Diaries of Mario M. Cuomo: The Campaign for Governor, by Mario M. Cuomo, New York: Random House, 468 pp., $19.95
"The brightest star in his party," coos the doyenne of chichi liberalism, Mary McGrory. "The most humane, most sympathetic New York Governor since Al Smith," swoons Albany savant and Pulitzer Prize–winning author William Kennedy. The "hottest property" on the Democratic block, concede right-wing columnists Rowland Evans and Robert Novak.
The man who sets these political hearts palpitating was written off as a loser by political insiders two short years ago. A run-of-the-mill paleo-liberal given to gratingly self-righteous and pedantic oratory. A hapless lieutenant governor who'd lost the only two contested races he'd ever run (the 1974 Democratic primary for lieutenant governor and the 1977 New York City mayoralty election) and who'd piloted Jimmy Carter's 1980 statewide campaign to disastrous losses in the primary and the general election. And a man engaged in a quixotic battle for the 1982 Democratic gubernatorial nomination against the redoubtable mayor and avatar of middle-class Gothamites, Ed Koch.
But Mario Cuomo had a shtick, and he won. He beat Ed Koch in the Democratic race with a stirring come-from-behind victory, then edged out supply-side drugstore magnate Lewis Lehrman in November. Democrats, desperate to retake the White House once the curtain closes on the Reagan reign, immediately recognized Cuomo as a candidate straight from central casting. Ethnic, Catholic, ugly-cuddly basset hound face, an orthodox liberal who seems like a regular guy, denizen of our second-largest state—perfect. You got a sneak preview when he delivered the keynote address at this year's Democratic convention in San Francisco. The full-length feature will probably be released in your state in '88.
Now none of this would be remarkable were Cuomo your basic garden-variety hack. After all, somebody has to be the Democratic nominee for president. But Mario Cuomo is different. The themes he has used to great effect in New York might revivify the Democratic dinosaur. And if they provide him with the key to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, prepare for four years of unyielding hostility to individual liberties. Better fasten your seatbelt, too. More on that later.
The heart and mind of the New York governor are currently on display in Diaries of Mario M. Cuomo: The Campaign for Governor. As the title suggests, the book is largely devoted to the voluminous and usually soporific diary Cuomo kept from late 1980 until his inauguration on January 1, 1983. When we first meet the protagonist he is Everyman. His boss, Gov. Hugh Carey, neither likes nor trusts him (he sees Cuomo as a potential rival), and his neglected wife spends much of her time whining about his measly lieutenant governor's salary.
Though he frets that the long hours he puts in laboring for the people of the Empire State have damaged his home life, the lure of what he calls the "beautiful profession" is too strong. Soon our hero is battling Ed Koch, Lew Lehrman, and the forces of reaction. Most of this is dull potatoes indeed, although the diligent reader may ferret out hints that Mario is motivated by more than mere power-lust. Savor this gem: "The political power one wins is good for the good it can do. The acceptance is good for the political power it gives. The joy of winning is the joy of having an opportunity to do the good."
Between lucubrations, Mario the Good spends scores of pages doling out fulsome praise for everyone from goofy Sen. Alan Cranston ("bright, progressive, pleasant") to the lowliest Brooklyn ward heeler. Virtually every man, woman, child, and household pet Cuomo came into contact with during his campaign is eulogized. A grateful winner? Perhaps. But also a savvy politician who'll need these people again in 1986, a reelection he hopes will put his name on everybody's short list two years hence.
Not to spoil the ending, but Mario wins. He describes his coalition as "labor, business, homeowners, minorities, the disabled, those who work and those who want to work but can't." (New York's Aleut population is omitted—I believe it's a publisher's error.) But don't mistake this for the usual Democratic promise-the-saps-everything triumph. For Cuomo's campaign had a theme, a motif that invested every nostrum he advanced and every speech he gave with a dignity rare in politics. Mario spoke of the family.
His own family is, by all accounts, exemplary. Momma and Papa Cuomo were Neapolitan immigrants who entered this country penniless and illiterate and, with equal parts of love, thrift, and hard work, built a respectable grocery business in Queens. Their children were raised in the Catholic Church, whence Mario apparently acquired a missionary zeal to do good for others. Indeed, he believes Christianity demands its votaries "try to do good things for other people…insistently." An eminently worthy raison d'être—for a private citizen.
Alas, Cuomo conducts statecraft as though New York were his living room and its residents his prepubescent children. He fused his militant do-goodism with his reverence for the kinfolk to produce the most arresting political metaphor of the decade—the Family of New York. Just as the Cuomos shared their burdens and blessings, so must New Yorkers begin "feeling one another's pain, sharing one another's blessings, reasonably, equitably, honestly, fairly." If such sharing strengthens the family, asks Mario, "why shouldn't that be true for polities as well?"
Of course, the difference is that transfers of wealth within a family are voluntary and are motivated by love and generosity rather than by the fear of arrest and imprisonment. Moreover, we make the transfers directly and assist only those whom we deem worthy of assistance. Few families employ welfare bureaucrats to skim 40 percent off the top.
But if Cuomo is blind to the glaring flaws in the metaphor, so are the many New Yorkers entranced by the Good Governor. He won statewide approval for a $1.25-billion infrastructure bond issue to pay off his brothers in the building and construction trades unions, then satisfied environmental faddists by signing a bottle bill requiring a five-cent deposit on beer and soft drink containers. He allied himself with the neoprohibitionists in an effort to raise New York's drinking age to 21 (before the federales commanded it anyway), and Naderites across the land are still applauding New York for being the first state to make buckling one's seat belt mandatory. Almost always, the family metaphor is invoked.
His diaries suggest Mario the Good would govern the nation as he has the state, dismissing individualist objections to his coercive schemes as the selfish babblings of misguided children. The economy would be regulated by a benevolent father who considers Felix Rohatyn his economic guru and who, when confronted with a deserted steel mill in Lackawanna, New York, that was laid low by high taxes, excessive wages, and imbecilic management, solemnizes that "all around us there are evidences that we have failed as a society to do all the good things we could have done." The national defense would be in the hands of a fellow who supports the nuclear freeze "to reaffirm the simple truth that peace is better than war because life is better than death." And you'd better believe that if the kids aren't public-spirited enough to volunteer to keep that peace, Dad'll send 'em to the neatest summer camp you could ever imagine.
A man who really believes that "ever since Adam and Eve, human nature has needed to be coaxed into doing the right thing" is to be pitied. A candidate for president who believes that is to be feared.
William Kauffman, a former legislative assistant to a US senator, is now a graduate student in political science at the University of Rochester.
This article originally appeared in print under the headline "Fasten Your Seat Belt: Here Comes Cuomo".
Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.