Oregon Student Government: Dressing Up as Any Character Is Cultural Appropriation, Not Okay
War on Halloween


The student-governments of rival schools Oregon State University and the University of Oregon have announced a temporary partnership, which is kind of like how it would be if Negan from The Walking Dead could somehow join forces with Ramsay Bolton.
And why are these villains teaming up? (UO and OSU, not Negan and Ramsay.) You can probably guess: they want to play Halloween costume police.
In a strongly worded email to students at both campuses, student-government presidents Rachel Grisham and Quinn Haaga warned their communities that acts of cultural appropriation "are not acceptable." Full stop.
Seriously:
Cultural appropriation is the act of borrowing or using aspects of a culture by another culture, typically a dominant culture. Around the time of Halloween, we often see people dressing as a culture or a character, which is offensive and reinforces negative stereotypes. These costumes reinforce racism, sexism, and classism. As active and respectful members of the OSU and the UO communities, we expect everyone to not engage in cultural appropriation.
Or what? is a tempting response. Unfortunately, we know exactly what will happen to transgressors. The University of Oregon, for example, harbors one of the most dangerous bias response teams I've written about. Students who push the line, as far as costumes are concerned, can expect to be investigated.
The idea that students should avoid particular costumes because they happen to involve other cultures is absurd, and this email unintentionally points out exactly why. Note that its authors have inadvertently outlawed practically all Halloween costumes in their zeal to punish cultural appropriation, which isn't even a bad thing that should be discouraged in the first place.
Can I dress up as Ramsay? He's a character, after all, and I wouldn't want to appropriate Westerosi culture.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
The races and cultures should never mix, that's the truly progressive position. From now on, I will eat nothing but sauerkraut and kielbasa, with the occasional beer, per my ethnic heritage.
Doing that would confine me to Scottish, Irish, and German, which I will not do. As someone who grew up in North Jersey, I consider myself an honorary Italian.
You consider that an honor?!?!
"You sayin' it ain't an honor?"
/Public-relations representative, Legitimate Italian Businessmen's Social Club
I'm making over $15k a month working part time. I kept hearing other people tell me how much money they can make online so I decided to look into it. Well, it was all true and has totally changed my life.
Go this web Site and click to Tech tab to start your work... http://www.Trends88.com
Fuggedaboutit
https://youtu.be/_nc42tliHDE
Cultural appropriation was first invented by the Nazis, they didn't want pure Aryan Germans listening to Jazz music because of it's black background. Germans were instead encouraged to listen to music from their own ethnic background like Mozart, and Wagner.
Therefor any non-German who accuses someone of cultural appropriation is in fact guilty of cultural appropriation themselves.
I will now report this bias incident.
Well, self policing for cultural appropriation was invented by them (probably not really, but let's go with it). Cultural appropriation was invented the first time two distinct human cultures encountered each other.
Makes sense; Progressives are America's Fascists.
"No mixing of cultures, but please produce all the mixed-race children you wish! We need more bodies to fill the Cultural and Ethnic Grievance Army!
PS--Dressing up as rednecks to mock working-class whites is still acceptable and is not cultural appropriation."
How dare they appropriate Red neckware from the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution!
Also dressing up as stereotypical horned-helmeted, pillaging Vikings.
So, what are you supposed to do when your traditional culture consists of appropriating other cultures? Like every culture that didn't develop in complete isolation?
Surrender yourself to will of your betters.
You will be assimilated. It is futile to resist.
Dude. The line is "resistance is futile".
Dammit
For values of less than 1 Ohm
No halushki?
I hope you are an actual homosexual, otherwise that's serious cultural appropriation!
Alternate joke: I guess that means all those white SJWs can only dress up as Nazis.
For those who say that this stuff doesn't matter. Take a look at Quinn's LinkedIn page.
She's already worming her way into government, where she can tell everybody what to do (or not). These nutjobs want to rule us.
Well of course they do; meanwhile they get tons of sympathy and support from the White House on down.
Jesus, what a nightmare--nearly every single item on that resume is a bureaucrat position of some sort. Someone get this girl a summer internship in some blue-collar industry so she isn't permanently blinded to all the stupid shit her colleagues propose.
