and get away as quickly as possible?

      1. I am the 0.000000013%   8 years ago

        "I'll show your lenses some gender you'll find revelatory..."

    2. D.D. Driver   8 years ago

      Hilarious.

      Abortions for some, miniature American flags for others....

  4. John   8 years ago

    I find nearly everyone in this forum absolutely terrfying, sans KMW who is just sadly naive. How about this idea?

    There's a game I like to play called When I'm Emperor in which people go around the table and say the first thing they would implement if every decision in government were theirs alone to make. My answer is always the same: When I'm emperor I'll abolish private education.

    1. Ken Shultz   8 years ago

      I think the first thing I'd do . . .

      I'd make it so that taxes are all due on election day.

      I'd add a balanced budget amendment.

      1. Eidde   8 years ago

        I'd schedule a referendum on a constitution which abolishes my office and replaces my regime with a federal republic with guarantees of basic rights - with a note attached saying "don't mess it up this time."

        1. Ken Shultz   8 years ago

          You'd have the oval office redesigned as the bridge of the Enterprise, and you'd staff your cabinet with nothing but strippers.

          1. Eidde   8 years ago

            If the voters refused to accept my abdication then of course I'd have a mandate, and I would need an imperial residence suitable to my...I mean the people's dignity.

            1. Mickey Rat   8 years ago

              Just reduce to a purely ceremonial position with the caveat that Emperor gets to decide the nature of the ceremonies.

    2. lap83   8 years ago

      My answer is always the same: When I'm emperor I'll abolish private education.

      I'm reminded of Louis CK's bit about discussing time machines with an annoying friend

      "'well, here's what I would do'...because the whole point of asking me is to stare at me while I say mine and then say his"

  5. John   8 years ago

    Kareem Abul Jabaar, a guy that I really try to like and sometimes has good things to say, really embarrasses himself here. He wants government mandated critical thinking classes. That sounds nice except that he goes on to claim that Trump, Breitbart, and Foxnews would melt under the force of reason. Yeah, Kareen, everyone who disagrees with you is irrational. Way to bring the understanding and unity there pal.

    1. CE   8 years ago

      Tell your old man to drag Walton and Lanier up and down the court for 48 minutes sometime.

      1. TrickyVic (old school)   8 years ago

        Do you like gladiator movies?

  6. Ken Shultz   8 years ago

    A lot of the heart to heart political discussions I've had with people were over them approaching me thinking that we were natural allies. Usually, this happens when they oppose the guy in the White House. They see me denounce Obama for having killed more children than Adam Lanza and ObamaCare as an abomination, so they assume I must be ripe for recruitment into the Republican party. They see me go off on Bush for being having violated our rights or hear about my opposition to the Iraq War, and they think I must be ripe to become an enlightened progressive.

    What I find in those situations is that the more we all get to know each other, the more they realize how much I genuinely hate their heroes and their hypocrisy.

    Nothing makes a progressive angrier than pointing out that Barack Obama murdered hundreds of children in drone strikes, campaigned with the slogan, "Marriage is between a man and a woman", or point out that he used $hundreds of billions to bail out Wall Street.

    The thing they falsely accuse Republicans of being--rabid capitalist--is what I really am. I am their real boogeyman, and I know the root cause of our problems aren't really being addressed because there aren't millions of unemployed, hungry, former government employees protesting in the streets, I can see them start wincing. They can't believe it when I say that if the Republican Party were really out to slash the budget and kill all the taxes, I'd probably register as a Republican.

    1. Tony   8 years ago

      Republican without any pretense of morality. Bravo.

  7. Ken Shultz   8 years ago

    Republicans are highly sensitive to accusations of hypocrisy, too. Point out the folly of the Iraq War, and I'm a traitor. Point out that the Republicans spent $350 billion bailing out Wall Street, that George W. Bush expanded Medicare to cover prescriptions, that he violated our rights with warrantless wiretapping, that he disgraced us all by torturing prisoners, launched an attack on our Bill of Rights in the name of fear mongering that we may never fully recover from, etc., etc.--they don't come to any realization about how we're really not so different after all.

