Reason.com - Free Minds and Free Markets
Reason logo Reason logo
  • Latest
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Crossword
  • Video
  • Podcasts
    • All Shows
    • The Reason Roundtable
    • The Reason Interview With Nick Gillespie
    • The Soho Forum Debates
    • Just Asking Questions
    • The Best of Reason Magazine
    • Why We Can't Have Nice Things
  • Volokh
  • Newsletters
  • Donate
    • Donate Online
    • Donate Crypto
    • Ways To Give To Reason Foundation
    • Torchbearer Society
    • Planned Giving
  • Subscribe
    • Reason Plus Subscription
    • Print Subscription
    • Gift Subscriptions
    • Subscriber Support

Login Form

Create new account
Forgot password

Civil Liberties

Brickbat: Leave the Driving to Us

Charles Oliver | 6.19.2013 6:55 AM

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL
Media Contact & Reprint Requests

Johnny Cook drove a bus for the Haralson County, Georgia, school system, and he got upset when a middle school student told him he didn't get to eat because his lunch card was 40 cents short. He posted about the incident on his Facebook page and said the next time that happens someone should call him and he'd pay the 40 cents. School officials fired Cook after he refused their demand to recant the post.

Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

NEXT: Video: What if Miss Utah Gave the Correct Answer at the Miss USA Pageant?

Charles Oliver is a contributing editor at Reason.

Civil LibertiesNanny StateEducation
Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL
Media Contact & Reprint Requests

Hide Comments (80)

Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.

  1. Fist of Etiquette   12 years ago

    I guess he won't be floating any kids lunch money again any time soon.

  2. RBS   12 years ago

    Fries, tater tots and square pizza? I'm pretty sure they never served us the three best foods at the same time.

    1. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

      Starch with salt, starch with ketchup and starch with a genuine-artificial red tomato smear and fake cheese. Yum.

    2. SIV   12 years ago

      Its been a long time but I think we got pizza, roll,mashed potatoes, corn and cake once.

    3. Fist of Etiquette   12 years ago

      Square pizza is the worst flavor of pizza. There are parts without crust.

      1. Ted S.   12 years ago

        Worse than round deep-dish?

        1. Fist of Etiquette   12 years ago

          Let me make this clear as possible: There is absolutely nothing in the universe worse than square pizza.

          1. PS   12 years ago

            Ha!

            You forgot Epi's "chili".

        2. General Butt Naked   12 years ago

          He's talking about pizza here, not casserole.

      2. Auric Demonocles   12 years ago

        I suspect this to be satire, because the fact that there are ones where you don't get stuck eating the crust is the best part.

        1. NeonCat   12 years ago

          Clearly we need to add crust vs no crust to the deep dish/thin crust debate on H&R.

    4. DaveAnthony   12 years ago

      School lunch pizza was always nasty.

      I went to public school in Hawaii for about 8 years, and there was only one good lunch. Kalua pork day -- everyone lined up for that! Kalua pork, sticky rice, and coconut haupia square. I think there were vegetables also but I didn't eat them. :-p

      1. DaveAnthony   12 years ago

        Also, if you couldn't stomach the daily offering, ther was always the saimin line which was a styrafoam cup of sad water with noodles, spam slices, and a piece of white/pink fishcake swirl (a.k.a. the japanese hot dog).

      2. Geoff Nathan   12 years ago

        Mmmm! Ono. UH cafeteria had the best bulgogi. Two scoops rice, etc.

        On the other hand, Toronto high schools had french fries with gravy, which I though were wonderful, at the time...

        1. KDN   12 years ago

          French fries with gravy are awesome anytime.

          They phased out Ellio's as school pizza by the time I got to 5th grade. It seems that some genius administrator (actually not sarc!) noticed that there were at least 5 actual pizza places within a mile of each school in the town and connected and used them instead.

    5. Greg   12 years ago

      Are those tater tots? I thought they were at first, but now they look more like chicken nuggets to me.

  3. sarcasmic   12 years ago

    My kid will hate me once she gets school age, since I'll be sending her with a nice brown bag instead of money. You're having the same thing for lunch that I'm having, kid: leftovers.

    1. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

      Growing up I preferred a bag lunch. School food was just. that. bad.

      1. Ted S.   12 years ago

        School didn't offer liverwurst sandwiches.

        1. sarcasmic   12 years ago

          With extra mustard. Yum!

          1. JW   12 years ago

            Best kid sandwich? Bologna on white bread, with yellow mustard and Utz potato chips on top.

