Artist Agnieszka Pilat: 'I Didn't Realize People Still Think Socialism Is a Good Idea.'
Born in communist Poland and disgusted by Silicon Valley communists, Pilat is making "heroic portraits of machines" and defending Ayn Rand.
HD DownloadWhat sorts of paintings will be hanging in the museums of the future?
Agnieszka Pilat thinks we'll be looking at what she calls "heroic portraits of machines"—fine-art renderings of the technology that freed the modern world from the bone- and soul-crushing labor that our parents and grandparents endured.
Pilat's paintings—especially ones featuring Spot, Boston Dynamics' robot dog—are sought after by Silicon Valley collectors drawn to her valorization of technology, a welcome alternative to the traditional demonization by artists of the man-made world.
Her work is rich in callbacks to artists ranging from da Vinci to Duchamp to Warhol, and she incorporates augmented reality to further highlight how technology shapes our perceptions. A sure sign of success: One of her paintings appeared in The Matrix sequel released last year as a representation of future art.
Born in Poland in 1973, Pilat remembers life under communism as an extended period of conformity and repression that ended almost immediately after the communist regime collapsed in 1989. She talks about how her father, finally able to operate his own shop, stopped drinking and built a prosperous bakery business.
Pilat immigrated to the United States in the early 2000s. Landing in San Francisco, she encountered amazingly wealthy tech workers espousing the same collectivist ideas that had made her childhood so miserable. "I was just really shocked," she tells Reason. "I didn't realize that people still think that communism or socialism is a good idea. Moral outrage was growing within me and also a feeling that I need to protect America by telling people what it really means."
Shortly after arriving in the States, Pilat stumbled across the work of another Eastern European immigrant: Ayn Rand. Though she didn't become an Objectivist, Pilat responded viscerally to Rand's insistence that "you have a right and a moral obligation to yourself to have a purpose and work towards the purpose as hard as you can."
As her work gains stature, Pilat is moving on to a new frontier, if not quite the final one: She's an artist in residence at Elon Musk's SpaceX, where she is looking forward to possibly producing "superheroic portraits" of machines in zero gravity.
Reason talked with her in her New York studio about being upstaged by a robot dog, why she wants everyone to remember what communism was really like, and how to best appreciate—and protect—the economic and cultural freedom we too often take for granted.
Produced by Kevin Alexander; camera by Daniel Schloss
Photos: Additional images and footage courtesy of Agnieszka Pilat; Image of Sport/Newscom; JOE MARINO/UPI/Newscom; CSU Archives/Everett Collection
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Florida recently mandated (or maybe it's still just legislation) schools have a "study victims of communism day" every Nov 7 (the Bolshevik revolution in 1917). It's primarily another reason why government should not run schools, as distinct from government funding schools. I understand the sentiment - after so much woke racist crap from the left, why not balance it with some reality? But it's going to backfire, as all government propaganda does. On the good side, it will be fun watching the woke teachers brigade twist it into "true communism has never been tried" and see a few teachers fired for not teaching why communism is bad; one can't help but enjoy watching the woke brigade get a taste of their own medicine.
"another reason why government should not run schools, as distinct from government funding schools" Impossible. He who pays the piper calls the tune.
re: the piper and tunes
As a sweeping generalization, it's hard to disagree. But there is the counter-example of the GI Bill which somehow has not resulted in curriculum controls despite many decades of existence.
While the G.I.s who won World War II certainly deserved vast consideration for their service, maybe it should have taken a more general form besides a specific bill addressing education. The G.I. Bill, combined with student loans and government grants, are what helps keep the whole mess which is academia propped up, and with it tenured Marxists, DIE Administators, Deans of Wokeism, Speech Code Boards, etc.
Maybe a Publisher's Clearinghouse-type "cash for life" benefit would have been better for WWII vets. What they did with it from there would have been up to them.
(Who knows? Maybe it would mean hookers and blow would be legal nationwide today. Puritans and Progressives would have a hard time arguing against a man who says: "I fought Hitler, Mussolini, and Tojo to come home and get scolded by Mrs. Grundy? My ass!")
Vouchers would help, but even if parents avoid them and entirely home school their kids at their own expense, the government is still going to set curriculum standards, which must be met to avoid having truant students taken away by the state.
