When Bigots Become Reformers
The Progressive Era's shameful record on race.
The Progressive Era and Race: Reform and Reaction, 1900–1917, by David W. Southern, Wheeling, W.V.: Harlan Davidson, 240 pages, $15.95
The Progressive movement swept America from roughly the early 1890s through the early 1920s, producing a broad popular consensus that government should be the primary agent of social change. To that end, legions of idealistic young crusaders, operating at the local, state, and federal levels, seized and wielded sweeping new powers and enacted a mountain of new legislation, including minimum wage and maximum hour laws, antitrust statutes, restrictions on the sale and consumption of alcohol, appropriations for hundreds of miles of roads and highways, assistance to new immigrants and the poor, women's suffrage, and electoral reform, among much else.
Today many on the liberal left would like to revive that movement and its aura of social justice. Journalist Bill Moyers, speaking at a conference sponsored by the left-wing Campaign for America's Future, described Progressivism as "one of the country's great traditions." Progressives, he told the crowd, "exalted and extended the original American Revolution. They spelled out new terms of partnership between the people and their rulers. And they kindled a flame that lit some of the most prosperous decades in modern history."
Yet the Progressive Era was also a time of vicious, state-sponsored racism. In fact, from the standpoint of African-American history, the Progressive Era qualifies as arguably the single worst period since Emancipation. The wholesale disfranchisement of Southern black voters occurred during these years, as did the rise and triumph of Jim Crow. Furthermore, as the Westminster College historian David W. Southern notes in his recent book, The Progressive Era and Race: Reform and Reaction, 1900–1917, the very worst of it—disfranchisement, segregation, race baiting, lynching—"went hand-in-hand with the most advanced forms of southern progressivism." Racism was the norm, not the exception, among the very crusaders romanticized by today's activist left.
At the heart of Southern's flawed but useful study is a deceptively simple question: How did reformers infused with lofty ideals embrace such abominable bigotry? His answer begins with the race-based pseudoscience that dominated educated opinion at the turn of the 20th century. "At college," Southern notes, "budding progressives not only read exposés of capitalistic barons and attacks on laissez-faire economics by muckraking journalists, they also read racist tracts that drew on the latest anthropology, biology, psychology, sociology, eugenics, and medical science."
Popular titles included Charles Carroll's The Negro a Beast (1900) and R.W. Shufeldt's The Negro, a Menace to American Civilization (1907). One bestseller, Madison Grant's The Passing of the Great Race (1916), discussed the concept of "race suicide," the theory that inferior races were out-breeding their betters. President Theodore Roosevelt was one of many Progressives captivated by this notion: He opposed voting rights for African-American men, which were guaranteed by the 15th amendment, on the grounds that the black race was still in its adolescence.
Such thinking, which emphasized "expert" opinion and advocated sweeping governmental power, fit perfectly within the Progressive worldview, which favored a large, active government that engaged in technocratic, paternalistic planning. As for reconciling white supremacy with egalitarian democracy, keep in mind that when a racist Progressive championed "the working man," "the common man," or "the people," he typically prefixed the silent adjective white.
For a good illustration, consider Carter Glass of Virginia. Glass was a Progressive state and U.S. senator and, as chairman of the House Committee on Banking and Currency, one of the major architects of the Federal Reserve Act of 1913. He was also an enthusiastic supporter of his state's massive effort to disfranchise black voters. "Discrimination! Why that is exactly what we propose," he declared to one journalist. "To remove every negro voter who can be gotten rid of, legally, without materially impairing the numerical strength of the white electorate."
Then there was political scientist John R. Commons, an adviser to the Progressive Wisconsin governor and senator Robert M. LaFollette and a member of Theodore Roosevelt's Immigration Commission. Commons, the author of Races and Immigrants in America (1907), criticized immigration on both protectionist grounds (he believed immigrants depressed wages and weakened labor unions) and racist ones (he wrote that the so-called tropical races were "indolent and fickle").
Woodrow Wilson, whose Progressive presidential legacy includes the Federal Reserve System, a federal loan program for farmers, and an eight-hour workday for railroad employees, segregated the federal bureaucracy in Washington, D.C. "I have recently spent several days in Washington," the black leader Booker T. Washington wrote during Wilson's first term, "and I have never seen the colored people so discouraged and bitter as they are at the present time."
Perhaps the most notorious figure of the era was Benjamin "Pitchfork" Tillman, a leading Southern Progressive and inveterate white supremacist. As senator from South Carolina from 1895 to 1918, Tillman stumped for "Free Silver," the economic panacea of the agrarian populist (and future secretary of state) William Jennings Bryan, whom Tillman repeatedly supported for president. "Pitchfork" Tillman favored such Progressive staples as antitrust laws, railroad regulations, and public education, but felt the latter was fit only for whites. "When you educate a negro," he brayed, "you educate a candidate for the penitentiary or spoil a good field hand."