            1. SugarFree   12 years ago

              Ours was an olive loaf home. Lots of olive loaf. Which was fine with me.

              Of course, we never had white bread. Fucking Roman Meal.

      2. Matrix   12 years ago

        The things kids like the most are probably the worst things on the school menu:
        Pizza
        Spaghetti

        At home... fantastic. At school? Horrible.

        The only thing I really looked forward to for school lunch was the chicken nuggets. Got mashed potatos, gravy, corn, and a roll with it. Everything else was barely edible.

        1. generic Brand   12 years ago

          Double Turkey Thursday was good at my high school. It was really just turkey Thursday, but we were allowed to pay an extra $2.25 or whatever a single lunch was and get twice as much of everything. Even two milks!

      3. sarcasmic   12 years ago

        I might have eaten at the cafeteria once. Maybe twice. Food was awful.

  4. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

    Where we are, if a kid doesn't have a lunch or lunch money, the cafeteria gives him a cheese sandwich and a half pint of milk.

    When my girls see something like that, they get something extra and slip it to him. We consider it to be the same as when some kids' families can't afford school supplies. We go to Sam's Club and buy big boxes of pencils, loose leaf paper and such and take it to the teachers to give to them.

    1. invisible furry hand   12 years ago

      Aww, your girls sound like sweethearts. Well done!

      1. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

        Aww, your girls sound like sweethearts. Well done!

        Thank you. To listen to them you wouldn't believe it, but they take after their mother.

    2. Matrix   12 years ago

      what do they do for the lactose intolerant kids?

      1. RBS   12 years ago

        They have a zero tolerance policy for intolerance.

        1. SugarFree   12 years ago

          They punch sarcasmic in the face.

          1. sarcasmic   12 years ago

            I spray gas propelled diarrhea in their general direction.

            1. invisible furry hand   12 years ago

              if that's what happens when you're punched in the face, what happens when you're punched in the arse?

              1. Heroic Mulatto   12 years ago

                Projectile vomiting, of course.

              2. sarcasmic   12 years ago

                It's what happens after I wash a cheese sandwich down with milk.

              3. SugarFree   12 years ago

                if that's what happens when you're punched in the face, what happens when you're punched in the arse?

                Both.

  5. mr simple   12 years ago

    School lunch is come on? I think you're burying the real story, Oliver.

  6. Brian D   12 years ago

    My outrage-ometer is barely registering with this one. If the kid didn't eat because he didn't have enough money, he'll be more concerned about making sure he has lunch money in the future, like reminding a parent who may have forgotten that detail. And it's not like the kid starved to death. He missed one meal.

    And the bus driver, whose heart was in the right place, violated a policy he knew about.

    1. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

      Maybe the school lunch itself _is_ the outrage?

    2. mr simple   12 years ago

      So you think he knew that post would cause "substantial disruption to the instructional environment," or that it even did? I guess he should have known that was just code for anything that casts a slightly disparaging light on the school or its administrators. I think the school system has a weak case that his post meets the standards laid out, besides being a public institution where speech should be protected.

      1. Brian D   12 years ago

        I think it's reasonable to suspect that a Facebook post about a kid going hungry would generate a substantial amount of attention on a social networking site, and that some of said attention would get back to the school, and that it would be disruptive, unless you think angry calls from parents concerning an incident that didn't involve their kid isn't disruptive. How else did the superintendent know to call the driver in for a meeting "the next day"?

        Also, according to the article, it seems the school had a contingency in place for students who didn't have enough money for the regular mean--a bagged lunch. So from the school's perspective, the student could not have even gotten in line for lunch or he would have been given that. If that's the case, the student lied to the bus driver, who then posted that lie to the internet. I wonder if lying to the public about your employer's doings would constitute substantial disruption...

        The driver should have first gone to the principal or whatever to verify the student's claim before making his Facebook post.

        1. mr simple   12 years ago

          There is nothing in the article to indicate it was a lie. The student said he was refused the contingency option because he already owed the school. But I guess as a bureaucrat, you're always going to take the bureaucrats word and demonize the man that only stamped his form 4 times instead of 5. Good to know you think a person should get permission before expressing an opinion to others.

          1. Brian D   12 years ago

            There is nothing in the article to indicate it was a lie.

            According to the student's own statement, he got in line and got his tray and was told to go put it back down and sit down. The superintendent said that video coverage of the cafeteria doesn't show the boy getting in line at all.