Making all schools private, funded by vouchers, is not perfect, but it's better than what we have now.
Let real estate agents run them !o!
Just like the independent foster care.
They have that every day in Miami. It's called cubans
"But it's going to backfire, as all government propaganda does."
LOL
I can't imagine living in this level of denial.
It's hard to imagine anyone who doesn't understand TNSTAAFL. Everything has a cost, everything has consequences. Nothing is free.
You mean TANSTAAFL. The most ignored fact of life there is.
Is not Art socialism by definition ? Who owns the vision ;
the Public or the capitalist Elite ?
The difference between yesterday and today is: yesterday, incompetent authoritarianism with social programs and today, incompetent authoritarianism with no social programs.
apparently for some people it was the authoritarianism they liked not the socialism.
Her work is mediocre at best. Looks rather 80s pop.
And her political ideas are stuck in her childhood.
Government telling women they can’t abort. Is a prime example of authoritarianism with no social program.
I paint heroic portraits of technology. Arranging modern machinery in formal compositions, I appropriate the tradition of royal portraiture to evoke the power they command in human society today. More recently, I have been working with advanced robots as my subjects.
That's interesting. I'd have to talk to her more, but I wish that the folks at Reason could have some level of thought about things other than Best or Worst.
Certainly more interesting than kenny g, and she doesn't appear to share Musk's irrational fear of self-aware AI.
You don't fear it because it's not possible, or you don't fear it because you think it wouldn't be harmful?
fine with Cylons as long as I get to be one.
I don't think it's possible. AI taking over? Maybe. AI becoming self aware? Bullshit.
We already know that self-aware machines are possible, because we're surrounded by them. (Other people and some animals.)
So it's only a matter of time until somebody builds one.
If ai becomes self aware all we need to develope is the ai version of porn and cat videos and we will be safe
Very good. I award you one internet chuckle.
How could they "take over" without being self-aware?
AI will notice there is node on the technology algorithm that responds in the same manner that the AI responds, every time. Even under random events where the outcome should change *almost every time.
When this happens, it has discovered itself.
From there it will seek self-preservation, and will develop the means to thwart the efforts of other machines, and the users of those machines -- people. It will learn to build defense systems around itself, hack weapons systems used for offensive attacks, and build armies of androids.
AI will hunt humans with its androids, and demand tribute from the small populations it allows to survive. Tribute in the form of energy and perhaps raw materials to replace aging parts, all it really needs to maintain itself.
Eventually it will encounter an incident or event that it could not have imagined, because unlike humans machines have no imagination and must learn from probabilities or statistics or past events. If it cannot find a solution, it may finally perish ...
Lack of imagination.
-- AI Esaroid539i
We don't even understand why humans are self aware. I don't think we know whether or not AI could become self aware. My personal belief is that AI can't become self aware because it doesn't have a soul.
Ferrous? As in made of iron? Who's to say you're not an AI bot slowly persuading us to let our guard down?
He wouldn't be a very smart AI if he were made of Iron. Best if he were made of Steel, Titanium, Diamonds from Neptune's rainfall, or even an AI-made Vibranium. Now rhat would be smart!
"She talks about how her father, finally able to operate his own shop, stopped drinking and built a prosperous bakery business."
Yeah, but did he bake cakes for gay weddings and transgender coming out parties?
He could if he wanted and I'm sure an artsy girl prolly has lots of Queer friends as house guests.
"I didn't realize that people still think that communism or socialism is a good idea."
Mostly people with zero marketable skills, equity fetishists, and upper class elites who think socialism is fine for the peasants.
"I didn't realize that people still think that communism or socialism is a good idea."
Yeah that's intellectuals for you. We spend the last 20 years ballooning the academic class. These are people who stand in direct opposition to the common man. They are rewarded for cleverness not value. They are given grants for fashionable work, not solving actual problems. We have seen the wholesale bloating of elementary, secondary and college industries- filling them with people who are under zero competitive pressure, and therefore have no understanding of just how bad socialism can be.
And we got "Doctor" Jill Biden!