Nor did African Americans always fare better among those radicals situated entirely to the left of the Progressives. Socialist Party leader Eugene V. Debs, though personally sympathetic to blacks, declared during his 1912 campaign for the presidency, "We have nothing special to offer the Negro." Other leading radicals offered even less. Writing in the Socialist Democratic Herald, Victor Berger, the leader of the party's right wing, declared that "there can be no doubt that the negroes and mulattoes constitute a lower race—that the Caucasian and even the Mongolian have the start on them in civilization by many years." The celebrated left-wing novelist Jack London, covering the 1908 heavyweight title bout between black challenger Jack Johnson and white boxing champ Tommy Burns, filled his New York Herald story with lurid ethnic caricatures and incessant race baiting. "Though he was a committed socialist," observed Jack Johnson biographer Geoffrey C. Ward, London's "solidarity with the working class did not extend to black people."
As Southern thoroughly documents, these examples just begin to scratch the surface. Progressivism was infested with the most repugnant strains of racism. But was there something more, something inherent in Progressivism itself that facilitated the era's harsh treatment of blacks? According to Southern, who repeatedly maintains that racism derailed "the great promise" of Progressivism, the answer is no. "The ideas of race and color were powerful, controlling elements in progressive social and political thinking," he argues. "And this fixation on race explains how democratic reform and racism went hand-in-hand."
That is surely correct, but is it the whole story? As the legal scholar Richard Epstein has noted, "the sad but simple truth is that the Jim Crow resegregation of America depended on a conception of constitutional law that gave property rights short shrift, and showed broad deference to state action under the police power." Progressivism itself, in other words, granted the state vast new authority to manage all walks of American life while at the same time weakening traditional checks on government power, including property rights and liberty of contract. Such a mixture was ripe for the racist abuse that occurred.
Take the Supreme Court's notorious decision in Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), a case that has rightly come to symbolize the South's Jim Crow regime. In Plessy, the Court considered a Louisiana statute forbidding railroads from selling first-class tickets to blacks, a clear violation of economic liberty. In its 7–1 ruling, the Court upheld segregation in public accommodations so long as "separate but equal" facilities were provided for each race, setting off an orgy of legislation throughout the old Confederacy. South Carolina, for example, segregated trains two years after Plessy. Streetcars followed in 1905, train depots and restaurants in 1906, textile plants in 1915–16, circuses in 1917, pool halls in 1924, and beaches in 1934.
No doubt many of those businesses would have excluded or mistreated black customers whatever the law. But in a market free from Jim Crow regulations, other businesses would have welcomed blacks, or at least black dollars, forcing racist enterprises to bear the full cost of excluding or mistreating all those potential paying customers. (This was one of the chief reasons the segregationists pushed for those laws in the first place.) The state, in the eloquent words of the historian C. Vann Woodward, granted "free rein and the majesty of the law to mass aggressions that might otherwise have been curbed, blunted, or deflected."
Furthermore, this tangled web of regulations, ordinances, codes, and controls was spun during the heyday of Progressivism, precisely when such official actions were least likely to receive any meaningful scrutiny. Southern, despite his otherwise close attention to the many permutations of race and racism, fails to recognize this major defect in the Progressive worldview.
A similar failure handicaps his treatment of one of the era's rare victories for African Americans. In Buchanan v. Warley (1917), the Supreme Court unanimously overturned a Louisville ordinance segregating residential housing blocks by race. The case involved a voluntary contract between a white seller and a black buyer for a housing lot located in a majority-white neighborhood. Under the law, the new black owner could not live on the property he had just purchased.
Writing for the Court, Justice William Rufus Day held that "this attempt to prevent the alienation of the property in question to a person of color…is in direct violation of the fundamental law enacted in the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution preventing state interference with property rights except by due process of law."
Yet Southern dismisses this rare and important victory as "hollow" and incorrectly asserts that it "was decided not on the grounds of human rights, but on those of white property rights." In fact, the judicial recognition of black rights stood at the very center of the decision. Justice Day's opinion clearly states that the Fourteenth Amendment "operate[s] to qualify and entitle a colored man to acquire property without state legislation discriminating against him solely because of color."
