4/20

This Is What Legalizing Marijuana Did to the Black Market in Colorado

Illegal pot dealers still undersell licensed marijuana merchants in Colorado, but their advantage may be fading.

|

Marcos Fernandez Diaz Vj Catmac / photo on flickr

On New Year's Day, when Toni Fox became the first state-licensed marijuana merchant in Colorado to serve recreational customers, nearly 200 reporters crowded into the 3D Cannabis Center while hundreds of customers waited patiently outside the store. "It was controlled chaos," she recalls with a smile. "We saw close to 500 people that day. We ended up turning away over 300 people."

Business since then has been brisk, validating Fox's decision to switch completely from medical to recreational marijuana. "Pre-2014," she says, "we were seeing, on average, 25 customers a day, doing $1,000 a day in sales. Today we see, on average, 200 people a day, and we're doing $11,000 a day in sales. In the first three months of recreational sales, I did as much as three years of medical revenue." It does not hurt that Fox's store is conveniently located for tourists, on the way into Denver from the airport.

Fox has had no trouble attracting customers even though she charges substantially more than black-market dealers do: about $60 for an eighth of an ounce after taxes, compared to something like $40 for pot of similar quality purchased from unlicensed sellers in Colorado (judging from Craigslist ads and PriceOfWeed.com, a website that collects data from consumers, and assuming a 30 percent discount for buying an entire ounce). Some dispensaries in mountain resort towns charge as much as $70 for an eighth after taxes, and people happily pay it.

"It's a night-and-day difference between medical and recreational," Fox says. "We did medical for three years. We operated in the red. We dealt with patients who were on serious budgets, who were making sacrifices to get their cannabis. They wanted the best price. Something extra. There was always negotiating. And they were always making a conscious choice on whether they were going to use cannabis or pharmaceuticals. Their pharmaceuticals are covered under insurance, but cannabis helps them, so it's a vicious struggle. And everybody is sick and wants to tell you why they need the cannabis because they're sick. With recreational, it's tourists coming in with cash, pockets full of money, saying, 'I want the best. I can't believe this is happening. This is amazing.' Night and day."

'Black-Market Prices Are Definitely Lower'

Visitors from other states, eager to enjoy the novelty of legal weed, may not blink at the prices, especially if black-market dealers where they live charge about as much. But locals, especially regular consumers, are apt to be more price-sensitive. The owner of one mountain dispensary told me he has one set of prices for tourists, and a different, lower set for locals. Many consumers balk even at those prices, which helps explain why the black market persists in Colorado in spite of legalization. How long that situation will last is an important question for Colorado and for other states that are considering following its example, since eliminating the black market is one of legalization's main selling points.

"The black-market prices are definitely lower than recreational prices," says Michael Elliott, executive director of Colorado's Marijuana Industry Group. "The taxes are a big reason why, the new testing requirements, the packaging requirements, and basically this whole hurdle of the extraordinary expenses people have had to go through to open these businesses. Another reason is that the businesses have had limited supply." The supply problem was especially acute in the early months, before the first harvests of plants raised for the recreational market, when repurposed medical marijuana was the only source.

The relatively high prices may help explain why the number of medical marijuana patients registered with the state Department of Public Health and Environment rose from 106,763 in November 2012, when voters approved Colorado's legalization initiative, to 115,210 in May 2014. The increase is not huge, but other things being equal you might have expected that number to shrink during this period, assuming that recreational users posing as patients would shift to the general market, where you can buy marijuana without a bureaucratic hassle. But patients are exempt from most of the taxes on marijuana, and dispensaries generally charge them less to begin with.

Although some conditions covered by Colorado's medical marijuana law, such as cancer and HIV/AIDS, are pretty hard to fake, by far the most commonly reported condition, accounting for 94 percent of registration cards, is "severe pain," which cannot be objectively verified. "It is no secret in Colorado that some medical marijuana users use that market without a legitimate medical need," writes Brookings Institution fellow John Hudak in a July 2014 report on Colorado's regulatory rollout. "The state has an obvious interest in moving some 'gray-market' medical consumers to the new retail market. Unfortunately, the tax and fee structures for medical and retail marijuana did nothing to limit gray-market activity."

