BIO Convention – I Speculate on the Single Diagnostic Test You'll Ever Need – Whole Genome Sequencing.
Diseases used to be caused by evil spirits, and later illness was blamed on unbalanced humors. A considerable advance was made when the germ theory of disease was widely accepted in the late 19th century. As modern sanitation, vaccination, and antimicrobials drove back the infectious diseases and life expectancies lengthened, other illnesses, such as cardiovascular disease and cancer, became more salient. At the BIO Convention, Cecilia Schott, the business development director for Astra Zeneca, noted that modern molecular medicine has redefined cancer. Not so long ago, cancers were classified based on organs affected and location in the body, but now they are defined by pathways and molecular targets. Consequently, molecular diagnostics are becoming central to figuring out the best ways to treat cancers and other diseases.
For example, Mitch Raponi, the director molecular diagnostics at the biotech startup Clovis Oncology explained how his company is using companion diagnostics to guide them in treating a specific version of pancreatic cancer. Currently, the standard of care is a chemotherapy drug called Gemcitabine. The drug enters a cancer cell through a specific surface receptor hENT1. However, it turns out that hENT1 expression is low in 40 to 50 percent of pancreatic tumors which means that the drug is not very effective. Clovis is using a modified version of Gemcitabine by adding a lipid molecule enabling it to enter pancreatic cells with low hENT1 expression. The company is in the midst of Phase IIb clinical trials. If its technology proves out, when the company's diagnostic test reveals that a specific patient has low hENT1 expression, then physicians will treat pancreatic cancer them with Clovis' version of Gemcitabine.
Joseph Monforte, the chief scientific officer for AltheaDx, stated flatly, "All parties now agree that companion diagnostics are required for oncology." Another example of how diagnostics are changing the way that cancer is treated was offered by Wayne Klohs, vice president and global therapeutic area leader at Astellas Pharma. As others noted at the convention, Klohs too pointed out that about half of patients fail to respond to medicines in the manner intended. Astellas is working on a treatment for a type of acute myeloid leukemia (AML) in which patients express the FLT3 mutation. The 30 percent of AML patients who have this mutation do not respond well to current chemotherapy treatments. Astellas' diagnostic is critical for identifying FLT3 patients.
I suspect that coupling specific diagnostic tests with specific drugs is just a passing phase. Why? I dropped by the Knome booth on the convention floor to talk a bit about their whole genome interpretation service. For just under $5,000 the company has a person's whole genome sequenced and then interprets its therapeutic and other aspects using the latest science. The company sends along a hard drive to each person containing all the information about the person's genome along with the company's annotations of what is scientifically known about it and software to navigate the data. The company offers periodic updates to customers. As I see it, some day in the not-too-distant future, each of us will carry a memory stick with all our genomic information (or better yet store it somewhere online where we can get to it whenever we want). At which point specific diagnostic tests will no longer be needed since companies Knome will provide us with any information that we or our physicians need to know about how various medicines are likely to affect our specific maladies.
Corrective update: H&R commenter sure points out that FLT3 is a somatic mutation which would not be detected by prior full genome sequencing. This means that specific diagnostic tests would still need to be coupled to specific therapies.
Up Next: Biotech crops and biosecurity.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
What do you mean, "used to"???
All my ills are caused by Black Bile, which is easily countered by a good Bleeding.
Uh, that is, after a few more BILLION are wasted on getting approval from the FDA...
I promise you Knome is not actually sequencing a person's whole genome for $5000. As of this date only 20 people have had their whole genomes sequenced, and it is NOT a trivial affair. One of the biggest problems is you need a class-X cleanroom because the sample handlers can very very easily contaminate the samples with their own genomes.
(which is a problem when you are shotgun sequencing, or, especially when you are using technology such as 454 or illumina)
Has Reason ever done a science article that wasn't full of non-sense?
The FLT3 and hENT1 mutations are somatic, AKA limited to the specific cancer line. Getting your genome sequence is of minimal use for cancer.
sure: Excellent point about FLT3. Thanks. Obviously don't agree with the implied answer to your question.
Squirting around your own DNA oughtta be a fireable offense, aside from being disgusting.
Not true.
With new platforms such as Illumina's Hi-Seq, coverage and read length is much larger and with good bioinformatics software to sort out the reads you can get incredible accuracy. Plus, contamination is not nearly so problematic as you make it out to be.
I laugh at Illumina. here is illumina's viedo:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=77r5p8IBwJk
With such a complex scheme with many points of failure what could possibly go wrong! It's all good, they got 3d animation from the douchebag at harvard
You go ahead an use youtube videos to judge a sequencing platform and I'll use read length, throughput, and senstivity.
you are probably a PacBio troll on here to push your new million dollar craptastic sequencing paperweight
also, that picture of DNA is infuriating for many, many reasons.
Are you referring to the fact that its all the colors of the rainbow - or that it is a left-handed helix?
But how long until the genomic databases are hacked and people start making targeted virii that will, for instance, only target specific people? Or groups of people, ? la Sewer, Gas & Electric? Clearly it's not going to be science fiction much longer.
in order to do that they have to solve the protein folding problem, so no worries.
Two words: quantum computing.
Or "Send it to the cloud."
I think we're operating on different definitions of "clearly".
This is a nice dream, but the FDA will never let it happen because it will never figure out how to fit genomic data into its double blind testing protocol.
My wife is a physician and recently went to a lecture on genomics and the practice of medicine. While the general tone was "human genomics for clinical use is on the horizon, but not real soon", there are a few niches that are closer. One is a genomic blood test that can identify the exact organism(s) causing infections. Expected to take a couple of hours as opposed to the days needed to do a culture, it would allow precise targeting of antibiotics as opposed to the current practice of giving a bunch at once to cover most types of bacteria.
20 whole human genomes in the world is so 2009... Knome's recently updated downstream sequence analysis pipeline has the capacity to analyze at least 200 whole genomes per month. Not including the capacity of core sequencing centers or BGI, Complete Genomics alone will sequence at least 4,000 whole human genomes this year and Illumina's competing service will probably sequence a similar amount or more....