In a Military Embracing Social Change, Troops Increasingly Identify as Independent and Libertarian

Shifts in social attitudes, politics, and attitudes toward government are seeping from the civilian world into the U.S. military. The military is quickly adapting to increased tolerance toward gays and lesbians in American life, expanding roles for women, and growing distaste for the established political parties and the performance of the U.S. government. And, like many Americans, soldiers, sailors, and marines are drifting away from the major parties, increasingly identifying themseves as independents and libertarians.
A survey of active-duty armed forces personnel among the readership of Military Times finds that support for gays and lesbians openly serving in the military rose from 35 percent in 2009 to 60 percent in 2014. Overt disapproval fell from 49 percent to 19 percent in the same time.
Support for opening at least some combat-arms jobs to women rose from 34 percent in 2011 to 41 percent in 2014, with opposition falling from 43 percent to 28 percent.
So military personnel match civilians in their increasing social tolerance and embrace of expanding opportunities for everybody. Honestly, why wouldn't they when they're recruited from the same population?
Likewise, the troops match their friends and relatives in growing disgust with the way the government handles its responsibilities. The country at large has presidential approval underwater and opinions of Congress sunk somewhere in the Mariana Trench. Military personnel, who generally think they're underpaid, undersupplied, and underappreciated say that neither major party has their best interests in mind. Approval in the ranks for President Obama plummeted from a weak 35 percent in 2009 to 15 percent this year.
And like other Americans, military personnel look for alternatives elsewhere. A generally conservative bunch, Democrats and liberals make up only about 8 percent of the poll respondents. But support for the Republican is hemmorrhaging away, with members of the armed forces increasingly identifying as independents and libertarians.
As Brian Doherty noted in 2012, the libertarianization of the military began several years ago. At the time, Ron Paul had raised from active-duty servicemembers and Pentagon employees more than four times the combined take of the other three Republican presidential candidates. President Obama had better fundraising luck than the other Republican candidates—taking in a bit less than half of what Paul managed.
If I remember right, a couple of Reason luminaries have written something or other about the growing independent strain (and role of libertarian ideas) in American life.
Then…

…and now.

Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Some of us were libertarian before 2012...
...and are encouraged that others are joining us.
Present!
If only there were women libertarians
Woah, woah - lets not go chasing an unrealistic dream now!
I was going to write something about at least it's not as bad as being a gay libertarian, but I think there are actually more gay men than straight women on here.
The fitness standards haven't been lowered enough yet.
*ducks and runs outta the room*
Fitness standards wouldn't be a problem if they put all combat arms women in their own units and assigned them based on their performance & capabilities *ducks but then remembers this is a dead thread*
9%? That's just one more than 8%, well within the margin of error.
..............VOTE MARGIN OF ERROR PARTY 2016
-------------BRINGING AMERICA CHANGE---------------
THAT YOU CAN DEBATE THE STATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF
Will someone poll the Millennials? I want to know what they think.
How about Millennial Troops?
Off topic, Joe Cocker passes from lung cancer. Shit.
At least we still have Lou Reed.
Are you a Cleveland Brown? Cause that joke...
Hasn't hurt his guitar playing any.
Members of the military have the benefit of seeing firsthand how shitty big government really is.
And how the pro-war parties need no goodreason to use them as cannon fodder.
I got to see how bad the Feds AND the State mishandle everything.
Hmm... Republican goes from 49% to 32%, Independent from 22% to 28%, Libertarian from 3% to either 7% (from the article) or 9% (from the graphic). Where did the missing folks go? The article says Democrats make up 8%, but does not information on the change.
On a related note, I know someone in the military who has been in about 15 years or so. He's probably going to be a lifer. Over the time he's been in, I've seen his actions and argumentation style change to match those of Progressives and other Obama supporters. I have no idea what he would say his political affiliation is, but actions speak louder than words. He's become a Progressive.
"but does not information" should be "but does not provide information".
I proofread my post. Really.
I'd like to see those poll numbers broken down by length of service. It's easy to think inside of that artificial bubble that society can be organized along similar lines with everything provided by BigArmyGovernment and everyone working towards a purpose handed down from above. Sick? Just go to the TMC. Hungry? There's the dining facility. Tired? There's your bunk.
Mr 2-Chilly,
Need a new photo - that is two uniforms behind the times...
But that's the one I wore...
I'm just going to drink my Metamucil now.
I'd be a bit leery of the poll as;
"From July 8 through Aug. 7, Military Times conducted a voluntary, confidential survey of readers, including active-duty, National Guard and reserve component service members as well as military veterans, retirees and spouses.
About 70,000 subscribers received email invitations to participate. Others were recruited via social media. In total, about 10,000 respondents completed the survey, including 2,299 who identified themselves as current active-duty personnel."
The military is quickly adapting to increased tolerance toward gays and lesbians in American life...
Sailors always had a high tolerance towards gays, if you know what I am saying.
When I first came on board with the libertarian movement about 30 years ago, I pretty quickly became used to seeing charts with numbers like 0.2% next to the "libertarian" label. Occasionally the numbers would climb as high as 1.2%.
About 10 years ago I noticed that the numbers were climbing into the 2% - 4% range.
To see a number like 9% next to the word "libertarian" is pretty astounding.
The cool thing is that ideas spread virally. So, I'm hopeful we'll see exponential rather than linear growth going forward.
Opinion polls are one thing, actual vote totals are another.
Vote totals don't matter as much as the center of mass of public opinion.
In the earlier days of the Republic, the career military (officers and NCO's) rarely involved themselves in political affairs, even avoiding voting.
Perhaps we are returning to that ethos.