    I can generally agree with Republicans that Hillary or Bernie would have been much worse, but being better than having HIV doesn't say much for gonorrhea. I tell them I'm tired of hearing about how illegal immigrants shouldn't be allowed to use government services--as if American citizenship somehow made native born Republicans entitled to my paycheck?! You goddamn welfare queens, there isn't anything about your kids being American citizens that makes me feel better about having to pay for your kids to go to school.

    Like I said, the more people talk to each other, the more they realize that they really . . . don't like each other at all.

    The people who are most reachable are the people who probably don't want to talk about politics.

    1. Eidde   8 years ago

      Take a safe topic like sports and which teams are best.

      1. Ken Shultz   8 years ago

        They tried to recruit me into their shit eating club.

        I'm offended. They need to know why.

        1. Eidde   8 years ago

          You should be the top person in KMW's libertarian missionary squad, this is gonna be great!

        2. Citizen X - #6   8 years ago

          They Need To Know Why I'm Offended, the new weekly column from Ken Shultz, coming this fall to Parade Magazine.

          1. John   8 years ago

            I like that.

          2. $park? leftist poser   8 years ago

            I'm not sure Ken could limit himself to a column if given an outlet.

            1. Eidde   8 years ago

              I'm thinking book deal.

              1. Eidde   8 years ago

                The book would be as long as Kant's Critique of Pure Reason, but with more use of the f-word.

                1. $park? leftist poser   8 years ago

                  Ken doesn't use swear words, he's too uppity for that.

                  1. Eidde   8 years ago

                    The publisher would insert swear words at appropriate places, like they did with Wittgenstein.

          3. lap83   8 years ago

            I used to live in a town with a publication for senior citizens and it had a column which could have had that for a title, but it was for film reviews. It was the (unintentionally) funniest thing ever

      2. Uncle Jay   8 years ago

        "Take a safe topic like sports and which teams are best."

        ...like the NFL teams and what's going on with them lately.

  8. $park? leftist poser   8 years ago

    I argue that libertarians are the gateway drug to transpartisan understanding

    You all stay the fuck away from me. It's bad enough I gotta deal with my father.

  9. Uncle Jay   8 years ago

    RE: Are Libertarian Friends the Key to Fixing American Democracy?

    I don't see how any libertarian could possibly do any worse.

  10. Juice   8 years ago

    Let's reimagine the democratic right of voting as a citizen's obligation. In our doppelganger ally down under, Australia, voting is compulsory. They have far higher turnouts, and their elections boast greater legitimacy.

    So when the votes are forced they're more legitimate?

    1. Eidde   8 years ago

      Translation: Low-info voters tend to vote Democrat *if* they go to the polls. Also, informed but alienated members of their base often stay at home out of frustration. These key Democratic demographics must be *forced* to elect Democrats.

      1. Juice   8 years ago

        Low-info voters tend to vote Democrat *if* they go to the polls.

        I think that depends on the geography. I don't think the end result would be that much different, honestly.

        1. Eidde   8 years ago

          Maybe not, but I think the ones pushing for this "reform" at least think it will elect more Demcrats.

      2. Tony   8 years ago

        So Trump is the product of high-information people?

  11. Juice   8 years ago

    Fuck. Some of these ideas are truly fucked. From just plain dumb to totalitarian.

    A NEW HIGH SCHOOL COURSE: IDENTITY 101

    OUTLAW PRIVATE EDUCATION

    MANDATE MILITARY OR CIVILIAN SERVICE

    A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT ON EQUALITY (don't they already have it?)
    oh it's really an "Anti-Bigotry Amendment" (ah, ok, that's so much better then)

    CELEBRATE GOVERNMENT

    LET GOVERNMENT CO-OWN NEW TECHNOLOGIES

    MANDATE GUN INSURANCE

    BRING BACK THE COLD WAR ECONOMY

    WTF, people?

    1. John   8 years ago

      The entire thing is pretty terrifying. These people are hideous.

      1. Eidde   8 years ago

        You're not being very friendly, how can you convert them to libertarianism with that attitude?

