For Disaster Recovery, the Best Knowledge Is Local Knowledge

Federal intervention won't help Hurricane Matthew relief.

|

Hurricane
Sheyenne Storm/newzulu/Newscom

As residents all along the Southeastern coast start to put their lives back together after a devastating visit by Hurricane Matthew, these communities will face unique challenges. Not surprisingly, the calls for billions of dollars in federal government aid are already coming out loud and clear. In states affected by storms, government is often thought of as the only answer to reconstruction. However, research on the aftermath of natural disasters reveals that more often than not, local residents are better-suited to efficiently address these challenges than government on the local, state and federal levels.

Even if the federal government could increase the funding to help these communities above and beyond the $5 billion available in FEMA's disaster relief fund, the money would have to come from an omnibus bill passed by Congress in a lame-duck session, meaning it could be months before they receive an increase in funds. Even if Congress were to approve unlimited funds for rebuilding, it would most likely be surrounded by the type of bureaucracy that benefits a few while undermining true recovery of getting people back into their homes and communities.

Take a recent investigation by PBS' Frontline and NPR into flood insurance and aid distribution in the aftermath of Superstorm Sandy. They found that disaster victims' flood insurance claims were systematically underpaid, while the insurance companies selected by the feds to handle these claims were busy finding ways to increase their profits and limit payouts. Meanwhile, aid programs were slow to distribute funds while punishing homeowners with mountains of red tape and unqualified contractors, which ultimately prevented them from returning to their homes and communities.

Brad Gair, a disaster recovery manager in New York, said during the Frontline episode: "Did we put a bunch of money out? Yes. Is everybody mad? Yes. Did people get what they needed to get back into a home? No." These horrifying stories were unfortunately a repeat of previous governmental responses to disasters—for example, after Hurricane Katrina and Hurricane Andrew.

In a recent book titled Community Revival in the Wake of Disaster, three of my colleagues at the Mercatus Center—Virgil Henry Storr, Stefanie Haeffele-Balch and Laura E. Grube—explain in detail why we shouldn't be surprised that governmental responses to disasters lead to high administrative overhead costs and little relief to those who need it the most. They also show how entrepreneurs, "conceived broadly as individuals who recognize and act on opportunities to promote social change," end up filling this critical role.

They reveal how in general, these entrepreneurs promote community recovery by providing necessary goods and services and restoring and replacing disrupted social networks. The entrepreneurs also provide signals to indicate that a community is rebounding. These signals are essential to incentivize people and businesses to stay in the community or, in the event they deserted it during or after the hurricane, come back.

Just as importantly, they argue that creating space for entrepreneurs to act after disasters is essential for promoting recovery and fostering resilient communities. They tell many uplifting stories of communities that didn't wait for the various government agencies to rescue them and instead took matters into their own hands, finding ways to obtain funding, clean up and rebuild—which resulted in getting people back into their homes faster.

Storr and his co-authors link the success of these local entrepreneurs to people's knowledge of one another's needs, which allows them to find creative ways to overcome adversity. As opposed to the top-down approach of a distant government bureaucracy, the best knowledge is local knowledge. Those who have lived and worked in these communities know them best and are paramount to revival.

When it comes to the recovery after Hurricane Matthew, policymakers should remember that when social networks are broken by disasters, local knowledge is particularly powerful and holds an even bigger advantage over bureaucrats than usual, no matter how well-intentioned the public officials are. In fact, bureaucratic red tape will only cause more people more pain.

COPYRIGHT 2016 CREATORS.COM

NEXT: Two Women Say Trump Sexually Assaulted Them in the Exact Manner He Bragged About on Tape

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Letting people make their own choices? That’s crazy talk!

    /sarc

    1. My co-worker’s step-sister makes $97 hourly on the laptop . She has been out of work for six months but last month her paycheck was $14100 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Go this website and click to tech tab to start your work… http://tinyurl.com/hhwe4zl

  2. “….governmental responses to disasters lead to high administrative overhead costs and little relief to those who need it the most. They also show how entrepreneurs, “conceived broadly as individuals who recognize and act on opportunities to promote social change,” end up filling this critical role.”

    Utter nonsense. Those best equipped to help after a disaster are those who have donated the most to the Clinton Foundation.

    -Bill Clinton

  3. …they argue that creating space for entrepreneurs to act after disasters is essential for promoting recovery and fostering resilient communities.

    Preying on the victims of disasters by giving them an option for relief!

  4. My mothers neighbour is working part time and averaging $9000 a month. I’m a single mum and just got my first paycheck for $6546! I still can’t believe it. I tried it out cause I got really desperate and now I couldn’t be happier. Heres what I do,

    ————–>>>> http://YoutubeJobs.Nypost55.com

  5. I have seen unusual explanation of knowledge when I have to Do My Dissertation during searching on Google. I know Objective knowledge as a rule cannot be growing from using our senses. But we must differentiate with awareness the different forms of knowledge and trust only the most excellent.

  6. until I looked at the paycheck saying $4730 , I did not believe that…my… brother woz like actualy bringing in money part time from there computar. . there friend brother started doing this for less than 7 months and resently paid for the morgage on there home and bought a new Cadillac …….

    …….. http://www.jobprofit9.com

  7. Peyton . even though Billy `s report is cool… on monday I got a gorgeous Maserati after I been earnin $8985 thiss month and even more than ten k lass month . it’s certainly the easiest work Ive ever had . I started this 9-months ago and practically straight away started bringin home at least $78 per-hr . look at this now

    ……………. http://www.jobhub44.com

  8. until I looked at the paycheck saying $4730 , I did not believe that…my… brother woz like actualy bringing in money part time from there computar. . there friend brother started doing this for less than 7 months and resently paid for the morgage on there home and bought a new Cadillac …….