Why? She gets more money and power for less energy expended. And she can ride this cursus honorum all the way to the top and become a real power (i.e. high-level bureaucrat not appointed by the Executive) in some federal govt. department someday.
She did have a lead hostess at a cantina job...
Not too bad looking. Don't worry, if you knock her up she'll have no qualms about an abortion.
Then again, never stick it in crazy.
I kept thinking as a read her page that she was probably the teacher's pet in 6th grade, as well.
After gaining two years experience helping customers find clothes at Nordstrom's, the university gave her a $16m budget.
Worse than that - the Nordstrom's job was concurrent with the management of the $16m budget. The *prior* experience was as the lead door whore...oops, hostess...at a Mexican food joint.
My office with 30 employees grosses less than that a year - and they give some college airhead 16 million $ to pass out like candy? That's taxpayer money. Another of her student council friends has control over an additional $2.7m
Wait a second.... a Mexican restaurant? Has anyone on the bias response team investigated her background yet?
PANHELLENIC COUNCIL????
Oh, that's rich.
You would make a great Ramsay, Robbo.
Burn!
Agreed.
Even Robby has a way to go to get on the level of Ramsay's trolling.
Both have pretty magnificent hair, though.
I guess the term "melting pot" is racist now.
I imagine the pot calling the kettle black is too
Back when I was receiving my youthful indoctrination, we were taught that America was great because it was a melting pot. Now the concept of the American melting pot is being shamed as cultural appropriation.
The progs consider this progress?
I actually first started hearing about the "salad bowl vs melting pot" argument in middle school in the late 80s. My history teacher was a hardcore leftist and promoting the former rather than the latter, so this idea goes back a long way.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9286f1r-nY
Yes, and it was as ridiculous then as it is now. This bullshit about "cultural appropriation" is just the beginning of where it leads. Multi-culturalism Balkanization has never worked anywhere its been tried. You simply don't get an equilibrium when multiple civilizations occupy the same place at the same time. Forcing the public to subsidize the non-integration of foreign cultures (the melting pot is simply a metaphor for the natural cultural diffusion that occurs when free people are allowed to interact as such) can only end in the destruction of the original culture or the destruction of the imposed culture.
Anything that pushes us closer to total government control over every minute aspect of our lives, they consider progress.
Obviously it's about POWER. They'll push you in one direction, and when you're as far as you'll go that way, they find an excuse to push in the completely opposite direction. Case in point "get the people OUT OF these horrible big cities and out into the lands of plenty" only to turn around and "you're ruining Mother Earth with your parking lots and sprawl - back on top of each other in Super Cities!". There's dozens of other examples. Again, it all about Power, Force, and Control. The fascism of this country has a long and successful history, though it's usually been called something else. The only real change is the amount of the GDP the asshats are allowed to control - that ratchets ever upward as they zig-zag back and forth bereft of consistency or logic.
But, we live longer and it isn't dictators hounding us, so it's all good.
I better not see any Hispanics drinking or wearing green on St. Patrick's Day
Liberals have been pushing that the idea of America as a melting pot is racist since the 1990s.
Really? Growing up in the '90s, I remember the term being commonly used in a positive way. Then again, I suppose that's when the New Left had just started to gain prominence.
Did you just assume it's culinary function? Oh. My. GAWD.
Does anyone sell a social justice warrior costume? Asking for a friend.
I assume it involves a fat-suit, glasses, blue hair
You're a Randy Harper man? I thought she'd be more up Crusty's alley...
(looks her up)
Well i'll be damned. It really is sort of a species, isn't it?
Holy shit, you actually weren't making a reference and were talking in generic terms? Damn!
This one?
http://www.breitbart.com/big-j.....der-issue/
That's a Tumblrina costume. There are other types of SJW, you bigot.
Well help me out then and provide me a list of items for an easily-identified SJW uniform
I google-images the term? And I get lots of this sort of thing
Overweight, unnaturally colored and badly cut hair, rings piercing the lips & nose.