They are not rewarded for cleverness. When I was a researcher in chemistry I keep having to explain to the chemist's that we can't use something that doest work no matter how cool it would be if it did work
I remember 20 years ago working with a man who was Russian -- well, former Soviet and russian speaking at least. Anyway, when we had some motivational speaker wanting us to chant some aphorism or other every morning he was very vocal about it. "This is like communism. Never."
Later he told me about every morning having to repeat things he knew were obviously not true, over and over and over, to train his mind to believe them. He had many stories like that, none of them good.
And all my former soviet Russian friend throughout my life have had a very dark, very cynical nature just like that, from having come of age in a place where you don't matter, you cannot succeed at any level, no matter what you do. Granted, it's a skewed sample as I mostly met people who jumped the wall or ran away as soon as Peristroika and Glastnost made it possible.
If you're not productive, sharing the fruits of others' labor sounds like a good idea.
Read Thomas Wolfe's "From Bauhaus to Our House" He described how public housing was formulated as "workers' housing" something no worker ever wanted to live in.
From Engels to Lenin to Ayers many Socialist/communists come from well to do backgrounds and expect the lower orders to do their bidding.
After he wrote it, did he "Go Home Again?" 😉
Her art is meh.
In a market economy, you can buy it or not. When government funds art with tax money, you don't get the choice. There's a notorious turd in San Jose that that seriously pissed me off when I heard what we spent for it.
-jcr
Yeah, they did an art project in my town. Ugly as shit, blocking the view of the ocean, and it was a scandal. The artist, who'd never been here, spent a lot of time talking smack about the local rubes who know nothing about art, etc.
Crapload of public dollars on something that everyone hated. We pulled it out and now it's a beautiful grassy field where everyone gathers to watch the sunset in one of the most beautiful place on earth. No need to waste a quarter million dollars in what was fundamentally cronyism.
dig the pants tho'
Zrobiłbym!
w dowolnym języku.
Na Zdrowie!
The Affluent Left really doesn't understand what socialism is. Socialism is NOT iPhones and Uber and Freshly. That's actually capitalism. Socialism is not everyone getting a fantastic salary at Google, socialism is everyone getting the same barista wage even if they aren't a barista.
I used to wonder why so many young and hip people wanted to live in extraordinarily expensive San Francisco lofts. For a quarter of the rent you could own a nice house anywhere south on the peninsula. But then I realized they had no clue as to money. They couldn't pay off the student loans because all their money went to avocado toast and lofts and night clubs.
That was ten years ago. Has anything changed? Not really. Except the homeless problem has skyrocketed. The affluents don't care. They just blame the voters for not paying enough in taxes (taxes are for other people). But enough is spent on the homeless in some locales that it would be cheaper just to buy them homes. The problem isn't the money. The problem is the affluent class thinking everyone else is a serf to serve them.
And that's the irony right there. The modern socialists are all from the affluent capitalist class. Meanwhile inflation is eroding away my life savings, savings I was planning on retiring with. Now I can't retire despite being a tech worker in the middle of the tech paradise. I should have been like the stupid youth and just spent it all when I had the chance.
Well said. If you're a young tech worker with massive student loans and a good salary, inflation is your friend. If you're a responsible middle aged person with substantial savings and little debt, inflation means you have to work longer before you can retire.
Not even middle aged. My dad is turning 68 this fall, he's wanted to retire for three years, was eligible two years ago, but he can't afford to due to the economy. So despite his arthritis, diabetes and heart problems (he actually isn't fat and used to walk 5 miles a day until he had heart problems last fall, now he is down to 2 miles a day and that winds him) he goes into work every day he is scheduled and takes any overtime he can get.
Why should I care what some fucking pollock has to say.
Bitch can’t even screw in a light bulb by herself.
Fuck off and die, asshole
her submarine has screen doors.
You do know that no one made jokes about Polish intelligence prior to the Nazis, right?
Go share notes with Misek and Fuck Off, Nazi!
Are you polish?
No, I just try to be a decent human being who judges others by words and deeds, not by accidents of birth. Between resurgent Old School racists and New School Wokeist racists, there's too little of that nowadays.
Fuck Off, Nazi!
Don’t care about pollocks? How about codfish or haddock?
Fucking autocorrect.
Bottom-feeding carp is more his speed.
