Who's Watching the Watchers? Reason Is, That's Who
Your tax-deductible donations will help us keep a close eye on the surveillance state.
We have an incoming administration under President-Elect Donald Trump that's more likely to see surveillance whistleblower Edward Snowden as a traitor than a protector of Americans' right to privacy and government transparency.

During the lengthy presidential election race, you would have been hard-pressed to find very much discussion or debate on surveillance issues at all, even as the United States (and other countries) hammer out rules directly affecting the strength of citizens' rights to protect private data and communications from unwarranted and secretive snooping.
But Reason has not backed off keeping readers up-to-date in government snooping issues. Trump (along with the likes of Senators Dianne Feinstein and Richard Burr) may not have understood why Apple refused to simply help the FBI unlock an iPhone that was in the possession of one of the terrorists responsible for the deadly attacks in San Bernardino, California, but Reason was there to help explain.
Not only is it abhorrent for the government to use the courts to draft a company and force it to assist in its investigations via court order; Apple deliberately cracking its own encryption for the benefit of government officials created a huge vulnerability for every user of its products, not just a dead terrorist. As pretty much every tech company under the sun attempted to get the government to understand, once the security or encryption of a phone, or an app, or an operating system has a "back door" that would allow the FBI or other law enforcement officials in, that manner of getting access to data was doomed to spread. Politicians seem to think it's possible for companies to create "golden keys" to allow just the "right people" to break encryptions. Even if we were to accept the FBI and prosecuting attorneys around the country as the "right people" (and you really shouldn't), if there's a vulnerability in a system's security, the "wrong people" will eventually find it.
That's why Reason made it very clear during the midst of this fight why people who are not terrorists or criminals still need to be very concerned if our data and communications security gets deliberately weakened for the sole purpose of helping government investigations.
While America has avoided bad legislation on encryption so far, the United Kingdom has jumped full-force into citizen surveillance, thanks to new Prime Minister Theresa May, a huge fan of snooping on her own citizens. Not only does the newly passed Investigatory Powers Bill give dozens of British agencies the authority to access citizens' private browsing history, it gives the government permission to demand that tech companies remove or bypass their own encryption on demand. Reason has been tracking the journey of this legislation and its potential consequences not just on British citizens, but for anybody who uses a smart phone, tablet, or computer (in other words, just about everybody).
During the presidential race, neither Trump nor Clinton showed much capacity for even talking about cybersecurity or encryption coherently (as if the role of hackers in completely embarrassing the Democratic establishment with email leaks didn't make that clear), leaving Americans to wonder who will be developing policy under the incoming administration.
Reason will be staying on top of exactly what Trump's administration might do (will we follow in the United Kingdom's footsteps?) and what might be done to protect your basic right to privacy from unwarranted government snooping in an era where everything about our personal lives has become digitized.
Your donations help Reason keep sounding the alarm on these high-tech government-led privacy intrusions and also helps us discuss and debate policy-based solutions. For example, Reason's Scott Shackford will be leading a panel discussion at the popular South by Southwest Interactive conference in Austin, Texas, in March. The panel, titled "Get a Warrant: The Fourth Amendment and Digital Data," brings together a pack of tech and privacy experts to discuss what sort of legislative solutions Congress might pursue that could potentially keep America off the path selected by the U.K. Your donations help make outreach into venues like this possible.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
There are no comments.
First!
I haven't followed much lately. What's happening with Bayern? Is it Ancelotti or the team needs retooling or both?
Given the team names you referenced, I'm assuming you're talking about soccer.
As an aside, I see Reason is prompting the fact that they are projected to fall short of their donation goal. Can't say I'm surprised. As I stated last week: Ask for charitable donations based on the stipulation that a certain base amount of money be seen as a 'vote against' the prescribed writer of your choosing. )
Okay. I believe they added extra squirrels on the preview edit option. My keyboard can't operate properly as of the moment.
Yeh. I see the donation bar is a little low.
When your product is misaligned with your customers, you tend to lose business.
I find that the quality of writing here sucks, except for a few of the better writers. Whether it's a juvenile flow of the article, a superficial topic, or an unprincipled stance, most of the articles here aren't good.
