Publishing Charlie Hebdo Cover Lands Turkish Journalists in Prison
Just yesterday, Turkey's PM had promised to include the "principle of secularism" in new constitution.


Two journalists have been sentenced by a Turkish court to two years in prison after being convicted of blasphemy and "insulting religious values" for publishing several cartoons from France's satirical Charlie Hebdo magazine, including a caricature of the Muslim Prophet Mohammad.
Ceyda Karan and Hikmet Cetinkaya of Turkey's Cumhuriyet daily had faced up to four and a half years each for re-printing the cartoons in solidarity with the cartoonists who were massacred in Paris by Islamic radicals in January 2015.
Karan tweeted, "We will appeal (the ruling). We will not leave this country to fascists in Islam sauce," according to Reuters.
The sentencing comes at a time when journalists are increasingly under siege in Turkey, which was ranked 151 out of 180 countries on Reporters Without Borders recently released World Press Freedom Index. Last year, the group called Turkey "the world's biggest prison for journalists," and last month's government takeover of the country's largest newspaper has many wondering whether the NATO ally seeking to join the EU can be reasonably referred to as a democracy.
Ever more troublesome, just yesterday, Turkey's Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu — who was among the world leaders who marched in Paris in solidarity with the Charlie Hebdo victims in 2015 — tried to downplay comments made by the Parliamentary Speaker Ismail Kahraman, who had said that the nation needed a religious constitution.
Davutoglu later said that the country's new in-the-works constitution will include "the principle of secularism…as one guaranteeing individuals' freedom of religion and faith, and the state's equal distance to all faith groups," Reuters reports.
The modern nation of Turkey was founded on secularism in the 1920s, but the tenure of President Tayyip Erdogan and his AK Party have led to an increased role Islam in public life, as well as an authoritarian posture that extends beyond Turkey's borders.
Earlier this month, Germany said it would allow the prosecution of one of its citizens for the crime of writing a ribald poem insulting Erdogan. In a recently published article at The Atlantic titled, "The Thinnest-Skinned President in the World," Uri Friedman noted that the prosecution of German comedian Jan Böhmermann is the height of irony, considering Erdogan himself had served time in prison for reciting a poem.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
We will not leave this country to fascists in Islam sauce
Hey, consider yourself lucky. At least Islam sauce is spicy. Previous fascisms have been covered in saurkraut, marinara, and teriyaki. American fascism will, of course, be smothered in ketchup.
No, it'll have a balsamic reduction sauce and served with artisanal whiskey made in a micro distillery made possible by free college tuition.
Were the oak barrels used for the whiskey sustainably sourced?
Sadly, Islam sauce is never "conflict-free"....
What about the steaks?
You have your choice between tenderized from a three story government building, or hung-out from the local steak-crane and aged to perfection.
Can't tell you why but I like that phrase "We will not leave this country to fascists in Islam sauce," Sounds lIke a Tom Robbins or Richard Brautigan title I think the recipe got garbled in the translation, but it seems to taste pretty good.
Come now, even in the United States it is well understood that being "satirical" is not an excuse for committing crimes. Under Turkish law, these journalists committed the crime of blasphemy, and belong in jail. We should find shorter ways of dealing with some of the dissenters in this country too. Some progress has been made in New York, but perhaps not enough. See the documentation of America's leading criminal "satire" case at:
http://raphaelgolbtrial.wordpress.com/
Well the thais had sriracha with their fascism.
"Have"...they're on, what, dictator number 50 now?
What's ironic is that most Turks have no problem with the fascism known as Kemalism; they just prefer the secular, French dressing to the islamist one.
Yes...Yes! Every post must have a condiment related metaphor! Keep it up!
Are we allowed to refer to ejaculatory antics with the use of such metaphors?
Why would you not?
That would be a condom related metaphor.
Sorry, I must condemn the condom/condiment conflation.
Speaking of Wilson's Gravy, amirite?
*crickets*
Yours didn't. Fail.
You never heard of Keep Sauce?
Kecap?