UMass just sent out a chart so you can safely decide if your costume is appropriating of offensive; they use the color code system, identical to that used by Homeland Security, to tell you if you are green and safe, yellow and at risk, orange, and red for clearly crossing the line.
I suggest you get that and copy it onto a sandwich board; then just tell everyone that you are a social justice warrior. Or maybe a trigger warning.
Yes.
/hat tip to whoever originally posted this link
I'm thinking red pantsuit.
I'm adding a question to my job interviews:
"Have you ever used the terms "micro-aggression" or "cultural appropriation except to express mockery and abuse?"
I usually respond to comments about micro-aggression with references to clever uses of shivs. Would that work, because I may be looking for work soon.
Halloween derives from pagan rites and from the Christian celebration of All Saints Day, with the name "Halloween" being a contraction of "All Hallow's {i.e., Saints} Eve," as in Christmas Eve.
Therefore, any non-European who dares to celebrate Halloween is engaging in cultural appropriation.
I demand action.
You want to take action on this racial problem.
You might want to say you're looking for a solution.
Or wanting to "start a conversation" which is really "hey, you shut up and just listen because you ARE the problem"
You just un-Godwinned my joke. 🙁
I blame the Jews.
You know who else wanted an ultimate solution to racial conflicts...
(There, FIFY.)
You mean like some sort of Final Solution?
Like, a camp where problematic people can be concentrated? So they can get solved?
And wear nice little multicolored triangle armbands?
"Like, a camp where problematic people can be concentrated? So they can get solved?"
FDR?
From the article: "Cultural appropriation is the act of borrowing or using aspects of a culture by another culture, typically a dominant culture." So, it's basically a "heads I win, tales you lose" situation.
"Reinforces negative stereotypes."
Without even knowing what the costume is? So being a doctor is a bad thing? Man, I've been living my life like a crazy person then.
But Benny the Beaver and The Oregon Duck are okay at sporting events. I see.
"I'm a Beaver."
I know you are, but what school do you go to?
I always love it when Oregon State plays South Carolina. I know, I'm so juvenile.
The Cocks last reamed the Beavers in 2014.
To appropriate the show, Archer:
Do you want people to vote for Trump? because that's how you get people to vote for Trump.
Every time a white person puts on a headdress, a Native American baby contracts smallpox.
As someone of Scots-Irish ancestry, does this means I can dress up as a leprechaun and drink lots of whiskey? Because I can live with that.
No, you imperialist, you're not a true Gael, you should dress up as a Presbyterian minister.
My Presbyterian minister was an ex-Catholic Italian. True story.
Alright, you all. Here is how we fight this bullshit. We act like rednecks. We claim that "yes, this is a good idea. Race mixing should never happen. Black should stay with black and Asian with Asian." With enough trolling in good time we will beshit the term "Cultural Appropriation" and associate it with racism.
Interesting point. Is interracial marriage a form of cultural appropriation?
Well, if its a white man marrying a black woman, its practically the reinvention of slavery!
I've tried this, and sadly it doesn't work. I've literally been told that it's impossible for non-whites to be racist; it's all backlash against a white supremacist society. (Seriously. The Dallas shooter? Excused away as "backlash.") I've just stopped caring what they say anymore. It's truly sad when I am not bothered (to much, it still bothers me a little for the pure ignorance of it all) for being called a racist, but that's what happens when literally everything I do and am is titled racist.
...which is kind of like how it would be if Negan from The Walking Dead could somehow join forces with Ramsay Bolton.
Is Soave the millennial generation's Dennis Miller?
You were only reminded of Dennis Miller's abstruseness because I made a Dennis Miller joke in the other thread.
I don't read anyone's comments but my own. However, he was likely in my head because HBO recently showed The Larry Sanders Show every night, and Dana Carvey was doing that impression. So there.
How did you know to say this
at just the right point in the thread?
Needs moar political and drug references .
like
Then he would be the millennial generation's version.
Sorry, there should be a question mark at the end of that.
This is why new sports teams almost all use animals as their mascots. People don't get offended by Ravens, Panthers, Jaguars, Pelicans, Grizzlies, Raptors, Timberwolves and what-not. Even the new non-animal teams use innocuous mascots like Lightning or Magic.