        /sarc

  12. BestUsedCarSales   8 years ago

    Think about it: Those giant Ivy League endowments surging into state schools; the best teachers and administrators available to raise the standards in classrooms; public schools sporting planetariums and swimming pools and science labs and libraries, not to mention buildings maintained like country clubs instead of housing projects ? for the benefit of all children. Imagine the parents who, no longer able to ensure the futures of just their own child and those similar, would pour their considerable energy and resources into public education. The rising tide would lift all boats. There would be no other choice.

    There are a few probably outcomes there. First, the endowments would just not flow to any school period. The best teachers and administrators would possibly just become crushed under the forces of public education. There's a lot of other choices, her solution just assumes the end. Then she mentions how privileged she was to have had private Catholic education, and gives the solution that allowing no one that right is the solution.

    ESTABLISH NATIONAL UNITY WEEK

    I think we should have an hour every day where we sit and dwell on how great the government is.

    LET GOVERNMENT CO-OWN NEW TECHNOLOGIES

    I won't even joke. This chilled me to the core.

    CELEBRATE GOVERNMENT

    AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH

    ALLOW GARAGE UNIT RENTALS

    Looks like a good idea.

    1. TrickyVic (old school)   8 years ago

      ""ESTABLISH NATIONAL UNITY WEEK""

      2 Minutes Hate?

  13. Mickey Rat   8 years ago

    Libertarians only occupy a middle ground in their own heads. If anything, the Left thinks libertarians are worse than conservatives and have made that abundantly clear.

    1. BestUsedCarSales   8 years ago

      Yes, it really seems to be that way. That's why I'm so curious about the amount of hit pieces on Libertarians I see. They far, far outweigh the amount of power Libertarians actually wield. I can only thus assume that comes from a place of disgust and fear.

      1. Sam Haysom   8 years ago

        Libertarians are super easy targets because their ideals are unpopular and their members are generally socially awkward and often times resentful. So it's easy to run up the score against them.

      2. Tony   8 years ago

        Because it's fun.

  14. EscherEnigma   8 years ago

    Kind of a self-serving headline, isn't it? That said, if the idea is supposed to be that libertarians are some "middle ground" that can both understand and explain all sides of an issue, then you folks haven't been reading your own comment section. Libertarians are just as ignorant of other folks rationalizations and justifications as everyone else.

  15. Tony   8 years ago

    Everyone agrees with libertarians about some things. It's just that you're so wrong about some very big things.

  16. Mark22   8 years ago

    On the left and finding that Trump fans turn your stomach? Consider chatting with someone who will give you a hearty amen when you grouse about his immigration restrictionism and warmongering over a craft cocktail or a joint

    What "immigration restrictionism"? What "war mongering"?

Please log in to post comments

Mute this user?

  • Mute User
  • Cancel

Ban this user?

  • Ban User
  • Cancel

Un-ban this user?

  • Un-ban User
  • Cancel

Nuke this user?

  • Nuke User
  • Cancel

Un-nuke this user?

  • Un-nuke User
  • Cancel

Flag this comment?

  • Flag Comment
  • Cancel

Un-flag this comment?

  • Un-flag Comment
  • Cancel

Latest

That Time the FBI Conspired To Get George Foreman an Award for Boxing

Matthew Petti | 6.6.2025 10:00 AM

Another Divorce for Trump

Liz Wolfe | 6.6.2025 9:40 AM

Texans Gain the Right To Try Individualized Medical Treatments

J.D. Tuccille | 6.6.2025 7:00 AM

Review: There Are No Top-Down Solutions to the Problems Depicted in Adolescence

Autumn Billings | From the July 2025 issue

Review: A Comic Book Villain Runs for Mayor of New York in the New Daredevil Series

Joe Lancaster | From the July 2025 issue

Recommended

  • About
  • Browse Topics
  • Events
  • Staff
  • Jobs
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Media
  • Shop
  • Amazon
Reason Facebook@reason on XReason InstagramReason TikTokReason YoutubeApple PodcastsReason on FlipboardReason RSS

© 2024 Reason Foundation | Accessibility | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

r

Do you care about free minds and free markets? Sign up to get the biggest stories from Reason in your inbox every afternoon.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

This modal will close in 10

Reason Plus

Special Offer!

  • Full digital edition access
  • No ads
  • Commenting privileges

Just $25 per year

Join Today!