Friday A/V Club: What If the Beach Boys Had Been Communists?
The music of Red Shadow
From the 1975 LP Live at the Panacea Hilton, I give you "Gone, Gone, Gone":
That's Red Shadow, a trio of Marxist economists who decided to fight capitalism by forming a band. Besides that Beach Boys parody, they wrote socialist spoofs of Chuck Berry and Ray Charles, among others. (Their Ray Charles rewrite is, I think, what Schoolhouse Rock would sound like in the Red Dawn universe.) They also attempted to compose some original numbers, such as the ballad "Grand Rapids," which doesn't seem to be online and I wouldn't inflict it on you anyway; it nonetheless deserves a mention as one of the few songs anyone ever bothered to write about Gerald Ford.
After two albums the band disappeared from the music world, but not from economics. The man who wrote "Gone, Gone, Gone," one Ev Ehrlich, went on to become an undersecretary of commerce in the Clinton administration, an assistant director of the Congressional Budget Office, and—every young Marxist's dream—the president of "a Washington-based economics consulting firm serving Fortune 500 companies."
(For past editions of the Friday A/V Club, go here. For a better song about Gerald Ford, go here.)
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
This post is the best thing that will happen all day.
I'm going to see the Martian after work.
You mean MARS DAMON!
Did you end up reading it?
Shut up, Nikki. Reading is for fags.
I heard that above average use of grammar was just like Adam somebody....
Yeah bro I was the one who posted about reading it in the first place. The real question is whether you read it.
Ohhhhh right I forgot about that. I only remembered you saying you didn't want to. I have not.
You should, it's a pretty quick read and it looks like it's going to be kind of a generational touchstone.
Beach Boys suck
No, the Beatles suck.
No, Elvis sucks.
Fleetwood Mac sucks
Before Baa Baa Nicks joined the band they weren't bad. But having that bleating sheep on vocals ruined it for me.
The original lineup with Peter Green was great.
Yep. Oh Well is one of my favorite tunes.
But having that bleating sheep on vocals ruined it for me.
Don't you mean goat?
Don't you mean goat?
Sheep, goat, whatever. She sounds like a farm animal being sodomized.
Still would
That's what's missing from my playlist for tomorrow. Thanks, Hugh!
Has anyone ever told you that you're the Worst?
I'm just second hand news (I'm just second hand news).
I had a rough night and I hate the fucking Eagles, man.
Should I punish her by making her drink lots of mal?rt, Hugh?
Please say yes.
Listening to Fleetwood Mac is punishment enough.
Just remember, Hugh, that the sea that divides us is a temporary one.
Listening to Fleetwood Mac is punishment enough.
*memories of Clinton's inaugural parade*
*Hugh gets pulled from a red cab and is left standing on the street*
There's no reason you can't both be right.
Springsteen and Dylan suck more than everything else combined. AND are overrated to boot. The horror.
It can get worse than Springsteen and Dylan. Melloncamp and Seger come to mind.
U2 is worser than them all.
You are too right.
Achtung Baby was a good album. But other than that, yeah, I'll pass on U2.
It can be way worse than that: Barry Manilow. Neil Diamond.
Rush is pretentious and overrated.
I'm just kidding, people!
The Beach Boys are amazing. That's real American music right there.
Keith Moon was a huge Beach Boys fan, and had always wanted to play drums for the band. As late as 1974, Keith was hanging out in LA and trying to convince Brian Wilson to put the band back together with Moon as drummer.
Kieth Moon singing "Barbara Ann" on "The Kids Are Alright" movie is.....disturbing...to this Who fan.
There was a pivotal point in The Who where they were going to break up very probably. Townsend was losing his shit trying to complete Tommy. Daltrey wanted to be the white James Brown and was going to start an R&B group. Keith was lobbying to be in the Beach Boys. Their record company sent the band to play college campuses at Leeds and Hull. The crowd response to the new material was tremendous and the band decided to forge ahead. These concerts produced the Live at Leeds record.
It's amazing to think the Who were on the brink of dissolving right when their magnum opus was to be released.
Quadrophenia?
Damn Jesse, where do you come up with this stuff? I think you must have the best job in the world.
Jesse should get the website editor-in-chief's job when Nick goes to HuffPo or Salon.
Yeah, Jesse's kinda like the Quentin Tarantino of Reason. Listen to obscure old songs. Watching obscure old movies. Plus I think he once said the word "nigger" right to Samuel L Jackson's face.