We used to have mascots named after people, usually specific professions: Steelers, Raiders, Oilers, 49ers, Packers, Cowboys, Vikings. I don't think we'll see another "people" mascot any time soon.
"People don't get offended by Ravens, Panthers, Jaguars, Pelicans, Grizzlies, Raptors, Timberwolves and what-not."
Cougars?
Cougar just opens up a whole nother door; ageism, sexism, hatred toward older women who are trying to exercise their sexual freedom, this list can just go on and on.
The main thing you need to know about cougars though, is that they like to hang around watering holes, and as closing time approaches they pick their prey and pounce, Once they get their claws in you it's pretty much all over; best to just give up and go home with them for the night, and drink to forget about it the next day.
Once they are too old to claim their prey they morph into turkey vultures and subsist on passed out leftovers that can't fight back.
Thanks for that excerpt from "Confessions of a Tadpole."
I wish this site had a 'rec' button.
What sports team would even want to call itself Cougars? Outside of Washington State, I mean.
University of Houston? BYU?
Notice how nobody ever complains about how terrible it is to have Vikings as a mascot? As if all Nordish people are war mongering brutes who blow battle horns?
Would anybody today confuse Vikings with modern-day Scandiwimps?
Forget Vikings. How about "Celtics" (made worse because it is mispronounced with a hard "k" rather than a soft "c") and, worse yet, the "Fighting Irish?"
I think the Irish at Notre Dame pressed for this slogan.
Ha ha, the dumb Irish - they're racist against *themselves*!
Everyone agrees that Vikings are cool. Even the SJWs have to grudgingly admit that.
That's because we who are descended from the Viking raiders are proud of heritage and celebrate our wild and woolly past.
People don't get offended by Ravens, Panthers, Jaguars, Pelicans, Grizzlies, Raptors, Timberwolves and what-not.
What about vegans?!
Only inanimate objects can be mascots without being problematic, shitlord.
My father was murdered by a tree.
Didn't PETA once ask the Green Bay Packers to change their name?
Who evens knows what a packer is these days?
I believe it's vernacular for fudge packer.
These costumes reinforce racism, sexism, and classism. As active and respectful members of the OSU and the UO communities, we expect everyone to not engage in cultural appropriation.
So, everyone come as themselves, m'kay?
Can I dress up as Ramsay? He's a character, after all, and I wouldn't want to appropriate Westerosi culture.
With that hair you're a dead ringer for a Lannister.
"A Lannister always pays for his fruit sushi.."
There's a story out just today that some professor of some bullshit department in a Canadian University is claiming that the canoe, yes the boat one finds oneself in when up the proverbial shit creek without a paddle, is not only cultural appropriation but a symbol of oppression when used by white people. I did not make this up, but with I did.
My larger question is how far is this absolute nonsense going to go? Matters of race and oppression have become so nuanced that they only exist in subjective fantasies, and seem to be ever evolving without any sense of practical reality. Will it get to the point that it takes a Reich to deal with it [because these idiots would be all too happy to force it to that level]?
The good thing about the internet is it gives voice to the voiceless.
The bad thing about the internet is it gives voice to the voiceless.
Sometimes, people don't have a voice because their words are fucking dumb.
On that I fear you are mistaken Jay. Being fucking dumb in no way deprives them of a voice, in fact it only seems to amplify it and garner sympathy from other dumb fucks, like most news outlets. And universities.
Well, he is practically begging us white people to sail in Longships and raid every campus in the Great Lakes and down the Eastern Seaboard.
A canoe is a convenient watercraft for inland waterways. Full stop.
And bows and arrows were invented independently by multiple cultures.
"Or what?" is not as tempting a response as two other words I would use in this situation.
"Fuck off, slaver" is three words, sir
Yes, but brevity is the soul of wit. If you don't like a simple "Fuck off!" there's always "Piss off" (if you want to appropriate British culture.)
the vast majority of students hit delete whenever emails from their university show up in their inbox and these absurdly comical proclamations go ignored.
