Culture Trade Wars
Neil Hrab, the current Warren Brookes Fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, sounds the claxon on a brewing movement that could restrict the free trade in cultural products (and advocate for more state subsidization of culture in nations awash in American entertainment) through the International Network on Cultural Policy. The language of their FAQ is a bit squirrelly, but I suspect their plans would in practice add up to what Hrab says:
This alliance wants to pass a global treaty that would declare ?cultural goods and services? to be ?distinct? from ?ordinary goods and services,? with a ?specific nature? that must be ?respected.? That doesn?t sound very threatening, but such a treaty could hurt America?s ability to export its cultural products.
Once INCP?s hypothetical treaty is passed, it would guarantee that trade in cultural products be exempted from global free trade talks. This, in turn, would allow foreign governments to start imposing measures reducing consumer access to American entertainment products. Many American allies throughout Europe, as well as Canada and Mexico, already have such measures on the books. The passage of a global cultural protectionist treaty would make thus it impossible for the U.S. to press for further liberalization in global cultural exports in future trade talks. The treaty would act as a shield for protectionist actions wrapped in stealthy rhetoric about preserving ?cultural diversity.?
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
As far as I can tell, they are a bit too late; American dominance in trade in culture is on the wane due to lots of stiff competition world wide.
does this count region-specific foods as a cultural product?
very crazy.
Is anything more absurd than the idea that you have to protect your culture by preventing your neighbors from watching a movie?
Is anything more absurd than the idea that you have to protect your culture by preventing your neighbors from watching a movie?
sodomy laws still take the cake, frankly. that's protecting yourself from your neighbor's bedroom!
Along these lines, check out this way of protecting your culture from imports. Tyler Cowen over at marginalrevolution.com tells us:
French revenge on Hollywood?
Tyler Cowen
Henri Crohas's company, Archos SA, makes a small hand-held device, like a bulky Palm Pilot, that can record and then play back scores of movies, TV shows and digital photos on its color screen or a TV set. The gadget -- which in effect does to movies what Apple Computer Inc.'s iPod does to music -- already has sold 100,000 units world-wide during the past six months, beating the big consumer electronics makers to the U.S. market.
Archos's device, which costs about $500 to $900 depending on the model, ignores an anticopying code found on a majority of prerecorded DVDs. That means consumers can plug the Archos device into a DVD player and transfer a movie to it. Users also can transfer recorded TV programs and digital music files to the Archos device.
Full story linked on Cowen's page. Heh.
Jason Ligon,
My aunt has one; she loves it. What's interesting is that DVD sales have only now begun to increase in France (and Europe in general) like they have in the US; so I am curious whether this will deal a blow to that.
JB,
Do you know if the picture quality is worth a crap, or is your aunt one of those fortunate souls who lack the geek's eye for picture quality?
Jason Ligon,
I've not seen it myself; but she's not a "geek" no. But it was unusual for her to purchase such an item, and though I didn't ask her what prompted her to buy it, that it was unusual ... well, I think you understand me. I apologize; I am becoming fatigued of thinking in English. 🙂
JB:
I have to say, based on your posts, I am surprised that English fatigues you. Your posts read very naturally, as though they came from an educated native speaker. Not having remotely a fraction of that ability in a foreign language (I can go to the grocery, ride a train, and find a toilet in Japan, and I have passive knowledge of Spanish to some extent), I just assumed that you thought in English most of the time.
I'm not one for spraying sunshine usually, but color me impressed that you write the way you do through a linguistic barrier.
It would be nice to see the French culture industry face some stiff competition...in France. There never a protectionist yet that could cut the mustard.
Jason Ligon,
Well, learning English has been a project since my time of youth; and I have lived a number of years in the U.S. Most of the reason I come here is to better tutor myself. I know this seems strange, but thinking in English is much different from thinking in French; very different mental worlds.
Andrew,
In the 1990s, when TV content was opened up, French television was run over by American media; now the course has reversed because French media firms know French desires better. We may like the X-Files, but we despise most American "sit-coms."
There's already a treaty that restricts free trade in cultural products. It's the IP provisions of the Uruguay Round.
hehe I think most Americans despise American sitcoms as well.
Just tell me when I can call my sparkling wine champagne, will ya
but amelie will *so* get your dick sucked!
I believe this organization will go a long way in protecting Saudi Arabian women from seeing American women *driving* in movies.
This should also protect Iranian men from being forced to view *ankles*, which are destroying their culture.
Unfortunately, it probably won't save me from being forced for watch Amelie' by my girlfriend.
Unfortunately, it will also lead to continued violence on a global level, as people from different nations will continue to be unable to understand each other on a cultural level.