Nor should Southern's characterization of this victory as "hollow" pass unchallenged. As the legal scholars David Bernstein and Ilya Somin have argued, the Buchanan ruling played a major though sadly underappreciated role in the burgeoning fight for civil rights. "Buchanan could not force whites to live in the same neighborhood as blacks," Bernstein and Somin write, "but it did prevent cities from stifling black migration by creating de jure and inflexible boundaries for black neighborhoods, and may have prevented even more damaging legislation." It is well worth noting, they continue, that the South did not adopt South African–style apartheid at this time, despite widespread white support for such measures.
In addition, Buchanan was the first major Supreme Court victory for the four-year-old National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, a huge boon for the organization that would go on to win the landmark Brown v. Board of Education (1954), overturning Plessy. W.E.B Du Bois, an NAACP founder and longtime editor of its newsletter, The Crisis, gave Buchanan credit for "the breaking of the backbone of segregation."
Despite these significant shortcomings, The Progressive Era and Race deserves careful attention. The Progressive movement unleashed, aided, and abetted some of the most destructive forces in 20th-century America. The better we understand this history, the less likely we are to repeat it.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
hnr
small as far from any appeal to worsen while in the haystack. There are a number of assets, but access available, but Women Uggs are outside a little bit less abstruse to access the “skinny” about how to access Shorten Chestnut Cheap women Uggs Classic. ?
small as far from any appeal to worsen while in the haystack. There are a number of assets, but access available, but Women Uggs are outside a little bit less abstruse to access the “skinny” about how to access Shorten Chestnut Cheap women Uggs Classic.
Ugg Boots Outlet boots are used in useful. The environment has been adapted colder and colder than yesterday. According to the forecast, temperatures fell below Celsius anything.Ugg Classic Boots On Sale , How hateful the advice
for the layer suit, hat, glover alike Uggs Australia Outlet . It showcases the achievement of the organs of loading of articles to absorb heat. These accout accretion power can demand. Therefore, the dose of the sale Ugg Boots On Sale boots .
I am impressed by the quality of information on this website. There are a lot of good resources here. I am sure I will visit this place again soon Visit W3Schools.com!
The problem with this article is that it treats the Progressive Movements as united. Many reformers during the Progressive era participated in multiple movements, but this article’s oversimplified view incorrectly assumes all Progressive reformers supported black disenfranchisement, instsead of a Southern majority and a national minority. Southern racist legislation was absolutely not confined to the Progressive era. However, what one Progressive reformer stood for could differ significantly from what another stood for, and the CONSERVATIVE Southern Progressive Movement embodied the entirely Progressive ideal of purifying the voting system with the uniquely Southern and conservative (in the context of the time, obviously) spin of blacks being an impurity on the voting system.
I am, sadly, unimpressed by the quality of this article. Its primary purpose seems to discredit the Progressive movement and liberals in general by equating the two based on a rudimentary understanding of both.
Thank you, my dear on this important topic You can also browse my site and I am honored to do this site for songs
http://www.xn—-ymcj1bbw2eyau3b.com
This website is for travel to Malaysia
http://www.xn—-ymcj1bbw2eyau3b.com
wqeqweqweqwe
thank you
thank u
Excellent
http://www.iraqiae.com
Thank you very much
scoop
http://www.scoop.it/t/alaamiah
Company Global Services home
[The Progressive movement swept America from roughly the early 1890s through the early 1920s, producing a broad popular consensus that government should be the primary agent of social change]
This is a gross mischaracterization of the historical progressive movement, but perhaps that is an intentional thing – because the article’s premise depends on it.
Here is a much better definition:
One main goal of the Progressive movement was purification of government, as Progressives tried to eliminate corruption by exposing and undercutting political machines and bosses. Many (but not all) Progressives supported prohibition in order to destroy the political power of local bosses based in saloons.[2] At the same time, women’s suffrage was promoted to bring a “purer” female vote into the arena.[3] A second theme was building an Efficiency movement in every sector that could identify old ways that needed modernizing, and bring to bare scientific, medical and engineering solutions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_Era
http://gamesonfly.blogspot.com…..games.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspot.com/
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..games.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..flash.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..Crash.html
http://downloadgamesair.blogspot.com/
http://downloadgamesair.blogsp…..games.html
http://games-arab4.blogspot.com/
http://games-arab4.blogspot.co…..games.html
http://games-arab4.blogspot.com/
http://games-arab4.blogspot.co…..games.html
http://downloadgamesair.blogspot.com/
http://downloadgamesair.blogsp…..games.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspot.com/
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..games.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..flash.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..Crash.html
http://gamesonfly.blogspot.com…..games.html
http://gamesonfly.blogspot.com…..games.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…../zoma.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspot.com/
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..games.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..flash.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..Crash.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..s-gat.html
http://gamesfree4flash.blogspo…..rrior.html
http://downloadgamesair.blogspot.com/
http://downloadgamesair.blogsp…..games.html
http://games-arab4.blogspot.com/
http://games-arab4.blogspot.co…..games.html
http://gamessfreee.blogspot.com/
http://gamessfreee.blogspot.co…..Games.html
1
Hello! I just want to offer you a huge thumbs up for the excellent info you have right here on this post. I’ll be returning to your blog for more soon.