Nick Brown, co-owner of a company that specializes in cannabis-oriented tours, obtained a medical card based on lingering pain from an old shoulder injury. "It's a scam," Brown says. He adds that "anyone who uses cannabis regularly" should consider registering as a patient. According to figures from the Colorado Department of Revenue, medical sales exceeded recreational sales by 65 percent in the first six months of this year, although the ratio shrank during that period, almost reaching parity in June.

'$10 and $15 Eighths'

The advantages of a medical card should wane as supply rises and recreational prices fall. Kayvan Khalatbari, co-owner of Denver Relief, a medical dispensary that started serving recreational consumers in July, says after-tax prices in that market average $50 to $60 per eighth. He expects those prices to plummet by next year, however, as growers ramp up production and new suppliers enter the market. As of October 1, dispensaries no longer have to grow 70 percent of their inventory, and businesses dedicated to cultivation will be allowed.

"I would not be surprised, given the flood that's going to happen, if we see $10 and $15 eighths by early next year," Khalatbari says. "I would believe that. I could see ounces being sold for $50. I truly see that happening, because there is going to be so much competition [and] people are becoming so efficient in their production. They're automating much more. We're seeing best practices settle in. There's less risk in operating because people are operating at a higher level. I think we're going to become a very efficient industry very quickly. We're going to see competition, and we're going to see prices hit rock bottom early next year." At that point, he predicts, the black market will dwindle away.

Elliott agrees that "it will be harder and harder for the black market to compete," although he is reluctant to specify a time frame. He adds that black-market dealers will continue to thrive in parts of Colorado where local governments have banned pot stores. "The eastern plains of Colorado, which is about a third of the state, you're not going to find any marijuana businesses out there," he says. "They've banned the market."

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

27 responses to “This Is What Legalizing Marijuana Did to the Black Market in Colorado

  1. Nick Brown, co-owner of a company that specializes in cannabis-oriented tours, obtained a medical card based on lingering pain from an old shoulder injury. “It’s a scam,” Brown says.

    Ouch.

  2. “Nick Brown, co-owner of a company that specializes in cannabis-oriented tours, obtained a medical card based on lingering pain from an old shoulder injury. “It’s a scam,” Brown says.”

    OK, I understand scamming the system. It’s an American tradition. But announcing publicly that you’re doing it is kind of dumb. Brown will act all butt-hurt when his medical card is revoked based on his admission, and it will be nobody’s fault but his own.

    1. I think that he could argue that when he said “it’s a scam,” the “it” he was referring to the entire medical cannabis card system, not his own particular injury that gets him a card.

      That may have been his actual intent too (who knows).

      1. Yeah, that paragraph’s poorly written; it’s hard to tell what is being referred to…

      2. I took it as the retail market taxes are a scam. Could go any one of these ways

    2. Yeah, because the inefficient organization that has never checked on the 94% of people with “pain” is reading news articles for people that might have admitted it.

      Remember, doctors openly advertise that they give medical marijuana cards, and some do nothing but pour a long string of “pain” cards out, and yet the government has never done anything about *them*. They couldn’t care less about one guy who admits he faked a medical condition to get a card.

      Don’t give the government so much credit: they are shitty at what they do.

  3. I’ve forgotten, if I ever knew, the restrictions on personal cultivation. Anybody know? It seems to me that what this kind of pricing is going to do is encourage home growth.

    But I’ve never been in the market for pot, seldom smoked it (and that was a decades back), and probable;y have a grossly unrealistic idea of what unregulated prices would be like.

    1. 6 or less plants in Colorado.

      1. With no more than 3 producing buds at any time.

      2. None in Washington (where I am).

        FWIW, the high end shop in Washington is charging $100 for an 8th, so Colorado is doing a lot better than we are. But there’s literally two recreational shops open in the Seattle area, and they struggle for supply. Washington’s implementation has sucked compared to Colorado’s, though I’m still hopeful that in time the supply chains will start flowing and we’ll see prices come down.

        Also, that particular shop is in one of the wealthiest areas of Seattle. It’s actually kind of a trip: they only allow as many people in the shop as they have salespeople, and each person that comes in gets their own personal salesperson while you are there. They ask you what kind of buzz you are looking for, walk you through the different strains and prices, explain indica vs sativa, and generally are extremely professional.

