Drinking vs. Quaintness
Rockport, Massachusetts, a dry town for the last century and a half (except for a brief period right after the repeal of Prohibition), may go partly wet. At a town meeting on Monday, an overwhelming majority of the 1,000 or so attendees endorsed a petition asking the state legislature to approve a ballot measure that, if passed by local voters in April, would allow alcohol to be served in restaurants. Bars and liquor stores still would be banned.
A.P. reports that critics of the plan "say the sale of alcohol will erode the quaint New England character that gives Rockport its appeal." This is an odd complaint, since old-time New Englanders were big drinkers.
The Puritans--who, like most Englishmen, were leery of water as a beverage--brought beer with them on the Mayflower and started brewing their own within a few years; they also drank hard cider, wine, brandy, and rum. In colonial New England, settlers of all ages and both sexes drank alcoholic beverages throughout the day, and taverns ("ordinaries") were commonplace. The popularity of drinking during this period is reflected in the estimate (cited in Mark Edward Lender and James Kirby Martin's Drinking in America) that Americans in the late 18th century consumed something like six gallons of absolute alcohol per capita, compared to around two gallons nowadays.
There's little danger that allowing pre-dinner cocktails or wine and beer with meals will make Rockport that quaint.
[Thanks to Jeff Schaler for the tip]
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Jacob Sullum,
They don't call it the "gin age" for nothing. 🙂
Drunk for a Penny
Dead drunk for two pence
Clean straw for Nothing.
-- Slogan over the gin cellar in William Hogarth's painting Gin Lane
Painting is at the bottom of the following page; you gotta zoom into see the slogan:
http://www.wga.hu/frames-e.html?/html/h/hogarth/
Jacob Sullum,
Compare the painting to Hogarth's Beer Lane (they were meant to be contrasted with one another):
http://www.haleysteele.com/hogarth/plates/beerst.html
I always knew my love of art history would come in handy some day. 🙂
That wasn't gin, that was moonshine.
You've also got to remember that drinking water, back in the day, was a biochemical adventure. Beer, wine, and spirits were absolutely healthier for you, in that they didn't have all the extra bacterial goodies that water from the river would have: the alcoholic content in the booze killed off most of the harmful bacteria.
Prohibition left some weird artifacts in the public memories of what things were like before "town water" was filtered, chlorinated, and pumped to the home.
Back in the '70s National Lampoon ran some Hogarth parodies on pot and cocaine.
Being a bit of a beer maker myself I know that according to my research on the topic there are no known human pathogens that can survive in an alchoholic beverage such as beer. Oh, bacteria can make it smell and taste like ass, but it won't kill you.
I live in MA, rather close to Rockport. It is a lovely little place but hardly the "quaint" New England town of its seafaring history. It is a bustling little tourist trap (google "motif #1" for images) that has a number of lovely BYOB restaurants that charge a "setup" fee for the glass in which you will pour your personally supplied alcoholic beverage.
Allowing these establishments to stock and sell liquor is a problem how?
At one time, the majority of people in the town voted to ban liquor sales within town limits. I've no problem with that. It's their choice. Now, a majority of people within the town want to change that law. I've no problem with that, either. Again, it's their choice. What's the issue here?
I wish there were more BYOB restaurants. I used to eat at a place in Dallas called MoMo's where diners supplied the booze. Wine is much more enjoyable without the 100% mark up.
Rockport, MA - More Puritanical the Puritans since 1856.
The best Italian restaurant in my old town was owned by a Muslim. He wouldn't sell alchol, but the food was amazing, so there'd be a line out the door, and everyone would have a bottle of wine.
The packie across the street must have been a gold mine.
"You've also got to remember that drinking water, back in the day, was a biochemical adventure. Beer, wine, and spirits were absolutely healthier for you,"
Simply boiling water would take care of that, much less effort than brewing/distilling. Perhaps they didn't know or perhaps they liked to get boozed up.
Simply boiling water would take care of that, much less effort than brewing/distilling. Perhaps they didn't know or perhaps they liked to get boozed up.
Or maybe it was easier to let the town brewer/distiller do all the work and just buy it from him. Boiling water every time you want some, or doing it once a day for all your daily consumption, would be quite a pain in the ass. Alcoholic beverages, on the other hand, could be brewed/distilled and kept nearly indefinitely. Not that the intoxicating effects of alcohol can really be ignored ? try working in the fields for twelve to sixteen hours and then drinking frickin' water when you get back in . . .
Boiling water is a great idea, but fuel isn't cheap, and once the water cools it can easily become contaminated again. The popularity of coffee and tea can also be attributed, not just to the caffeine buzz and acquired taste for these infusions, but as an alternative to drinking an alcoholic beverage.
When Milwaukee had its Cryptosporidium outbreak in the `90's, we had to boil all our drinking and cooking water. That is a pluperfect pain. If you weren't planning on having a hot drink, buying bottled water, soft drinks or beer was much less time-consuming. Ice tea, made from hot brewed tea was a favorite at my house.
Kevin
Anybody read David Liss' novel, The Coffee Trade?
