How the Net Serves Journalism
Gravity Lens blogger Jeff Patterson points to this interesting case of how the Web abetted plagiarism and its correction:
Over at retroCRUSH, Robert Berry explains how his story about "The Worst Sex Scenes Ever" was ripped off by the British paper The Daily Star, which attributed the list to a "poll" done by the fictitious mag FILM. That story got picked up by a bunch of other publications and sites.
From Berry's account of an exchange with a Star editor:
On 1/05/04 I spoke with a the News Editor of "The Daily Star" named Kieran Saunders and what he told me takes the cake.
He said, "Well, if it's on the internet it's up for grabs. You can't copyright anything on the internet." I told him that was untrue and he then refused to speak with me further, and said all future communication needed to be sent to their legal contact, Steven Bacon in London. I even tried to call back an hour later to speak with the actual author of the piece, and Saunders answered the phone, stating, "I told you never to call here again, speak to our legal group" before ending the call.
Worth checking out.
Btw, the list at issue here, which I encountered in its fake form, is pretty good. Here's a link to Berry's original.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Flipping a quarter here: Should we discuss the issue of net plagiarism, or our own picks for the worst cinematic sex scenes?
My vote on latter: James Spader buggering Elias Koteas in CRASH, Malcolm MacDowell fisting a friend/Roman/countryman in the uncut CALIGULA, and Vince D'Onofrio suspending himself from hooks while ejaculating on a bleached corpse in THE CELL.
Uh, maybe this says a little too much about my taste in movies...
http://dailystar.insertdisc.com/
Fixed.
I will leave my nominee at this vague description: The scene in Pink Flamingos involving the chickens.
I elect Bogie's awkward mauling of Ingrid's lips during the flashback scene in Casablanca. Not exactly sex, but it WAS the 40s...
I guess by "worst", you must mean something like, "the most disturbing to my vanilla world". For that very reason I find some items makes my "best" list. I'll also throw in all of 9 ? weeks and another Malcolm McDowell entry, the rape scene in A Clockwork Orange.
My "worst" list would be just about every boring sex scene in every movie. Pretty, perfect, unblemished Hollywood bodies, oh so sensuously working up a 'glow' (never a sweat mind you) to the rising strains of elevator music (think every sex scene Tom Cruise ever filmed). Passion my ass! Give me something real or gritty any day. Overweight people, old people, young people (jailbait young) engaging imaginative acts (imaginative by the standards of this middle-aged ex-sailor) anal sex, water sports, BDSM, hell even oral and gay sex don't get much big screen representation. If it doesn't turn me on, at least it won't put me to sleep.
Jeremy Irons and some french woman whose name escapes me in the movie Damage. They look like artheritic greco-roman wrestlers, or perhaps life-sized plush dolls being posed by invisible manipulators.
It's a good thing that Ayn Rand never made it to Hollywood.
"It's a good thing that Ayn Rand never made it to Hollywood."
Oh but she did. In fact she started out there. She was a spear-carrier in a film version of the New Testament. Later a couple of her novels were made into movies. In particular, The Fountainhead starred Gary Cooper and featuring the rape scene. Keep in mind it was 1949.
What possible penalty could _The Daily Star_ suffer for this infraction?
First, Robert Berry has to prove that he's the original source of the article. That part should be the easiest.
Next, as I understand it, he has to prove loss.
Then, he has to take _The Daily Star_ to civil court?
It's an international case, which makes all litigation much more difficult.
Can he sue _The Daily Star_ in Sacramento?
How does this all work, logistically speaking?
And this is news because.....?? Jim Rome, the San Diego Union Tribune (and a bunch of other bucket heads) got taken for a ride by the Hoosier Gazette last month with an article a recruit for Purdue. Fark ran a story about this and the U-T (which basically cut and paste the article into their newspaper and website) were properly derided for it.
"Real" news organizations are getting taken for a ride by spoof articles (and are plagarizing them)all the time now.
Mo,
You could have an entire top ten list made up of scenes from Pink Flamingos. *That* scene with Babs and her son, for instance: "This is the greatest gift a mother can give her son."
Or any scene involving Irene Massey in her underwear.
First, Robert Berry has to prove that he's the original source of the article. That part should be the easiest.
Next, as I understand it, he has to prove loss.
That should be easy, too. Presumbaly, the Daily Star and other publications have generated revenues by selling copies that contain Berry's material. He is, thus, entitled to compensation.