The Bird's The Word: Obligatory Post About MIA Flipping Off Global Audience During Super Bowl Half-Time Show
It wasn't a wardrobe malfunction but it's close enough, especially given that there's really nothing else going on in the world or the country right now.
The singer in question, M.I.A., is British-born and of Tamil descent, and the NFL and NBC have apologized and tried to blame each other.
"The obscene gesture in the performance was completely inappropriate, very disappointing and we apologize to our fans," said Brian McCarthy, spokesman for the NFL, which produced Madonna's halftime show. He said that M.I.A. had not done anything similar during rehearsals and the league had no reason to believe she would pull something like that during the actual show.
The risque moment came during the biggest TV event of the year. The screen briefly went blurred after M.I.A.'s gesture in what was a late attempt — by less than a second — to cut out the camera shot.
"The NFL hired the talent and produced the halftime show," NBC spokesman Christopher McCloskey said. "Our system was late to obscure the inappropriate gesture and we apologize to our viewers."
Isn't it about time we cut ties with England anyway?
It was an excellent Super Bowl game and the only thing that worries me about all this is that the Supreme Court will be ruling on the FCC's ability to police the broadcast airwaves this session. Given that part of the current cycle of fear of fleeting expletives and nipple slips stems from Janet Jackson's and Justin Timberlake's half-time show from what frankly seems like a thousand years ago, this probably ain't good for that.
Rather than building on already onerous content regulations and ultimately arbitrary speech restrictions ("fleeting expletives" have no place in a world filled ExtenZe ads featuring Jimmy Johnson, right?), can we just agree that next year, the Super Bowl will carry a warning sticker noting that despite high-level of play, some viewers may be disturbed by on-field activities? That should solve it.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Grow. The. Fuck. Up.
Grow. The. Fuck. Up.
Starting with you? Lame. So lame.
Lamekettle, meet lamepot.
Stop stealing my material!
Hey, random dumbshit... wylie made a damned good point.
Seriously. Somebody really gives a shit about this?
I didn't even notice when I saw it.
Who decided to protect the sensibilities of viewers by placing a blue cover over the jester?
looking for the bilover?---datebi*cO'm--- is a site for bisexual and bicurious singles and friends.Here you can find hundreds of thousands of open-minded singles & couples looking to explore their bisexuality.sign up for free.
"
Isn't it about time we cut ties with England anyway?
Yeah I dunno. At least they kept their own currency. If we break up with them, Canada will stop talking to us. Then we'll be hanging out with Japan all the time.
Ah, don't you mean that the Rothschilds didn't give up their own currency?
You have somebody on the halftime show that's all but openly sympathized with terrorism in her lyrics, and you're surprised she flipped the bird on national T.V.?
You have an artist like M.I.A. that's openly courted controversy to make herself famous, and you give her an audience of 100 million people or so--and there is no downside for her personally for doing something controversial but tons of upside...and somebody's somewhere's surprised she took advantage of that opportunity?
I'm not one to approve of a fine for indecency for anybody, but on the other hand...
I think marijuana should be legalized too, but in the meantime, if you antagonize some cop by blowing a bong hit in his face, and he busts you for possession? Just because I feel for you doesn't mean I can always reach you.
NBC should have known better. The FCC shouldn't fine anybody for what they broadcast--but NBC should have known better. You stick your head in a lion's mouth, don't be surprised if you get bit.
+infinity
This is essentially my reaction. They wanted to have something that appealed to a younger demographic while totally ignoring the fact that unestablished performers can and will take risks to extend their fame when given the opportunity. Something like this was more probable than not.
It's not an issue worthy of much discussion, but it was a dumb move by the network and the NFL. Next time, stay safe. Too big of an audience to take gambles, and everyone's watching for the game, anyway.
Up With People next year?
Why not?
Or Sir Elton John?
The cast of Phantom of the Opera.
How 'bout the Beach Boys?
Or go with a real area act--bring back Foghat!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCr2APDza_I
Or better yet? Use the time to promote your own network. If it were on ABC, Disney might use the whole halftime show to promote Disney.
If I were a Fox executive, and the Superbowl were on Fox, maybe I'd want to use the cast of Glee to promote Glee--and other shows on Fox.
I mean, what's NBC get out of promoting Madonna, anyway? Did Madonna pay them to do the show? I don't think so.
And Madonna isn't on any of their affiliated labels--I don't think. She's on Sire, which is Warner Brothers!
They want artists that they think will bring in a demographic to watch the game that might not watch it otherwise, and maybe the bump they get out of that is worth the FCC fines? ...to get Generation Veal chicks to watch football, maybe it's worth it to them.
