The Insanity of Bureaucracy
Being a health care bureaucrat is a tough gig. It's not just long hours, or the dicey politics. It's, well, the bureaucracy—which can be very, very complicated, as staffers at the new office of insurance oversight within Obama's Health and Human Services Department are learning:
[HHS insurance office staffer Steve] Larsen also told the AHIP conference that HHS is trying to work around the "awkward" statutory language on rate review as it develops its reg. The way the law's written, it appears as though rates have to be deemed "unreasonable" before they're reviewed, potentially putting state officials in the tough position of reviewing rates to determine whether they're unreasonable before they're reviewed.
So in order to investigate whether a rate hike is unreasonable, it must first be deemed unreasonable? Gee, I wonder what the outcome of those investigations will be? Anyway, Larsen is right: That's awkward! You might even say it's unreasonable. Also, the first rule of tautology club is the first rule of tautology club.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
reasonably, I think Reason should donate to me, the reason being I believe in Reason, and therefore my reason and reasonableness should reasonably be rewarded.
I don't see how any reasonable person could reason otherwise.
Same with insurance rates - we don't need that unreasonable supply and demand - we need reason...
Wait, how many drinks am I supposed to take now?
an unreasonable amount
Okay, I can handle that.
This is just the beginning of the kafkaesque nightmare of Obamacare.
And if you want to get out of combat duty, you're too sane to qualify for a mental discharge.
Jump, Doc, jump!
Hermes Conrad: [a letter comes in on the mail tube] Great gorilla of Manilla! A letter from the Central Bureaucracy.
[Reads letter]
Hermes Conrad: "Attention, Hermes Conrad. You are about to receive a letter from the Central Bureaucracy."
[Another letter comes in]
Hermes Conrad: [Shocked] Oh, my God! It's from the Central Bureaucracy!
God damn it. In the three minutes it took me to get the lyrics and link, you post. Fuck you.
If there were no dissenters, we wouldn't have all these people disagreeing.
Colonel Cathcart is alive and well, and apparently writing legislation.
We could save money by firing everybody who developed this absurd law.
On second thought, under the law no rates could be legally reviewed, thus saving a lot of money. So, bonuses and promotions for everyone who developed it!
The only one who can fire those who developed this byzantine law is the guy who controls the Tides Center and the Apollo Alliance. It was not written by anyone elected or serving in a public capacity.
Don't worry. George Soros has only our best interests at heart.
We didn't choose to be bureaucrats/
No, that's what our mighty Jah made us/
We treat people like swine and make them stand in line/
Even if nobody paid us/
They say the world looks down on the bureaucrats/
They say we're anal, compulsive and weird/
But when push comes to shove you gotta do what you love/
Even if it's not a good idea
German Bender sounds even more evil than the regular Bender.
Is it in German? I just found the link and posted it (I have no speakers on this machine). That's pretty funny.
The song's in English, but Bender's line after the song is in German. Strange.
"That just raises further questions!"
It may have something to do with cigars.
Now that we passed it, we're finding out what's in it and why we shouldn't have passed it.
Can a hike be unreasonable enough to review but not sufficiently unreasonable to be overruled?
And is there more than one appeals process? Shouldn't you be able to challenge being reviewed in the first place as well as the outcome of the review?
Sam Lowry: Better still, send it to Buttle, after all it's his cheque.
Kurtzmann: I've tried that. Look at this/ [shows Sam a file] You see? The population census has got him down as dormanted. The Central Collective Storehouse computer has got him down as deleted...
Sam Lowry: Hang on. [goes to computer terminal and begins typing]
Kurtzman: ...Information Retrieval has got him down as inoperative. And there's another one - Security has got him down as excised. Administration's got him down as completed...
Sam Lowry: He's dead.
Kurtzman: L... [pause] Dead? Well, that's awful!
[Kurtzman sits down and looks at refund cheque]
Kurtzman: [desperately] We'll never get rid of the damn thing now! What are we going to do Sam?
If only we had a state that tried something similar, we could perhaps find out some potential flaws in such a system.
That's probably unreasonable to ask for...
I must admit that is a very elegant prejudicial method.
More funding will fix this.
Poorly written statutes...welcome to the practice of law.