Friday A/V Club: David Bowie at a Mid-Mutation Moment
Think of it as self-directed evolution in action.

When David Bowie died earlier this week, Nick Gillespie praised the musician for "constantly metamorphosing" from one public identity to another. Bowie's cultural value, Nick suggested—beyond the great music he made, which is pretty damn valuable in itself—is as a symbol of choice and self-determination: "We're all mutants these days, and that's a good thing, especially if we, like Bowie, are directing our own personal evolution."
In the clip below, you can see Bowie at a mid-mutation moment. Think of it as self-directed evolution in action.
The half-hour video comes from a 1974 episode of The Dick Cavett Show. At this point, Bowie's most recent studio album was Diamond Dogs, the last LP of his glam-rock period; his next would be Young Americans, where he plunged into the sort of soul music then coming out of Philadelphia. On the face of it, it's a radical shift in style. Yet Bowie manages to play songs from both albums without the change sounding jarring. He leads with a Diamond Dogs number called "1984"—a song whose horns and funky wah-wah guitar showed a glimmer of the soul sounds to come—before performing the not-yet-released track "Young Americans," which is firmly in the R&B camp.
Then there's an interview, in which Cavett observes that the musician's look and stage show are different but doesn't notice, or at least doesn't bring up, the shift in Bowie's music. And then the band plays one more R&B song. It sounds at first like Bowie's future hit "Fame," but that's just a guitar riff he'll find another use for later; it's actually a joyful cover of a doo-wop tune called "Footstompin'," with a few lyrics thrown in from an old jazz song, "I Wish I Could Shimmy Like My Sister Kate."
You shouldn't skip Cavett's conversation with Bowie, by the way. Bowie here is almost a caricature of a fidgety cokehead, but the interview takes some interesting turns all the same, as when the duo discusses William Burroughs' thoughts on weaponized noise, or when Bowie refuses to answer a question about the redevelopment ripping down much of London: "Oh, don't ask me about politics. I don't know."
(For past installments of the Friday A/V Club, go here.)
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I'm going to repost this in PM Links because it's insane, but I can't help posting it now as it is too good not to post as often as possible.
Ars Technica discussing free speech:
"Twitter has discovered what many proponents of democratic society already knew: censorship is not the opposite of free speech. In fact, so-called free speech can actually be used as a weapon to silence the vulnerable and dispossessed. Ironically, to maintain its position as a platform for free discourse, Twitter must censor its users. "
WHAT!?!?!?!
JESUS CHRIST! The real reason it's okay for twitter to censor speech is that they're a private platform. If you're upset with their censoring, you can take your business elsewhere and leave the site to wither and die with a shrinking user base. But that paragraph is so nonsensically Orwellian that I don't know how a human being could type those words without the cognitive dissonance ripping their brain apart.
A bit about the author:
As long as we can produce a parody advertisement that quotes Annalee talking about her first time with her father in the portajohn at the fair, we should be ok.
Her picture is everything I thought it would be.
Quit hatespeeching, or the Twitter police will be all over you.
She looks like Tumblr had sex with a troll doll.
She reminds me of what Rainbow Brite would look like if she were in a long term struggle with hepatitis and clinical depression.
Okay, I laughed pretty hard at that. But I felt super problematic afterward.
It's like she didn't even try to not be like the feminazi meme.
We have a lot to learn from these women. For example, I really go in for that mousy, just-this-side-of-cute look (improves my odds), but I'm learning to be very careful about it.
8/19 would, not bad
You can't fool *me*. That's from The Onion.
I would happily give it to little Mahroh there. She's a cutie.
She's currently on Hajj. You'll have to sneak in like T. E. Lawrence.
Serious question, is Burton's claim BS?
I have never been a big Bowie fan, musically, but he was a fascinating person. I will watch this for sure. I am patiently waiting for a retrospective on Bowie's film career.
Oh, don't ask me about politics. I don't know."
This statement alone commands respect.
"'When I grow up, I want to be just like you, and I think I'm on the right track. Get it? Track, because horses run on tracks, and you are a horse, and I am a horse. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the track?'"
"Okay, there's a whole page of this."
"Should I write him back and tell him I get it?"
"He goes on, 'My question for you is, I am a good kid, and I like to play, and I like to go to school, but sometimes I get sad. What do you do when you get sad? How do you not be sad? Sincerely, BoJack.'"
NO ONE WATCHES THAT STUPID SHOW SHUT UP
If you ever talk shit about Bojack Horseman again, I will hunt you down like an animal.
It's not open season on Doyers, yet. Not until the student loan forgiveness starts.
Doyers is mine to split open like a ripe melon with a sharp machete as I see fit. Back off, Irish.
Is that some sort of gay euphemism?
No. I've just called dibs on murdering Doyers.It's not like *everything* I do is for gay reasons. That's super racist of you.
"Doyers is mine to split open like a ripe melon"
Good point. I don't know how I read this and got a homoerotic vibe.
Sorry I'm a bigot.
Apology accepted. I've been threatening to murder Doyers if he gets student loan forgiveness for almost a year now. Normally I'd tell him I'll split *his head* open like a ripe melon, but it made the above sentence awkward to shoehorn that in.
And so he throws the bag of mulch over the side of the 101!
You were born broken, Warty.
"Wait, is this going to be like that time you promised to take me ice skating, and I got really excited about the ice skating, but then instead of ice skating, you left me at home so you could go to the strip club and then you took the strippers ice skating?"
""There's a right way and an easy way...are you going to sail around the horn like a gentlemen or go through the Panama Canal like a Democrat!""
God, that show is amazing.
Agreed. Not too many shows throwing around references to Emma Goldman these days.
That--and I'm not saying this lightly--was worse than a hundred September Elevens.
"When you're wearing rose-colored glasses, all the red flags just look like flags."
I can tell by your tone of voice that that was smart.
Son of a bitch ? that literal son of a bitch.
Related: the David Bowie appearance-changing gif.
Millennials and their celebrations.
That Tumblr background is problematic.
At least it's not on a shirt.
I guess I'll just loiter around in here until they shit out the Friday links.
Adele, Adele what's on your dress?
Adele, Adele your face is a mess.
Bowie refuses to answer a question about the redevelopment ripping down much of London: "Oh, don't ask me about politics. I don't know."
*thunderous standing ovation*
Yeah, that's pretty excellent.
I heard an actor/singer died. Was it Lou Reed?
No, you idiot, it was Patrick Stewart.
Far as I know, Ovid was one man, and the only metamorphosis he had was from a thin poet into a fat poet. I admit, I could be wrong, as Latin poetry was only a tangential interest ever...
Well, he was exiled for something. I'm guessing he was a werewolf.
Ovid was an otherkin? That might explain his magnum opus!
I took the "Ovid" in "one-man Ovid" to be a synecdoche for Ovid's Metamorphoses. But you're right, the final phrase is a redundancy. I may go back and snip it.
Sorry for being an ass, but the "I'm mangling a reference because I want to look smart" (e.g. Maldives when you want to say Malvinas) is the kind of error I hate the most.
Well, it's gone now. ARE YOU HAPPY?
YES! One small victory against forces of Friday!
I say, Jesse should wear the Jacket - who's with me?
Why is everybody talking about Bowie in the past tense, lately? I mean, everybody knows he's over the hill, but come on.
In fact, so-called free speech can actually be used as a weapon to silence the vulnerable and dispossessed. Ironically, to maintain its position as a platform for free discourse, Twitter must censor its users.
"I've been to one World's Fair, a picnic and a rodeo, and that's the stupidest thing I ever heard come over a pair of earphones."