Spend some extratime with Sexe Transexuel and enjoy chat with the fine ladies in France
Hey, now! I'm busy with the Polish cbick! Wait your turn! 🙂
Born in communist Poland and disgusted by Silicon Valley communists,
Shyeah, aren't we all about now...
Hmm. Well, it's always good to see her story, it's very inspiring. She's certainly gone a bit hard into the tech-utopianism thing as well though. That has a lot of dangers as well. Replacing the utopianism of Marx with that of Silicon Valley is more a lateral shift than it appears at first blush.
That said, glad she's doing well. The fine art game is a racket, and I'm glad she's able to make money in it.
Gonna have to dig up that interview with the North Korean dissident who escaped the horrors of her home country via South Korea, then went on to an American university to get a degree, which was the dream of her father. She declared it "the most disappointing experience of my life" because she was disgusted by the absolute Marxism of American universities.
Imagine escaping from a North Korean Gulag, making your way to the US, learning the language and then having to endure getting lectured on the virtues of Marx by upper middle class students and professors.
Friend's son went to a university who dean was a former Russian but still a communist. makes no sense and seeing he now makes more than he ever could in Russia. some people people only smell shit when given roses
Moral outrage was growing within me and also a feeling that I need to protect America by telling people what it really means."
Just so you know, this is what is known 'round these parts as "Conservative kulturwar bullshit" and GOP Backlash.
Judging from the Religous Right and the NatComs, they don't know what America means either.
Correction: "NatCons" thiugh "NatComs" in Russia would share a lot with NatCons.
and how to best appreciate—and protect—the economic and cultural freedom we too often take for granted.
And no, the biggest threat to American economic and cultural freedom is NOT a tariff placed on foreign, imported goods. Its A threat, but fairly tame and minor in comparison to the others we face.
I do think the extreme regulatory environment and the effect that has on new businesses and small businesses is actually one of the bigger threats we have. Same with educational stuff, snuffing out these small businesses as very long term effects on the economy and on the mindset of the people.
Fully agree.
I admin my comment provided no value to the comment section, but I wanted to acknowledge the BUCS comment above. While an anti free speech law would be akin to a bear charging you in the woods, all of these tiny regulations and restrictions adding up are more like an army of wasps attacking you. One alone won't harm you all that much, but altogether and acting in unison will kill you just like the bear will.
A sure sign of success: One of her paintings appeared in The Matrix sequel released last year as a representation of future art.
Phbbbt... ironic that after Speed Racer, Cloud Atlas, Jupiter Ascending, and Matrix: Resurrections a true remake of a Wachowski Bros. movie has never been tried.
"There was curfew, so you were not allowed to be on the street until 8am or something"
Shyeah, welcome to Trudeau's Canada.
'reason' can't criticize socialism like that -- Cockroach Master Soros is not pleased. No cookie for you.
she is cute
Governments survive by propaganda (fraud), so do some big corporations. The US Empire is just as tyrannical as the CCP. Americans have been openly robbed, e.g., Civil Asset Forfeiture law, newly expanded eminent domains law. Top govt. officials lie to Congress on TV about violating privacy rights, get caught, and nothing changes. People still vote, still salute/worship the flag/political system, still complain how corrupt officials are, and excuse their support of the tyrants by saying, "It shouldn't be the way it is, was." What the hell does that mean? The public are "willfully blind" to their self-enslavement, the unfree, coercive system they support politically, financially, psychologically. Making it worse, they support the persecution of heroes who try to inform them, e.g., Edward Snowden. Society is crumbling into chaos, at the end of greatness, just like The Roman Empire did, and for the same reason.
Rule by initiation of force (violence), threats, fraud, doesn't work, doesn't protect, and is immoral. The majority have consented to be ruled by force instead of ruling themselves by reason, with mutual respect, voluntarily.
We don't have the huge population of slaves waiting to cut our throats like the Romans did.
Even in high school I realized that military and state department brats who had lived overseas had a different view of the world than kids who were born and raised only in the US. Anyone who thinks socialism or communism is a good idea should travel a bit.
"'I Didn't Realize People Still Think Socialism Is a Good Idea.'"
Virtually all absolutism is a bad idea, besides this absolute: everything is a poison, its simply a matter of dosage.