But then I feel even less sorry for them than before. In fact, I start feeling like an idiot for standing up for their freedom of speech if they're calculating the fine into their cost/benefit analysis...
Now let's see, we're getting $3 million for every 30 second ad, and then we get hit with a $5 million fine--but we're selling more ads appealing to females under 30, so it's worth it!
...and the civil libertarians will come to our defense and champion our brand--it's a win/win!
How about a magic act? A live performance of a hit TV show? Strippers?
Say, maybe HBO should get the Super Bowl.
*cue the congressional hearings about the public's "right" to receive the superbowl from broadcast networks*
If they want to appeal to trendy chicks, they should promote their own products that target trendy chicks.
I wish Justin Berber would go the way of Leif Garret, but don't you get as much of a pop out of somebody like that--without all the risk?
The Cirque du Soleil didn't have any traveling shows available? You throw Justin Berber doing whatever the fuck it is he does in the middle of a Cirque du Soleil act--and you've got zero FCC risk.
Or maybe you trot out that hillbilly chick, whatzhername...Taylor Swift!
You throw Justin Berber doing whatever the fuck it is he does in the middle of a Cirque du Soleil act--and you've got zero FCC risk.
but is it worth the gaping wound in the space-time continuum that would result?
See, if it were up to me? The half-time show would be Robbie Knievel jumping KISS while they were performing "Rock and Roll All Night". With the Swedish Bikini Team worked in there somehow.
And then Clint Eastwood would come out and make that speech from the Chrysler commercial.
http://www.youtube.com/chrysler
But I'm not a 20-something or under chick, so... They've already got me watching. What do they care about what I want to see.
I think the NFL, not the network plans the halftime show.
To me, the fact that someone might expose themselves or do something like this is really the only reason I would actually watch the thing (if I didn't have something better and more interesting to do like watch paint dry), so I say good job.
You did read where it is the NFL that books the talent, not the network, right?
Then the NFL should rethink that strategy.
They're batting somewhere around a buck 50.
Pretty much. That middle finger is part of what M.I.A. and her whole industry sells. They all knew that when they hopped into bed together just hoping that nobody stuck any fingers in the wrong place.
But now that the eminently predictable has occurred, let's act all surprised as though we thought they were gonna act like Lawrence Welk.
We originally scheduled Pat Boone thinking he would be a safe choice, but he showed up at the office in a pair of leather assless chaps and leather cap with a Cruisn'4Luv emblem on the front.
Then we tried Barney, and they refused to change his best pal's name to Beej. Seriously, 2012, Barney. Nobody hears those two letters together doesn't think it!
So we said, screw it. Christian entertainment is no longer wholesome. Maybe an Islamicist terrorist would keep it clean cut.
It was a good move; she's getting great publicity out of it. Before the outcry, I promise you, most people watching that show thought that she was just another one of Madonna's back-up girls.
Indeed. Smart move on her part. Unless of course she signed something saying she wouldn't do anything like that.
She'd only be on the hook for her appearance fee and maybe the fine, if there is one. That's probably worth the lift in publicity, though I'd like to add that people who are impressed by that sort of lameness are, well, lame.
It appears there was something in writing.
Also, see Bee Tagger's comment below.
"Comment below.." you say?! Are you from the future?
If you watch the video, most people didn't see the "obscene" gesture because she pulled her skirt to one side and flashed her panties right before it.
Her latest performance was as delectable as dipping my bottom over and over into a bath of the silkiest oils and creams.
Damn it! I blinked again!
This time I'll see it.
lol! I think the more obscene was she flashed her crotch, the bird was merely an FU for looking.
her mike shoulda been cut for the rest of the show. same for fools who are too effed-up to remember the national anthem.
Hooray for lip sync, which is what they were doing. Her mic already was cut. Tool.
microdifference. then the soundtrack shoulda been cut. jeesch.
For the entire show? How can you... I don't even...
Yeah, that would work.
"She's making obscene gestures! Quick! Cut her mic!"
I saw it at the time but have a hard time seeing it in that video.
Bah. End the half-time show and play more commercials.
We'll comment on anything!
First of all, M.I.A. is a no-talent piece of garbage. Second, the NFL is to blame for this - they hired the performers, knowing full well that every popular figure on that stage is known for raunchy lyrics and for courting controversy. They should have known better. Finally, to echo wylie above but to aim at a different target, my fellow libertarians (some of them) need to grow the fuck up. Should she have been free to do what she did? Sure. But if we want to convince people with prohibitory inclinations to come over to our side, so to speak, we need to condemn people when they abuse their liberty to act like fools. Otherwise, ordinary Americans with children who want to watch the Super Bowl - a sporting event that should be family friendly - will shut us out and flock to the FCC generalissimos for support.
abuse their liberty to act like fools
funny, I thought liberty meant the freedom to be foolish if one so chooses.
