The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
"Where Is the Third Rome, Where Is the Third Reich, and Where Is Pompeii?"
Maksim Pokrovsky, a prominent Russian musician who is now working in New York, has just released this song; it has been out for 15 hours on YouTube, and so far has been viewed 825K views. My sense is that Pokrovsky is fairly prominent, as the frontman of Nogu Svelo! (literally, "Leg Cramp!"), which has been around for over 30 years.
Since the start of the war in Febturary, he has put out several anti-war songs recently, mostly satirical and often quite witty (and vulgar): "We Don't Need the War!," "Backward, Russia!," "The Letter Ziu" (my favorite of the four), and "Generation Zed" (opening line: "Russians, we shat everything away"). This one, though, called just "Ukraine," has a different tone; I liked its mix of the impassioned political outrage and the everyday (the wartime everyday)—"I hope the patrol won't waste their bullets on us / I hope we have enough diesel fuel"—so I thought I'd pass it along. I have to say the video does not work for me at all (everyone's a critic), but whether or not you agree with me on that, I hope you enjoy the words. Note that "the Third Rome" refers to the historical Russian concept, originating around 1500, that Moscow is the heir of Rome and Constantinople.
Here are the English lyrics, very slightly adapted from the translation that comes with the YouTube video:
[Refrain (next two stanzas)
Ukraine!
My other half!
A deadly avalanche from heaven,
Will come down at the whim of obsessions.Ukraine!
From the Dnieper to Berlin
Let angels fly unseen,
Keeping your children safe along the way.Son, don't fear and wait a bit.
The air raid sirens will go quiet.
They seem to have subsided,
It seems the enemy has flown away.
Looks like you and I survived today.Don't be afraid, daughter, and wait a little longer,
I know it's not an easy road ahead,
I hope the patrol won't waste their bullets on us,
I hope we have enough diesel fuel.[Refrain]
Son, don't be afraid and wait a bit.
No one knows what God has going on there.
And with whom he is contending now.
We just need to hold on a little longer.They salivate among the bloody puddles
And summon spirits at the cost of innocent souls.
They call themselves descendants of the gods,
Bringing ruined cities as a sacrifice.Don't be afraid, daughter,
Love is always stronger!
Where is the Third Rome, where is the Third Reich, and where is Pompeii?
But they will live and become only greater—Odessa, Kiev, Kharkiv, Mariupol, Bucha![Refrain]
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
The worthless lawyer garbage running our country is going to lose the Ukraine to the Russian hordes of Huns. These are the stupidest people in the country.
Forget my oligarch theory of history and of war. All this suffering and damage is caused by one man. I am not allowed to discuss the remedy on this pro-criminal lawyer blog.
I feel sympathy for the Russians who are against the war and have no way to stop it.
I have nothing but disgust for the Western politicians who are not willing to fight to stop Putin.
Based on Fox News talking heads speaking glowingly of it, Trump would have given Ukraine up straight away, like Buggs Bunny sawing off Florida and saying, "South America, take 'er away!"
Some of them are libertarian types. I was unaware it was a libertarian principle to hide away from tyranny on the march, whistling past the graveyard. "Not my problem," I guess.
Yet, all Russian aggression coincides with a weak Democrat President in office. The cause of war is weakness. America bashing, kowtowing, appeasement is the way of the Democrat Party. Then cause a war that enriches its oligarchs. Coincidence? You decide.
Had the election or January 6 gone the other way, would we have the Trump who increased military aid to Ukraine? Or the Trump who called the invasion a genius move?
If Trump were President, there would not have been a Ukraine invasion. It was caused by Biden weakness.
We would have had the radically unpredictable Trump we have always had.
Most likely, Putin would not have invaded because if Trump was personally insulted he might have gone to war.
If Putin had invaded Trump's response would be a crap shoot - anything from "Take her, she's yours!" to "Withdraw your troops within 24 hours or we attack."
An article I read this morning divided the West into three camps. (The descriptions below are mine.)
Italy wants to surrender and walk away to tame inflation.
France wants a negotiated settlement where Putin gets enough of Ukraine that he doesn't feel humiliated. Wouldn't want to upset that nice Mr. Putin.
The UK wants Ukraine to win.
Where's Biden? Napping.
I think the U.S., after a very slow start, is moving towards doing the right thing and helping Ukraine. While the details doubtless come from his handlers, Biden's apparently off script remarks (Putin has to go; he would defend Taiwan) tell me he is inclined towards intervention rather than isolationism.
Maddie. Weakness is the cause of all aggression, victimization, and loss. That is the way of nature. You have a responsibility to be strong.