I'd love to see Reason give the commentariat a place to put out longer material, even if it were only once a week and were somehow moderated/edited/etc. I think that a Wednesday Woodchipper type article from a commenter would be one of the most well received each week.
And they need better trolls. The quality has really gone down lately.
See below for evidence.
I remember the glory days of Herc.
The Age of Titans, that was.
All those caps, it was beautiful.
There was a playful innocence to those days that doesn't exist now that our troll brigade consists solely of socially awkward, self-entitled, bitter, angry man-children.
Enya = flaky girls in college I dated.
"I'd love to see Reason give the commentariat a place to put out longer material,..."
The Agile Cyborg Saturday Night screed would be a thing of beauty.
People would ask, 'what do you read?' I'd show them an Agile Cyborg piece from Reason. And then they would all just...behold.
Try that with SugarFree.
I read that. I did not know whether to be insulted or feel proud. I got so introspective I just turned off my computer. Which may have been the point. I'm not sure.
Still here.
But who's keeping an eye on Shackelford? Who knows what kind of impish knavery he might commit?
Aloysious,
Did you mistype Scott Shackford's name? If not, I missed your reference.
If so, I can answer your question with regards to who is keeping a watch on H&R's Scott Shackford:
For example, Reason's Scott Shackford will be leading....
This from the man who wrote the article and not only referenced himself in the third person but on several occasions in his article today he took the opportunity to post links to previous articles he has written.
Aloysious, my fellow commentator, clearly Scott Shackford himself keeps watch on himself.
(As do some of us, Scott Shackford's superior Alt-Text notwithstanding)
It's just a running gag someone else started that makes me laugh. I'm pretty sure it was inspired by one scene from King of the Hill:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S580EX1nnYU
Needling Shackford, Bailey, Welch by getting their names wrong is a fun hobby.
Thanks for the explanation.
I thought only Spider-man could have webathons.
hahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
oh my
If you look it up, I was a subscriber, but....oh my.
Soon, I'll only have South Park
Phillies Peanut vendor Emily Youcis fired for public Alt-right views.
http://deadspin.com/phillies-p.....1789696359
What a bunch of assholes.
I found your cousin, Alabama Man.
New at Reason: Why this man should have the right to keep his job no matter what his employer thinks about his speech.
It's funny, I remember constantly being lectured by the left that McCarthyism and blacklists and such were wrong, that someone's political views, even if they shill for a murderous and hateful ideology, should not prevent from from working in their chosen field.
But apparently they just meant commies and Soviet stooges should be left alone
Communists aren't really bad. Their hearts are in the right place, they just go too far sometimes. It's different when they do it.
Nutjob loses nut job.
Fuck off, asswipe.
Thicc
Who is that?
Twin Peaks.
It is tax deductible because they are kowtowing to DA MAN!
If you did nothing wrong you should have nothing to hide.
D
Try harder
"Murder convictions rare for owners or landlords of deadly sites"
http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/.....701598.php
IANAL, but I'm pretty sure "murder" requires intent and action in pursuit of that intent, so, yeah, murder is going to be real hard to prove.
It not helping the DA here in that the city inspectors have been turning a blind eye to the arrangement, which they seemed to know existed.
Do they bother giving any other flavors of homicide convictions for owners? Just from what you stated, I am not giving them a click.
Yeah, but it's mostly a whine about how Bangladesh is 'more advanced' than we are...
We just had a forest fire not that far from here that burned over 1,700 homes with 14 (so far) fatalities. Looks like Sevier County, TN is more advanced than Oakland.
See my link above about Alabama Man.
And when he moved to Oakland, his prepaid pad was gone.
I think the Oakland death count is over 30, now.
It was over 33 yesterday. CNN is saying 36 as of a few hours ago.
It is probably going quite a bit higher. I think the latest claim is there were 50 who were not accounted for.
Starbucks mourns...
(too soon?)
I'm thinking more along the lines of 'negligence resulting in death'. Even then...
It's going to be Man One times 37 (or whatever the final toll is. Probably over 40.)
This has replaced TRUMP, TRUMP,TRUMP, TRUMP, TRUMP, TRUMP, TRUMP,... on the Chron's front page. Somebody mentioned last night that this is zoning's 9/11, and I'm sure it'll produce its own "TSA" which accomplishes the opposite of the desired effect.