  4. I think the situation you’ll eventually see is similar to liquor and moonshine. People will primarily utilize the legal route but you’ll never completely eliminate the black market. There are certain risks ,up to and including death, involved in playing in the black market mostly revolving around interacting with people willing to operate illegally, risks that will tend to push people into the legal market.

    1. The richie-riches and casual users who’s habit is well within their budget will go with the legal stuff to avoid having to go into bad neighborhoods. The lower classes will still want to get more dope for their money.

  5. But what about the skyrocketing murder rate? What about all the robberies the pot addicts are committing to fund their addiction? What about the crazed negros doing heinous criminal acts? What about the downward spiral of society due to all the dopers smoking pot all day and collecting welfare? And for shits sake, what about the children?

    1. The murders are caused by street gangs fighting for their market share. A dwindling market may even make that worse like the crack wars of the 80s.

      1. I believe his comment was satirical.

  6. my classmate’s step-mother makes $72 /hour on the internet . She has been out of a job for 8 months but last month her income was $13320 just working on the internet for a few hours. find out here now ….

    ????? http://www.netjob70.com

  7. So, I guess boutique weed dealers will get into the whole organic, locally-grown, cruelty-free-range heirloom GMO-free stuff in short order..

  8. If the gov’t of CO wished to truly put the Black Market in MJ out of business, they would just form a marketing co-op (assent to such would be part of the business license scheme) that would have the power to set pricing levels and just set the levels so low that the Black Market would be squeezed out. Of course, they would have to subsidize licensed sellers to some degree to keep them in business.
    Or, they could just throw their hands up, and get out of the marketing/regulating business altogether and take the state back to how it operated in the pre-Progressive Era of Laissez Faire – but that would be ‘small-c’ conservative, even TEA Party (oh, the horrors).

  9. Well I live in Colorado and I think it is interesting what is happening. Pothead friends of mine who voted to legalize because ‘if we leglaize/regulate, it can raise revenue’ (the statist argument) are still buying it on the black market – because its cheaper. Those who voted for it because ‘it’s not dangerous so get the government out of it’ are buying it legally.

  10. Can you have some spare time to sit back in your chair having your laptop with you and making some money online for some interesting online work said Jenny Francis in the party last nightsee more what is for you there to increase your pocket money??.

    http://shorx.com/clickforsurvey

  11. We really ought to refer to it as the Free Market not the Black market
    Black seems to imply intentionally dishonest dealing when it was the policies that drove the market underground that were dishonest.
    Free market
    Black policies

  12. My neighbor’s mother-in-law makes $88 hourly on the laptop . She has been out of work for 8 months but last month her check was $21643 just working on the laptop for a few hours.
    Have a peek at this website. ????? http://www.jobsfish.com

  13. “The black-market prices are definitely lower than recreational prices,”

    Garage sales and craigslist are cheaper than stores. To whom should is this news?

    No storefront, no taxes. Duh.

  14. The business in cannabis market has increase after its legalization for recreational purpose. Brandsy provide services by using the best strategies for cannabis branding http://www.brandsy.co/, so your brand reach the targeted market.

  15. We sell and we’re suppliers of various types of kush.They’re available in Good Quality and are ready available for those above 18years, we do both retailing and wholesales.Our products are of High purity (99.92 -99.98 %).We globally ship discretely with our prices being moderate.Contact for more information if interested in any of our stuffs for prompt and discrete supplies.Willing to mix and match strains.We sale top quality naturally.
    grown bud strains like .
    *Green Crack
    *Sour Diesel :::::Grade: A+ Top Shelf.
    *Grand Daddy Purple ::::Grade: A.
    *Sensi Star x ak47 :::::::Grade: AAA.
    *Afghan Kush ::::::Grade: A.
    *Northern Lights #5 ::::::Grade: A+.
    *Lemon drop::::::Grade: A+.
    *Purple Kush:::::::Grade:A+ Top Shelf.
    *OG Kush ::::::::::Grade:A++ Top Shelf.
    if you are interested text (803) 271-0876 or email (morgananderson450@gmail.com) for more info.

  16. “The owner of one mountain dispensary told me he has one set of prices for tourists, and a different, lower set for locals.”

    I’d like to know the name of this dispensary that is ripping off tourists.

  17. We can get the hack instagram account online for this game here which is so easy to play all the times we are here to get the instagram hack.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.