It does . . . no doubt. That does not mean that foolishness is then placed beyond condemnation.
Absolutely. You are free to be a fool, and free to take the consequences of being a fool.
I wasn't trying to place such behavior beyond condemnation, I just didn't like the concept of "abusing liberty" applied to that context.
(disclaimer: personally, I see nothing really worth condemning.)
I just don't fucking care. As far as I'm concerned, anything some entertainer does on TV is not something even worth having an opinion on.
Hey, I like M.I.A.
As a Patriots fan, the nip-slip game (SB XXXVIII), indeed, seems like a lifetime away.
But flipping the bird? I never realized how edgy and original this M.I.A. was. I'll be sure to listen to what I'm sure is her impressive oeuvre over and over. In fact, I may purchase one of those fancy Apple "i" devices for easy downloading so I won't have to wait more than a second to bask in her genius.
M.I.A.'s gesture was the physical manifestation of her frustration and anger at being payed an exorbitant amount of cash to lip-sync to crappy music while wearing a ridiculous costume that pays homage to a 53-year-old pop tart. I feel her pain.
They all love the publicity. If they really wanted to put a stop to it they would just put something in the contract that says if you curse or flash or flip the bird, you don't get paid.
Ding! We have a winner!
Contracts are amazing things. Want to perform in front of millions of people on our dime? Play by our rules, or no money for you. Don't like our restrictions on your artistic freedom? Don't sign the contract.
This is where the NFL and NBC went wrong. A simple contract clause prohibiting offensive behavior at the cost of forfeiting your pay, and all of these "edgy" "radical" "committed" "activist" "artists" would have towed the lion like so many little teacher's pets.
There's probably a morals clause in the agreement. But the gain in publicity is probably worth the loss of the appearance fee, which her label would likely cover, as I'd be surprised if they didn't propose a stunt in the first place.
It wouldn't do any good. The pay is not that much. It is about the publicity. Before this, no one had hear of MIA in America. Now God knows how many people are looking her up on youtube and Itunes to see what the big deal is.
For a less established artist, no amount of pay is worth forgoing the publicity you get from doing something stupid.
The only way to avoid this is to have old established artists who don't need the publicity. Anytime you put an upcoming artist on there, it will be in their best interest to do something offensive.
I mean, she actually was pretty widely known/established for the past few years, but she's not really a mainstream radio artist like Madonna and Nicki Minaj. She was the toast of the indie world and critics for a while, known for her attention-seeking antics and intriguing/revolutionary backstory. Then I think everyone realized how wildly overrated she was.
Good points, all. I forgot one of my standard pieces of advice for clients: A contract is no substitute for trust. If someone isn't trustworthy, no contract can make them trustworthy.
Didn't know who MIA was since I could give two shits about pop music. I just thought it was an ugly woman from the subcontinent when I saw it during the lame half-time show. Now that I know she is a favorite of the "politically conscious" youth I really could care less.
If you are some sorry ass third rate British Hip Hop artist whose 15 minutes were about to end, flipping the bird at the Super Bowl and getting the FCC to pay attention to you is not a bad way to extend said 15 minutes.
What a tryhard. So annoying. It's really too bad she wasn't K.I.A.
Speaking of tryhard...that was cheesy as all hell.
And completely sincere.
You sincerely wish death on this person who you don't know and who has done no harm to you? Seek help.
If she were just another rich and famous rebel without a clue, I suspect I'd not care about her one way or the other. I imagine I'd feel the way you profess to in your repeated posts about how much you don't give a fuck. (Maybe if you post it again, I'll believe you!) However, given M.I.A.'s vocal support for the Tamil Tigers, I don't feel all that bad about wishing she'd drunkenly fall on a spike or something. Sorry.
Here's a better line for the aspiring insult comic dogs:
In another year, M.I.A. will be W.H.O?
I fail to see how that improves things.
If MIA is a tryhard, what does that make a person who sincerely wishes death upon a sideshow performer at a concert in the middle of a "sporting event", using a really awful pun?
Well, when I was young I heard about the us being the land of the free. Obviously that was only an ad attempt from Madison av. There is not much freedom in Europe but when it comes to female bosoms and speaking bad words we have a more relaxed attitude... you could learn a lot in that department. It also begs the question thin skinned ate Americans? Sorry have you become sissies by now that you cringe before words?