One hopes.
Cultural appropriation is the act of borrowing or using aspects of a culture by another culture, typically a dominant culture.
No curry or tea for you, England.
No tea for India, either. Or cricket. There will be much wailing and gnashing of teeth.*
*With apologies for the Hebrew cultural appropriation. Or is that from the Greek part?
I think I'll dress up as Henry VIII and just walk around calling everyone a fucking peasant.
Or act like old King Harry and just fuck the peasants.
And lock your wife up in a Tower! Amirite?
since Halloween is European in nature (maybe?) then only europeans can partake otherwise it would be appropriation of white culture
It only counts if it's not a "dominant". these fully baked retards were the assholes that went around smashing everyone's Lego creations in kindergarten.
These types dominate student government because no one cares about it. Maybe the students should launch a campaign to vote them the hell out. Hey, kids do it all the time to make sure the retarded kid gets to be Prom King so go ahead and work to get these retarded folks out of student government.
Perhaps a rule that the offices go unfilled if there's less than, say 15% turnout in a student government election?
The only people who want to be in student government are budding politicians. Everybody else has better things to do. It's just like real government.
Ok someone has to post this so might as well be me:
https://youtu.be/4OpiqyyCBc4
"These types dominate student government because no one cares about it."
In school mine got taken over by a group of trolls who pretty much won the election by setting up a bunch of video game systems for people to play in the Union lobby on the election day and telling people to go vote for them. Oh, and they also ran around taking all the free copies of the student paper that were out for people because the student paper ran an article against them for not taking shit seriously.
Bored people swayed by video games apparently outnumber the SJW types who take student government seriously, however, because they won in a landslide. They did pretty much nothing but fuck around, which was great, but sadly they were forced to resign their post to more "serious" student politicians following a "controversy" where the members of student government were showing each other "2 Girls 1 Cup" on school computers. Alas.
In four years of college, I could not have identified nor named anyone in student government. Of course, I was an angry, misanthropic loner who actively discouraged human contact, but still.....
"Can I dress up as Ramsay? He's a character, after all, and I wouldn't want to appropriate Westerosi culture."
As if all Westerosi culture was the same!! First Man culture is clearly different from the cultures of Andal, Ironborn, and Rhoynar.
Your ignorance of the different culture groups of Westeros is clear racism!!
What about all those fureners in other countries going to their knock off American burger joint and listening to blues music and the Beach Boys. People, we are being culturally appropriated more than any other culture! Is everyone ok? Don't jump yet, just drink more!
Honestly, I have talked to people from other countries about this and they will not believe it's a real thing. They are first just incredulous and then they laugh. I have to actually show them these articles to make they believe it. Then they are just not sure what to think, they still think it has to be a joke.
That's cultural imperialism. Cuba is being victimized by it right now.
Have you even been to college?
The most charitable explanation is that they are bad at grammar and put a comma before "which" where there shouldn't be one. With the comma it means without qualification that all dressing as a culture or characters are offensive and reinforce negative stereotypes. Without the comma it would be criticizing only the dressing as cultures or characters that are offensive but not the non-offensive ones.
Still stupid, even if that's what they meant, maybe marginally less so.
Then it would be "that," not "which."
Unfortunately, they said exactly what they meant.
Eh, not that many people follow that rule consistently, many even doubt the rule, and in any case you really can't expect people who are ignorant of how to use commas to know the supposed distinction between "that" and "which."
Cultural appropriation is too limiting. Just in case I've missed the social trends among the prudes, scolds, naggers and harridans, is there such a thing yet as sexual appropriation? Gender appropriation? Temporal appropriation? Taxonomic appropriation?
Dear Rachel Grisham and Quinn Haaga,
Go fuck yourselves.
Love,
Sane people
Sane people
GUARDS!
"Hey!!! I need some muscle over here!!!!"
Students at both schools should dress up as the others mascot.
My god the KKK is beaming with pride right now. I love seeing progressives become the monsters they fought. Nietzsche had it right:
"He who fights with monsters should be careful lest he thereby become a monster.