        2. Robert   12 years ago

          angry calls from parents concerning an incident that didn't involve their kid isn't disruptive

          No, it isn't. It's part of the job to field complaints, even if the complaints are baseless.

          1. Brian D   12 years ago

            Well then let me go make a Facebook post about how that superintendent sacrificed a small child to the Dark Lord Satan. I'm sure it won't interfere with their work at all.

    3. Heroic Mulatto   12 years ago

      he'll be more concerned about making sure he has lunch money in the future, like reminding a parent who may have forgotten that detail.

      No. It's more likely he would acquire the funds by beating the snot out of a younger, weaker, and richer kid.

      Jus' sayin'

      1. PS   12 years ago

        Yeah, that's much more likely than him saying, "Hey Mom, you forgot to give me lunch money."

        1. RBS   12 years ago

          This brings up something I was talking to my wife about the other day. Everyone is so concerned/paranoid about their children getting bullied at school but nobody seems to think that their own kid could be the bully.

          1. SugarFree   12 years ago

            "Welcome to Lake Denial, where all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the children are above average."

          2. PS   12 years ago

            Back in the day, I think the parents usually knew their kid was kind of a bully, but they wrote it off as boys being boys, or else it was because they were the shitty dysfunctional family. Nowadays, I've no idea.

            1. SugarFree   12 years ago

              When I was a kid, the difference between being a bully and just a plain asshole was mostly socioeconomic. Bullies were poor kids from white trash parents who would tell a teacher to go fuck themselves when caught doing something and assholes where rich kids that acted exactly like the bullies, but could flash perfectly white teeth at the teachers and be obsequious with the teachers and therefore get away with anything.

              1. PS   12 years ago

                Yeah, pretty much. But the bullies were also the ones who were much more like to physically hurt you.

                1. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

                  But the bullies were also the ones who were much more like to physically hurt you.

                  When I was a kid, I got good with an axe handle. "You hit her, we hit you" or "You be nice, I'll be nice." Reminded me of the Craftsman Mower. The problem went away first time, most every time.

                  I got a reputation as a mean little shit, but my friends were safe.

        2. Heroic Mulatto   12 years ago

          Indeed. In this day and age, if a kid is going to school without lunch money, it's because the parents are extremely fucked up in some way (substance abuse, mental illness, I don't give a shit you're just a childsupport check syndrome, etc.). Asking his parents for 40 cents would probably result in a open hand slap to the face. Thus, the rational economic choice is to extort the money.

          1. DaveAnthony   12 years ago

            Or his parents left the lunch money out on the counter and he forgot to grab it. :p

            That is usually what happened to me.

          2. PS   12 years ago

            (I've no idea if you are being serious)

            Or it's just because both parents work and they spaced it out and the kid spaced it out.

            My kid would wear his PJs to school if I didn't remind him to get dressed in the morning.

            1. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

              We have families around here who just cannot afford what we think of as "normal expenses" from time to time. These people work their butts off and don't use the rent money for tatoos.

    4. PS   12 years ago

      Yeah, I'm with you on this, Brian.

      Employees who post or contribute any comment or content on social networking sites that causes a substantial disruption to the instructional environment are subject to disciplinary procedures up and including termination.

      Also a kid who hasn't had his metabolism screwed up ought to have access to fat stores, certainly enough to last him the two or three hours it takes till he gets home.

      1. RBS   12 years ago

        causes a substantial disruption to the instructional environment

        I find it very hard to believe his post rose to this level. Or it least in a sane world without hyper sensitive school administrators.

        1. PS   12 years ago

          That's debatable for sure but I think public schools ought to be able to fire whoever they want whenever they want. Not that this would ever happen or that it would impact the people who really ought to be fired but I think they ought to be within their rights to fire this guy.

          I also think the bus driver is within his rights to make a cause c?l?bre out of this, and I wouldn't be surprised if they were shamed into hiring him back or if someone else hired him because of the publicity.

    5. Agammamon   12 years ago

      ". . .he got upset when a middle school student told him he didn't get to eat because his lunch card was 40 cents short."

      Are you sure it was the kid? "Cause the brickbat is written as if it was the *bus driver* who didn't get to eat.

    6. Agammamon   12 years ago

      ". . .he got upset when a middle school student told him he didn't get to eat because his lunch card was 40 cents short."

      Are you sure it was the kid? "Cause the brickbat is written as if it was the *bus driver* who didn't get to eat.

