WSJ Puts a Hurtin' On Kurt
Prissy but amusing effort by Nancy DeWolf Smith to link Kurt Kobain's antisocial angst with hardcore perversity and homicidal rage. There's some pretty lurid stuff in Kurt's diary—"I like to make incisions into the belly of infants then [expletive deleted] the incisions until the child dies," reads one entry that makes you suspect little Frances Bean may have gotten off lucky. There are also some pretty funny examples of Neil Strauss types (including Neil Strauss himself) trying to whitewash the content. But really, who's surprised? I watched the new Nirvana home video recently and what is most striking is what a completely banal, disagreeable dickhead Kobain was. It's becoming more clear every day that Dave Grohl was the real genius in that threesome.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Who in the f*ck are you Douchebag to judge somebody especially if they are not here anymore. I’m gonna go ahead and be your judge for a moment. What if your life was under a microscope? Don’t spend too much time pondering that I’m sure it will never be the case…Would you like if it your child/family had to read washed out opinions of you by such narrow-minded critics..Do the world a favor and keep your opinion to yourself and that includes any response to this…You’ll just further embarrass yourself.
UnJustin- you hit the nail right on the head. The pompus ass will never know what it is like to have his life under a microscope for the rest of his life. How would you like if you were something you did not want to be but could nothing about it…….you would probably be pretty off yourself. You probably are, but just one of the stupid crazies that thinks you’re not. You should quit as an analyst because you’re shitty at it, and maybe you should look up more facts than just the man’s diary. By the way the dairy could have been altered, you would never know. You should check out his suicide letter, than reanalyze. Most of all before analyzing other people, analyze yourself first. This way people don’t have to tell you you’re an idiot, you’ll just know!!!!
kurt cobain was one of the greatest artests that ever lived! any one who disagrees can bite my ass and all that happened was he couldnt handle the spot lite. he wanted his own life to himself.
Kurt was lyricly AWESOME!!!!!! if u don’t like nirvana u don’t apperciate rock!!!! and u don’t understand it! R.I.P. KURT COBAIN….. WE ALL LUV U!!!!!!!
Kurt Kobain ROCKED HARDCORE! If you dont appreciate him,you have no right to be here and dis him! he was the greatest out of The three In Nirvana, Althought Everyone in Nirvana was great, he rocked the most. I miss him deeply and wish him still alive. R.I.P Kurt! He’s so great. Who agrees?
Kurt Kobain ROCKED HARDCORE! If you dont appreciate him,you have no right to be here and dis him! he was the greatest out of The three In Nirvana, Although Everyone in Nirvana was great, he rocked the most. I miss him deeply and wish him still alive. R.I.P Kurt! He’s so great. Who agrees?
Kurt Kobain ROCKED HARDCORE! If you dont appreciate him,you have no right to be here and dis him! he was the greatest out of The three In Nirvana, Although Everyone in Nirvana was great, he rocked the most. I miss him deeply and wish him still alive. R.I.P Kurt! He’s so great. Who agrees?
Sorry that posted three times, My bad.
Kurt made great music. If what we read is true, he killed himself. Little Francis Bean will never get to know her dad. Doesn’t matter if he was a poet, a superstar, the voice of rock, whatever. Every celebrity today will produce a product that is equally as significant as that of those in the 16th century (if they are fortunate). The real tragedy is Francis’ loss.
The decision of somen’s takin their life is not a subject to comment on. Do not embaress yourselfs by saying stupid stuff about those who had the courage leave this shit –
hole….
U R PRETTY SORRY FOR SAYING THAT ABOUT KURT HE IS ONE OF THE GREATEST PEOPLE AND I THINK HIS EX WIFE KILLED HIM I MEAN IT IS PRETTY OBVIOUS SHE DISAPPEARED AFTER HE DIED. HE LOVED HIS LITTLE GIRL MORE THAN ANYTHING. R.I.P KURT
i agree with amanda&liz that courtney did kill him it all makes sense. WE LOVE YOU KURT!!
all of u made great points and personally i’m not sure what happened with kurt…but his music was awsome…i cant say i miss himbecause i dont know him personally but i miss his music and i feel terible bout his daughter just imagine not bein able to know ur dad but havin ppl all over da world talkin about him……..u ppl should be ashamed for sayin dat shit bout him!!!
i love ur work kurt!!!
R.I.P kurt kobain
all of u made great points and personally i’m not sure what happened with kurt…but his music was awsome…i cant say i miss himbecause i dont know him personally but i miss his music and i feel terible bout his daughter just imagine not bein able to know ur dad but havin ppl all over da world talkin about him……..u ppl should be ashamed for sayin dat shit bout him!!!
i love ur work kurt!!!
R.I.P kurt kobain
oopz sorry that posted to many tymz lol
Kurt Cobain was the greatest musician to ever live. He cut through all the bullshit and said things straight to ur face. Kurt’s song were great, even today people listen to him. Kurt was a good person and personaly i dont think he killed himself. Kurt still lives on in our hearts and he will never die. Kurt is remember through his music. KURT NEVER REALLY DIED BECAUSE NO MATTER WHAT WE STILL HAVE HIS MUSIC AND NO ONE WILL EVER CHANGE THAT. I LOVE YOU KURT!
Kurt Cobain was the greatest musician to ever live. He cut through all the bullshit and said things straight to ur face. Kurt’s song were great, even today people listen to him. Kurt was a good person and personaly i dont think he killed himself. Kurt still lives on in our hearts and he will never die. Kurt is remember through his music. KURT NEVER REALLY DIED BECAUSE NO MATTER WHAT WE STILL HAVE HIS MUSIC AND NO ONE WILL EVER CHANGE THAT. I LOVE YOU KURT!
Kurt Cobain was the greatest musician to ever live. He cut through all the bullshit and said things straight to ur face. Kurt’s song were great, even today people listen to him. Kurt was a good person and personaly i dont think he killed himself. Kurt still lives on in our hearts and he will never die. Kurt is remember through his music. KURT NEVER REALLY DIED BECAUSE NO MATTER WHAT WE STILL HAVE HIS MUSIC AND NO ONE WILL EVER CHANGE THAT. I LOVE YOU KURT!
Kurt Cobain was the greatest musician to ever live. He cut through all the bullshit and said things straight to ur face. Kurt’s song were great, even today people listen to him. Kurt was a good person and personaly i dont think he killed himself. Kurt still lives on in our hearts and he will never die. Kurt is remember through his music. KURT NEVER REALLY DIED BECAUSE NO MATTER WHAT WE STILL HAVE HIS MUSIC AND NO ONE WILL EVER CHANGE THAT. I LOVE YOU KURT!
Kurt Cobain was the greatest musician to ever live. He cut through all the bullshit and said things straight to ur face. Kurt’s song were great, even today people listen to him. Kurt was a good person and personaly i dont think he killed himself. Kurt still lives on in our hearts and he will never die. Kurt is remember through his music. KURT NEVER REALLY DIED BECAUSE NO MATTER WHAT WE STILL HAVE HIS MUSIC AND NO ONE WILL EVER CHANGE THAT. I LOVE YOU KURT!
Let it GO!
He’s dead…
Musicians die all the time!
Shut up already!!!