And if thou gaze long into an abyss, the abyss will also gaze into thee."
Progressives have become so god damned self-righteous they do not even realize what has happened to themselves.
They now have more power. That is, was, and forever shall be their only goal or principle.
As a white male of European descent, it is my culture to appropriate other cultures.
As a white male of European descent, it is my culture to appropriate other cultures.
HOW DARE THEY APPROPRIATE THE ROMAN ALPHABET WHEN COMPOSING THEIR EMAIL!!!!
ACK, NOW I'M CULTURALLY APPROPRIATING!!! I BETTER SELF-IMMOLATE. WAIT, IS THAT APPROPRIATING BUDDHISTS? OR MUSLIMS? SHIT, DID I JUST STEREOTYPE???
QUICK, SOMEONE TELL ME WHAT TO THINK!!!!!!!!!!
They can all go fornicate themselves. I'm going to dress as whatever the hell I want.
So my zombie costume is clearly transgressive because it appropriates cadaver culture by a member of the dominant (living) culture.
I will just be a trans (transgressive), then. I sometimes wish I was still a student, just so I could hurl insults at these nimrods! *
(* Nimrod was a Babylonian historical figure, and therefore also culturally problematic.)
If I dress as Ron Swanson, am I appropriating dude culture?
No, but you will have to eat all the bacon and eggs. All of them.
Fuck them both in the most painful orifice possible.
I'm sure the student government would like us to wear arm bands indicating our ethnicity and status; they would like to force the Jews to wear a yellow star, homosexuals to wear a pink triangle, etc. Only that way can these social justice warriorsfascists make sure that everybody is properly assigned to their correct minority.
Fuck these fascists.
I've made $64,000 so far this year working online and I'm a full time student. Im using an online business opportunity I heard about and I've made such great money. It's really user friendly and I'm just so happy that I found out about it. Heres what I do,
???????? http://YoutubeJobs.Nypost55.com
I'm using it now and it's awesome! I've signed up for my account and have been bringing in fat paychecks. For real, my first week I made $1305 and the second week I doubled it and theen it kind a snowballed to $120 a day! juet follow the course...... they will help you out...........
visit More This Site---------->>> http://www.jobnet70.com
Being a white male born in Virginia I'm so glad my KKK costume will pass muster.
Frankenstein really could've used some alt-text up there.
In five years, this will be a hate crime. They won't just have the stinky, fatassed he-shes of the SJW Cultural Sensitivity Police "investigating" you. They will see you walking around campus dressed as Cleopatra or wearing a sombrero, and they will have you thrown in jail and charged with a hate crime.
And I'm going to let them. Let them strip me of my freedom, I will go on a hunger strike while in prison.
This sounds like something Donald Trump MIGHT do if he was elected president. It's a good thing that he won't be president! Whew!
This is what's astonishing to me. Trump level authoritarianism is already here. Obama literally bombed another country with zero approval from congress. Twitter and Youtube are openly censoring content they personally find objectionable.
The left is basically pissing in their pants over mean things Trump said about Mexico and sex stuff. That's the real reason they hate Trump. These people were chanting for Obama to "change the law all by yourself" not even a year ago.
Thank you, thank you UO and OSU. Long overdue support for racial and cultural discrimination. We must keep up barriers to prevent societal cross over. We can't allow mixing of races or cultures. How many radio stations will close down in pursuit of social purity? 300, 800? Good riddance! Both universities should adopt brown shirts for their uniforms. I love freedom!!!
>Or what? is a tempting response. Unfortunately, we know exactly what will happen to transgressors. The University of Oregon, for example, harbors one of the most dangerous bias response teams I've written about. Students who push the line, as far as costumes are concerned, can expect to be investigated.
I say let them investigate me. I am prepared to be persecuted for my beliefs, as University of Toronto professor Jordan Peterson is. I'll never be the modern-day Socrates he is, but if the PC Police should sentence to drink hemlock juice, then they better hand me a whole damn pitcher.
? ? ? News Update
Watch Full HD Movie Streaming Online For Free Trial
visit ? ? ? http://theaterbox.club/ ? ? ?
Register Needed