Friday A/V Club: The Amateur Cameramen of 9/11
Before the streets were filled with people carrying cameras in their pockets, nonprofessional news footage was still on the rise.
Fourteen years ago today, this happened:
Writing in Reason shortly after 9/11, I called that "the most staggering footage to emerge from the terror." It wasn't just the video's apocalyptic content that staggered me; it was the fact it had been captured by an amateur who happened to have a camera with him that day. That hardly sounds significant now, but in 2001 the typical cell phone didn't come with video capabilities built in. You needed an actual distinct device that you thought of as "a camera" to get footage like that. In this case, a doctor named Mark Heath had brought one to document the scene for future reference, as he always did when responding to an emergency. Not long afterward, his recording was playing on CNN.
It wasn't the first time a nonprofessional had captured some key footage. (Just ask Abraham Zapruder.) But it seemed to be happening more and more often. Video cameras were becoming cheaper, more powerful, and more common, and they were much more likely to be running when an unexpected event struck. Since you couldn't count on a professional TV crew to be in place during a natural disaster or a terrorist attack, news programs frequently drew on this additional material. Whenever critics complained that bloggers and other amateurs were heavily dependent on the mainstream media's work, I would think of people like Heath and remember that the dependence was running both ways.
When disaster strikes these days, you can usually assume that at least half the crowd will have cameras in their pockets. And in the age of livestreams and Vines, their footage will turn up not just on outlets like CNN but in more direct and unedited venues as well. It all feels very futuristic; but then, back in 2001, Mark Heath's video felt futuristic too. Who knows what vernacular newsgathering will look like in another 14 years?
(For past editions of the Friday A/V Club, go here. For a particularly relevant installment, go here.)
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
That hardly sounds significant now, but in 2001 the typical cell phone didn't come with video capabilities built in.
Yeah, amateur cameraman? Back then you were a professional caveman with your flip phones and your acid wash jeans. Anyway, the best footage to emerge from the day to my mind was from those two French documentarians who happened to be following an FDNY company around.
Yeah, that was some kind of timing to have a professional crew right there.
Agreed.
Yeah...some kind of "timing", all right.
Looks like we have a couple of Truthers here.
I didn't think I knew any truthers, but Facebook is telling me otherwise today. Once guy is in the Nation of Islam, so no surprise there.
Time for some spring cleaning.
WAKE UP SHEEPLE FIST!
"Looks like we have a couple of Truthers here."
Mark Heath started it in his video, repeatedly mentioning explosions going off.
Yes, it was all staged by the French for the documentary.
Horrible and upsetting footage
9/11 was the first major news event I remember clearly and vividly. I watched one of the towers collapse live on television while waiting for my mom to drive me to school.
I also remember it was weird not seeing any airplanes in the sky since you could always see them flying in and out of LAX or Long Beach from where I was living at the time.
Shut up, kid.
I also vaguely remember Princess Diana's funeral and the Clinton impeachment verdict.
Do you remember the Luke and Laura saga?
Was your birth filmed on an iPhone?
Diana died on my birthday, which was also my first day at college. I have no memory of the funeral.
911 doesn't seem that long ago. It still seems weird to me that there are regular adults who were young kids when it happened.
I was watching the TV at work when the second plane hit. We were all standing there stunned.
Early that afternoon I was at home, since the University cancelled afternoon classes. I went outside at one point and there was a single contrail crossing the sky, heading northwest. Didn't think much of it, until later when I realized it must have been Air Force One, heading from Florida to Offutt AFB (I was in Carbondale, IL, which could easily have been on the route, which stopped in Louisiana first).
Spooky in retrospect.
Something that stands out to me is just how level headed most people around there were despite buildings falling down around their heads.
Same sort of thing after the bombing at the Boston Marathon.
Two bombs go off and within seconds most of the people around who were unhurt rushed towards where the danger had been, and spontaneously organized themselves to get things done despite the possibility that more bombs might go off.
It is funny how so many people just expect that people will panic and act like idiots when disaster strikes. Seems like that is rarely what happens.
Hm. When I watched the 2nd plane hit on 9/11 I will admit I ran like hell away from the scene.
Sounds like a pretty rational response.
I'm getting to the age where I've had a few friends die, but this one bothers me the most.
Wow, man. RIP. And go Buffs. A guy with whom I played high school football died on 9/11. When his father visited the memorial a few years ago, it became a brief media thing:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/new.....grief.html