I can understand that some of this comes from the puritarians and all the Christian settlers some 200 years ago, but really even today?! I think there is one other ideology that supports your stand: Islamic theocracy.
But well with all you libertarians at reason, it is probably not something new 😉
It also begs the question thin skinned ate Americans?
No it doesn't. You may not speak well English but logic is logic no matter what your native tongue is. Learn what begging the question means.
There is not much freedom in Europe but when it comes to female bosoms and speaking bad words we have a more relaxed attitude...
So it's like prison, then?
No thanks on your suggestion to be more like you. That is what got us the FCC in the first place. It was the invention of a political class that imported your ideas about controlling the economy, and in this case specifically the communications industry, from such fine outstanding Europeans as Benito Mussolini. Unfortunately I do not exaggerate. He was THE model for the New Dealers. We need to be more true to ourselves than to be anything like you. For the record, I know not a single person with an ounce of Puritanism in their body or souls. That is a common myth about us, you Europeans have. Everywhere else except that which the government directly controls such as words over the airwaves, America is a gorgeous cesspool.
Goddamn, who knew there were so many curmudgeons on this site.
Honestly. Why does anyone care? Yeah, she's a pop-leftist moron.
I care about the wasted taxdollars the FCC is gonna burn over this "issue". Fair enough?
From the more-reliable-than-Vanneman website TMZ:
M.I.A.: She'll Be Left Holding the Bag If NBC Gets Fined
Probably, still worth it for her. She'll more than make up for the lost hipster fans (for appearing at the Super Bowl, in the first place), lost prudish fans and potential FCC Fine.
I happen to like a good number of her songs, but it's always seemed like the producers she works with are at least 50% of the song equation.
Don't forget, her boyfriend/baby-daddy is a trust fund, billionaire wannabe radical musician himself. I'm sure whatever she has to pay, he'll cover.
I doubt anyone with even the slightest inkling of prudishness was a fan of hers before this incident.
If you're going to do it, you should do it with feeling.
Brilliant. The photo was taken during his performance at San Quinten prison, but iirc, Cash paid to have this photo published in Rolling Stone, with a screed explaining to whom the bird was directed.
http://www.savingcountrymusic......dle-finger
How about this: no halftime show? Why are we subjected year after year to acts that are last year's model? Who's next, Frankie Valli? How about "Jersey Boys"? Watching this crap is like watching a Broadway show anyhow.
Watching this crap is like watching a Broadway show anyhow.
I think that is the point. The NFL wants to attract women and gay men to the audience once a year.
The tight pants aren't doing it for them?
This is why you're supposed to watch the Puppy Bowl at halftime, you idiots.
I'm pretty sure Warty is a closet furry. Then again, maybe he's not in the closet...
I am very furry, yes.
How about people just get over it? It's not like she molested your kids. If kids already know what the gesture means, they're probably already doing it. If they don't, they probably won't even know to ask. What a nation of prudes.
Moreover, if NBC doesn't want to get fined, why can't they do a three second lag where they can switch cameras before such scenes get broadcast - at least for the performance part of the show if not the football game. I don't think audiences will cry a river about being three seconds behind the live action.
It was an excellent Super Bowl game
No it wasn't. It was a close game. It was an exciting game. It was a memorable game. But the actual quality of football played on Sunday was mediocre at best. The Giants turned in a B- performance and that was enough to beat the Patriots' C+ effort.
+100
I actually came out of that worrying about the state of the NFL. A team with no defense can get through an entire conference, and a team that's more balanced but just a little better than average won the whole shebang.
Close games are not necessarily good ones. This was not an impressive game. Even the uninterrupted completions spoke more to the poor secondary performances than "epic" QBs.
The state of the NFL is only about the state of gambling. The worse the economy is, the better the NFL does. The quality of the on-field product has never mattered.
Such bullshit. The NFL obviously loves the controversy. They figure they can't get away with it every year, but every 4 brings them lots of attention.
Get back to me when public funding for NFL stadiums/stadia ends because of the "controversies".
Na na na na na na na na na
Na na na na na na na na na
Boys there...
How many?
Thinking about this more, the outrage is patently absurd. You have a band called LMFAO singing their hit "I'm Sexy And I Know It"; Cee Lo Green, whose big smash is called "F*** You"; the M.I.A. rap already had a bleeped-out curse word, and the show was starring by one of the most risque pop icons of all time. Sorry if it's not entertainment meant for your average 6-year old, but maybe parents should have exercised better judgement if they're going to be total prudes?
Yeah, and even before the bird-flipping the halftime show's theme seemed to be "A Salute to Upskirts"
The finger. How shocking. Such untamed rebellion.
Shame GG Allin never did a Super Bowl...