    ……………… http://www.jobprofit9.com

  9. They expose how, in general, these entrepreneurs promote community retrieval by providing necessary things and services and repairing and replacing disrupted social networks. Essay Writing Service UK

  10. They expose how, in general, these entrepreneurs promote community retrieval by providing necessary things and services and repairing and replacing disrupted social networks. Essay Writing Service UK

  11. They expose how, in general, these entrepreneurs promote community retrieval by providing necessary things and services and repairing and replacing disrupted social networks. Essay Writing Service UK

  12. It is important to have geographical knowledge because during disasters it might increase your probability of survival. I was writing my Dissertation report on disaster recovery and the above post helped me a lot.
    Thank You.

  13. While coming to education, the technology has brought many advantages to students and as well as teachers. showbox For example, students can do their homework or assignment with ease and can complete it faster by using the Internet.

  14. Thank you for sharing this post. It creates a path for the entrepreneurs who promote social things in websites. I am a writer and know what most important thing in writing report or statements.

  15. I have seen abnormal clarification of information when I need to British Dissertation Home amid seeking on Google. I know Objective learning when in doubt can’t be developing from utilizing our faculties. In any case, we should separate with mindfulness the distinctive types of information and trust just the most amazing.

  16. It is always complicated for someone who is living in these areas and one of my cheap assignment help research says that it always make lots of damage to that area which is harmful to the peoples who live in these areas.

  17. I posted an Essay Example on the same topic in my blog.
    Everyone is welcome to visit. Feel free to open conversation there

  18. Really wonderful and useful post! I think that because of your advice, the number of my followers will increase. Thank you! Also many useful works you can read on this site http://quality-writings.com/, I always read it with enthusiasm

  19. thanks for sharing such a knowledgeable post ,as i am writer in uk essay writing service
    it helps me alot writing my essay similar to this topic.

  20. I heard about this disaster before. It is also important to unite people in groups. Good to know that you are not alone with your problem. My friend lost his job due to this hurricane. So he had to start over again. He asked me for help and I decided to create a blog for people who need to find a job. We just shared our thoughts there, give advice and share experience. You may join my blog here

  21. Nice post but when it comes to the recovery after Hurricane Matthew, policymakers should remember that when social networks are broken by disasters, local knowledge is particularly powerful and holds an even bigger advantage over bureaucrats than usual, no matter how well-intentioned the public officials are. In fact, bureaucratic red tape will only cause more people more pain.

  22. Nice post but when it comes to the recovery after Hurricane Matthew, policymakers should remember that when social networks are broken by disasters, local knowledge is particularly powerful and holds an even bigger advantage over bureaucrats than usual, no matter how well-intentioned the public officials are. In fact, bureaucratic red tape will only cause more people more pain.

    Assignment Writing Services

  23. Finish up something. Try not to confound a decision with a synopsis. The last section or two ought to be the finish of your contention, not a repeat of it. Clarify the discoveries of your examination, propose a clarification for the information exhibited, bring up roads for future research, or bring up the essentialness of the realities you’ve spread out in your paper. Essay Mafia

  24. I know Objective information generally speaking can’t be developing from utilizing our faculties. Be that as it may, Best Assignment Writing Service should separate with mindfulness the distinctive types of information and trust just the most brilliant.

  25. Decent post yet with regards to the recuperation after Typhoon Matthew, policymakers ought to recall that when informal communities are broken by fiascos, neighborhood information is especially ground-breaking and holds a much greater favorable position over administrators than common, regardless of how benevolent the general population authorities are. Indeed, bureaucratic formality will just best assignment writing service motivation more individuals more agony.

  26. It is essential to have geographical expertise due to the fact all through disasters it’d increase your opportunity of survival. I become Best Dissertation Help record on disaster healing and the above put up helped me lots.

  27. Yes I do agree with the topic that having a locality knowledge will help you out in these circumstances. Just like a students who are studying apart from home can avail writing service assistance from a local professors than availing essay writer service from the web.

  28. Very informative post. In our country is very actual. We need to know how to keep patience and then how to recover after the disaster. I read a great essay about this on original-writing.com. You can find here a lot of useful tips and information.

  29. They generally help these people recover the community by providing essential things and services to help rebuild social networks and restore social networks. Assignment writing service

  30. very apt said, I am currently looking for the same exact phrases for my a soldier’s story summary

  31. There should be training institute for spreading education and awareness for disaster recovery as these disaster occurs more often. To get help in assignment writing, visit http://www.assignmenting.com
    and you will be guided by our team of professional writers.

  32. Have you finished the race and would you like to try your luck in another country? The United States presents itself as the favorite destination of many graduate students, and it is not strange that this is the case: its universities never lack in the rankings with the best degrees in the world. essay help uk services

  33. They expose how, in trendy, these marketers sell community retrieval by offering vital matters and services and repairing and changing disrupted social networks. It’s far important to have geographical information due to the fact in the course of screw ups it might increase your opportunity of survival. Dissertation Service Online UK

  34. Having an assignment due tomorrow and understand you can’t do it yourself? But you’re afraid of delegating your paper to some scam services as well? Why not check speedypaper reviews on Scamfighter.net

  35. Just getting started in your career? Often it is difficult to put an attention-getting resume together when you are just starting out. Employers want some demonstrated expertise in potential new employees. As an entry-level applicant, you are at a disadvantage because of your limited experience. Our writers can help you capitalize on the experience you do have. Using information you provide on volunteer work, course work, and relevant skills developed at any previously held positions, your writer will construct a resume that presents you as a candidate with true potential. Check our resume writing service website.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.