Dude, HM is our sauciest commenter, it is known.
HM is only two away from HP.
Shouldn't they be complaining to their MP?
DOES NOT COMPOTE
Nice.
It seems the secularist republicans of Ataturk's ilk have lost their courage, or have become too few to challenge the theocrats. Perhaps the military could assist?
Erdogan purged the secularist generals out of the military.
Yep. The Turkish military is no longer gonna "step in" and enforce secularism. And the conscripts are the ill-educated young men from rural areas who don't know how, or don't have the money, to game the system and avoid conscription.
Huh. Did not know that. Whelp, Turkey was fun while it lasted.
Theocrats are outbreeding secularists in Turkey. It's a foregone conclusion.
Kick them out of NATO
Indeed. Times have changed. The USSR is dead.
Hmm, I wonder whether Trump or Hillary would be more likely to do that? It must be causing a lot of cognitive dissonance around here that that Trump's foreign policy looks more like Rand Paul's than Hillary's does.....
America First.
Last Thanksgiving our turkey had Islamic gravy. It burned my tongue.
Mine collapsed a wall on me 🙁
"fascists in Islam sauce"
One of my favorite recipes.
Austrian "far-right" Freedom Party is on the way to winning their Presidential election.
http://www.yahoo.com/news/austrian-go.....tml?ref=gs
This didn't work out so well last time.
Neither did the last time millions of Muslims moved into Europe.
I recall Austria in particular having some issue with Turks.
Spain, Italy, and Greece have some stories, too.
Don't forget Malta, and well, Crete still has their Turk problem.
You know what other Austrian oh fuck it.
OK, that was LOL.
If the guy wins, the EU apparatchiks will throw a sanctions hissy fit and, like Joerg Haider, he'll be kicked out of office
Most of Eastern Europe has similar leaders already.
The EU bureaucracy did manage to get Haider kicked out.
By the way, is there a clear explanation of "far right" in this case, other than "badthinker on immigration"?
Under the leadership of Heinz-Christian Strache, the FP? has focused on describing itself as a Heimat and social party. This means that the party promotes its role as a guarantor of Austrian identity and social welfare. Economically, it supports regulated liberalism with privatisation and low taxes, combined with support for the welfare state; however, it maintains that it will be impossible to uphold the welfare state if current immigration policies are continued...
The principle of individual freedom in society was already one of the central points in the FP? (and VdU's) programme during the 1950s. The party did not regard its liberalism and its pan-German, nationalist positions as contradictory. From the late 1980s through the 1990s, the party developed economically, supporting tax reduction, less state intervention and more privatisation. In the late 2000s, the party combined this position with support for the welfare state. It criticised unemployment and alleged welfare-state abuse by immigrants which, it said, threatened the welfare state and pensioners' benefits.
http://www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_Party_of_Austria
They sound about as right-wing as Jim Webb.
Thanks for looking that up. Good point to mention Jim Webb.
"You fucked up! You trusted us!"
Hey, the USSR had many fine-sounding guarantees in their constitution....
China's constitution guarantees freedom of speech and religion.
15 comments and no Airplane jokes? I has a sad.
I *thought* it - does that count?
I'm really disappointed in you guys. No Airplane reference yet?
I expected more from you people.
It would be easier for Europe to take a stand against oppression of journalists in Turkey if they walked the talk about free speech. As long as European countries have their own laws against blasphemy, historical revisionism, religious insults, and other Thought Crimes, the Turks are justified in responding with, "NO, YOU!"
The world has gone nuts and muslims and politicians are in the first railcar.
The are some strange bedfellows. I'm sure both have plans on how they are going to finish off the other when it becomes convenient.
#InsultErdogan
When people try to ban speech say it ten times as often and 10 times as loud.
"Turkey's Cumhuriyet daily"
The euphemisms are getting out of hand.
Oh no! I euphemismed myself!
I mean how's that possible? getting 2 years jailed for publishing charlie hebdo cover. Once a journalist posted a false news about my lowes life but later was left with a warning!.