Cheers,
http://www.prokr.com/cleaning-company-riyadh/
http://www.prokr.com/water-lea…..ny-riyadh/
A similar failure handicaps his treatment of one of the era’s rare victories for African Americans. In Buchanan v. Warley (1917), the Supreme Court unanimously overturned a Louisville ordinance segregating residential housing blocks by race. The case involved a voluntary contract between a white seller and a black buyer for a housing lot located in a majority-white neighborhood. Under the law, the new black owner could not live on the property he had just purchased.
???? ??? ???? ???????
???? ????? ???? ???????
The best thing they assistance to new immigrants and the poor, women’s suffrage, and electoral reform, among much else.
http://el-dman.com/
http://el-dman.com/?p=2250
thank you
http://el-dman.com/
http://el-dman.com/?p=2271
thank you
http://el-dman.com/
http://www.sadawan.com/showthread.php?p=291920
http://www.mexat.com/vb/showth…..p=35652212
The best thing they assistance to new immigrants and the poor, women’s suffrage, and electoral reform, among much else.
http://www.riyadh-companies.co…..mpany.html
Hello there, You’ve done an excellent job. I will certainly digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I am sure they will be benefited from this website.
Anti Bugs In Riyadh Cleaning Couch In Riyadh
I need to to thank you for this fantastic read!
! I certainly enjoyed every bit of it. I have got you saved as a
favorite to look at new things you post?
Palace Cleaning
Killing insects
This is a topic which is close to my heart.
Moving Furnture
Furniture storing
Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog
and wished to say that I’ve truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!
Apartment Cleaning
Water Leak
I visit daily some websites and sites to read articles, except this weblog offers quality
based writing.
Cleaning company
Anti Rat
http://www.companyinriyadh.com…..mpany.html
http://www.companyinriyadh.com…..iyadh.html
http://www.companyinriyadh.com…..mpany.html
http://www.companyinriyadh.com…..store.html
http://www.companyinriyadh.com…..iyadh.html
http://www.companyinriyadh.com…..iyadh.html
http://www.companyinriyadh.com…..iyadh.html
The clarity for your post is just spectacular and i could suppose you are knowledgeable on this subject.
detect water leaks
detect water leaks in Riyadh
The clarity for your post is just spectacular and i could suppose you are knowledgeable on this subject.
detect water leaks
company
detect water leaks in Riyadh
Welcome to the perfect company with development and modern technology
Perfect company Ultimate company and a leader in the field of hygiene and public detecting leaks and insect control are always trying to please their customers and their trust in them, we have the expertise and the possibility and working techniques and highly skilled and precise work
???? ??? ?????? ?????? ???????
Noor Dammam with the company say goodbye to dust and mud that are in floors and walls
? Using the finest detergents Our company is working day and night on the basis of organization is present in high
???? ??? ??????
In ALMANARH offer transfer Furniture Company in Khamis Mushayt service using the best machinery and equipment also have the best fleet of vehicles large and modern, which can travel within Saudi Arabia The fully as we have the best workers trained in
???? ???????
Our Middle East Company cleaning door and Khamis Mushayt and neighboring cities Haya company like all companies Let Alolh in scope and effective in turn, the performance of outstanding service to the most beautiful face and the best field so offer Amila best of our experience and important Middle Company
???? ????? ????? ????
thanks for this article
http://emc-mee.com/movers-in-riyadh-company.html
http://emc-mee.com/transfer-furniture-jeddah.html
A similar failure handicaps his treatment of one of the era’s rare victories for African Americans. In Buchanan v. Warley (1917), the Supreme Court unanimously overturned a Louisville ordinance segregating residential housing blocks by race.
????? ?????
The case involved a voluntary contract between a white seller and a black buyer for a housing lot located in a majority-white neighborhood. Under the law, the new
????? ???????
black owner could not live on the property he had just purchased.
beautiful
http://barbie-girls-games.blogspot.com
https://www.weebly.com/weebly/main.php
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..mages.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..ogram.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..droid.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..mages.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..ogram.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..droid.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..stems.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..tools.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..-apps.html
http://pramgweb1.blogspot.com/…..grams.html