Plus I think he once said the word "nigger" right to Samuel L Jackson's face.
I really hope that's true and that someone caught it on video and uploaded it to YouTube.
Is that *Lenin* with the broom?
And who's that person in the lower left supposed to be? A witch?
I think a Charles Dickens style Scrooge with top hat and cape.
I thought it was this.
Yes it is
Caption: Comrd. Lenin CLEANS the Earth of garbage.
And I'm disappointed, Eddie - person in lower left is clearly a priest of (probably Russian) Orthodox Church.
I swear this wasn't here when I replied!
I knew the hat looked like a Kalimavkion, but the person looked like a witch with a long nose.
Jesse, have you done any radio shows in the past few years? I remember I used to love the one you did when you lived in Michigan in like 2007 or 2008.
Thanks. No, I haven't had a regular radio show since 2009 (though I sat in with Lucy S. on her radio show once in Pittsburgh this past summer).
You mentioned her!
DON'T TALK ABOUT L....
Too late....
That Chuck Berry one is spine-tingling -- bemoaning that all the experts don't have the knowledge of the working class. Yes, jack, that's the libertarian theme -- but of course, as soon as they get in power, then it's the knowledge of the working class as embodied by them as elites.
Gaaak, I hate politicians.
Well, they ain't exactly the Almanac Singers.
And keep your goddamn, filthy Commie hands off Chuck Berry.
Meet the new boss
Not the same as the old boss
In fact, we'll have you pining for the old boss
As we work you to death in the frozen Arctic
She's my poorly-built deuce coupe
I don't know what I got
Video is better
That's some good shit.
Based on a quick reading of Erlich's blog, he seems to have moved far away from his Marxist days.
His "unofficial bio" is pretty funny and he sounds like an interesting dude. Makes it hard to hate the pinko commie rat bastard.
He seems to be a New Democrat type now. Even has a position at the Progressive Policy Institute.
He's even suspicious of market access regulation by the FCC. That's not a popular position among the far left these days.
"Their Ray Charles rewrite is, I think, what Schoolhouse Rock would sound like in the Red Dawn universe."
That's an awesome line.
Hey Jwatts,
You think you're tough for eating beans every day? There's half a million scarecrows in Denver who'd give anything for one mouthful of what you got. They've been under siege for about three months. They live on rats and sawdust bread and sometimes... on each other. At night, the pyres for the dead light up the sky. It's medieval.
Don't you dare imply the Democrats are a bunch of closet commies.
I think I see why Ev Ehrlich stopped being a Marxist - the fact that he's actually kind of funny would be absolute death in Marxist circles. I'm sure he had to sit through many an irrelevant showtrial.
Not too far OT since it has to do with commie nostalgia:
New York City Council honors Ethel Rosenberg for 'great bravery'
Seriously. NYC politicians officially honored a commie spy and devoted Stalinist with a proclamation of her great bravery.
Can't get the link to work, but you can Google the title.
The link works, but wasn't in preview.
There's no evidence that Ethel was directly involved in espionage, and the testimony that was used to convict her was later recanted.
Do you have any evidence to back up the claim that they were devoted Stalinists other than the fact that they spied for the country that Stalin was in charge of?
By around 1938, non-Stalinist members of the CPUSA either quit or were purged from the party. Anyway, according to Nikita Khrushchev, Stalin had a soft spot in his heart for the Rosenbergs -- plural:
You can simply Google "rosenberg devoted stalinist" for a host of articles that confirm this.
As for the recantation, it's irrelevant. Greenglass was Ethel Rosenberg's brother. He ratted her out to save his own treasonous ass, and later felt bad about it. One has to be pretty naive or deluded to think the commie was not up to her neck in the conspiracy.
A quick search brought up a bunch of articles on conservative sites that claimed she was devoted, or at the very worst was described as 'devoted' in Soviet documents. I'll take that for what it's worth.
And I'm not as limber as I once was, so I can't leap to conclusions in the absence of actual evidence the way I did when I was a kid.
Glorifying Ethel Rosenberg not bad enough you say? How about a terrorist?
Visit our HTML tutorial"There's more where that came from.
They named a street corner after convicted IRA terrorist Joe Doherty.
Oops -
http://irishecho.com/2011/02/joes-freeat-last-2/
Blocked.
Solidly overplayed.