Venezuelans Sick of a Government That Claims to Act For Them
Had enough of chavismo


The old saw that "government's just a word for the things we do together" provides comfort to those whose politics demand a total (or totalitarian!) state, one that claims to care for and control almost every aspect of everyone's lives. Leftist parties in some countries have gotten the paradigm down to an art. Take Venezuela, where Hugo Chavez considered himself and his party and the people of Venezuela one and the same. He created an expansive welfare state that built a dependency in the population not just on the Venezuelan government, but on Chavez' United Socialist Party. After his death, his chosen successor Nicholas Maduro mobilized every part of the Venezuelan state he could to secure his election, "officially" winning with just 50.8 percent of the vote. That was enough of a victory, nevertheless, to claim a mandate to move forward on an ambitious program of total control by the state. What happened next shouldn't be surprising. The standard of living in Venezuela continued to decline. The government imposed price controls on everything from used cars to toilet paper to all consumer goods, then blamed capitalists and not their own destructive government intervention on the economic disaster price controls exacerbated.
Now, less than a year after Maduro's "victory," a critical mass of Venezuela's population has had enough, taking to the streets in some of the largest protests the South American country has seen in its history. El Comercio in Peru explains that the Maduro government is using its "Board of Social Responsibility in Radio and Television" to threaten news outlets in the country that transmit images that could "foment anxiety," like video of the protests and government violence therein, with sanctions. You can see video via Peru's El Comercio purporting to show a student being killed by pro-government forces here.
Reuters reported on three deaths earlier this week, in what it describes as "a militantly pro-government neighborhood" in Caracas. The government's response to the bloodshed was to order the arrest of an opposition leader who helped organize several of the recent protests. According to the president of the National Assembly, a member of an pro-government paramilitary group was killed, by "fascism," the Chavez politician said.
Watch amateur video of the student killing also purported to be shown in the El Comercio video linked above below:
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
When Maduro finally kicks it, the people will "vote" his handpicked successor in to continue the "mandate" toward social "justice" or whatever.
government's just a word for the things we do together ... under threat of violence.
-jcr
The government imposed price controls on everything from used cars to toilet paper to all consumer goods, then blamed capitalists and not their own destructive government intervention on the economic disaster price controls exacerbated.
So Venezuela is different from the U.S. only in degree.
Exactly right. The mindset of government control is the same.
Look, the most important thing is that we don't rush to blame any of Venezuela's economic and social problems on its leftist authoritarian government.
We blame it on the 50.8%. Assuming the 50.8% existed.
Venezuela is democratic! /joe
Seriously tho, it's only been 170 years since Paez. The toilet paper shortage is probably definitely his fault. I'm sure the evil right-wing VZ libertarians are to blame for the rest.
Goddamned free market.
If Venezuela had a right wing Pinochet type regime, this would be ALL OVER the international news.
They blame the shortages on "hoarders" and speculators. They blame the student demonstrators deaths on the opposition leaders who told them they could demonstrate. The youth demonstrating are cut down by youth who are paid to be thugs, while their mothers are out standing in line six hours for a quart of milk or a package of corn flour.
Maduro's solution to the food shortages? Eat less! Why do you have to eat so much food! It's unpatriotic.
Of course, if Venezuela had a Pinochet-type regime, it would actually have a functioning economy.
True! Crime and food shortages wouldn't be issues.
Paging joe...paging joe.
50.8%! 50.8%!!!!
I still treasure the time he snapped at me for calling Chavez a caudillo. Good memories. Hey, you remember that one time that joe was hilariously short?
Was that before or after he was doing God's work, on the mean streets of Lowell, MA?
I believe it was after the time he threatened to punch SugarFree in the face.
can't do that...a) too short b) will get the diabeetus.
I usually describe Chavez as a "murdering commie rat bastard", but "caudillo" certainly applies as well.
Of course, Chavez did become a good commie by dying, as I wish they all would.
-jcr
Maduro has twice the rat bastardness with none of the charm. At least Chavez could dance and was funny once in awhile.
Is the protest movement growing the past two days, or is it faltering? Not a lot of reporting on this...
Not a lot of reporting because all but official government news media have been shut down. Journalists cameras and recorders confiscated and threatened at the point of a gun. Literally everything not put out by the government is on social media - Twitter, Facebook and the like, and now they are trying to shut those down as well.
Maduro must think he's still in Cuba.
Hmm, watching the video, is it me or does that protester have a gun in his hand at 00:28?
Meh, could be a phone... very hard to say.
BLAMBLAMBLAM!!!!
PUT DOWN THE GUN! FURTIVE MOVEMENT! SUSPICIOUS OBJECT!!
/Chicago PD
We told him to put down the gun, but the bullets got there first, due to the humidity.
What I got from the video - the Venezulans aren't using molotovs. The Ukrainians loved those things - but in Venezula, whose sugar daddy is oil, they can't get gas for their molotov cocktails?
The genius of socialism.
tequila?
Honestly i don't know what flammable drinks Venezuelans drink.
Can't we do some kind of Berlin Airlift for them, but drop bundles of toilet paper and something educational to read while on the pot - maybe The Road to Serfdom, Economics in One Lesson, or Wealth of Nations?
The backward fucks would read the toilet paper and wipe their asses with The Road To Serfdom.
I don't see how Venezuela isn't every socialist democracy fanboy's logical conclusion.
They've got welfare programs, price controls, rampant property confiscation, class warfare... something for everyone.
I guess they took it to far. Then again, who's to say no to democracy?
Democracy's a great idea, until you're outnumbered.
Don't forget crime. Particularly murders - 24,000 last year.
Sick of a government that claims to act for them? You mean, one with an imaginary social contract, like pretty much all governments?
I'm treated like a child by my government. Therefore I'm not allowed to enter any social contracts.
three deaths
order the arrest of an opposition leader
I said years ago to former commentor and Chavez apologist joe it was only a matter of time until the mass graves were uncovered.