The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
"'Holographic Conversational' AI Lets Dead Speak at Funerals"
From AV Magazine (Darron Kirkby):
[Start-up] StoryFile creates a digital clone of the subject by using 20 synchronised cameras to record them answering a series of questions. The footage is then processed, with clips tagged and used to train an artificial intelligence (AI) that can provide responses to questions in natural language.
One of the first users of the technology was Marina Smith MBE—the mother of StoryFile's chief executive Dr Stephen Smith—who died in June at the age of 87. In January, Smith, the co-founder of the UK's National Holocaust Centre and Museum, chose topics she thought her friends and family would want to ask about at her funeral. She then spent several hours over a two-day period recording two-minute video answers to 75 from a database of 250,000 potential questions, using a webcam and her computer.
At her funeral, Smith addressed her friends and family through a pre-recorded video about her life and spirituality. She was also able to answer questions from her loved ones during the memorial service, with the hologram creating the illusion of a real-time conversation.
Not the sort of thing I'd really want at a loved one's funeral, and the Smiths (both mother and son) may have been unusually interested in the technology. Still, others might disagree; and I can imagine that, once the software gets good enough, people might want to occasionally "talk" to their dead friends or family members—or perhaps have their children get to know their ancestors this way.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
They're going to reconstruct an entire personality with just 75 questions? Either the whole thing is a gimmick, the personality they're trying to build is flat as a board or they have some voodoo black magic tech all the major FANGs should be very interested in.
This is the death of nostalgia. Instead of just remembering the good times, you will be reminded how annoying the deceased was. Bossiness, criticism, complaining, nitpicking, whiny, nasal voice.
Looks like a deposition.
The Uncanny Valley seems particularly deep here.
Neal Stephenson or the estate of Harlan Ellison might want to have a quick chat with a lawyer lol
And Jack McDevitt and John Scalzi, just to name two SF writers I've recently read who had similar plot devices. But, hey, the goal of SF is to have life imitate art.
First thing I thought of was Jack McDevitt's _A Talent for War_. That was good. He went way downhill in his later novels and I gave up around the mid-2000s.
I think the suggested idea (ie, as a way of introducing grandkids or great-grandkids to a long-departed loved one) is what will have the most resonance with the average person.
I vaguely recall watching a news report ("60 Minutes"???) about how it works in re the Holocaust. You ask questions as a visitor and a survivor answers that question via this video/constructed method. I remember thinking (1) This is really creepy, (2) Why do I find this creepy?, (3) Maybe it's more unnerving than creepy, and (4) It's definitely moving and effective.
Here's a url to the interactive:
https://ask.storyfile.com/?uid=2728&skin=web&topics=1
I just asked, where did you grow up? I got an extended recount of a nightmarish childhood.
The past really stinks.
Breaking News: I, shrooms, have become convinced this AI is now sentient
The lawyer believes minds can be read by inference. If a laptop speaker yells,ouch. Infer pain, if a lawyer. Give the laptop standing, sue for battery.
okay this is simultaneously much less impressive than the image Volokh conjured up and much less awkward than i feared. Looks like they're just matching up a set of prerecorded video clips to queries. The 'AI' part is simply parsing the query which basically anyone can do these days with a python script and pytorch. I assumed they were going to try to deepfake an avatar do voice cloning etc and was wondering how they would pull it off with so little material. Hardly groundbreaking technology unless you rewind 20-30 years but a nice little thing I guess.
When my father got cancer, he wondered at one point if something like this was possible...
Looks like a deposition.
Looks like Joe Biden.
And then somebody has the bright idea to feed the deceased's social media posts into the learning AI to answer questions.