Russian Proposal: Marry a Prostitute, Avoid Criminal Penalties


In St. Petersburg, Russia, it's currently against the law to sell sexual services but not to pay for them. One city lawmaker, Olga Galkina, aims to change that with a bit of provocative political theater.
Galkina recently introduced a bill that would impose heavy fines on prostitution clients in Russia's second-largest city. Under her proposal, those caught purchasing sexual services could face a charge of 4,000 to 10,000 rubles (about $95-$240) or up to five days in jail. The fines and jail time would increase if a client knew an individual was being forced into selling sex.
However—and here's where things get interesting—a client could evade these penalties if they agreed to marry the person providing the sexual service. From RT:
In the explanatory note attached to the bill Galkina quotes international experience, saying that introducing responsibility for clients had helped to decrease the prostitution rate in Finland, Norway, Sweden and Iceland. If the St. Petersburg city legislature approves the bill in two readings it would be sent to the Federal parliament with the possibility to become a national Russian law.
Law experts say that while the purpose of the bill is good it might face difficulties in real life as it would be very difficult to collect proof of the crime.
Let's be clear: the purpose of the bill is good. But not for the reasons these alleged law experts purport. Galkina's true motive in introducing the legislation was to get Russians thinking about how and why they criminalize sex.
The lawmaker told Kommersant-St Petersburg that she's actually an advocate for decriminalizing prostitution for sex workers and their clients. Her marry-a-prostitute proposal has almost no chance of passing, but she introduced it to spark a conversation.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
However?and here's where things get interesting?a client could evade these penalties if they agreed to marry the person providing the sexual service.
Clearly, Russia has no explicit statutes forbidding cruel and unusual punishment.
I had to duck to avoid that zinger
I had to read that first sentence 5 times and it just got weirder every time.
How's that?
So it's against the law to sell sexual services unless you pay for them? I'm sure this is my poor reading comprehension so cut me some slack. I've been editing Japanese all day.
I may have written it unclearly, that's why I was asking. Was just trying to say that being a prostitute is illegal, being a prostitute's client is not.
Your sentence is fine, E. Well, that sentence is fine.
Never mind. Sleepy and drunk.
It took my 2nd reading to get it too.
I am coming up with a joke about paying for the milk and still having to buy the cow. Give me a minute.
In Soviet Russia, milk buys you?
In Soviet Russian, cow milks you?
Vodka?
*golf clap*
WELL TELL THE DAMN JOKE ALREADY.
I'm thinking.
Is that the one with the milking machine in the Farmer's Barn? where the traveling salesman sticks his willy in the hole?
That's not funny at all.
Marry a prostitute
Enough of my wife...
A marriage based on expediency and coercion - what could possibly go wrong?
Nothing that doesn't go wrong anyway
Speaking of which, what about the gay prostitutes (OK, maybe the ones in Finland, Norway, Sweden, etc.)? Are they be forced to marry or be more responsible at each other as well?
It's not the statism, it's the lack of equality that really gets you.
A divorce and she gets half his stuff.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SniOXFhwIZ8
$240 seems cheaper than a divorce.
That would never be abused.
The silhouette in that ad is bullshit. They don't look like that unless you shell out 8,000 - 12,000 rubles.
Well, the girls name is Olesya, maybe she does look like that.
That said, telephone pole? Even bears have internet in Russia nowadays.
The silhouette in that ad is bullshit. They don't look like that unless you shell out 8,000 - 12,000 rubles.
Or just move the light source really far away.
In other words a rent to buy option. No thanks, it's not the purchase price but the maintence cost that will kill you.
Don't forget the termination fee.
The state won't let me forget.
/bitter divorced guy
" Her marry-a-prostitute proposal has almost no chance of passing, but she introduced it to spark a conversation."
That's all fine and good but what happens when an unholy alliance of Russian SOCONS(whatever Russian socons are, cossacks? Kukaks?) Feminist( I assume there are more feminist in Russia than that one shitty punk band) and human trafficking mongers pushes this bill through? Hooray for liberty, more people on jail.
To review, the top legal approaches to prostitution:
Decriminalization: No penalties for the seller or buyer. Both have legal protection.
The Swedish Model: The buyer faces full, unmitigated penalties. The seller cannot be put in jail, but can be 1) forced to entrap her clients, 2) is not allowed to seek a safer environment by working in a brothel, and 3) may be forced into rehab, which may seem just like jail, but it has throw pillows and therapists, so it's totally not. They only try to escape because their invisible pimps have beaten them into Stockholm syndrome!
The American Model: The seller faces full, unmitigated penalties. Anyone she enlists to transport or protect her faces even worse penalties. Buyers must be fully licensed before hiring a prostitute. Licensure requires attending a police academy. Once appropraite licensure is obtained, both payment and consent of the sex worker are optional.