  7. Drake   12 years ago

    What the hell is wrong with that bus driver? If you want to help the kid - give him the 40 cents. Why put the good deed you never really did on Facebook?

    1. Ted S.   12 years ago

      It sounds as though the driver only learned about the kid's being 40 cents short after the fact.

  8. Ted S.   12 years ago

    I presume they arrested the kid too, for revealing state secrets or something. I'm sure they can come up with something.

  9. JW   12 years ago

    Now that my kids are teenagers, we have one rule about lunches: make your own or starve.

    1. sarcasmic   12 years ago

      Nice.

  10. SugarFree   12 years ago

    In high school we had an a la carte line as long as you were paying with cash instead of vouchers. I'd get a rectangle pizza or a sad hamburger and a carton of orange drank. Woot!

    But good fire, school system. Abusive coaches, rapist teachers, lazy, mean, and evil are all fine, but one hint of criticism and the generous bus driver has got to fucking go, right?

    1. Ted S.   12 years ago

      The a la carte line of my high school cafeteria was where I learned to drink coffe. Black, with no sugar.

      1. Heroic Mulatto   12 years ago

        We had Taco Bell at my high school cafeteria. Also, for upperclassmen, it was an open campus, so you could grab lunch (and porno mags) at any of the shady-ass convince stores/sub shops in the vicinity.

        As the step-son of a chef, I also brought a bag lunch.

        1. Heroic Mulatto   12 years ago

          * also = always

        2. SugarFree   12 years ago

          We were very close to having an open campus when a retard in Evansville plowed into a group of students milling around the front of their school. That they were hit by a car on campus during lunch proved it was too dangerous to let students leave campus during lunch. School officials are fucking idiots, assholes, and abject goddamn liars.

    2. Robert   12 years ago

      a carton of orange drank

      I initially read that as "a cartoon of orange drink".

      1. Robert   12 years ago

        Well, whaddaya expect for that price?

      2. Agammamon   12 years ago

        Its the hierarchy of juices

        (fruit) Juice
        (Fruit) Drink
        (color) Drank

  11. sarcasmic   12 years ago

    Whose Line: Greatest Hits Songs of The Bus Driver

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5sg691tneEQ

    1. Live Free or Diet   12 years ago

      And that hit song: "Pffffffssssst!"

  12. Mainer2   12 years ago

    "I can assure you it did not happen," Haralson County Superintendent Brett Stanton said.

    Isn't it pretty well established that any statement that opens with "I can assure you..." will be followed by bullshit ?

  13. Dave Krueger   12 years ago

    Of course he was fired. The government doesn't like whistle blowers.

    For those who don't know, whistle blowers are people who embarrass someone in the government by publicizing the stunningly stupid stuff they do but don't want the public to know about.

  14. Anand   11 years ago

    Fathers Day poems from Daughter

    fathers day Poems

Please log in to post comments

Mute this user?

  • Mute User
  • Cancel

Ban this user?

  • Ban User
  • Cancel

Un-ban this user?

  • Un-ban User
  • Cancel

Nuke this user?

  • Nuke User
  • Cancel

Un-nuke this user?

  • Un-nuke User
  • Cancel

Flag this comment?

  • Flag Comment
  • Cancel

Un-flag this comment?

  • Un-flag Comment
  • Cancel

Latest

Judge Dismisses RICO Charges Against All 'Cop City' Defendants

Joe Lancaster | 9.9.2025 4:35 PM

Trump's 'Department of War' Rebrand Might Be His Most Honest Move Yet

Jacob R. Swartz | 9.9.2025 4:21 PM

Milei Coalition's Loss in Buenos Aires Calls Argentine Libertarian Movement's Strength Into Question

César Báez | 9.9.2025 4:00 PM

Hyundai Raid Shows Trump Can't Deport His Way To a Manufacturing Boom

Autumn Billings | 9.9.2025 3:00 PM

The GAIN AI Act Looks More Like Protectionism Than National Security

Tosin Akintola | 9.9.2025 2:45 PM

Recommended

  • About
  • Browse Topics
  • Events
  • Staff
  • Jobs
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Media
  • Shop
  • Amazon
Reason Facebook@reason on XReason InstagramReason TikTokReason YoutubeApple PodcastsReason on FlipboardReason RSS

© 2025 Reason Foundation | Accessibility | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Take Reason's short survey for a chance to win $300
Take Reason's short survey for a chance to win $300
Take Reason's short survey for a chance to win $300