The Frozen-Baby Parades
Sanctions-era child deaths are back in the news today, as Newsday reporter Matthew McAllester -- the guy who was held captive by Saddam?s sputtering regime for eight days during the war -- goes back and interviews doctors from some of the same hospitals that until recently served up sanctions-are-killing-babies propaganda to western reporters.
Doctors said they were forced to refrigerate dead babies in hospital morgues until authorities were ready to gather the little corpses for monthly parades in coffins on the roofs of taxis for the benefit of Iraqi state television and visiting journalists. The parents were ordered to wail with grief -- no matter how many weeks had passed since their babies had died - and to shout to the cameras that the sanctions had killed their children, the doctors said. Afterward, the parents would be rewarded with food or money.
This is hardly the final word on the correlation between sanctions and child mortality in Iraq over the past 13 years, a subject so heavily politicized that even the pro-war crowd enthusiastically propagated the false high-end estimates to support their cause. But it will be interesting to see what the Saddam-era Iraqi sources for the sanctions stories say now.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
The sactions were a real bitch! Can you believe that I could only get 16 gold plated toilets for my palaces?
BTW- thanks to all my anti-war brothers and sisters out there! Especially the libertarian ones, who all knew that Iraq was my legal property and all those dead Kurds were trespassers killed in self-defense. Knew you would understand!
Later dudes.
I really wonder what the Chomsky-ite left would do with those interviews if it ever bothered to confront logic....
a modest proposal (you all know where this is going) that would alleviate the hunger...
so, here's one: should daddy bush have moved into baghdad to avoid all of this mess? was there anything that could have been done since feb 1991 to prevent this bruhaha?
drf
"was there anything that could have been done since feb 1991 to prevent this bruhaha?" Supporting the popular uprisings at the end of the war. A nice DeGualle moment, with the Iraqi resistance riding into Baghdad first.
hey joe,
being in college when the gulf war was played out, much of the end is, errr, in a fog, shall we say. what do you remember of daddy bush's call to the kurds to rise up? was that an indirect sign of support, from what you remember, or was it a call to arms with no backup?
and how much of the current state was already decided by rumsfeld, et al in their feb 1998 letter to prez clinton? that seems to have shown that sh's days were numbered....
thanks!
drf
Poppa Bush inspired not only the Kurds, but the Shiites to rise up. Then he ordered our military not the support them, allowed armed helicopters to put down rebellions, and released POWs so they could assist in the supression.
I'd say the PNAC people were as disgusted by this behavior as the left. They've been looking for an excuse for a second Gulf War since 1992, and September 11 elicited cries of "Now's our chance!" from that quarter.
The party line seems to be forming, something like "these doctors lied when they were afraid of Saddam, and they still lie now because they are just as afraid of the Americans." By this reasoning of course only bad news need be believed. If the Iraqis praise us, they're currying favor and not credible; but those that condemn us are straight shooters expressing heroic "dissent".
Never mind that we're not exactly loading people into giant paper shredders... yeah, they're afraid of us. Right.