It's already got the new Chron 'identity' columnist pimping for gov't-subsidized 'artists collectives' and of course the 'artists' are drooling at the free shit. And given the quality of art' in the bay area (Bush jokes, verbal and visual, are 'edgy'), I'm sure the 'artists' won't mind gov't vetting.
My opinion of how an "artist" is defined it pretty simple: Does your art pay your bills?
If not, you're a hobbyist, and we ought to subsidize model railroaders just as much as you.
Now you gave them the idea of a national model railroader's collective agency. Thanks.
gov't-subsidized 'artists collectives'
JFC.
It's called "college". It's mostly performance art.
Exactly.
The motto of any urban administration is, "how can i use this event as justification for spending more money and creating more bureaucratic constituents."
The housing admin simply doesn't have enough budget! the fire code is being 'neglected'! its because of a lack of 'affordable housing'.
There will be a half-dozen solutions thrown at this, none of which involve improving the system that exists, and all of which involve spreading more money around. I'm sure they'll even squeeze in extra fire-drill training money for all the local schools.
Its always the way it goes.
"Chicago continues to break records for violence this year, reaching another milestone at the end of last month by recording its 701st homicide. There were fewer than 500 in 2015."
http://www.infowars.com/chicag.....ed-so-far/
Think Rahm might re-think the gun laws in Chi-town?
"Complaints to the city that brought out an inspector, who tried to enter on Nov. 17, failed and never returned."
Returned to the building, or from the building? Did they eat him?
I laughed.
So, let me get this straight. They live in a city that insists on inspecting every fucking thing, at the insistence of the vast majority of the residents, but an inspector for these kinds of issues can't get the Sheriff's deputies to assist them in doing a codes inspection?
Am I missing something here?
Nope. That's pretty much how it works in lands run by enlightened top people.
FTA:
"One entity that will be off the hook is the city of Oakland, for failing to conduct an inspection that might have shut the building down. A 1963 state law shields local governments from liability for harm allegedly caused by not performing inspections."
See above for the 'cure'...
oops; meant for next comment...
I know it is not a laughing matter, and I am sorry about all the kids who were dumb enough to hang in this place, but ya, this is the Government so many want more of. My guess is they inspected it, but the inspectors knew if they chucked the people on the street they would never hear the end of it.
It *seems* like it's getting increasingly difficult for people to do their jobs in several domains for fear of a backlash of some sort.
There was selective enforcement. I have no doubt.
Absolutely. Betcha anybody with two nickels to rub together was paying fines out the ass for an improperly edged yard during the same time this was festering.
No, I'm sure it's because these people simply had the "right" opinions, being hippies.
The government always gives a pass to lefties for anything short of murder, and even then there is often a lot of weaseling involved.
This FUCKING narrative is ridiculous. Gentrification and housing costs? Yeah, that's totally what caused this.
Two former residents of the Ghost Ship have said that the police were there at LEAST once a week. They have body cam footage of the entire facility, including changes to the internal structure over several years. Social workers have been there a dozen times and they are supposed to note unsafe conditions. Somehow, those 2 freaks still got their kids back.
There was an entire army of 6 figure salaried government employees that were in contact with these people. NONE of them did their jobs. They still can't figure out what the fuck happened and they're "conducting a review".
But yeah, the problem is totally gentrification.
See above for the 'cure'...
In my county, on the other side of the country, and I did my job like that, I would be fired. And I am a full figure away from six.
I am not a codes inspector, I am air quality. So my job starts when some pollutant crosses a property line (with just a couple of exceptions). If I am not allowed access to find the source of the problem, I call the Sheriff's department. If a fire is involved, I call the fire department/company that handles the location and the Sheriff's department if needed.
So how many of the inspectors will be charged with negligent manslaughter at least?
(OK, I'll stop laughing.)
Standing Rock update from an impartial source, finally.
Umm...why does that toddler have B cups?
Soy milk and phytoestrogens
Seems legit.
Some natives grow tiny.
And thicc.
You.
Are a beautiful human being?
I would not know.
You are you, HM, you are you.
Ehyeh asher ehyeh.
You are you and you know that that is not you.
I'm bummed that "Freezing Man" never caught on.
I dig that one.
"I'm bummed that "Freezing Man" never caught on."