Kevin
Boiling water is a real pain, no doubt about it - when I lived overseas we had to do it all the time, since even water filters wouldn't catch everything (not that boiling would get rid of heavy metals, of course.) Another alternative is iodine (when camping, say), though of course it takes a while to get used to the taste.
Something else to consider - before germ theory, how would people even know what was wrong with their water, and thus how to fix it?
They didn't know what was wrong, they just noticed that if you drank too much water you dropped dead.
peachy,
While their theories for disease were incorrect, they did understand that bad smelling water, etc., was bad for them.
If you believe Homer, the Greek world drank insane amounts of wine.
Don't forget the other reason for drinking fermemted beverages, especially beer: it was the world's first preserved carbohydrate format. Bread went stale after a day and wheat and barley could go moldy, but beer can last a long, long time. A stout beer could be a meal in the ancient world, and an old bartender I knew pointed out that you could live on a diet centered around beer as the starch.
So, that killed two birds with one stone: drinkable beverage and carb source. Plus it helped tavern-dwellers get laid in the days before customary bathing.
It always amuses me how medieval monks got around the lenten fasting rules in days of old. Drinking didn't break one's fast, so Belgian Triple Bock for the whole abbey!
The CAMRA/Homebrewer slogan is true. Beer is Food.
Kevin
Gallery wallpaper solange knowles ass. Strip tease gallery eliza dushku fake. Beautiful bikini dENiSe RIcHards nippLe. Undressed hot kELLy Hu NipPLes. Wallpapers boobs SummeR SAnDErS. Nude sex KIrStEN DUNSt faKeS. Fake desnuda lUcY Liu undreSSes. Sexy naked SOPHIA LOREN FAKES. Playboy dirty pATRIciA hEAToN dIrTY. Photo videos AliCia key. Sex wallpaper TARA REID PICS. Naked porn alyssa milano fakes. Dirty pictures hAlLE BErRY PIC. Striptease wallpaper STEPHANIE MCMAHON HOT. Pictures sex michelle branch home video. Tits pussy SARAh MIchelLe GElLar tit. Pic sex leah remini. Porn tape LIV TYLER DIRTY. Sex photos ROse mCgowAN ToPlESs. Hardcore tape eva mendes wallpaper. Photos striptease GABRIELLE UNION. Clips blowjob SUZANNE SOMERS VIDEOS. Blowjob pic christina aguilera nipples. Porn naked NICOLE KIDMAN WALLPAPERS. Having sex tape GWEN StEFaNi. Galleries uncensored MICHELLE VIETH CLIPS. Movies clips DiANE LANe PosteRs. Tit naked MiKo lEe hoMe VIDEOS. Dirty blowjob KATHY IRELAND VIDEO. Clip sexy VERONIKA ZEMANOVA BOOBS. Pictures uncensored DREA DE MATTEO PICTURES. Beautiful movies avrIL lavIGne. Fake tape MARtiNA MCbRiDE. Pics playboy sung hi lee nude. Pussy sex lisa dergan photos. Xxx pictures LISA RAYE BLOWJOB. Nipples pussy braNde RoDERiCK. Pic wallpaper KArOLiNa KurkoVA UndRESSEs. Wallpapers uncensored EMMA WATSON NAKED. Fakes fakes SCARLETT JOHANSSON VIDEO. Tape playboy RAQUEL WELCH NAKED. Hot clip CarLy paTteRSoN pICTURe. Home videos naked brooke burke xxx. Pussy porn natASHA hEnStRIdgE PiCTuRes. Posters naked AISHWARYA RAI NAKED. Naked dirty amy lee sex. Video pussy heather graham breast. Desnuda beautiful LEEaNN TWeEDEn BeautifUl. Undressed xxx MONICA BELLUCCI HAVING SEX. Videos tits lAcey chAbeRT. Blowjob home videos KrIstin kREuK. Boobs topless amanda bynes poster. Undressed xxx anna kouRNIKovA BloWjOB. Photos nude mischa barton hot. Home video dirty AlIcIa SilveRstONe. Sex desnuda milla jovovich nude. Photo tit CYNTHIA NIXON TAPE. Wallpapers fakes shu qi pussy. Wallpaper uncensored KARIN TAYLOR PLAYBOY. Home videos hardcore anna nicole smith. Sex bikini jOAniE LAURer galLeRIES. Striptease videos carmen electra. Sex galleries JANET JACKSON PHOTOS. Breast videos SHANIA TWAIN PIC. Fake wallpapers melissa joan hart. Desnuda video faRraH FawCETT nUDE. Sex nude CINDY MARGolIs HAVING seX. Home videos fakes jENNIfER aNISton Ass. Pics boob christina applegate clip. Home videos having sex NICOLE RICHIE BLOWJOB. Naked pics hiLLaRy cliNToN. Video beautiful SAra EVaNS PICtURe. Nude hot UMA THURMAN NAKED. Blowjob sexy GwyNeTH PALtROW. Pussy gallery JENNifER GArnER MOvie. Nipple home videos jODIe FoSTEr BoobS. Stripped pic KARI WUHRER POSTER. Sexy hardcore PAULINA RUBIO WALLPAPERS. Sex fake HILARY DUFF. Undresses desnuda tera patrick.