Emmet, North Dakota
Light Snow
14?F
Feels Like
-7?F
Humidity: 86%
Wind Speed: 29mph
Wind Direction: 290?
Dew Point: 10?
Visibility: 0.75mi
Tonight: Snow along with gusty winds at times. Low near 10F. Winds NW at 35 to 50 mph. Chance of snow 80%. Snow accumulating 1 to 3 inches. Winds could occasionally gust over 60 mph.
http://www.intellicast.com/Local/WxMap.aspx
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9jgTW_btOHs
If done for political reasons, I look forward to the collapse of youtube AND Twitter.
I found JR over at The American Spectator:
"albertconstantinejr
6 days ago
From the New York Times, April 30, 1945:
Berlin (NYT)- The controversial reign of the German Leader came to an end today, as reports are received that Adolf Hitler took his own life. His term in office was marked with significant transformation for the German people, though critics suggest that his treatment of certain minorities would mar his legacy. The depressed chief executive will be remembered for his fierce commitment to the German people and their bloodlines, and his life was also marked by his affection for dogs, particularly his own Shepherd Blondi, who preceded him in death. Advocates for vegetarianism and non-smokers will also continue to point to the charismatic politician for the example that he set for those who choose these lifestyles."
"Vigil in SF mourns transgender victims of Oakland fire"
http://www.sfgate.com/
No, I'm not gonna reward the identity-whores with a link to the story, just to the page proving such assholes exist.
GRAB that bloody shirt, shitbags! Wave it so all can see how pathetic you are!
Some months back I was working for a condo HOA and the lady I was dealing with was telling me about the lawsuit they had had against the contractor who built it. He was paying off the inspector and they both got caught. Of course work was done that was very obviously not anything close to code. It didn't even matter that the inspector was fired, the city had immunity. That even surprised me. I knew that they were immune if the inspector made any mistakes, but not if they were completely negligent or on the take. Thank god we have the city to protect us.
"Thank god we have the city to protect us"
I know *I* sleep better at night...
No need to mourn the cisgender ones. Their cis-privilege gives them each an extra life.
Enter to win the Trump Truck!
http://thetrumptruck.com/
Needs stars and bars and tila tequilas face on hood.
No. Naked tila tequila on hoid.
OT
Generally speaking, you are more likely to win a war through sudden and overwhelming force than through gradual escalation. This is because gradual escalation gives the enemy time to adapt to your tactics and develop countermeasures.
In order to defeat your enemy, you must inflict damage on him faster than he can recover. Otherwise, he can fight indefinitely.
"War is cruelty. There is no use trying to reform it. The crueler it is, the sooner it will be over."
-William Tecumseh Sherman
+ nuclear warheads
Other relevant quotes:
Every attempt to make war easy and safe will result in humiliation and disaster.
-Sherman, again
The essence of war is violence. Moderation in war is imbecility.
-Lord John Fisher
The imbecile trueman was here earlier today bloviating that superior generals will sin over weapons; tell that to the Japanese WRT the samurai spirit.
Similarly, Overy is wrong regarding the outcome of WWII.
In any war which is fought as a war, rather than a 'regime change'; he who has the weapons and the ability and desire to use them wins the war.
There have been many tribes an civilizations who boasted of having the toughest warriors: Aztecs, Maoris, Lakota, Spartans, Zulus, etc
They usually end up getting conquered by someone with better weapons and tactics.
Usually people who have to live without all the amenities of modern technology are tougher. They also tend have shittier weapons.
Now we know how awful a prog has to be to get fired from Oberlin:
Ohio professor fired over anti-Semitic Facebook posts
Brooke Singman is hot.
Only with a shovel.
"Assistant Professor of Rhetoric and Composition"
IOWs an imbecile.
"She claimed on social media that the Jewish state secretly planned the Sept. 11 terror attacks, the Charlie Hebdo attack in Paris and that Mossad, Israel's national security agency, former Islamic State"
Malkin went to Oberlin? No wonder she's so angry:)
Using familial dna for law enforcement
http://abc6onyourside.com/news.....milial-dna
All CPD wearing body cams by mid 2017
http://nbc4i.com/2016/12/05/ci.....-contract/
Someone who does not need another pork chop
http://nbc4i.com/2016/12/05/te.....over-pork/